American Bison Steak vs USDA Prime Beef Steak - A Taste-Off!

Cordial Cooks
243 followers
11 Video Views·Jun 15, 2023
Hey everybody, I'm Joey, and take a look at these steaks.
Right here I have two rib-eyes, but they're different.
This one is beef, and this one is bison.
We're gonna cook these babies up,
and then my favorite part, share the results with you.
So follow me, and let's turn up the tasty.
All right, so I'm really excited about this test.
I've actually never had a bison rib-eye.
I've had bison burgers, but never the rib-eye.
Also, this is not really an experimental test,
which is the best.
This is a prime grade beef rib-eye,
so I already know it's gonna be excellent.
This video is really about testing for those differences,
those flavor profile differences,
and sharing those results at home with you guys.
Now, the first thing you're gonna notice
is that these steaks have already been salted.
Why?
Well, because we recently did an experiment,
and we determined that if you salt your steaks
at least an hour before cooking, it helps turn up the tasty.
I wanna talk about the rib-eye here for just a little bit.
One of the things I wanna point out
is that these are very similar-looking cuts,
even though they come from different animals.
The one thing I'm really impressed about here
is that these are very well-trimmed steaks.
A lot of times, when you buy rib-eyes at the store,
it comes with all this additional fat cap
that goes all around the exterior here.
It's typically an edible, and what it really is
is the market driving up its weight
on the steak that you're buying.
I really wanna take a moment
and thank my friends at MeatAndBone.com
for sending me these steaks.
If you're interested in trying it out for yourself,
we've included a link in the description below,
and I'm just really impressed
with how well-trimmed this beef rib-eye is.
That's my best comparable because I've had these before,
and I just have to assume the same is true for the bison.
Now, one quick note about the rib-eyes.
They both have what we call the spinalis.
That's the rib-eye cap.
It's often the most flavorful and tender,
most desired part of any rib-eye steak.
It has all that great intermuscular fat,
which just adds a lot of flavor.
Now, it's time to turn up the heat and cook this meat.
All right, so we're gonna get these steaks cooking
right here in this cast iron skillet.
Why am I using a cast iron skillet?
Well, it delivers a nice, consistent, even heat
throughout the cooking process.
I know from my experience cooking bison burgers
that bison can be a lean cut of meat,
and we don't wanna risk overcooking it.
It will be dry and just not a good steak.
So I don't wanna take this bison any higher
than a medium-rare temperature.
Also, I wanna address why we didn't use
any other seasonings.
Why salt only?
Well, it's because I want to be able to isolate
the true flavor of each steak
so I can share authentic results with you guys at home.
I don't want any other flavor profiles getting in the way.
We're gonna get the skillet nice and hot,
and we're gonna season it with a little bit
of avocado oil.
Why that?
Well, we've done experiments there, too,
and we just are really impressed with the results
that avocado oil produces,
because it has a very high smoke point.
So let's turn up the heat.
While we're waiting for the skillet to get nice and hot,
I just wanna point out the salt.
It was very heavily present
when we first dropped it on the steaks,
but what happens is that initially
it brings the moisture out of the steak,
but after time, that begins to reabsorb into the steak
and gives it a nice, balanced salt
all throughout each bite.
Just wanted to kind of share that.
Now, the other thing that you'll see,
I don't know if you can see it on the camera,
but the salt that's on the fat cap doesn't absorb at all.
That does not penetrate in the same way.
Now that we got the pan going nice and hot,
you can see some smoke coming off,
I'm gonna go ahead and hit it
with some of this avocado oil.
There is some debate about whether you oil the pan
or oil the steak.
I've always oiled the pan.
Might be a future experiment.
We try.
So we're gonna go ahead and get this on,
or in, rather.
I'm just gonna pick it up,
let it get all the way around the pan.
Now, I wanna address the myth of a ripping hot pan.
I've heated this up to a medium-high heat,
not as high as it goes.
I find that sometimes that just overcooks
the exterior of the steak.
So this is a medium-high heat.
Because our beef ribeye is just a tad thicker
than our bison ribeye,
I'm gonna go ahead and drop that first.
I love that sound.
It's the sound of tasty.
Next, here we go with the bison.
Now what I'm gonna do is I'm gonna let these things cook
for about two minutes on each side,
and then I'm gonna gauge the internal temperature.
I'm also gonna switch out this cutting board.
Okay, so these steaks are finished cooking.
They've been resting here for five minutes.
We pulled both steaks at an internal temperature
of 125 degrees.
The bison steak took about five minutes,
and the beef ribeye took about six minutes.
It was just a little bit thicker.
So now here's one of my favorite parts.
Let's cut it open and see how it looks.
We'll just go right through the middle here.
That, we got some nice color right there.
Nice medium rare, just what we were shooting for.
And now let's take a look at this bison.
Again, that's a great looking color.
That's just what we want on the bison.
Again, it is much leaner meat,
and so we don't want it drying out.
All right, so before I actually do the taste test,
I just wanna kind of point out
just one difference I'm seeing.
It looks like the beef ribeye
has just a slightly better crust on it
than the bison.
I think that probably has to do with the fact
that this is prime steak,
which means it's heavily marbled, a lot of fat in there.
I think some of that fat helped
bring up the crust a little bit,
but it's really a negligible difference.
I really just kind of wanna share
that small point with you.
So now it's time for my favorite part,
but before I bite in and taste test these,
many people have pointed out
that I need to cleanse my palate in between each bite.
I'm gonna grab a beer.
Sorry for the suspense, guys.
Wanna make sure I'm doing this experiment right.
So the first thing I'm gonna do
is I'm gonna try this prime steak.
Guys, this is a steak I'm used to.
I mean, prime beef is just so good.
And then when you mix that in with it,
with the ribeye just having a lot of fat on it,
it's a really rich cut of meat.
And I've noticed this with wagyu meat too,
which is even more marbled than prime beef,
is that all that fat can add a lot of richness.
I often find that I can't eat as much
of a prime steak or a wagyu beef
because of all that richness, all that fat,
and it's creating a lot of flavor,
a lot of great umami flavor.
So let's cleanse the palate.
All right, next up, let's try this bison.
A little bit of a fat cap over here.
Wow.
I'll tell you, I would have absolutely no idea
that this was bison.
I would have no clue that it is not
a traditional beef steak.
Some of the things I'm picking up on this
is it has a really nice chew to it.
Again, it's a ribeye.
I don't know if bison comes in grades.
Actually, if you guys know at home,
let us know in the comments below.
We'd love to hear from you.
It has a great bite.
The one thing that's sticking out
is it's just not as rich as this steak over here.
Now, that could be an excellent thing,
especially if you're looking to monitor your fat intake.
I know that's one of the reasons people love eating bison.
Also, there's another component to it
in that bison are almost always raised,
free-range, eating throughout the period.
I think that's another thing.
I wanna go in for another bite,
just to make sure I'm giving you guys
an honest, authentic review,
and it's pretty damn good as well.
You get that salt coming through,
end-to-end on each bite.
If I'm really trying to stretch here,
there might be a little additional sweetness.
It's kind of hard to distinguish
between a richness and a sweetness,
but I'm finding this to have just a slighter, sweeter flavor.
So this steak was just incredible.
A lot of people have contacted me
and told me that I should add more game meats
to our channel, and that's part of the reason
why we wanted to feature this.
If you guys are looking to try this out,
you can get yours today from meatandbone.com.
As I mentioned, there's a link in the description below.
Hey, while you're down there, you know the drill.
If you like this video,
go ahead and hit that big thumbs-up like button,
or even better, subscribe to our channel
so you can keep learning how to cook meat made easy.
We release a new video every single week.
Look, I'm gonna get back to these two delicious steaks,
and I'll see you guys next time.
