We got to sit down with Dr. Christopher Palmer to learn about his Brain Energy theory which argues that mental illness is really metabolic disorder. Thank you so much Dr. Palmer for chatting with us!
HELP SUPPORT THE CHANNEL We depend on the support of our audience to create this valuable resource. If you have found our content helpful, please consider supporting us today. Your contribution can make a huge difference and enable us to continue providing valuable resources to those living with mental illness. • One-time donation: https://donate.stripe.com/9AQ6oV5S0eft5568ww • Monthly donation: https://www.patreon.com/livingwellwithschizophrenia
JOIN OUR ONLINE PEER SUPPORT COMMUNITY Join a welcoming community of your peers and find comfort in sharing your experiences. By joining our community, you can benefit from the support of others who understand what you’re going through. We offer live weekly facilitated video peer support groups and text channels to communicate about a wide range of topics. Join today and start feeling less alone with what you’re going through. • Schizophrenia Peer Support Community: https://www.schizophreniapeersupport.com • General Mental Illness Peer Support Community: https://www.onlinepeersupport.com
MENTAL HEALTH APPAREL Wear your support for mental health! Our t-shirts, sweaters, and mugs not only spread awareness but also help support this channel. Pick up some mental health apparel today and make a statement while making a difference. https://livingwell.myspreadshop.com/
SPEAKING & CONSULTING Looking for an expert speaker or consultant for your upcoming event or project? With years of experience and a passion for mental health advocacy, I can provide the insight and inspiration you need to make a positive impact. Visit my speaking website to learn more! https://www.laurenkennedywest.com/
Have we been thinking about mental illness the wrong way all this time,
and is mental illness really just metabolic disorder?
To tackle this topic, we are joined today by Dr. Chris Palmer. Dr. Palmer is a board-certified
psychiatrist and an assistant professor of psychiatry at Harvard Medical School.
He is also the director of the Department of Postgraduate and Continuing Education
at McLean Hospital. Dr. Palmer recently published his book Brain Energy,
which I really recommend checking out if you have the chance. You can also learn more on his website
for the book, brainenergy.com, both of which we will link to in the description below.
We will have links to this book as well as books that Dr. Palmer mentions in this video
in the description below. All right, so hello. I'm joined today by Dr. Chris Palmer. I'm so
excited to have you. We actually learned about your work through our audience. A lot of people
were recommending that we get in touch with you and interview you on the channel because you're
doing some really amazing and kind of groundbreaking work around treating mental illnesses like
schizophrenia. So welcome. I'm so excited to have you. Thank you for having me on. I'm excited to
be here. Yeah. So just kind of briefly talking about it, you talk a lot about the shortcomings
of how we currently treat mental health disorders, namely the sole focus on symptom reduction,
and have introduced a new theory to get more directly at what the underlying problems may be
with mental illness. And so your theory, the brain energy theory argues that mental disorders
are really metabolic disorders of the brain. And it has been so fascinating digging more into your
research. And I want to get into that, but I suppose, could you just kind of start off first
by explaining to our audience what metabolism is and what metabolic disorders are? So metabolism,
most people know that word and they think about it as burning calories. And they think that it
relates to how much we weigh and that that's really primarily what it is. It's like some
internal furnace. We're burning calories. And if you have a high metabolism, you're going to be
thin no matter how much you eat. And if you have a low metabolism, then you're going to be
overweight no matter how little you eat. And in reality, metabolism is in fact burning calories
and it absolutely plays a role in our weight. But it is so, so, so much more than that.
It is actually fundamental to the definition of all living organisms. And in a nutshell,
the easiest definition is that it's the process of taking food and oxygen and turning it into
energy or building blocks that get used to build ourselves or maintain ourselves.
And it also involves the management of waste products. So we take food and water and oxygen
and turn it into energy or building blocks. And then there's some waste products that need to be
managed. That is what metabolism is at its core. Okay. And you mentioned a lot
when you talk about metabolism, about mitochondria specifically and their function in that. Can you
talk a little bit more about that? Exactly. So when we ask the question like, well,
what causes a metabolic disorder or a problem? I realize I didn't answer that part of your last
question too. So it gets really complicated and actually scientists can't universally agree on
what that means. And what I'm arguing in Brain Energy is that if we look at a lot of cutting
edge research that has occurred over the last 20 years, in particular, in a wide range of medical
specialties. So this includes the metabolic fields of obesity or diabetes or cardiovascular disease,
but it also includes the aging field. Researchers trying to figure out what causes humans to
age prematurely, but also the neurodegenerative field. What causes disorders like Parkinson's
disease or Alzheimer's disease? Even some cancers are related to all of this.
You have to get really granular and specific about, well, what does it mean to have a metabolic
disorder? And all of that leads us to these tiny things in our cells called mitochondria.
So mitochondria, most people know as the powerhouse of the cell. And that means they
take food and oxygen and they turn it into ATP, which is the energy currency of the cell.
And that's probably what you learned in biology class. And that's probably what the teacher asked
you on the test or quiz. And yes, those things are true. But in fact, again, cutting edge research
over the last 20 years completely upends this simplistic definition of mitochondria.
Mitochondria do so much more than that. And when we do a deep dive into the science of mitochondria,
that is when we can start to connect the dots of the mental health field.
Yeah. So, I mean, you mentioned in your book and in other talks about all the different functions
mitochondria have, and a lot of them seem to be highly linked to things that have to do with
mental illness. So things like you've talked about regulation and production of neurotransmitters
that are commonly come up with mental illness, serotonin, dopamine. Can you talk a bit more about
all those different kinds of functions that they play as well? Absolutely. And this is something
that is a journey I've been on for the last seven years. And as I uncovered more and more of this
cutting edge science, that is what blew me away. Because as a psychiatrist, I've known,
like we in the mental health field are trying to understand what causes the neurotransmitter
imbalances or what causes hormone imbalances, what causes the brain inflammation, and how does it
exactly cause mental illness? But psychological and social factors play a role. Trauma,
stress, substance abuse, all of these things play a role in mental disorders. And, you know,
up until now, our field hasn't been able to connect the dots. And what I'm arguing is that
mitochondria specifically connect all of those dots. So you mentioned production and regulation
of neurotransmitters. They also play a key role in hormone production, some really key hormones,
like cortisol, estrogen, testosterone. They play a pivotal role in epigenetics, which is the
expression of genes from the nucleus. So they send all of these signals to the nucleus that turns
genes on or off. They play a key role in calcium regulation, which helps turn cells on and off.
They play a key role in inflammation, turning inflammation both on and off.
Fascinatingly, they also play a key role in psychological and social stressors.
So when humans are stressed, either physically or psychologically, mitochondria actually play a role
in our stress response. They are controlling cortisol levels or at least playing a role
in cortisol levels. They're playing a role in the release of neurotransmitters. They're playing a
role in the inflammation that ensues and even the epigenetic changes that ensue. And so when we take
a comprehensive look at the function of mitochondria, we can start to connect the dots of
more importantly, when we look at like, well, what would happen if a cell has dysfunctional
or malfunctioning mitochondria, we can actually start to make sense of how the brain might
malfunction and how that might result in mental symptoms. Right. That's really interesting. So
you mentioned environmental factors playing a role in terms of how this comes about,
but what sorts of things impair or impact mitochondrial function? Is it just these
environmental factors or what else plays a role? So definitely genetics and epigenetics play a role.
And that's important because we know that mental disorders can run in families. People largely
think of that as genetic. And I actually think we have more than enough evidence to say,
that's not actually the right answer anymore. That the answer appears to be epigenetic.
Mothers and fathers can transfer epigenetic signals to their children and that can be
transferred to those children's children. And the reason that distinction is important,
it still says that mental disorders run in families. But the reason that distinction is
important is because epigenetics can be changed fairly easily sometimes with lifestyle strategies
or lifestyle interventions, whereas genetics are fixed and permanent. And so genetics,
epigenetics can play a role. Diet plays a role. Exercise plays a role. Sleep plays a role.
Light exposure, getting some sunlight during the day, avoiding light at night when we should be
sleeping in a dark room, that plays a role. Substance use plays a role. And the key substances
that we know are highly associated with mental illness directly impact mitochondrial function
and metabolism. Things like alcohol, marijuana, smoking cigarettes, those things all play a direct
role in mitochondrial function. And that can start to help us connect the dots between how do those
play a role in mental illness and in people with mental illness. And I'll stop there. I could
probably go on forever, but there are lots of exciting roles. But the good news is that you
kind of already know them. This isn't new information. This is about putting together a lot of stuff that
we've known for a long time. But now once and for all, we can start to make sense of it. And once
we can make sense of it, it leads to new treatment strategies and new solutions.
I think that's something I find really exciting about this theory is that it's not just this
new concept. It's really pulling together things that we already know, like you said,
and kind of making sense of it. So what does treating this through diet look like?
So there are lots of dietary strategies that can be used. So I look at diet in two different ways.
So one is looking at dietary patterns or ingredients in our diet that are harmful.
And so we want to look at that and we want to remove that or change those behaviors or change
those aspects of our diet. But then there are also dietary strategies that can be really beneficial
and helpful. So the dietary strategies that can be harmful, highly processed foods,
are known to impair mitochondrial function. They are highly associated with obesity and type 2
diabetes. And if you don't know this, they're also highly associated with things like depression,
anxiety disorders, and even Alzheimer's disease.
The type 2 diabetes or insulin resistance is really important. So we actually just got a very
large controlled trial over 24 years where researchers followed children from the ages
of zero to 24. And what they found was that the children who had the highest levels of
insulin resistance beginning age nine had a five-fold increased risk for having a psychosis
at risk mental state by the time they turned 24. And what that means is that high levels
of insulin resistance in childhood make it more likely that somebody might be diagnosed
with bipolar disorder or schizophrenia. That is directly impacted by diet. And more importantly,
we can use dietary strategies to treat insulin resistance and, with hope, maybe reduce the risk
of somebody ever having a first episode. So those are just a couple of the harmful
things that diet can do. The beneficial things that diet can do, we can use some dietary strategies
like intermittent fasting or the ketogenic diet to actually help improve mitochondrial function
and improve metabolism overall. Now, obviously, for some people, especially in the mental health
community, we need to walk the line in a careful, balanced way. We're not here to set off eating
disorders. We don't want people being underweight. We don't want people obsessing about foods in a
maladaptive way. And I already hear the people in the eating disorder community yelling at me,
how dare you talk about intermittent fasting or a restrictive diet like ketogenic diet.
But I'm here to tell you, if used in a safe and proper way, they can be powerful metabolic
treatments and mitochondrial treatments, and they can help some people heal and recover from
chronic disorders sometimes. Right. So what exactly is happening in the brain when a person
is on a ketogenic diet? So the quick answer that I'll give for the keto diet, a lot of people know
the keto diet is a weight loss diet. Some people think of it as a fad diet, and some people think
it's a dangerous diet. It's all those eating bacon and steak all day and no fruits and vegetables,
nothing else. It's an awful, toxic diet. Everybody's going to have a heart attack.
Unbeknownst to all those people, the ketogenic diet is actually a 100-year-old evidence-based
treatment for epilepsy. It can stop seizures even when medications fail to stop seizures.
The reason that is important to me as a psychiatrist is because we use epilepsy
treatments in psychiatry all the time in illnesses like bipolar disorder, schizoaffective disorder,
and schizophrenia. And so the names, for those of you who may not know, you probably recognize
some of these names, Depakote, Tegretol, Lamictal, Neurontin or Gabapentin, Valium,
Klonopin, Xanax, Topamax or Topiramate. All of those are seizure medicines. Most of them
were actually developed for the treatment of seizures, and yet you're probably familiar at
least one or two of those names because either you've been on them or you know somebody who's
been on them because we use them in tens of millions of people with mental disorders.
And so in that way, using the ketogenic diet to treat mental disorders is nothing different.
We are using an evidence-based treatment for epilepsy to treat mental disorders. And in fact,
we have decades of neuroscience research on this diet. We know that it changes neurotransmitter
systems, decreases brain inflammation, changes calcium channel regulation. Central to my thesis,
it actually improves mitochondrial function, improves mitochondrial biogenesis, and those
things can have powerful healing effects for people with mental disorders, I believe.
So if someone starts the ketogenic diet, roughly how long can it take for a person to start seeing
benefits to their mental health? It's really fascinating because just like a medication,
the ketogenic diet doesn't work overnight. So it's not like you do the keto diet and within
two days, poof, all your hallucinations or delusions are gone. I'll outline a typical
trajectory. So number one, I just have to say this, I have to back up and say,
if you have schizophrenia or know somebody with schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder
or bipolar disorder, please do this with medical supervision.
This is a real medical treatment. It's not something to wing on your own.
It's not that the keto diet is dangerous, but it's that the keto diet is powerful.
And when you pair a powerful intervention with what can sometimes be a dangerous brain disorder,
people can end up in trouble or with dangerous symptoms. I just want people to get
effective help. So with that said, the typical trajectory that I notice,
if I start somebody with schizophrenia on the ketogenic diet, the first week is awful
and symptoms can actually get worse before they get better. So this is the reason I backed up
and said, please do this with medical supervision. Symptoms can get worse. There's something called
the keto flu or keto adaptation. And I just want people to get through that safely.
Once they get through that adaptation, usually within two to four weeks, I begin to notice
pretty powerful antidepressant effect. So with no med changes at all, people start noticing
that they have more energy. Their mood is improving. Yes, they're losing weight. And
some people just assume, oh, maybe they're feeling better because they're losing weight.
I actually think it's a brain effect. The diet is actually impacting brain function
in the same way that it can stop seizures. It's actually restoring brain function.
So this antidepressant effect starts first. The antipsychotic effect can take anywhere from
probably two to four months in reality. So most of the people that I've worked with,
usually around that two to four-month mark, and you have to stay on the diet consistently.
You can't be cheating every weekend because that would be like taking a medication and
stopping your medication every weekend. That's a recipe for disaster. Same deal with this diet,
that you have to be consistent with it. You have to do it all the time.
But if you're consistent with it, usually around that two to four-month mark,
people will spontaneously notice hallucinations start to go away, or maybe they just get quieter,
or maybe people can start to ignore them before they couldn't ignore them. They felt compelled
to listen or even respond. And delusions start to go away. I will say, I usually notice that
hallucinations go first, and then the delusions start to go away, which is a pattern I've noticed
for over 27 years in clinical practice. Even when medications work, that's usually what I
notice, is that the hallucinations start to go away first, and then the delusions just seem to
have a stickiness to them. They're harder to make go away. I think if nothing else, because people
are out to get me. That's a fact. I know it. And it can be harder to start to challenge that,
or to forget about it, or to think maybe that's not true anymore.
But yeah, usually I tell people when they try the diet, let's give it at least three months
before we make a decision about whether this is something that's going to work for you or not.
I want you to give it a fair chance. That's helpful. I started learning about the ketogenic
diet, and I tried it back in 2020, the beginning of 2020. So interesting timing to try a new diet,
dawn of a global pandemic, lots of different stressors. But I stopped probably just before
the three-month mark because I didn't feel like it was having much of an effect, and it became
hard to stick to the diet with kids home 24-7 now and whatnot. But I'm definitely interested in
trying it again. And so knowing that that's the two to four-month parameter is kind of something
to be worried about is good to know. So thank you. Are there any other means such as supplements or
anything like that beyond diet that may be able to improve mitochondrial function as well? Because
this is not an easy diet and it may not be possible for some people. So is there anything
else that can work to improve mitochondrial function? So the good news is again, so there
are lots of common sense health and wellness strategies that you've all heard of that you're
going to think, well, yeah, we've all heard that. But I'm also going to say this, a lot of people
with schizophrenia are not doing these things. So let me be clear, even though you're going to say,
this is nothing new, if you're not doing it, then it is something new. So you got to start doing it.
Good sleep. That means regular bedtime, regular wake-up time. Light exposure, good light in the
morning, avoiding light at night. All of those things impact mitochondrial function and circadian
rhythms. Stress reduction, exercise improves mitochondrial function. Checking for any
vitamin or nutrient deficiencies or hormonal imbalances is really critical
because those can play a role and affect mitochondrial function.
So all of those things can play a role. To be honest with you, that is the most exciting thing
to me, existing strategies that we have today. And the reason it's exciting for me is because
I am seeing dozens of patients recover from, they are putting their symptoms of schizophrenia
or bipolar disorder into remission and moving on with their lives and achieving things they
thought were impossible. And that's the most exciting thing to me. But also exciting is that
this research opens up entirely new areas for research pursuit. There are many supplements
that researchers have been trying actually for decades because it's not that this is a new
theory. Researchers have known mitochondrial dysfunction is playing a role in mental illness.
And so that was the basis of all of the clinical trials of antioxidants, for instance,
giving people with schizophrenia vitamin E. We did lots of trials on that in the hopes that the
vitamin E would correct the mitochondrial dysfunction. It doesn't. And so giving
somebody a simple supplement that is supposed to be a mitochondrial supplement is not effective.
And simply getting good sleep and not doing anything else probably won't put schizophrenia
into remission. It certainly won't hurt. It'll help. And we kind of already know that,
but I believe that people need comprehensive strategies. So you need to probably do more
than one of these things. You need to kind of give the person the maximum chances of recovery.
Right. I like taking that holistic approach beyond just treating with medication and
really looking at all the factors that impact how to achieve wellness. So what has it looked
like as a clinical psychiatrist treating your patient's mental illness by treating metabolic
disease? I'm going to be honest with you. When I first started this, the first patient that I saw,
I was initially in disbelief. I actually, the patient that I was treating,
his father was very involved in his life and his care. And I think fortunately for me,
this patient was also seeing a clinical psychologist for occasional therapy as well.
I actually had to go to both of them at different times and ask them,
are you seeing what I'm seeing? Because I can't believe this is happening. He's only on a diet
and his hallucinations are going away. And he's like coming to life and I've never seen him this
way. Have you like, dad, have you seen like what's happening here? The father and the psychologist
were both equally in disbelief and yet saying, no, it's true. We're seeing it too. This is real.
What is this? What is going on? Since then I have had patients who come from wealthy families,
for instance, they have had access to the best care in the world. They've seen numerous
psychiatrists, leading psychiatric professionals, experts in the world. They've flown all over the
country for expert consultations. They've tried dozens of medications. They've been in and out
of hospitals or private residential treatment programs. And at the end of all of that,
they were told there's nothing more we can do for you. You have a treatment resistant,
chronic, persistent mental disorder. And they and the families were told you kind of need to
change your expectations for life. Like, it's okay that you don't work. It's okay that you
don't finish college. It's probably not going to happen with the illness that you've got.
And then they come to me and within three months, the illness is in remission.
I remember one such person. So his parents are literally billionaires and he was almost in tears
at one point saying for the first time, I think maybe I can be normal. And I remember just being
dumbstruck by that statement. You're a billionaire and your biggest hope and
dream was just to be normal. And all the money that you have couldn't get you that.
And then I did. How does that happen? So there's a part of me that has so many stories like that
where I almost want to like cry because it's heartwarming. It's amazing. It seems like a
miracle. And quite honestly, there's another part of me that is heartbroken because I know
millions of people need this information and are not getting it. Millions of people.
I can empathize with what you're saying about the things you're told in terms of, well, you need to
reframe how you engage with your life and that sort of thing. And I think that that's what a lot
of people with mental illnesses like schizophrenia are often told. And so I guess that just leads me
to ask, why isn't nutrition taken more seriously as a form of prescribed treatment? Why are we so
focused collectively in the medical system on medication and these types of interventions as
opposed to looking more holistically at things like diet when they're clearly so effective?
I think in fairness, I think because although once you understand the science and once you
understand the tool like ketogenic diet, it's implementable, it's understandable. And actually,
it's not that in the grand scheme of life, in the grand scheme of having a disabled life,
it's not that hard at all. And yet it's not intuitive. If you ask somebody, what's a healthy
diet? The overwhelming majority of human beings on the planet would not say the ketogenic diet.
So it's a dietary treatment or a dietary strategy that's mimicking the fasting state.
So it's an unusual dietary strategy. And so in those ways, it's not obvious. It's not necessarily
intuitive. And yet again, I want to come back to yet this diet stops seizures and we use seizure
treatments all the time. So this is kind of a no-brainer. The other reason I think a lot of
in the medical field, mental health field are skeptical of this is because our field has gone
through many phases where people have said schizophrenia is caused by a niacin deficiency.
We have that phase in the 70s, 80s. And so let's put every person diagnosed with schizophrenia
on niacin and that'll cure them all. It didn't work. We've gone through maybe B vitamins,
maybe lots of vitamins, healthy fruits and vegetables, Mediterranean diet, get rid of
gluten. It's all gluten. Gluten causes schizophrenia. If we just get rid of gluten,
that'll solve the problem. And there are these case reports out there. There are rare people
who will say niacin saved me. Niacin cured my schizophrenia or a gluten-free diet seemed to
cure my schizophrenia or whatever. So we have these rare cases, but they don't work for the
overwhelming majority of people. So mental health professionals are appropriately skeptical
and appropriately thinking, is this just another one of those fads? Is this just another one of
those things where some crazy person, now it's Chris Palmer. He's got some wackadoo idea about
oh, this is going to save everyone with mental illness. And by no means do I think the ketogenic
diet is going to save everyone. I think the ketogenic diet is one of many metabolic
interventions. And that is the reason I was mindful of that from day one. Nobody's going
to believe this. I need to understand the detailed science. I need to make sense of this.
And through that process, I developed this larger theory that goes far beyond diet that goes to,
again, what seems like common sense, holistic things like stay away from the marijuana,
stay away from the alcohol. They're not good for your brain. They're not good for your mitochondria.
They can trigger psychotic symptoms. Smoking, smoking cigarettes is awful for mitochondria.
And yet the majority of people with schizophrenia are smoking. So there are lots of things that are
happening to people with mental health conditions like schizophrenia that I think if people really
fully understand the big picture and the science, it's going to open our eyes and we're going to
realize, oh my gosh, we've got a lot of changes to make. We've really got a lot of work to do here.
And yet when I say that, let's get off the cigarettes, the cigarettes might be harming
your brain. Everybody's kind of like, well, yeah, I guess that kind of makes
pretty obvious actually now that you say it. And yet we're not insisting that people with
schizophrenia stop those cigarettes. We're not insisting. We're not letting them know the
magnitude of the damage they are doing. And so we think, well, if I was disabled,
what's the harm? I mean, they're disabled anyway. They're suffering. They're tormented.
Who cares? Let them smoke. And what I'm saying is no, let's not take that approach. Let's take
a comprehensive, holistic, scientific approach. Let's help them fully recover. So we're not just
going to take away the good, quote unquote, addictive or good thing for them. We're not
going to take away their cigarettes and leave them to be miserable. We're going to help them
heal so that they can thrive in life. I really appreciate that approach. And thank you so,
so much for taking the time to sit down with us and talk about all this. It's been really,
really interesting. Thank you very much. Thank you for having me on.
So thank you so much again, Dr. Palmer, for joining us in today's interview. I know I learned
a lot and I hope that you as the audience did as well. Make sure to check out the links in
description below to Dr. Palmer's book, his website, and any books that he mentioned as well.
Thank you so much, everyone, for watching. And as always,
wishing you and your loved ones good health. We'll see you in the next video. Bye.