Italian PIZZA Mac & Cheese - The PERFECT Pair!

Cordial Cooks
243 followers
17 Video Views·Jun 4, 2023
Today, we are making the baby and Johnny of recipes, the Jim and Pam, the David and Victoria,
the perfect couple recipe, pizza, mac and cheese.
That's right.
Some things are just meant to be together.
I'm Erin from WellPlated.com, and let's hang out while we celebrate the love of pizza and
mac and cheese in one dish.
To start, we're going to boil water and cook our whole wheat pasta until al dente.
I like to use whole wheat for an additional nutritional boost and a fun, curly shape.
This is cavatappi.
Now, for the mac and cheese mix-ins, or if you're pizza-centric, the toppings.
I loved mac and cheese growing up.
Could not get enough of it.
Anytime that my mom asked me what I wanted for dinner, the response was predetermined
and instantaneous, mac and cheese, please.
Moms out there, I bet that sounds familiar.
Right now, I am chopping up a red bell pepper and a green bell pepper to saute.
I'm keeping the pizza theme here fairly classic.
Feel free to swap in other vegetables that your family prefers.
In fact, I remember as a kid grocery shopping with my mom, I would try to sneak Velveeta,
aka the fancy brand, mac and cheese into the store cart instead of the store brand.
Oh boy, did I ever get a scolding.
Now we are going to saute our peppers and onions in a bit of olive oil.
These are classic pizza toppings.
We'll cook them until they are crisp, tender.
That will take about two minutes.
Next up, I am going to add a can of diced tomatoes.
I drained off the extra liquid.
I like to add the tomatoes here because it is a nod to the red sauce in pizza.
Let this cook for five minutes until most of the remaining tomato cooking liquid has
evaporated.
Now for the foundation of this ultimate couple recipe, the cheesy sauce.
Adding a couple of tablespoons of butter.
Let that melt just a little.
Some garlic.
I tend to go pretty heavy handed here.
It's pizza.
And now I'm going to sprinkle one quarter cup of flour over the top.
This is going to help the sauce thicken.
At this point, you want to stir and cook constantly until all of the white bits of flour disappear
and it starts to smell a little bit nutty.
That is going to make sure that we don't have any off raw taste of flour in our resulting
mac and cheese.
Every year for my birthday growing up, my Grammy would make me a special dinner of whatever
I wanted.
And can you guess what my longest tenured request was?
Are you sensing a theme here?
That's right, macaroni and cheese.
I asked for her homemade macaroni and cheese every year from the ages of four to 18.
And you know what?
If I were going to be home for my birthday this year, I would ask her to make it for
me again pretty please.
In fact, I love my Grammy's mac and cheese so much.
It was the inspiration for the ultimate creamy mac and cheese in my well-plated cookbook.
I've added some milk and some half and half.
This macaroni and cheese is mostly milk based.
I like to keep things on the lighter side even though I promise you can't tell.
And then just a quarter cup of half and half will give us the perfect macaroni and cheese
richness.
You're going to bring this to a simmer and then let it cook until the sauce has thickened.
That will take about seven-ish minutes.
This looks glorious.
I am going to turn off the heat and then now season up our tasty sauce.
We have some red pepper flakes.
I add a full teaspoon because our house can really handle a kick.
It makes it spicy.
So if you're not as much a fan of spicy food or some members of your household aren't,
definitely dial that down.
Oregano gives a little herbaceousness.
It also reminds me of the herb shakers that they sometimes put out at Italian restaurants
and I mean that in the best possible way.
Now it would not be pizza and it would not be mac and cheese without, of course, cheese.
I am using two different kinds, mozzarella, which is just very mild and melty and gooey.
It is the pizza classic.
So that will be my first cheese and then for the second one, I'm going to add fontina.
Fontina is also nice and melty just like mozzarella, but it has a slightly more complex flavor.
You'll notice that I am grating the cheese myself.
That is because as convenient as the pre-shredded cheese that comes in bags may look and seem,
it is actually coated with a powdery substance meant to keep it from sticking and that means
that it will not get as nice and melty.
And if you don't have nice melty cheese in your macaroni and cheese or on your pizza,
what are you even doing?
This adds up to about a cup of cheese total.
I might have put a little bit of extra in, but I find that nobody's ever mad about that.
Now it is time for one of my all-time MVP healthy swaps.
That is plain Greek yogurt.
It makes the sauce taste thick and creamy just like it would if I used heavy cream,
but Greek yogurt is high in protein and lower in calories.
Just look at this sauce.
I could like put a chip in this right now, but no.
It's destined for a higher purpose.
All right, here we are.
Time to add our cooked whole wheat noodles.
I pulled these out about a minute early and that way they're still a little bit too chewy
right now, but once this bakes in the oven, they will be absolutely perfect.
Undercooking them on the stove means that your macaroni and cheese won't be too mushy.
Now all that's left to crown this as a pizza is pepperoni.
Part of the inspiration for this recipe, aside from my childhood obsession with mac and cheese,
and let's be honest, my adulthood obsession with mac and cheese, is when my husband Ben
and I were living in Madison, Wisconsin.
He was in law school and I was working a super boring desk job, so by Friday night, we really
needed some laughs.
One of our favorite things to do was to hit up our local comedy club for some standup.
Then we'd walk home and we always passed a local pizza joint where they served macaroni
and cheese pizza.
I know it sounds a little bit odd, but I tell you what, nothing hits the spot at 11 p.m.
on a Friday night quite like that pizza did.
I have lightly coated a 9x13 casserole dish with nonstick spray, and now I just gotta
go for it.
There's no super classy or super graceful way to do this.
You just gotta get in there.
You'll notice that I left out a little bit of our pepperoni, and I'm going to arrange
that on top like so.
Then when this bakes in the oven, the pepperoni gets really nice and crispy on top.
This is actually turkey pepperoni.
It is another just really easy, healthy swap that you can make at home.
Yum.
Top it off with some Parmesan cheese.
Whenever I would go to Italian restaurants as a kid and the server would come around
with the Parmesan that they would grate right for you over the pasta, I think I almost made
my server's arm fall off.
I asked for so much cheese.
Then last but not least, olives.
I know that not everyone loves olives.
If it is not your thing or not your family's thing, you can totally just leave them out.
A really fun thing about pizza mac and cheese is that you can use all of your family favorite
toppings.
Fantastic.
Now, all that is left to do is pop it into the oven for 20 minutes until it is hot and
bubbly and the pepperoni is crisp on top.
See you shortly.
Creamy mac and cheese meet pepperoni pizza.
Now, this is a match made in heaven.
If you love creamy pastas, don't forget to check out my turkey tetrazzini.
Now, that is well plated.
