The Real History Behind Pho and Banh Mi

History Of Food
342 followers
13 Video Views·Jun 2, 2023
When America embraces refugees,
we get some of our favorite foods.
Look no further than Vietnamese dishes pho and banh mi,
which are now some of the most popular dishes in America.
So how did that happen?
We're here at Good Girl Dinette,
one of the more than 8,000 Vietnamese restaurants
in the U.S., to find out.
Thank you.
I have no idea how I'm supposed to properly eat pho.
So if you're unsure about how to use your chopsticks,
go lower.
Lower, lower?
Instead of higher.
Yeah, if you have more control, you go lower.
Okay.
There you go.
All right.
That's not terrible.
Yeah.
So this has to be, hands down,
probably the most popular Vietnamese dish
in America, I would say.
Do you agree with that?
Sure, yeah.
So your family has,
their story about coming here to the U.S.
has a lot of ties to sort of the same way
that pho became popular.
Why do you think pho is sort of the ubiquitous
Vietnamese-American dish at this point?
My grandmother came in 1975.
This is right after the American embassy collapsed.
At the time, she came through a refugee resettlement program
that the U.S. created.
After the end of the Vietnam War,
thousands of Vietnamese immigrants came to the U.S.
in three main waves.
First, the U.S. government evacuated
more than 100,000 Vietnamese in 1975.
Second, ethnic Chinese and refugees often from rural areas
came in the late 1970s.
And then third, more refugees, political prisoners,
and Emiratians, the children of U.S. service members
and Vietnamese, arrived in the 80s and 90s.
The American government had to figure out
how to resettle refugees.
They said, oh, how are we going to assimilate these refugees?
So it was not too long ago that Asians were considered
the unassimilable aliens, hence the China's Exclusion Act.
Like, the American government could not see
how Asians could be American.
That's kind of similar to some of the talk
we hear about refugees now, too.
Absolutely.
You know, there's so much fear and fear,
like, what these refugees would do
to the fabric of America.
Today, there are close to two million
Vietnamese people in the U.S.
My grandma was an entrepreneur, had been all her life.
When she was 16 in Vietnam, she sold her wedding jewelry
to start her first business.
Wow.
Like, she was hardcore.
And so she told Grandpa, go to the Goodwill,
get the biggest pot you can find.
We're going to make pho.
And so she made this huge pot of pho in her garage.
And there were other Vietnamese refugees in the area.
They came to her garage, and she made a big pot,
and then she stopped when the pot was empty.
And that's how she kind of recreated
like a tiny bit of Vietnam.
And she called it Quan Hue Hung, which means homeland.
That's how she started making pho in the U.S.
It filled a need.
It was not just a need for sustenance,
but it's also like this community.
Food is familiar.
Yeah, and it felt like they didn't have
their country anymore.
So what makes this pho rather than a different noodle dish?
It's the noodles themselves, the way they prepare it.
It's flat noodles, and then it's cut,
so it's like a more rectangular,
versus other rice noodles are round, more like a spaghetti.
Pho is traditionally a soup made with pho rice noodles,
broth, and protein.
Its popularity rose in Hanoi due to a surplus
of beef bones during French rule in the late 1800s.
Pho then made its way to Saigon and Southern Vietnam.
Now, it's the country's national dish.
So when your grandmother, she started selling pho
out of her garage, pho definitely left the community
and became more popular.
So what helped that happen?
Hard to say.
Almost, it's kind of like how did sriracha
become ubiquitous in every household, you know?
Because Vietnamese community isn't walled in,
you know, and communities are porous.
How do I know about falafel, you know?
So especially in California, we intermingle all the time.
You can't control it.
Do you believe that there is such a thing
as authentic Vietnamese food?
I don't think it's a debate.
I see.
It doesn't exist.
Food is culture, and culture is not static.
Culture changes all the time, you know?
And somehow, I think like when we think
about immigrant food, we want it to be like a-
The same forever.
Yeah, we want it to be like frozen in time.
Especially in America, they want the other
to not have humanity.
So if you make Vietnamese food static,
you're kind of denying like the culture's humanity,
its ability to grow.
You tell me a food that has not ever changed,
and I will tell you that you're completely wrong
because agriculture has changed.
Climates have changed.
Like all these things that affect even like
the growing of ingredients that make a food.
Well, I think a lot of the time
when that conversation comes up,
part of it is that maybe a person outside
of that community, that ethnic community,
is presenting a dish, and maybe people feel
like they're stealing something from another culture.
You're talking about cultural appropriation.
Yes.
I think that term is such an umbrella term
that I think it's hard to tease out what it actually means.
I really don't care how many white people make pho.
I don't care.
But when there's so many Vietnamese Americans
cooking in obscurity, and trying to hone their craft
every day, and not just in their adult life,
like probably since like their childhood,
the first time they ate pho.
I think that's more objectionable,
like to have so many people cook the same stuff,
and who do you highlight?
This white person that went to Vietnam for three months.
You know?
It's like, who do you give the mic to?
Right.
A business is extremely hard to open,
and extremely hard to maintain,
and to keep its doors open.
So I think immigrants are, for the most part,
you know, undercapitalized.
So it's like, who gets to succeed?
I think it has to do with power, has to do with money.
What does it mean when you highlight,
and you make a white person an authority on,
let's say pho?
What you're doing is you're giving them authority,
and authority translates into economic viability.
Because they're considered the expert,
and people are gonna come to them,
and you know, they'll get opportunities like,
give Vietnamese Americans that opportunity
to be experts.
I think women of color,
we have to try so hard to be an expert.
You can't be mediocre.
You don't have the safety net to be mediocre.
No, because we're not considered authorities to begin with.
You know, we have to be so much more
to be at a certain level with straight white men.
Thank you.
Bye.
I'm gonna miss it.
So you did great.
Thank you.
The pho's finished, but we're not done yet.
Banh mi is next.
So what's in here?
Garden of lettuce is a local farm.
Okay.
And then it's a cilantro maggi mayo.
Okay.
Which you make here.
And there's pickled green tomatoes,
because it's a summer banh mi.
And there's red boat bacon.
Bacon that we infuse with cinnamon, star anise, cloves,
and then also red boat fish sauce.
Ooh.
Yeah.
All right, I'm gonna take a bite.
I don't have to use chopsticks for this one,
so I feel more ready.
A banh mi sandwich typically includes a protein,
chilies, and pickled vegetables inside a baguette.
No one really knows who exactly invented banh mi.
There are multiple claims to that title.
But generally, the story goes that the modern version
was probably created in Saigon
toward the end of French rule.
France colonized Vietnam from the late 1800s
until the 1950s.
And for better or worse,
they left some influence on the culture.
And they always like to say,
oh, it's a product of colonialism.
What isn't?
Like, you know?
You know, the French colonial imperial power,
you know, like, wanted a baguette,
and that's what they got.
But the Vietnamese baguette has as much to do with France
as Japanese ramen has to do with Chinese ramen.
It's the reality that borders are really, they're arbitrary.
So the banh mi that immigrants had originally come
from Vietnam with, what's changed about it over time?
Lee's sandwich.
I think that changed a lot.
Brothers Henry and Chiu Le opened
the first Lee's sandwich's location in San Jose in 1983.
Henry Le died in 2016.
By then, they had more than 60 locations in multiple states.
Their innovation was that they had this neon sign
that would say hot baguettes.
All these chains kind of helped increase the profile
of banh mi in the U.S.,
but I think Lee's in particular,
because it was such a phenomenon, I think-
Didn't you try to bring Lee's sandwich
to your grandfather at some point?
Yeah, before I came to see him,
I made a pit stop at Lee's, brought him a sandwich.
I said, grandpa, you gotta try this.
And I thought he would really love it.
And he had one bite, and he goes, this is atrocious.
He was so offended.
And I go, it's great, what's going on?
He goes, oh, it's just cutting off the roof of my mouth,
you know, so he loves the, he loves the soft French fry too.
So I do think it has a lot to do with what you like,
you know, and what you grew up with.
So this is also your restaurant,
which is very cool and amazing.
So what do you want your food to do
in terms of introducing people to Vietnamese food,
or is maybe that's not the goal at all?
I don't care to introduce people to Vietnamese food,
but people are introduced to Vietnamese food
by my restaurant.
It was a crowd of people, you know what I mean?
Everyone's not the same?
Yeah.
You know, like I want it to reflect our full humanity.
That's my goal.
Like somebody one time asked like,
oh, I know about your restaurant.
I heard you serve Vietnamese food and then regular food.
Oh my God.
My understanding of that is regular food
is sort of what we think of stereotypically
as American food.
But aren't we at a point in 2018 where pho,
bánh mì, Vietnamese food is American food?
Absolutely.
I don't think you can deny it.
I mean, I think sometimes Anglo food is like the default,
but that's not really what America is
or has been for a very long time.
Well, this is awesome.
Thank you.
Loved eating everything that we had.
Thank you so much for letting me come here
and teaching me things about Vietnamese food.
I feel like my chopstick game has really risen 100%.
I saw the progression.
Yeah, it was great.
It was great for me.
I think that we can finally finish this now.
Lovely.
So I'm gonna do that.
