J. R. R. Tolkien - A Biography' by Humphrey Carpenter - Unabridged Audiobook - Part 8: Postscript

John Ronald Reuel Tolkien
30 followers
32 Video Views·May 25, 2023
Postscript
The Tree
Nowadays it is fashionable to regard the Inklings,
the handful of men who met at Mauldin on Thursday nights in the 1930s and 40s,
as a homogenous group of writers who exercised an influence over each other.
Whether or not you subscribe to this view, you may, if you are passing through Oxford,
decide to visit the graves of the three best-known Inklings, C.S. Lewis, Charles Williams,
You will find Lewis's tomb in the churchyard of his own parish,
Heddington Quarry. A plain slab marks this grave, which is shared with his brother,
Major W.H. Lewis. It is adorned with a simple cross, and with the words,
Men must endure their going hence.
Williams lies beneath a shadow of St. Cross Church, in the centre of Oxford.
His fellow Inkling, Hugo Dyson, is buried not far away, and the graveyard contains the tombs
of many other university men of their generation.
Lewis and Williams were members of the Church of England, but there is now no
Catholic burial place in Oxford other than the Corporation Cemetery at Wolvercote,
where a small area of ground is reserved for members of the Church of Rome.
So if you are searching for the remaining grave, you will have to travel far out from the centre
of the city, beyond the shops and the ring road, until you come to the tall iron gates.
Go through them and past the chapel, crossing the acres of other graves,
until you come to a section where many of the tombstones are Polish, for this is the
Catholic area, and the graves of emigres predominate over English adherence to that faith.
Several of the tombs bear glazed photographs of the deceased, in the inscriptions of Florida.
In consequence, a grey slab of Cornish granite, rather to the left of the group,
stands out clearly, as does its slightly curious wording.
Edith Mary Tolkien, Lucian, 1889-1971
John Ronald Ruel Tolkien, Beren, 1892-1973
The grave stands in suburban surroundings, very different from the English countryside
that Tolkien loved, but not dissimilar to the man-made places in which he spent most of his days.
So, even at the end, at this plain grave in a public cemetery, we are reminded of the antithesis
between the ordinary life he led and the extraordinary imagination that created his
mythology. Where did it come from, this imagination that peopled Middle-earth with elves, orcs,
and hominids? What was the source of the literary vision that changed the life of this obscure
scholar? And why did that vision so strike the minds and harmonize with the aspirations of
numberless readers around the world? Tolkien would have thought that these were unanswerable questions,
certainly unanswerable in a book of this sort. He disapproved of biography as an aid to literary
appreciation, and perhaps he was right. As real biography as The Hobbit, The Lord of the Rings,
and The Silmarillion, for the truth about him lies within their pages. But, at least,
we might allow an epitaph. His requiem mass was held in Oxford, four days after his death,
in the plain modern church in Heddington, which he had attended so often. The prayers and readings
were specially chosen by his son John, who said the mass with the assistance of Tolkien's old
friend, Father Robert Murray, and his perished priest, Monsieur Monseigneur Doran. There was
no sermon or quotation from his writings. However, when a week later a memorial service was held in
California, by some of his American admirers, his short story, A Leaf by Niggle, was read to the
congregation. He would perhaps have considered it not inappropriate. Before him stood the tree,
his tree, finished. If you could say that of a tree that was alive, its leaves opening,
its branches growing and bending in the wind, that Niggle had so often felt and guessed,
and had so often failed to catch. He gazed at the tree, and slowly he lifted his arms,
and opened them wide. It's a gift, he said.
The End
True to the end, no finer friend, now and for always, sit by the fire, lights glow,
tell us an old tale we know, tell of adventures strange and rare, never to change, ever to share,
stories we tell, we'll cast a spell, now and for always.
