'J. R. R. Tolkien - A Biography' by Humphrey Carpenter - Unabridged Audiobook - Part 6: Chapter 1

John Ronald Reuel Tolkien
30 followers
3 Video Views·May 18, 2023
Part 6 1949-1966
SUCCESS
CHAPTER 1 SLAMMING THE GATES
It had taken twelve years to write The Lord of the Rings.
By the time that he had finished it, Tolkien was not far from his sixtieth birthday.
Now, of course, he wanted to see the huge book in print,
but he was not sure that he wanted Ellen and Unwin to publish it,
even though he had discussed it with them while it was being written,
for he believed that he had now found someone who would publish it together with the Silmarillion.
Over the years he had become angry with Ellen and Unwin for rejecting the Silmarillion in 1937,
though in truth they had not really rejected it at all.
Stanley Unwin had merely said that it was not suitable as a sequel to The Hobbit,
and Tolkien had come to believe that it was a case of
once rejected, always rejected,
which was a pity, he thought, because he wanted to publish the Silmarillion.
It was possible to say that The Lord of the Rings stood up as an independent story,
but since it included obscure references to the earlier mythology,
it would be much better if the two books could be published together.
But most of all he wanted to find an audience for the earlier book,
and this seemed the ideal, perhaps the only, opportunity.
So when Milton Weldman from the publishing house of Collins showed an interest in publishing both works,
Tolkien was strongly inclined to abandon Ellen and Unwin and join forces with him.
Weldman, a Catholic, had been introduced to Tolkien by Gervais Mathieu,
a scholar and Dominican priest who often attended meetings of the Inklings.
When Weldman learned that Tolkien had completed a lengthy sequel to that very successful book The Hobbit,
he expressed interest, and late in 1949 Tolkien sent him a bulky manuscript.
But it was not The Lord of the Rings, it was the Silmarillion.
The earlier mythological work, begun in 1917 as The Book of Lost Tales, was still incomplete,
but Tolkien had begun work on it again while he was finishing The Lord of the Rings,
and it was in a sufficiently ordered state for Weldman to read it.
It was like nothing else Weldman had ever seen,
a strange, archaically worded tale of elves, evil powers and heroism.
Some of it was typed, but much was in finely lettered manuscript.
Weldman told Tolkien that he thought it was remarkable,
and he said that he wanted to publish it, providing Tolkien could finish it.
Tolkien was delighted. Weldman had passed the first test.
He had provisionally accepted the Silmarillion.
He was invited down to Oxford by Tolkien, and was handed the manuscript of The Lord of the Rings.
He took it on holiday, and began to read it.
By the beginning of January 1950 he had almost finished it,
and again he told Tolkien that he was delighted.
It is a real work of creation, he wrote, although he added that the length of the book worried him.
But he was very hopeful that Collins would be able to put it into print.
Indeed, they were in a good position to do so.
Most publishers, including Ellen and Unwin, had been desperately short of paper since the war.
However, Collins were not simply publishers, but were also stationers, diary manufacturers and printers,
so they had a far greater allowance of paper than most firms.
And as to the commercial viability of Tolkien's lengthy mythological stories,
the company's chairman, William Collins, had already told Weldman
that he would be happy to publish any fiction by the author of The Hobbit.
In fact, it was really the lucrative Hobbit that Collins wanted to acquire,
while Tolkien, unhappy with the first post-war reprint of The Hobbit,
which had, for economy reasons, been shorn of its coloured plates,
told Weldman that he would be happy to see it bought from Ellen and Unwin,
and reissued according to his original intentions.
He was also cross with Ellen and Unwin for what he considered to be
the inadequate publicity for Farmer Giles of Ham,
and he believed that Collins would be better at selling his books.
So all seemed set fair for a working partnership between Tolkien and Collins.
There was, however, one point which Weldman wished to clear up.
"'I take it,' he wrote to Tolkien,
"'that you have no commitment, either moral or legal, to Ellen and Unwin?'
Tolkien replied,
"'I believe myself to have no legal obligation.
"'There was a clause in the Contract for The Hobbit
"'providing for a two-month's consideration of my next book
"'that has been satisfied by
"'A. Stanley Unwin's subsequent rejection of The Silmarillion,
"'and B. by Farmer Giles.
"'But I have had friendly personal relations with Stanley, you,
"'and especially with his second son, Rainer.
"'If all this constitutes a moral obligation, then I am under one.
"'However, I shall certainly try to extricate myself,
"'or at least The Silmarillion and all its kin,
"'from the dilatory coils of A. and you, if I can,
"'in a friendly fashion, if possible.'"
Tolkien had, in fact, worked himself into a state of mind
in which he considered Ellen and Unwin to be if not an enemy,
then at least a very unreliable ally,
while Collins seemed to represent all that he hoped for.
The real position was much more complex, as events were to prove.
In February 1950, Tolkien wrote to Ellen and Unwin
to say that The Lord of the Rings was finished,
but he did not exactly encourage them to show an interest.
"'My work has escaped from my control,' he told them,
"'and I have produced a monster, an immensely long,
"'complex, rather bitter, and rather terrifying romance,
"'quite unfit for children, if fit for anybody,
"'and it is really not a sequel to The Hobbit, but to The Silmarillion.
"'Ridiculous and tiresome as you may think me,
"'I want to publish them both, The Silmarillion and The Lord of the Rings.
"'That is what I should like. Or I will let it all be.
"'I cannot contemplate any drastic rewriting or compression,
"'but I shall not have any just grievance,
"'nor shall I be dreadfully surprised
"'if you decline so obviously unprofitable the proposition.'"
Almost as a footnote, he added that the two books together
added up to the vast size of, in his estimate,
more than a million words.
Stanley Unwin replied,
admitting that the size of the books set a problem,
but asking whether they could not be split into
three or four to some extent self-contained volumes.
"'No,' answered Tolkien, "'they could not.
"'The only natural division was between the two works themselves.'
"'And he went even further in deliberately discouraging Unwin
"'from showing any more interest.
"'I now wonder,' he wrote,
"'whether many beyond my friends, not all of whom have endured to the end,
"'would read anything so long.
"'Please do not think I shall feel I have a just grievance
"'if you decline to become involved.'
"'I profoundly hope that he will let go without demanding the MS,'
"'he wrote to Waldman.
"'But says Stanley Unwin, who had received a knighthood just after the war,
"'was not to be deterred so easily.
"'He wrote to his son Rainer, who was studying at Harvard,
"'and asked for his advice.
"'Rainer replied,
"'The Lord of the Rings is a very great book in its own curious way,
"'and deserves to be produced somehow.
"'I never felt the lack of a Silmarillion when reading it.
"'But although he claims not to contemplate any drastically writing, etc.,
"'surely this is the case for an editor who would incorporate
"'any rarely relevant material from the Silmarillion
"'into The Lord of the Rings,
"'without increasing the already enormous bulk of the letter,
"'and, if feasible, even cutting it.
"'Tolkien wouldn't do it,
"'but someone whom he could trust and who had sympathy,
"'one of his sons, might possibly do it.
"'If this is not workable,
"'I would say publish The Lord of the Rings as a prestige book,
"'and after having a second look at it,
"'drop the Silmarillion.'
"'Unwisely, Stanley Unwin sent a copy of this letter to Tolkien.
"'Tolkien was furious.
"'He wrote to Unwin in April 1950
"'that Rainer's letter confirmed his worst suspicions.
"'In other words, that you may be willing to take The Lord,
"'but that is more than enough,
"'and you do not want any trimmings,
"'certainly not The Silmarillion,
"'which you have no intention of genuinely reconsidering.
"'A rejection is, after all, a rejection,
"'and remains valid.
"'But the question of dropping The Silmarillion after a discreet fame
"'and taking The Lord, edited, just does not arise.
"'I have not offered, am not offering The Lord of the Rings to you,
"'or anyone else, on such conditions,
"'as surely I made plain before.
"'I want a decision, yes or no,
"'to the proposal I make,
"'and not to any imagined possibility.'
"'Stanley Unwin replied on the 17th of April,
"'I am more sorry than I can say
"'that you should feel it necessary
"'to present me with an ultimatum,
"'particularly one in connection with a manuscript
"'which I have never seen in its final and complete form.
"'As you demand an immediate yes or no,
"'the answer is no.
"'But it might well have been yes,
"'given time and the site of the typescript.
"'With sorrow, I must before leave it at that.'
Tolkien had achieved his objective.
Now he was free to publish with Collins.
In the meantime, he was moving house once again.
Merton College had offered him 99 Holywell,
an old house of much character with a large number of rooms,
and he, Edith and Priscilla moved there from Manor Road,
which is only a few hundred yards away,
in the early spring of 1950.
Priscilla was now an undergraduate at Lady Margaret Hall,
while Christopher, no longer living at home,
was working as a freelance tutor in the English faculty
and completing a B. lit.
Milton Weldman of Collins was quite certain in his own mind
that his firm would publish Tolkien's books.
He arranged for Tolkien to come to the Collins offices in London,
and he met William Collins
and discussed the books with the production department.
All seemed ready for an agreement to be signed
and The Lord of the Rings to be put into print,
likewise The Silmarillion, when it was finished,
although Tolkien would still have to do
a good deal of work on the letter book
before it was in a publishable state.
There was just one matter that remained to be settled.
In May 1950, Weldman came to Oxford
and told Tolkien that The Lord of the Rings
urgently wanted cutting.
Tolkien was dismayed.
He told Weldman that he had cut often and hard already,
but he would try again as soon as he found the time.
Weldman, in his turn, was taken aback to learn
that in Tolkien's estimate The Silmarillion would,
when completed, be almost as long as The Lord of the Rings,
taken aback because the manuscript that he had read
was nothing like so lengthy.
Tolkien's estimate was, in fact, wildly inaccurate.
The total length of The Silmarillion,
as then planned for publication,
would perhaps have been as much as 125,000 words,
maybe less, but certainly nothing like as long
as the half-million or so words of The Lord of the Rings.
But Tolkien, who considered that The Silmarillion
was as important as the letter book,
had come to believe that, in consequence,
it was as long.
Nor did he help matters at this juncture
by handing Weldman several additional chapters
from The Silmarillion without explaining
how they fitted into the story.
Weldman was a little puzzled by them.
They leave me rather bewildered, he said.
Altogether, negotiations, which should have been
clear and simple, were becoming confused.
At this point, Weldman left for Italy,
where he generally spent much of the year,
only visiting London during the spring and autumn.
His absence did not help.
William Collins knew little about Tolkien's books
and had left the whole business in Weldman's hands.
Then Weldman became ill and his autumn trip
to London was delayed.
The consequence was that by the end of 1950,
a year after the completion of The Lord of the Rings,
Tolkien found that he was no nearer to publishing it.
Word of this percolated through to Stanley Unwin,
who wrote to say that he still hoped
to have the privilege of being connected
with its publication.
But Tolkien was not to be wooed back
to Ellen and Unwin so easily.
His reply was friendly, but he made no reference
to the book.
Much of Tolkien's time was occupied by academic
and administrative duties in Oxford,
and by visits to Belgium for philological work,
and to Ireland as an examiner.
And soon another year had passed
with nothing further achieved towards publication.
Late in 1951, he wrote a long letter
to Milton Weldman,
outlining in about 10,000 words
the structure of his entire mythology,
and hoping by this to convince Weldman
that the books were interdependent and indivisible.
But by March 1951,
he had still not signed an agreement with Collins,
and the Silmarillion was still not ready
for publication.
William Collins was in South Africa,
Weldman was in Italy,
and the price of paper had soared.
Tolkien, who had rarely been as much responsible
for the delay as anyone,
wrote to Collins saying that his time
had been wasted.
Either they must publish The Lord of the Rings
immediately, or he would send the manuscript
back to Ellen and Unwin.
The result was inevitable,
for William Collins did not like Ultimata
any more than did Stanley Unwin.
He came back from South Africa,
read Tolkien's letter,
and replied on the 18th of April, 1952.
I am afraid we are frightened
by the very great length of the book,
which, with the present cost of paper,
does mean a very big outlay.
And he told Tolkien that it did indeed seem
best for him to send the manuscript back
to Ellen and Unwin.
But would Ellen and Unwin have him back?
On the 22nd of June, 1952,
Tolkien wrote to Rainer Unwin,
now returned to England and working
for his father's firm.
As for The Lord of the Rings and The Silmarillion,
they are where they were,
the one finished, the other still unfinished,
or unrevised, in both gathering dust.
I have rather modified my views,
better something than nothing,
for though to me all are one,
and The Lord of the Rings will be
better far and eased as part of the whole,
I would gladly consider the publication
of any part of the stuff.
The years are becoming precious,
but about The Lord of the Rings,
can anything be done about that?
When luck gets, I slammed myself.
