AIR FRYER Shrimp v. OVEN Shrimp | Which is the CRISPY Winner?

Cordial Cooks
243 followers
323 Video Views·May 18, 2023
Hey everyone, it is the battle of crispy breaded shrimp.
Air fryer versus oven.
I'm going to be rating them on three different categories.
I'm Erin from WellPlated.com.
To see which wins, let's make them together and find out.
When I was in high school, if I wanted a hot lunch,
it came out of my work money.
I worked a minimum wage job,
so I was packing my lunch most days.
I had one important exception,
or should I call it a temptation?
That was fried shrimp day.
I had that one circled on my calendar.
Pretty sure I circled it in probably
some cute colored gel pen.
I was very into those back then.
Today I am looking to recreate a version
of the fried shrimp that I loved so much in high school,
but I am doing it in a healthy way,
in the air fryer and in the oven,
and that way we will figure out
which one is really the best.
To start this recipe,
I am using a pound of jumbo frozen shrimp.
I bought them already peeled and deveined,
and then just rinsed them under some cool water
to thaw them before adding them to the bowl.
You may have noticed me patting them dry with a paper towel.
I did that just because it will help
the breadcrumb coating stick a little bit better,
and that will make the shrimp more crispy.
Listen, you do not need to spring for fresh shrimp for this.
Not only are they a total pain to prep,
but the flavor payoff is just not there.
Most of the shrimp that you buy at the seafood counter,
unless you are lucky enough to live on the Gulf
and have access to fresh shrimp, is frozen anyway.
Give yourself a shortcut.
Buy the frozen one that is already peeled and deveined.
To doctor our shrimp up, I am adding some lemon zest,
and I like to zest directly over the bowl.
When you zest any piece of citrus,
some flavorful oils escape,
and by doing it over the bowl,
you make sure that you don't lose those.
I added a variety of herbs, some parsley,
oregano, garlic powder, good old salt and pepper.
Oh, hello.
Help if I cut the lemon to juice it.
So we're gonna use every little bit of this lemon too.
Getting a little ahead of myself.
I love this citrus juicer tip.
You actually put it in here cut side down.
I think I just picked up on that maybe a couple of years ago.
I was using it wrong for a long time.
Little bit of olive oil.
I'm gonna eyeball it.
Now we stir to combine.
I'm gonna set this aside to marinate a bit
so the flavors can get cozy
and then get to work on that breading.
Back in high school,
I could not resist that crispy fried batter.
To my 15-year-old palate,
it was the epitome of gourmet.
It was probably about 120% of my daily sodium intake,
and it was definitely more breading than shrimp,
but back then, I didn't care.
Today, I care more,
which is why I am looking to create a healthy version
of that breaded shrimp that I loved so much
back in high school that still passes flavor muster.
You want two shallow bowls.
I like to use pie plates because they work really well,
but any shallow bowl is just fine.
In this first bowl,
I am combining Italian seasoned breadcrumbs.
I like to use the ones that are already seasoned
because it saves me a step,
with some Parmesan cheese.
We want the Parmesan just because we are not
dunking the shrimp in a vat of oil,
so we need to make sure that it still has
a little bit of indulgent richness
that lives up to the crispy fried shrimp
of high school errands memory.
In this pie dish, I am beating together one large egg.
The egg is what makes sure that our breadcrumb coating
actually sticks to the shrimp.
Dunk the shrimp in the egg,
and then right over into the breading mixture.
I usually work a few at a time.
So now with this hand,
I am going to toss them in the breadcrumbs,
and then this one I'm gonna try to keep out of the plate
just to keep things a little bit tidier.
Coat the shrimp on all sides,
shake off any excess,
and then put it onto a sheet pan or a big plate.
This is going to be kind of our staging station.
For our battle of the shrimp,
I will be grading on three key categories,
crispiness, ease of preparation,
and which one best lives up to the deep fried experience.
Let the battle commence.
I'm gonna cook half of the shrimp in the air fryer.
The other half are going into the oven.
Going to air fry at 390 degrees for just four minutes.
The air fryer is quick.
In my oven, it'll be 400 degrees
for about eight to 12 minutes.
For both, I'm going to flip the shrimp over halfway through
and hit them with a little nonstick spray
to help them get nice and brown.
The ones that go into the oven,
I have elevated on a cooling rack.
That will help the air circulate so that they cook evenly.
And in the air fryer,
I'm putting the shrimp in just a single layer.
Again, we need that air circulation.
This means if you're air frying a lot of shrimp,
you'll need to cook it in multiple batches.
It is judgment time.
On our blue plate, I have the air fryer shrimp.
On our gray plate, I have the oven shrimp.
Only the taste will tell.
There is a really nice crispiness on this shrimp.
You can even see the difference with the golden color
and the shrimp is pretty juicy.
Let's see how it stacks up
to the ones we baked in the oven.
I'd say the shrimp is equally juicy,
but this breading definitely tastes a bit more damp,
didn't get quite as crunchy.
So in the crispy crunchy category,
I'm giving it to the air fryer.
Category two, ease of preparation.
This one for me is a tie.
The air fryer cooks the shrimp super quickly,
just four minutes,
but you have to do it in multiple batches.
For a pound of shrimp in my air fryer,
it took about three batches.
In the oven, you can do all the shrimp at once,
but it takes a little longer.
As far as our third and most important category,
the overall winner, I'm gonna give it to
the air fryer shrimp.
When we are craving something crispy and deep fried,
these are what is going to seal the deal.
Do you have any burning air fryer questions?
Please leave them in the comment section below.
Don't forget to check out my killer air fryer chicken breast,
another excellent way to use your air fryer,
and I hope to see you next time.
Mm, now that is well-plated.
