Aaron Judge Cheating?

Antonelli Baseball
48 followers
1 Video View·May 17, 2023
Now Aaron Judge was caught on camera twice looking out of the corner of his eye before
hitting an absolute mammoth homer on the setter.
Blue Jays announcers asked what he was looking at and they mentioned he could be looking
at the catcher for location but didn't want to accuse him of that.
Watch what he's looking at.
What is that?
Where's he looking?
And he did it more than once.
Yeah.
Just did it again.
I'm not going to accuse him either but I'm going to talk about what I've seen players
do in the past.
I'm not saying this is what Aaron did because only he knows but this is what could have
been happening.
Now after the game he was asked by reporters what he was looking at and at first he was
perplexed by the question but when asked a second time he said he was looking at the
bench to see who was chirping at the umpires in a 6-0 game.
Now to me his glances are too quick to be able to scan an entire dugout and see who's
yelling.
There's a lot of guys over there and he glances for like a split second.
But again he said that's what he did so I'm going to believe him.
So let's get back to the announcer's thoughts of glancing at the catcher.
First off this 100% happens in games.
Not all the time but it happens.
Now the announcers and a lot of people on Twitter are saying you can't see the catcher
by looking at the pitcher and glancing to the side but I'm telling you 100% that you
can.
Now you can't see their signs and they don't even give signs anymore but you can see where
the catcher is setting up.
So try this right now because I'm doing it.
Look out like you're looking at a pitcher and glance to your right.
You can see behind you just enough to see if a catcher is moving towards the outside
part of the plate or the inside part of the plate.
Now if you can't see them then your peripheral vision isn't great because I'm doing it and
I can definitely see behind me.
And when you do this remember you're not looking for signs from the catcher.
All you're doing is you're trying to catch a quick glance at which direction his body
goes.
So if I'm doing it here you see the catcher is about to set up.
So right there.
So all I'm looking for is this movement right here.
As he starts to shift to the outside part of the plate now I know he's set up away.
Now catchers are taught to set up late for this reason.
They don't want to set up early because a hitter could see or they could hear the direction
that you're moving.
If Aaron knows their opposing teams attack him in two ways, sliders away and fastballs
in which is a typical pattern to a lot of hitters but especially to big power hitters
that he knows that if you set up away it's a breaking ball and if you set up in it's
a fastball.
So all he needs to see is a little bit of the catcher's body moving away or a little
bit of it disappearing in and he knows the pitch.
So again if he sees this little shift right here he knows slider.
If instead the catcher were to move this way and kind of disappears out of his peripheral
vision he knows it's fastball.
Now I've seen a lot of catchers will set hitters up so if they have any angling that a hitter
might be peeking then they'll call a fastball in, they'll set up early away and then at
the last second they'll switch back to the inside.
And also for anyone that says oh this doesn't happen, back when catchers would give actual
signs and not use pitch con they would typically look up at hitters eyes while giving the signs
to make sure that they weren't peeking back.
There are definitely certain hitters in the league that would peek back and try to see
signs.
I've heard catchers tell hitters to get their eyes away from their signs.
They said it a lot meaner than that.
I've also been on teams where we intentionally threw at batters for looking back at signs.
I've been in dugouts where the catcher will say that a certain guy keeps peeking at his
signs and if he does it again they're going to hit him.
And what do you know?
He does it again and they hit him.
And then they let him know that if he keeps it up he'll continue to be hit.
And I've also seen hitters do this same type of thing in day games but instead of peeking
back you peek down.
Because at certain times of the day depending on how the shadows are falling you can see
if you look down you can see the shadow of the catcher and you can tell if they're moving
away or if they're moving in.
So this has been part of the game for a while and I'm not saying that this is what Aaron
Judge is doing.
I'm just saying that it does happen.
I've seen it with my own two eyes.
Now here's another interesting possibility.
So this is Aaron Judge on the on-deck circle before his at-bat and you can see him looking
over at the bench and he's going to make a sign right there.
Slider.
All right.
Fastball.
Okay.
Got it.
So what is he doing here?
Now again I'm not accusing him of anything because I have no idea but I'm just telling
you what I've seen in the past.
Either the pitcher or the catcher again could be tipping something.
So the hitter instead of getting it with his own eyes could be looking at the bench.
So let's just for example say that the catcher setting up too early.
Well if the catcher sets up away there could be some type of signal coming from the bench.
Someone on the bench could relay that to Aaron.
Now you don't want to do it verbally because that can be heard but it could be a simple
hand gesture or something quick from a player on the bench.
And it's almost like he's going through a little quick quiz right here.
So he's like okay slider.
That's what you're going to do.
Okay.
And what are you doing now?
Yep.
That would be a fastball.
Right.
Okay.
We're on the same page.
All right.
Got it.
Now again there's nothing preventing a team or a bench from looking at a catcher seeing
the way he's setting up and then relaying in where he's setting up.
That stuff happens all the time as well.
I've been on teams that have done it before.
I've seen teams do it before.
It's the pitcher and the catcher's job to make sure that they don't fall into patterns
and give away what pitchers are coming.
And if you can pick it up go for it.
I played with Adrian Gonzalez who is the best I've ever seen at picking up signs or tells
from the pitcher.
He could look at a pitcher and very quickly go through our entire bench and say when the
pitcher sets his glove up here it's going to be a curveball.
When the pitcher sets his glove up here it's going to be a fastball.
So again I'm not saying that's what they're doing but it is a possibility.
I've seen it before.
So that's all I have.
Let me know if you have any questions in the comments section below or comments.
Subscribe to the channel.
Hit the notification bell.
Give it a thumbs up.
All that good stuff.
And we'll talk to you later.
