Where did it go wrong for Southampton this season?

Sky Sports News
24 followers
1 Video View·May 15, 2023
To Southampton, the first side relegated from the Premier League this season on Saturday after 11
years in the top division. They'll drop down into the championship after a 2-0 defeat to Fulham
on Saturday. Paul, I think that the most sad thing for Southampton fans was that they went
with a whimper in the end, there didn't seem to be any fight there. Didn't they just eight
losses, three draws in the last 11 games. It was almost, they were sleepwalking towards
relegation from a long way out. I think the temporary appointment of the manager I don't
think gave the fans much hope at that time. They clearly got it wrong with Nathan Jones
mid-season, it didn't work for them. I think the three managerial appointments this season
obviously cost them. I think, like you say, the lack of fight that they had, they were
almost sleepwalking towards relegation. The appointment of Nathan Jones mid-season I think
was potentially something that they got wrong. Wrong man at the wrong time for the wrong club.
I think, don't doubt his managerial credentials when you look at what he's done in the championship
but at the time he wasn't able to do it at Southampton, he came into a dressing room
and it just didn't work. From then on you appoint Ruben Seles who has no real managerial
experiences, he goes to Stamford Bridge and gets a fantastic result that you think at the time.
But a lot of people got fantastic results if that's what you call them this year at
Stamford Bridge. It's not a mark of a good season really. If you give the manager a job
off the back of a win at Chelsea this year it's not much of a marker. He's been in there,
he's not been able to get a tune out of the players, he's not been able to get them winning
games and inevitably that's cost them. I think recruitment, they signed a striker in January,
spent most of the second half of the season on the bench. I think their recruitment's been poor,
their recruitment of experienced players has been poor. Listen there's quality players on that side
when you look at Bednar, you look at Ward-Prouse, you look at other players in there, they have got
that ability to win games but the manager just couldn't get a formation or a formula together to
do that. Much has been made of their recruitment. Too young, not enough experience. If you're down
there in a scrap what you need is some old, gnarled campaigners. There's hope for Paul yet.
Is that a fair comment? Yeah it is and it's probably something that we've praised Southampton
for previously, many years ago where we've said they've sold a player but then they've brought
somebody in, the recruitment's been very good, who've matched that but I think you're bringing
in potential there aren't you? There's a lot of good young players but I just think you need that
experience in and around, especially when you're losing some experience too. When you're in a fight
I think you need players that have probably been there and done it and there was too many
young players. Yes, there is potential, there is quality there but probably just not enough for the
season so that's certainly something that they need to look at, the recruitment side of things.
Obviously having three managers in a season isn't going to help with chopping and changing and
different ways of playing and things so yeah it's been a real difficult season I think for
Southampton and the fact that they sort of went down with a whimper was really sad for the fans.
They've got Jason Wilcox going in there now, I think as a director of football, who's headed
Manchester City's academy for a while and I'd like to think he has a big input and the new manager,
the direction the club's going, it's a clear change in direction by bringing somebody like that in,
somebody who has vast experience, vast knowledge of the game and has a clear vision of what he
wants to do and if he's given a role where he has an input in appointing the manager,
the recruitment, that strategy's obviously changed by bringing him in so it's a different direction
they're going in but when you look at the money that's been invested on players that have
underachieved, that haven't played regularly and haven't played well, it's an astonishing amount
of money that they've actually spent especially in January.
Yeah, the argument is as well is maybe hindsight's a wonderful good thing, gives you a 2020 vision
doesn't it but Ralph Harsenhutl, his points per game this season has been the best of all three
managers they've had, it was November, he'd proved in previous seasons that if they're in a sticky
patch he could get them out of it and get them safe, was that the wrong decision?
Potentially, I mean like you say hindsight is a great thing to have but I think if
Southampton for the last couple of seasons have always been a team that can go on a bad run but
can equally go on a good run, we were at the beginning of last season I think they were
like in the top four of the division and then they went on a terrible run, it was relegation for them
and under Harsenhutl they had that trait of going on a really good run and a really bad run
but never being consistent and never being able to put a run of results together and I think it's
his sacking in hindsight, you look at the Nathan Jones appointment didn't work, Ruben Sellers didn't
get a tune out of the players, you ask Southampton fans and listen I'm not close to the club so I
don't know but I suspect in February, January, February time if you'd have said do you want
Nathan Jones, Ruben Sellers or Harsenhutl at the club I think they'd have probably taken Harsenhutl
because he could get a result when they needed a result. Sellers, he's manager until the end of
the season, does he for you stay on, take them into what they hope would be a promotion campaign?
Well I listened to an interview with him and he said look he wants to be there for the next
10 years, I think he's out of contractors near the end of June, I'm not sure if they'll continue
with him but I think whoever they bring in it's got to be the right appointment, it's got to be
somebody that's going to coach these young players, develop these young players and I think like you
said that the change in direction in the club it's got to be somebody that's going to work together
because it just needs a reset doesn't it and I think that's what they're going to do so
he wants to stay but whether that's for the best of the club I'm not sure. Well look at his results
I mean eight losses and three draws in the last 11 games, it's not like they've gone down with a
fight, if you want the manager's job and you want to stay at a club and you
want to develop and build things okay you've got a couple of good results at the beginning of his
tenure but does he know the Championship, one of the hardest leagues in the world that we know about
I think if they are going to restructure and reboot you look at the job that Vincent Company's
done at Burnley this year, that type of manager, look at what Michael Carrick's done at Middlesbrough
this year, I think for Southampton I think you know they've got to look at those type of
managers, I mean Stephen Gerrard's still out there, you look at the job that he did at Rangers
okay at Villa it didn't quite go well for him but you put him in the same bracket as Vincent
Company, Michael Carrick, those type of managers and Gary Rowett at Millwall he's done an absolutely
extremely good job on his budget and on his playing staff, if you could tempt a manager
away like that and keep a squad together in a budget at Southampton it's an attractive proposition
for somebody. What about James Ward-Prowse, I mean it feels like he should be about 45
he's been at Southampton so long, he's only 28, he's been there for 20 years though at the club
signed as an eight-year-old, is it inevitable that he will move on and if so where would be a
good fit for him? I don't think it's inevitable that he'll move on, I think there will be a number
of suitors for him to potentially move on and I think he probably he's put himself in a fantastic
position because he's shone again this year, he's been an absolute example, a leader in that
tough times, he's put in performances, hardest thing to do for a player is play well when your
team's not playing well and he's done that this year and I think his dedication to stay at the
top level for as long as he has, I think he's, we all talk about his ability with dead balls and
free kicks, that's an ability in itself that some clubs will look at. Southampton will be tested
this year, this summer, bids will come in for him and I think it depends on what direction the club
wants to go, what talks he's going to have with the club and I think he's earned the right to
actually decide what he wants to do himself. Right, a simple yes or no, will they bounce
straight back? Yes. Depends on the manager, no. No, okay.
