Tycho Brahe, Johannes Kepler and Planetary Motion(1/2)
5 Video Views·May 6, 2023
The Sun, the center of the universe. The Earth, just an ordinary planet orbiting the Sun, like all the other planets.
With this bold insight, the 16th century astronomer, Nicolaus Copernicus,
ushered in a fundamentally new view of our solar system. It was a scientific revolution.
But it was not until half a century later that the German mathematician, Johannes Kepler,
using observational data provided by the Danish astronomer, Tushar Brahe,
succeeded in drawing an exact picture of the solar system.
Since time immemorial, man has taken an interest in the heavenly bodies and sought to understand the rules by which they move.
It was soon noticed that most stars seem not to move relative to each other. These were known as fixed stars.
Where they formed conspicuous patterns in the sky, they were grouped together in constellations.
Mythological significance was attached to these groupings.
In the course of a night, the stars revolve in a circle around the pole star, or at least they seem to.
For today, we know that it is really the Earth that moves.
Greek philosophers regarded the circle as the perfect form, and at the center of this circle, they were sure was the Earth immobile.
But it was also noticed that some stars did move relative to the others.
These were called planets, after the Greek word for wanderers.
Curiously, sometimes some of these planets seem to be moving backwards.
Mars, for example, when observed from Earth, moves slowly from west to east for months,
then seems to come to a halt and move east to west for a few weeks before continuing in its original direction.
In order to keep Mars conceptually on a circular orbit, which they regarded as ideal,
Greek astronomers hit on the idea that these planets might move on circles within circles, known to mathematicians as epicycles.
In around 100 AD, the astronomer Claudius Ptolemy, who lived in Alexandria in Egypt,
summarized the work of the Greek astronomers before him into a system that was to hold sway for more than a thousand years.
In this Ptolemaic system, the Earth is at the center of everything.
All the celestial bodies revolve around it.
Ptolemy assumed a total of 70 circular movements, all going on at the same time independently of each other.
This system allowed him to predict the positions of the planets with reasonable accuracy.
During the Middle Ages, the Arabs brought back to Europe the knowledge which they had inherited from the Greeks.
From then on, the Ptolemaic system determined the world view of the Catholic Church.
But could God's creation not be explained rather more simply?
This question occupied the Polish scholar Nicholas Copernicus in the early 16th century.
After years of calculations, he came to the conclusion that all the planets moved at uniform speeds in orbits around not the Earth,
but the Sun, which he thought was at the center of all things.
But he had no way of proving this.
The Catholic Church rejected the Copernican system and placed his writings on the index of banned books.
The German reformer Martin Luther didn't think much of the new theory either.
For him, Copernicus was just a fool.
Even so, Copernicus had his supporters.
One of them, a teacher at the Protestant University of Tübingen, was the astronomer Michel Meslin.
He had a student named Johannes Kepler.
Johannes Kepler was born on the 27th of December, 1571, in Weil, a small town in southern Germany.
Although his parents were poor, he was able to attend school.
The Protestant state of Württemberg provided all of its children with three years of free education.
It was soon realized that young Johannes was a bright boy, and he was sent off to Tübingen University with excellent school grades.
There, Michel Meslin fired his interest in mathematics, astronomy, and the Copernican system.
Young Kepler had wanted to become a pastor, but now he felt himself called upon to provide a proof of Copernicus' theories.
It was also Meslin who persuaded the 23-year-old Kepler to go to the Protestant Austrian city of Graz,
where they needed not only a good mathematician, but a Protestant mathematician.
One of Kepler's responsibilities in Graz, alongside mathematics, was to produce an annual calendar and horoscope.
But Kepler was not interested in putting the exploration of the heavens to such banal use as making earthly predictions.
In 1596, he published his Mysterion Cosmographicum,
the secret of the universe, in which he defended the Copernican system, but still he had no proof.
One man who thought he did have proof was the Danish astronomer Tucho Brahe,
not of the Copernican system, but of the Tuchonic system, named after him.
This still had the Earth in the center,
but he thought it was orbited only by the Sun and the Moon.
All the other planets in the spirit of Copernicus went round the Sun.
Brahe found that his model would precisely explain the planetary movements as seen from the Earth,
except for that of Mars, which still showed irregularities.
Brahe had at his disposal the best observatory of the age.
His patron, King Frederick II of Denmark, had even given him the use of the island of Fenn for just this purpose.
Here, Brahe was able to observe the night sky undisturbed.
His rapidly growing and very accurate database made him famous throughout Europe.
But when Frederick died, Brahe's days on Fenn were numbered.
The new king, Christian IV, was no longer willing to finance this often domineering astronomer.
Brahe left his observatory, island and homeland in disappointment.
Two years later, the man with the golden nose, he had lost his own in a duel,
was wandering around Central Europe when he found a new sponsor.
He became court astronomer to the Holy Roman Emperor, Rudolf II in Prague.
Some 30 kilometers from the city, in Vernadsky Castle, Brahe set up a new observatory,
with the best instruments money could buy.
What he lacked was a capable assistant who could derive the definitive proof of the two-sonic system from his extensive database.
Kepler applied for the post and got it.
He had already had to leave Graz after the city was reoccupied by Austrian Catholics.
Any Protestants had either to return to the old faith or clear out.
In the summer of 1600, Kepler arrived in Vernadsky Castle and took up his employment with Brahe.
Relations between the two men were tense from the outset.
Brahe regarded Kepler as a mere assistant, someone to whom he could delegate mathematical tasks, a human computer in other words.
Kepler, though, was a sensitive man and Brahe's domineering manner irritated him.
Quite apart from that, he thought the two-sonic system was plain wrong, but he kept his mouth shut on that score.
He had come to Prague to make use of Brahe's observational data, the best in existence, and he wanted to keep his job.
Then, just a year after his arrival, things suddenly changed with the unexpected death of Tucho Brahe.
On his deathbed, Tucho had implored his assistant to fight for the final recognition of the two-sonic system, but Kepler was unable and unwilling to keep his promise.
Now, as Brahe's successor at the court of Emperor Rudolf II,
he found himself in possession of papers which would finally ditch any view of the universe, including the two-sonic which placed the Earth at the center.
Kepler looked particularly hard at Mars, whose orbit Brahe had measured.
He sought to understand the planet's path in Copernican terms.
After four years of hard work, he realized this wasn't possible.
There was only one conclusion, something in Copernicus' theory was wrong.
As a result, Kepler came to formulate his first law, which dispensed with the two-thousand-year-old tradition.
The planetary orbits were not circles, but ellipses, with the Sun at one focus.
Kepler also slaughtered another sacred cow, namely the idea that the planets moved at constant speeds.
In reality, they move faster when nearer the Sun than when further away.
In his second law, he showed, again using Brahe's data,
that an imaginary line between a planet and the Sun sweeps out equal areas in equal times.
Kepler published both laws in his second law.

