The Decline of Iron Chef America and The Food Network

Bobby Flay
372 followers
106 Video Views·Apr 25, 2023
In the mid-1990s, TV was all about two things. Action and sports.
The Walt Disney Company's acquisition of ABC and ESPN had led to a programming shift that could
only be described as… radical. In stark contrast, mid-90s food network was boring and cerebral.
Most of the shows were just chefs standing around cooking some food,
sometimes in front of an audience. Of course you had some standouts like Emeril Lagasse,
who were able to amass a large viewership with a bombastic brand.
But most of these cooking shows were meant to be purely educational,
and feature dense explanations of recipes and cooking techniques.
That was until in 1999, when the Food Network started airing
English-dubbed episodes of the Japanese cooking show, Iron Chef.
See, Iron Chef did something that no other cooking show at the time was able to do.
They treated cooking like it was a sport, and the chef like an athlete.
These dubbed episodes were such a hit in America, that they even inspired a SNL skit.
A couple months later, Fuji Television would bring Iron Chef to New York City,
for a special battle between Iron Chef Japan Masaharu Morimoto, and celebrity chef Bobby Flay.
Most of the battle was your standard Iron Chef episode, until the very end when Bobby Flay,
in an early victory celebration, hopped up on top of his cutting board and thrust
both his fists in the air. Something that was considered very disrespectful to Morimoto.
Morimoto went on to defeat Bobby Flay in Battle Rock Crab by 8 points.
Bobby responded to this loss by complaining about the cooking equipment.
The success of the dubbed episodes, and New York special, brought tons of viewers to the Food
Network. But they weren't going to grow, without bringing something new to the table.
The producers quickly realized that they already had their own roster of star Iron Chefs.
So in 2004, the Food Network would produce a special crossover episode with the original
Iron Chef series, called Iron Chef Battle of the Masters.
The battle featured Iron Chefs Hiroyuki Sakai and Masaharu Morimoto from the Japanese series,
going head to head against three American Iron Chefs, Bobby Flay, Wolfgang Puck, and Mario Batali.
While these battles mostly served as a ceremonial bridge between the original Iron Chef series and
its new spinoff, the competition between chefs was some of the most serious. The first matchup,
Battle Trout, was between Bobby Flay and Iron Chef Sakai, and featured the infamous
trout-flavored ice cream.
The trout ice cream would go down in history as one of the worst dishes ever presented on Iron Chef,
becoming an inside joke mentioned multiple times throughout the series.
The next two battles both featured Iron Chef Morimoto.
First, he went up against Mario Batali in Battle Spiny Lobster, and lost.
Then, he went up against Chef Wolfgang Puck in Battle Eggs, and lost again.
Despite losing both his battles, Morimoto was looked at as one of the highest value
competitors in Iron Chef history. After the Battle of the Masters, Morimoto would go on
to join the Iron Chef America cast, and would further solidify the legitimacy of the brand
new iteration of Kitchen Stadium. After the success of Battle of the Masters, the Food Network was
to dive straight into the first season of Iron Chef America. But Wolfgang Puck was starting to
blow up with his eponymous chain of casual family restaurants, and no longer had time for Iron Chef,
so he was quickly replaced with Chef Cat Cora, who would join Morimoto in rounding out the roster of
four Iron Chefs for season one. Also returning from Battle of the Masters was the show's
commentator, Alton Brown. When you think of Iron Chef America, perhaps its biggest character,
even more than the flamboyant chairman, is Alton Brown. His expert commentary as a
play-by-play announcer is the main element that makes Iron Chef America so much like a sports
show. Aside from Iron Chef, Alton Brown's Good Eats show laid the foundation for what
most of culinary YouTube looks like today. Nowadays, people on the internet still praise
Alton Brown, despite the New York Times outing him as a proud, politically conservative southerner
who carries a bible and a firearm. All enough to say, don't meet your heroes. And don't spend too
long googling them either, or else you might find out about how they also endorsed a known child
predator in the appendix of their cookbook. Yup, Alton Brown did that too. It does seem, however,
that between his second divorce and third marriage, that Alton has made a pivot in his political
beliefs. Aside from the personal stuff, Alton Brown was incredibly dedicated to his Iron Chef
America job, something that would eventually lead to him leaving the food network for good.
But more on that later. Iron Chef America was one of those special TV shows that managed to be
educational and entertaining at the same time. Although it wasn't tied to a culinary institution
like the original series, Iron Chef America managed to get the masses interested in cooking.
And that was the point. See, Iron Chef America was not a cheap show to produce. The decadent
ingredients and enormous New York City kitchen stadium meant that a 10 episode run would cost
more than 5 times what a typical Food Network show would cost. But the Food Network's theory
was that over time, fans of Iron Chef America would begin to seek out more content from the
Food Network, which would in turn raise overall viewership. And they were right. Iron Chef
America was an instant hit, and would soon become the Food Network's biggest property.
In season 6, Chef Michael Simon would join the cast.
It's all good in the hood.
Then, season 8 would bring Jose Garces. Season 9, Mark Forgione.
And I'll take the butter whenever you're ready, dude.
Season 10 would bring Jeffrey Zakarian.
We're gonna show him up.
And then finally, season 11 would add Alex Garnaschelli.
Hell yeah.
By season 12, Iron Chef America had run for almost 200 episodes.
But by this point, it was 2013, and the formula for Iron Chef had begun to grow stale.
Jerky!
Grapes!
Avocado!
Lemons!
Mexican!
Chocolate!
Mozzarella!
At the same time, soon-to-be hit show Guy's Grocery Games would make its series premiere.
Welcome to Guy's Grocery Games. Go!
On this show, the chefs are cooking and shopping exactly the way you do.
Triple G would further solidify the Food Network's shift into competitions that felt
more fun and accessible for the viewer. The food presented on Iron Chef America
was considered too high-brow to be cooked at a local restaurant, let alone in someone's home.
So after season 12, Iron Chef America was put on an indefinite hiatus by the Food Network.
Four years later, Iron Chef America would return from its hiatus
and make its final season for the Food Network.
This is Iron Chef America!
Season 13 would be released in 2018 and aired shortly after the brand new series,
Iron Chef Gauntlet.
Gauntlet was a short competition series that, at its end,
would induct chef Stephanie Izard into the slate of Iron Chefs.
At the same time, Food Network also took a gamble on a version of Iron Chef called Iron Chef Showdown
that featured Alton Brown as the sole judge.
This show featured an on-air scandal when Bobby Flay took off his apron to reveal a shirt reading,
This is my last Iron Chef battle ever.
It looks like Iron Chef Flay just stripped down to a t-shirt!
The Food Network had tried to give Iron Chef America one last push, and it failed.
The public reception to Iron Chef Gauntlet, Showdown, and Season 13 were incredibly low,
despite all airing within months of each other.
It seemed that the Food Network's audience had simply moved on
and weren't interested in serious competition shows anymore.
Food Network was done with the Iron Chef brand.
They slowly stopped airing reruns and sold off streaming rights to Amazon Prime.
Hell yes!
Most of the Iron Chefs returned to their successful restaurants,
and some of them got their own shows.
All in all, Iron Chef had done its job.
It converted its fans into fans of the Food Network.
Iron Chef was loved by many, but eventually,
the cost of producing it outweighed the benefit, and it just didn't make sense anymore.
What Iron Chef really needed was a network that didn't care about losing tons of money.
In May of 2022, almost 18 years after Battle of the Masters,
Netflix would announce that Iron Chef was getting an all-new reboot,
called Iron Chef Quest for an Iron Legend.
The show would bring on five new Iron Chefs,
and would see the return of The Chairman and Alton Brown.
Iron Chef is back!
Alton Brown had left the Food Network after 21 years
to pursue the Iron Chef reboot with Netflix.
And it made sense.
For the past five years, Alton Brown's personality
has not meshed with what you would typically see on the Food Network.
People like Guy Fieri have and always will be successful with audiences.
That is gangster.
Alton Brown just never fully figured that out, or never wanted to.
Alton Brown didn't want to be on your level.
He always wanted his audience to know that he's the smartest guy in the room.
But maybe you don't want to have dinner with the smartest guy in the room.
Maybe you just want to hang out with the guy named Guy,
who knows all the greatest diners, drive-ins, and dives.
And who would blame you?
That guy sounds way more fun.
Alton Brown belongs on Netflix, because just like Netflix,
he's bold, brash, and very corporate.
It's a perfect fit.
As for Iron Chef Quest for an Iron Legend,
it's okay.
I think it lacks the magic of the Food Network series.
But it's still worth watching if you like Iron Chef, I guess.
Cooking competition shows are a dime a dozen nowadays.
Top Chef, Master Chef, Hell's Kitchen, and Chopped are all incredibly popular shows.
Not just because of their cooking, but because of the stories of the chefs.
Perhaps Iron Chef Sakai was right when he said America's kitchen stadium was cold.
Maybe a true kitchen stadium is any warm place,
where food and stories are prepared side-by-side
to be shared with our closest friends and family.
