Make Nani sound white.
She can't be like,
Lilo, you gotta
go to your room and take this
crazy little alien dog with
you. Yeah, she can definitely
tan. I mean, I'm not Hawaiian, but I used to play
tennis in Texas, and I would get so dark,
black people would ask me if I was half black.
Has Disney's whitewashing
gone too far with the new
Lilo and Stitch live action movie, or
are there other possible reasons for it?
I'm here with Ronny Chieng's number one
Asian upcoming comedian to look out for,
Vic Tran, to talk about this issue.
Hey, what's up? I'm Vic Tran.
I'm Vietnamese and Filipino,
but am I dark enough for Lilo and
Stitch?
Maybe in the summertime. I don't know.
Guys, so we gotta talk about this
viral issue. It's going crazy on Twitter
and, of course, in the Asian community and also in
just the Disney and, you know, Hollywood community.
The casting
came out for the new Lilo and Stitch live action,
and a lot of people are mad because
Nani's character is played by
Sydney Agudong, who has way
too light a skin and very
Eurocentric features, right?
She's clearly part European, part white,
right? But she is from Hawaii,
so I think they got that right.
However, she really doesn't have a lot
of, like, the native Hawaiian or Pacifica
people features,
things like that. Obviously, Nani had
a wider nose, much tanner skin,
and so they're accusing Disney
of perpetuating Eurocentric beauty
standards and whitewashing.
Or is it just showbiz, you know? And we're gonna
talk about it in this video. If you guys
are interested by this topic,
please hit that like button and check out other episodes
of the Hot Pop Boys right
now. Vic,
what's your initial reaction, man?
I don't know. I feel like there's been examples
of whitewashing in the past with Emma Stone
playing a Pacific Islander
woman. But in this instance,
you know, I feel like she's Hawaiian
enough. You know what I mean? Like, I feel like
we're fighting over shades now. This isn't
whitewashing as much as...
It's lightwashing, if anything.
It's lightwashing. I mean, I feel like
at this point, it's hard.
Disney can't win that they
casted her. I mean, I'm sure she's...
I believe she is part Filipino, this actress.
But she's just like, you know,
the mestizo Filipino or the Hapa,
right, who's clearly, like, half-white.
But she grew up in Hawaii, so
I don't know if they can make her...
I don't know if they would make her darker. That might be
getting kind of dicey with makeup, but maybe if
she tans long enough...
Yeah, she can definitely tan. I mean, I'm not Hawaiian,
but I used to play tennis in Texas, and I would
get so dark, black people would ask me if I was half-black.
So it's possible.
It's possible she's gonna be darker
in the movie, and it's, like, an easy fix.
I mean, depending on the picture you use, I think she
looks a little bit, I guess, tanner
skin. But her nose is small.
Like, Nani and Lilo's nose
are clearly pretty wide,
and, you know, that's more the Hawaiian feature.
But, like, I don't know if they're gonna...
They can't make her nose
wider. Yeah, I think you just gotta...
You win some and lose some with, like, live-action
casting, you know? Sure, she
could have, like, a European nose, but as long
as she has that Tsunami Mommy booty,
I'm buying two tickets.
I'm watching.
Man, I hope
they just don't cast
Stitch as just, like,
an Asian guy.
Like, just don't put, like,
Kee Wei Kwan in there, and just, like, call it
a day. Because people already think that we're
aliens. God dang it.
Alright, we're gonna go in the comments section.
So, this comment was just, like,
Hey, how about you stop
remaking perfectly good animated
movies into live-actions?
They're really hit-or-miss here, guys.
The Mulan one recently
that came out, it was also really bad timing
too for that one, but that one was, like,
a big flop. And that was, like, right
during COVID.
And then, like,
I think there's some other Disney live-actions
that didn't really turn out. Obviously, Little Mermaid
has yet to be seen. That's a live-action
one. So, I guess, like, should they just
stop doing it? Because
with animated films, you can just
make people look however you
want, and then to go backwards
and try to find an actor that looks like them
is tough. It's tough.
And I don't think there's been a single movie
where people have been happy with
the cast. Like, they were upset with Lion King,
and that didn't even have real people.
Do you want to know something crazy? That the person
who actually voiced Lilo in
the animated film looks like
Avril Lavigne. Not
Hawaiian whatsoever.
And then also,
Tia Carrera, who is from Hawaii,
voiced Nani in the original.
But she's, like, a little lighter skin than Nani
is in the animated film too.
And she sounds very Hawaiian
in the movie.
Well, she is from Hawaii, so she was able to do the good
accent and the voice, but her as
an actress is like, she's lighter
skin. Anyways,
there was this other one that said,
man, these same people complaining
right now didn't say anything
when Ariel, the little
mermaid, became black.
She
became black, like she's Rachel Dolezal.
Well, you know, people are like, yeah,
well, you know,
when I said I wasn't interested in this new
black little mermaid, I got called
racist. But now people are
saying that
Nani's gonna be too light skin,
and they're not being called racist.
So everybody's arguing about race,
but we're only the ones being called racist.
Yeah, that analogy doesn't make sense
because, like, what is it, the
mermaid community that's being misrepresented
on screen? It's like, it's a fantasy
that can be played with.
Right, right, right. I mean, the mermaid
is not a real thing.
Yeah, and I guess
obviously Lilo, Nani, they represent
humans, so
I guess you want to be more accurate when you're casting
human for human. But I guess
this other comment was like, see,
there's that double standard against
white people I've always been talking about.
White characters can get replaced with
all the different colors of people, but
then when there's one
ethnic character that becomes a little bit more
light skin, it's a problem.
This double standard, how long is it
gonna last? I guess the question is,
and if you're, like, a frustrated white person,
I'm trying to put myself in their shoes, right?
They see, like, white characters turn ethnic
and they're like, how long is this gonna last?
Minority, how many roles
do you want?
Yeah, I don't know. Whenever an argument starts with
double standard for white people, my brain
sort of just starts muting the rest of the argument
out. I don't really listen to it.
Yeah. I mean, I
guess maybe it's, you know,
I gotta give it to them, you know, like
a casting issue maybe, like, it's just
hard to find. Maybe she was the best
actress. Maybe she can do the voice really
well. We don't know. We don't know the reasons, but yeah,
clearly she is more
European than Nani is
in the animated film. There's one more comment
that tried to make sense of it all
and tried to defend them and was like,
well, not all people
from Hawaii are even as tan
as Lilo and Nani. Nani
is clearly out in the sun a lot, and even trying
to find an actress who is
fully Hawaiian and fully
that dark and that tan skin
is actually really hard, so that's why
in all the Hawaii shows, they just keep
recycling the same actors
and actresses. Yeah,
because Hawaii, obviously,
even though there is a lot more Hawaiian people
and a lot more Asian people, it's the most
Asian state in the whole United States,
and people generally are more
tanner skinned. There's also, they're very mixed.
That's where the word Hapa comes from, right?
It's half Asian, so there's a lot of mixed
people, and I believe
Sydney Agudong is mixed.
How mixed? I don't know,
but yeah, I mean, they're just trying
to defend and say maybe there's not even that
many, like, I guess
to them, Nani and Lilo are pretty
tan skinned in the animated film.
It's hard to even find full Hawaiians
in Hawaii that are that tan. Yeah, that
makes sense. Maybe this live-action adaption
is a better representation of what
Hawaiians are actually like than
the Hawaiian cartoon.
Maybe, yeah, I mean,
maybe they casted
more for the Oahu
Lilo and Stitch and not like
the kawaii
one, you know, like the far out island.
But I think as far as my takeaway
is, I think it's tough. There's always a fine
line, for sure. No doubt
that this actress has more Eurocentric
features. Do I think Disney's
trying to do it to push Eurocentric beauty
standards? I mean,
I don't know. I can't say for sure,
but Disney does put out a lot of other, like,
ethnic movies. They did Raya.
If they turn Raya into a
live-action, they're gonna have to get a lot of, like,
Southeast Asian and tanner skin people for that.
But, yeah, I would
say, man, just don't
make Nani sound white.
She can't be like,
Lilo, you gotta go
to your room and take this crazy
little alien dog with you.
Yeah, yeah.
She can't sound like she kisses the alien
dog on the lips.
Yeah, she
can't be like, geez, I need to find
work. Where's the nearest Jamba
Juice?
It's gotta still be like, if
this actress can do, like,
pigeon, maybe she's really good at the pigeon accent,
you know, and, like, that way of speaking,
you know. Yeah, let the performance
and the movie speak for itself. We'll just
find out whenever it comes out. Yeah, I understand
their pain, though. I wanna say, like, I get it
because I think people wanna be seen
and, you know, I don't wanna complain.
I have no complaints because with a lot
of, like, the East Asian representation,
there's a lot of East Asian
actors you can find. Like, they'll never
have a problem finding
a girl to play Mulan.
That's true.
There's half a billion of them
that they can choose from, you know.
So I wanna say, like, yeah,
I get it because I think
everybody was so proud of Lilo and Stitch
and also, like, Moana.
That animated
film for, like, representing
Native Hawaiians and Islanders and
Pacifica, you know. So I get it.
It's harder. They have a smaller pool
of actresses and actors to pull from, you know.
So I guess they're kind of going for that. But, you know
what? Crazy rich Asians.
You got Henry Golding.
He's, like,
half Asian. So I guess, like,
I don't know. Some people even
had something to say about that casting as well, too.
Yeah, people are always upset.
I think what they should push
for is push for this actress
to represent Hawaii correctly.
Yeah, 100%.
She does have the small pointy nose.
Anyways, any
last takeaways, Vic, on this topic?
yeah, no. Lilo and Stitch, you know,
hopefully it turns out good. You guys, let me know in the
comments down below what you think about
it all. I think there's a multitude
of different perspectives here.
But I think at this point, I think
all you can hope for is that it's a good piece.
But for sure,
it definitely, like, falls in line
with what people already think that Hollywood
wants to do, which is whitewash, which
you let me know in the comments down below if you think that this is
an issue that's going to continue, right?
So, you know, is it always going to be like this?
Maybe it's a pooling issue. Maybe there's
I mean, they got the little girl right. I feel like Lilo,
the girl that they got to play Lilo fits.
Yeah, and maybe the guy who plays
David is an okay
pick, but seems like they went
more lighter with Nani.
But anyways, you guys let me know in the comments
down below. Check out Vic's stuff.
His link down below. And until
next time, we out. Peace.