*Sponsor Special: Up to $2,500 of free silver with American Hartford Gold. Call 877-260-2764, text “JOSHUA” to 6-5-5-3-2, or visit: https://ept.ms/3rshean
Twitter has begun placing labels on the pages of several news outlets, indicating whether they receive government funding. Outlets include NPR, BBC, and several others. And as the outlets have attempted to challenge the labels, details on the amount of state funding they receive has sparked debate online over whether this impacts the credibility of the news.
Meanwhile, as the debates have unfolded, other information has emerged, exposing similar state funding to the organizations that help the news outlets frame the information. It has exposed the media industrial complex, and how layers of organizations are helping frame state narratives.
In this live Q&A with Crossroads host Joshua Philipp, we’ll discuss these stories and others, and answer questions from the audience.
Hey, welcome back everyone.
Let's talk about government funded media
and one of the big debates right now happening on Twitter.
You might've seen that Twitter with Elon Musk behind it
is starting to put up warnings or just notes
on the web pages, Twitter pages of many major news outlets
noting if they received government funding.
That's PBS, that's NPR, that's CBC, that's BBC,
that's ABC in Florida, it's quite a few of them.
And a lot of people are saying,
how dare you say that we're publicly funded media
because that undermines our credibility.
Well, you're publicly funded media.
If you don't want it to undermine your credibility,
don't take money from the government.
And that's the argument going around right now.
I'll show you what's happening with this
because the way it has unfolded is very interesting.
You watched what started as a debate
on whether someone should be able to note
whether a media receives government funding or not,
transform into a broader discussion
about who controls the narratives that media produce.
And it even has peeled back the lid to an extent
and showed the public, and I wanna show you all as well,
how a system of government-funded research organizations
feeds into the government-funded media,
which then amplify government messages
under the disguise of legitimate journalism.
It's been a very interesting kind of spectacle.
It's unraveled right in front of our eyes.
And so I wanna make sure that we cover those folks.
Also, you might've seen some of the news
about rioting and teenagers
and by the thousands robbing stores and so on.
I guess there's another killing
that they're using to justify,
another shooting is just justified now,
but actually the rioting started
before the shooting took place.
And so as far as I'm concerned,
it's just lawlessness essentially.
But in Chicago, where Walmarts are closing down
because they can no longer stay open
because of theft and vandalism,
you have people now posting videos
showing just the damage taking place.
And they're saying,
where can I buy food for my children
now that essentially places are being ransacked?
And the mayor of Chicago came out and responded to this
and basically looked like he endorsed looting.
This is a public official publicly,
not at least condemning crime.
And to an extent,
while actually directly making an excuse for crime.
I'd say this goes against the basic contract,
the social contract we have with government.
The very reason we pay taxes is to ensure
that our life, our liberty and our property are protected.
And if government can ensure none of those things,
it raises the question of,
what are we financing y'all for with our taxes?
It's raising a pretty serious discussion, I think,
about the nature and role of government,
whether they're fulfilling their role still
and what can be done to fix it.
I'll show you this as well.
Also folks, I mentioned yesterday, big news,
Crossroads is gonna be on cable starting next month.
And I wanna clarify, we will still be on Epoch TV.
You can still 100% watch us there.
We'll still have clips on YouTube and so on,
but the full episodes, everything, even premiering live,
still gonna be on Epoch TV, so don't worry.
Also, it's gonna change times.
It's gonna be 7 p.m. Eastern time.
I do apologize for those of you who I know.
I mean, I love the discussion.
I would have kept it the same,
but they want it to be a primetime show.
We'll see where things go, but yeah,
it's gonna be 7 p.m.
For the beginning of next month, for the first two weeks,
I'll just be doing monologues,
and then after about two weeks,
we'll transition into the full live show,
and we're planning to expand it to an hour eventually.
It's gonna be a big opportunity.
It's gonna be a big move for us.
Really, this is a big shift,
and I think one that's gonna be really good
in terms of helping push the power of crossroads
on a broader scale.
Those of you asking, it'll be on NTD,
and so if you wanna find the cable view times,
it's gonna be in Fios and so on,
but go to ntd.com forward slash cabletv.htm,
and it's gonna be on cable in quite a few states,
but also if you have Fios,
you can get it pretty much just about anywhere on Fios.
Of course, though, again, we will still be on Epoch TV,
so don't worry about that,
and that said, folks, thanks for being here.
Thank you for your support,
and we're on this journey together,
so it's always a pleasure.
Now, so let's jump into the first story.
I wanna show you how this discussion
around state-funded media is unraveling
and around what it's exposing,
because I don't think anyone really anticipated
for it to go the way it's gone.
Let's start from the top.
It all began with NPR, National Public Radio.
Let me show you their Twitter page.
Twitter labeled NPR as a government-funded media,
and NPR was very unhappy about that.
They challenged it, and they said,
"'How dare you say that we are a government-funded media?
They were trying to argue that they are independent,
and this and that,' and people said,
"'Well, you can argue you're independent,
but the fact stands.
You exist through government funding.
Government funding, taxpayer dollars,
are what keep your company going,
and if you wanna claim that you're independent, fine.
Your reporting contradicts that,'
and people were quick to note some of the issues
with NPR's reporting, their track record
of backing state-run narratives,
and what appears to be a lack of independence
from state narrative and pretty much party politics,
mainly on the left.
People were defending it and even arguing
on whether or not it's state-funded,
and then this came out.
Let me show you, hotair.com.
"'How much money does NPR get from the government?'
It's very complicated,' and they go
into this very complicated analysis
that yes, they receive lots and lots of money,
and yes, most of their money does come from the government,
but technically, government money comes from taxpayers,
and you've seen this weird narrative emerge,
like even in the defense of BBC in the UK,
and even in the defense of CBC in Canada,
people are saying, "'It's not government-funded.
It's taxpayer-funded.'
Well, guess what?
Our tax dollars go to the government
so they can delegate our money to things,
and government-funded means taxpayer-funded.
The government does not generate money.
In any country, the government does not generate money.
Their money is taxpayer dollars,
and so if you're trying to go into technicality
that it's not government-funded, it's taxpayer-funded,
it's the same thing, and that was part
of the ridiculous way that the, ironically,
the legacy news outlets tried to defend this
and claim that government-funded is an improper label.
It really just a ridiculous play on words.
After NPR went through this whole thing,
they threw their hands up in the air, essentially,
and said, "'We're leaving.
We're gonna leave Twitter.
See you all later,' and people said,
"'Don't let the door hit you on the way out,'
and then PBS, public broadcasting,
announced they were gonna go with them,
and as they tried to define themselves,
people pointed to something else.
They said, "'Well, PBS, you're leaving with NPR,
and you're also claiming on the grounds
that you're independent, but hey, we remember as well
that you are a state-funded media,
and we also know as well that you have also pushed
false information, false information ironically
being promoted by government narrative,
and if you're a news outlet and you cannot show the truth
of the matter when the government says one thing
and it turns out to be false,
you are not demonstrating independence
from the very group that is financing you.
That is the concern that is arising from this.
Let me show you this.
Kennecoa the Great on Twitter, he said,
"'Defund PBS for running a malicious disinformation campaign
against the American people
and interfering in the 2020 election.'"
Let me play this for you.
Over the past few days, President Trump has highlighted
a report by the New York Post about Hunter Biden,
Joe Biden's son.
There are major questions about the origins
and the accuracy of that story.
The president's personal attorney
was peddling Russian disinformation.
Unfounded claims about Vice President Biden's son, Hunter.
Unverified story about Hunter Biden.
Adam Schiff suggested the claims
are Russian disinformation.
Disinformation.
Intelligence agencies warned the White House
that Russian intelligence used Rudy Giuliani
as a vessel to undermine the Biden campaign.
Public.
Now, I will emphasize, everything you just heard is a lie.
They just lied through their teeth
to defend what was real information,
that Hunter Biden's laptop was of course leaked.
Hunter Biden's laptop contains multiple photographs
of him sleeping around with women and hookers
and smoking crack and doing pushups naked
between a dresser and a couch, which I saw,
which was horrible.
And he's also doing things like having emails
which discuss business deals under which he notes
that they might have to register as foreign agents
in his own words and things like this.
And of course, you had intelligence agencies
or members of the intelligence community come out
in actually what are now emails being linked
to the Biden administration,
come out and claim that there was an intelligence assessment
of senior members of the intelligence community stating
this whole thing is Russian disinformation.
And then you had different social media pages
ban different media or kick them off briefly
on the grounds that they were spreading
Russian disinformation.
And then you have PBS.
Did PBS, while they were spreading actual disinformation,
while they were lying to the public ahead of an election
over a story that would have altered the outcome
of the election based on again, polling numbers,
while they were doing that, did they criticize Twitter
or Facebook or YouTube for deplatforming or censoring people
for spreading what turned out to be true information?
Did they ever repent, let's say,
for their crimes against the public
of spreading what was in fact government disinformation
to cover for the political party that they support
while receiving taxpayer dollars,
meaning they're government funded, while doing so?
Not that I saw.
And now they're trying to make this big,
all this noise around,
how dare you say we're government funded,
even though, yes, we're government funded.
And they're trying to make this big dramatic exit,
watch as I leave the building.
And that's what's happening right now, folks.
Now, that being said,
it only got more interesting from here.
I would argue that BBC was kind of the pinnacle.
What happened with BBC was like the icing on the cake.
BBC came out, British Broadcasting, right?
The state funded media in the UK.
And they also got labeled as a government funded media,
which they are, by the way,
but they said, hey, we're not government funded.
We are funded by taxpayers,
trying to use that ridiculous play on words yet again,
by skewing the idea that somehow government gets its money
from somewhere other than taxpayers.
But regardless of the,
and of course there's some nuances with BBC,
like you can choose not to,
from what I understand, if you're in the UK,
you can like choose not to have your money go to them.
So there's some nuance with it,
just for their narrative.
But then something interesting,
and that turned out to be just detrimental to BBC happened.
BBC asked for an interview with Elon,
and the results were incredible.
I'll go over that in just a sec, folks.
Now, before we go into that, though,
we do have a sponsor today.
Today's episode is brought to you
by American Heart for Gold.
Now, as you've been talking about,
inflation is going to continue and likely get worse.
Even Fed chair Powell is warning us to brace ourselves.
Well, there's one way you can hedge against inflation.
American Heart for Gold makes it simple and easy
to diversify your savings and retirement accounts
with physical gold and silver.
With one short phone call,
they can have physical gold and silver
delivered right to your door or into your IRA or 401k.
American Heart for Gold is one of the highest rated firms
in the country with an A plus rating from the BBB
and thousands of satisfied clients.
If you call them right now,
they'll give you up to $2,500 of free silver
and a free safe on qualifying orders.
So don't wait, call them now.
That's 877-260-2764.
Again, that's 877-260-2764,
or text Joshua to 65532.
Again, 877-260-2764,
or text Joshua to 65532.
And again, big things out to American Heart for Gold
for sponsoring today's episode.
Now that said, let's talk about the BBC.
We'll start from the top.
All the drama unfolded.
BBC came out very strong against Elon Musk
and they raised just all over British media.
The government was saying it.
All these public officials are coming out
criticizing Elon Musk,
saying, how dare he say the BBC is government funded media
and how dare he call into question
the integrity of our media by telling people the truth.
And then of course they came out
and they requested actually an interview with him.
While they were trying to pull all these narratives out,
Twitter has become a hotspot of hate speech.
Twitter, hate speech and racism
and all these other things on Twitter have increased
and that's all because of Elon Musk.
And then they asked Elon Musk for an interview
and Elon Musk agreed to that interview,
interestingly, like the same day
within a very short time span.
And the results actually ended up making BBC
look very, very bad.
Because Elon Musk did something interesting.
Elon Musk did not agree to go on BBC.
Elon Musk agreed to do a Twitter space
with a BBC reporter, broadcasted live,
meaning they could not selectively edit it.
And everybody got to watch in real time
how the interviewer performed,
how Elon Musk called into question the legitimacy
or lack thereof of their narratives
and how Elon Musk made this individual
frankly look like a fool.
Let me show you.
We'll go over a couple parts of this.
Let me play a part of this interview.
Elon Musk tweeted this out.
We have spoken to people who have been sacked
that used to be in content moderation.
And we've spoken to people very recently
who were involved in moderation.
And they just say, there's not enough people
to police this stuff, particularly around hate speech
in the company.
Is that something you want to address?
What hate speech are you talking about?
I mean, you use Twitter.
Right.
Do you see a rise in hate speech?
I mean, I-
Just a personal anecdote.
Like what do you, I don't.
Personally, for you, I would see I get more
of that kind of content, yeah, personally.
But I'm not going to talk to the rest of,
for the rest of Twitter.
You see more hate speech personally?
I would say I would see more hateful content in that.
Content you don't like or hateful?
What do you mean?
Describe a hateful thing.
Yeah.
I mean, you know, just content that will solicit a reaction
to something that may include something that is
slightly racist or slightly sexist,
those kinds of things.
So you think if something is slightly sexist,
it should be banned?
No.
Is that what you're saying?
I'm not saying anything.
I'm saying-
Well, I'm just curious.
What do you mean by hateful content?
I'm asking for specific examples.
And if, and you just said that if something
is slightly sexist, that's hateful content.
Does that mean that it should be banned?
Well, you've asked me, you've asked me whether my feed,
whether it's got less or more.
I'd say it's got slightly more.
That's what I'm asking for examples.
Right.
Can you name one example?
I honestly don't need, honestly, I don't-
You can't name a single example.
I'll tell you why.
Because I don't actually use that for you feed anymore
because I just don't particularly like it.
But you said you-
And actually a lot of people,
a lot of people are quite similar.
I only, I only look at my followers.
Well, hang on a second.
You said you've seen-
Folks, do you get that?
Oh my gosh.
He goes, hateful content is on the rise on Twitter.
It's becoming a serious problem.
I've been seeing all this hateful content.
Elon Musk goes, well, like what?
You know, give me an example of hateful content.
He goes, well, sexism.
He's like, well, should people be banned
for like, or slightly sexist?
He's like, well, you know, he kind of avoids the question.
And then he goes further.
He's like, well, I've seen all this hateful content.
Elon Musk says, well, tell me one thing you've seen.
He goes, I've seen it.
And then he admits that he hasn't actually seen anything.
He says he saw it on his feed, right?
I saw it on my feed.
I saw it on my feed, right?
And after he says he saw it on his feed,
Elon Musk corners him and he says,
well, actually I don't even look at the feed.
And so he contradicts himself.
In other words, this individual is making claims
based on information that doesn't exist.
Information he's never,
he's never personally seen apparently.
Information on which he can't name a single source.
And if you're a journalist,
part of the basic form that journalism works on
is verification.
As a journalist, if I'm going to accuse someone of something,
I need to go and look at it.
I need to go and make an effort to read it.
I need to, you know, put in some work on my own
to make sure that I'm not just reporting a rumor.
In other words, I need to look at the source
or at least make an effort to.
And if you're not looking at the source,
if you're not doing that,
all you're doing is repeating narratives.
And then people raise the question of,
well, from where is this individual getting his narratives?
It turns out it's getting his narratives
from government funded reports.
This is a government funded media
getting its narratives from government funded reports,
all of which is skewed information
around government talking points.
As the EU is trying to crack down on Twitter.
This is lack of verification.
And because it is lack of verification
while making accusations,
really serious accusations against somebody,
I would say this is a clear example of lack of integrity
through a medium, which is again, government funded,
citing sources funded by the same government.
I'll get into that in a minute, a bit more.
We'll get into that in a minute
on the whole government funded element of it.
But let me show you a bit more of this
because it went actually in a very interesting direction.
We play a bit more.
Let's move on. We only have a certain amount of time.
Um, COVID misinformation.
You changed the COVID misinformation.
Has BBC changed this COVID misinformation?
The BBC does not set the rules on Twitter, so I'm asking you.
No, I'm talking about the BBC's misinformation about COVID.
I'm asking you about you change the labels, the COVID
misinformation labels, there used to be a policy and then
disappeared. Why do that?
Okay, COVID is no longer an issue. Does the BBC call itself
at all responsible for misinformation regarding masking
and side effects of vaccinations and not reporting on that at
all? And what about the fact that the BBC was put under
pressure by the British government to change the
editorial policy? Are you aware of that?
This is not an interview about the BBC.
Oh, you thought it wasn't?
And I see now why you've done Twitter spaces. I am not a
representative of the BBC's editorial policy. I want to make
that clear. Let's talk about something else.
I'm interviewing you too.
All right, let's talk about something else.
You weren't expecting that.
Let's talk about something else.
Let's talk about something else. We have limited time. The
interesting way that that went, let's talk about something else.
We have limited time. Elon Musk at the end of the interview was
actually up for doing a longer interview. The BBC reporter
actually left. And imagine as a journalist, you have like one of
the richest guys on earth. He's the biggest story in the news.
And he's offering you a long interview and you get up and
leave. And Elon Musk actually stayed even after he left and
continued doing the Twitter space on his own. It's bizarre,
especially because again, he's using this idea of limited time,
suggesting Elon Musk has limited time, it appears, as a way to
deflect criticism and deflect questions. Of course, the real
narrative, the real overarching kind of context of that
discussion was BBC coming out and criticizing Elon Musk for
labeling them as government funded media. And so really, I
think Elon Musk, based on the way he was, of course, kind of
counter questioning them, was also seeing it as more of a
debate with BBC and what they represent, and as a way to make
them kind of put their money where their mouth is. If you're
going to criticize me, let's have a discussion about it. And
let's do it live so people can make their own assessment. This
gets into the idea of what Elon Musk has been pushing, which
actually he did discuss in that interview, which I think was
actually one of the more interesting points. Elon Musk
actually said that what he's doing with Twitter, and again,
take it for what you will, as far as I've seen, I think Epoch
Times, we still can't advertise on Twitter. I think, I mean, it
looks like they're still censoring us. And so I haven't
personally seen Twitter take a strong enough move, at least in
my opinion. I think actually they did change it now. So good
on them. Cancel that. Until recently, I just got told by my
producer, they did change it. So good on them. But Elon Musk
said something interesting, which is what he is doing as
he's taking the, he's changing the dynamic of who gets to
basically be the gatekeeper of truth. And he's promoting what
he calls citizen journalism, something that used to be a big
buzzword back when, you know, Twitter and stuff was first
starting. The idea of citizen journalists when, you know, I
guess prior to 2016, when they began launching these mass
censorship operations after Trump won the election, because
they wanted to make sure this never happens again. You had
YouTubers coming up, you had people on Twitter coming up, you
had small individuals like from their house on cheap laptops
with cheap cameras with like webcams, becoming some of the
biggest voices in the news industry. You had little
YouTubers getting more traffic than the major news outlets,
more traffic, more views in a day than CNN and, you know, NBC
and all that. And a big question came out, how can we remain
relevant if, you know, anybody basically can become a star? And
how can we maintain the integrity of news if anybody can
come out, if anybody could come out and gain an audience and
challenge the narratives we are producing? That was, again, not
me saying this, but this was the narrative a lot of the
mainstream media were pushing. Now, as that took place, the
solution they brought out was, well, we need to censor
everybody else to an extent, or at the very least, make sure
that the narratives being pushed by the governments of the
different parts of the world cannot be challenged by
independent voices. And in reality, that's what the
censorship system represents. It's the idea that established
narrative cannot be questioned, regardless of its accuracy. And
what Elon Musk did in that interview is brought that point
forward. He said, well, you're criticizing me, the narrative,
right, the government narrative in both BBC and in the state
run organizations, the state funded organizations, sorry,
that produced the report suggesting there was an increase
in hate speech on Twitter after Elon Musk took over, despite the
fact that, again, that's a government narrative funded by
the government, promoted by government organizations, funded
by government, they cannot name a single instance of it, meaning
it's debatable. And what they're suggesting is you need to have
censorship in place to prevent the other side of the narrative
from being demonstrated. And when the individual comes out,
this BBC reporter comes out and says, I can see why we did this
on Twitter spaces. That was a very telling, almost like saying
the quiet part out loud moment, in my opinion, because by
stating, I can see why you wanted to do this on Twitter
spaces, what I took that as him saying, right, at least the way
the way I interpreted that is it seemed like he was suggesting
that had they done this on the BBC, it would not be live, and
they could edit it and they could remove the part where
they're questioned, they could remove the part where they look
bad, they can remove the part where there's an aha moment and
the journalist has to answer and demonstrate the credibility
of a statement, which we saw in real time that there was no
credibility for these statements, at least none that
the individual could remember, or recall, which again, if
you're if you're a journalist making really serious
accusations against somebody, well, you better have an example
to justify it. Otherwise, the way I was taught as a
journalist is you could be sued. You know, if I were to come out
and criticize somebody and accuse somebody of spreading
hateful content, I better know like an example. You know, if
I'm going to say that I think it's at least basic courtesy,
you should show people and so it is important to do that.
Anyways, bizarre stuff. But I think what you're seeing as well
is this break in the system. I think that was kind of a kind of
a moment in public discourse where the public got to see what
the British government pressured BBC to push COVID
misinformation while simultaneously criticizing
Twitter of removing warning labels on COVID misinformation.
Wait a second, what's going on here? They while while they are
actually promoting false information as Elon Musk put
that guy in the hot seat on and call them out for directly is
BBC going to apologize for pushing false information on
COVID-19? The guy was actually asking Musk, why did he remove
these misinformation labels? Musk is like, well, what
disinformation like your disinformation, the stuff you're
Is disinformation true if the government says it is regardless
of whether it's true in practice? How do you define this?
And should we not be able to question it? That was the base
narrative that just rose to the surface through that debate, and
the public got to watch it all in real time. This is the break,
I would say between state narrative and independent voice.
And keep in mind the nature of media in the past of news out
in the past is they were meant to be the independent voice
journalists, media news outlets, they were supposed to
be the fourth estate, the public body, the watchdogs who hold to
account the who weigh the truth or falsehoods of what we're
being told and who hold individuals to account when they
state things falsely. Can you maintain that type of integrity?
If you're receiving money from the very people you're supposed
to be holding to account that is the debate we're now having as a
society. Now it got even more interesting. I'll show you this
in a minute before let's jump over to Epoch TV for the rest of
this. Before I jump over again, I do an hour and a half show. So
join us on Epoch TV. Before I jump over though, let me show
you a trailer and I'll see you there.
Hi there, Josh Phillip here. Our values are being assaulted
every day by the lies that mainstream media perpetuate.
It's put our country in the edge of a knife, no one knowing
whether or not we'll make it. If you love our country and the
freedoms we celebrate, I'll give you the number one thing you can
do to ensure this country stays this way. Now you probably feel
that's impossible. Maybe you think the situation is too far
gone. I felt the same way until I joined the Epoch Times,
started this show, saw the power that truth can bring our growing
audience. That's why I wanted to tell you there is something you
can do. You can share the truth that's out there from my show.
And by supporting me, you're supporting the Epoch Times, and
you're supporting independent journalism that is bar none,
this country's best hope in surviving the onslaught against
our values and freedoms. Shockingly, most people don't
even realize that almost every mainstream media company belongs
to one of six huge corporations, all with their own agendas and
demanding shareholds. Some even think it's a good thing. Folks,
how can we ensure the reporting is free of bias? You can't. This
is why my show and the Epoch Times is so critical. We're
completely independent. Our only interest is in traditional
journalism and reporting people. The Epoch Times is the antidote.
It's time to replace these prevalent narratives with the
truth, back to the basics, life, liberty, and the pursuit of
happiness. All you have to do is subscribe to Epoch TV, and you'll
get so much more in return. With your subscription, you get
access to hundreds of exclusive videos, over 30 channels, live
shows, events, and even hard hitting documentaries and films
that are changing the game. Just click on the link in the
description below the show, and you're on your way. Thanks so
much for watching, and for your support. And remember, the only
way to truly protect our freedoms is to stay informed.
Alright, folks, as I mentioned, things only got more interesting.
Again, those of you still on YouTube, jump over to Epoch TV, come join us there for
the rest of the discussion, and I'll see you there.
But folks, thank you for being here.
Things only got more interesting.
Because do you remember?