⭕️We are being censored by Big Tech. Our solution? Create our own independent platform free of censorship. Join us today on Epoch TV👉http://EpochTV.com/Crossroads
There is a clear and organized agenda behind social justice narratives, and to learn more about this we've invited to speak with us Mike Gonzalez, author of "The Plot to Change America: How Identity Politics is Dividing the Land of the Free" and a senior fellow on E Pluribus Unum at Heritage Foundation.
The Agenda Behind Social Justice Movements, With Mike Gonzalez
- - - - - - - - - 💎 Sign the Petition to Investigate, Condemn, and Reject the Chinese Communist Party👉 https://rejectccp.com 💎 Get real news other media outlets don’t report for only $1: http://ept.ms/JoshuaforEpoch
- - - - - - - - - Want to listen to our interviews? Check out our new podcasts! Links below:
Hey, welcome back everyone. I'm sure you've all heard about the different race and gender narratives going on in the country
But what a lot of people don't know is that there's a clear model with these movements that does not represent
The surface narratives that they have now to help us understand
What's really going on with these movements and what the real goal is including with the people who founded these movements
We invite to speak with us Mike Gonzalez
He's the author of the book plot to change America. That's how identity politics is
Dividing the land of the free. He's also at the Heritage Foundation and Mike. It's a real pleasure having on Crossroads
Thanks a lot. Josh Rice. My pleasure to be on with you. Great. So yeah, I was reading your book
It's it's it's it you actually touched on some really
interesting angles with it. I think the big one you talk about is
You really you give a framework on how to dismantle the narratives of these organization
I think the biggest one is helping people understand that these are not grassroots movements. Can you explain this to us?
Yeah, sure. I let me explain first what I mean by identity politics
I meant that identity politics is the reimagining of America as not a united
country not at a nation united but as a confederation of identity groups in and what matters is that
some of these groups are
Considered to be oppressed and then one of these groups are the is the oppressor and that that is, you know, white males
Who are able-bodied?
and in Protestant
But the rest are I thought to be in some ways others some more than others to be oppressed and marginalized
And and the thing about these groups then is that as you said they have been created synthetically
By activists by the left for the purpose of instilling the members of the groups
With a sense of victimhood with with grievances. So that would act as a catalyst to change
Society to change America. That's why I call my book the plot to change America
not because it's a conspiracy in which people leftist in Madison, Wisconsin go into a basement every Thursday night and
Discuss these things but because the philosophy behind identity politics is
Is a an attempt to change society to change the United States into something which would never was meant to be
Which is communist Marxist central planning. I don't know if that gives a good, you know
umbrella overview of this but
Go ahead and ask
Further questions. Yeah. So yeah, I want to go into a few different points with this
One I want to talk about of course what the real goal of these organizations is the ones that started this whole thing
we can go into the whole Frankfurt School issue and
Critical theory and how you know how this started and also understanding how they created these categories
but first I want to talk to you I guess about how they
Convinced people they were oppressed because what I found interesting and you show some good research on it
Is that a lot of people when they first tried starting these movements didn't actually identify
Along the lines that they now identify with really people these days
Seeing the news and so on we can forget that things weren't always like this
I think made a good example, for example with the Latino community that that was not really an identity
Before a lot of this couldn't can you talk about this? Well it Hispanics
Which came before Latino was created by government. It's it's it's a
Denominational label created by government. In fact, it was created by the Office of Management and Budget in
policy directive number 15 in
1977 and then applied to the census
The national census that came out in 1980 along with Asian Americans, which is another
synthetically, you know
confected identity group
The you're quite right. In fact, I have a book here. It's the report that UCLA
Paid some researchers to go into the southwest into parts of Texas in California
They picked quite a lot of money UCLA did for this report
In the late 60s. I think the whole thing came out to six hundred thousand dollars
there's a lot back then and they the this is one of the starting points of this because the researchers came back and
informed the Ford Foundation
It's actually the other way is the Ford Foundation who paid UCLA researchers to do this
The UCLA researchers came back and informed they informed the Ford Foundation
That Mexican Americans did not feel like victims. They did not feel marginalized
It did not feel at all that they were members of a minority
In fact
They knew they faced discrimination
Especially in southern, Texas, but they thought that they had
Individual agency that they could solve their problems through this individual agency needless to say the Ford Foundation was aghast
Because it wanted it needed a sense of victimhood
in these members so the process begins then including with his effort to instill
a sense of victimhood
This starts out from the idea
Best enunciated by Herbert Marcuse, which is an who's an academic a very influential academic member of the Frankfurt School
Who said in 1966 all liberation begins with a consciousness of servitude?
In other words, you have to be conscious of your servitude first of being of being oppressed
Before you can react
About the revolution. We see this again in
2015 when the Census Bureau brings in
Americans of Arab origin to create the MENA for Middle East North Africa
category the MENA category was
Going to be modeled on the Hispanic category, which is created in
1977 again first starts with the Census Bureau
So the left these activists care a great deal about this
but if you listen to the transcript, which I have done and I put online and I
Cite from it in my book to pot to change America if you listen to the debate
That they had at the Census Bureau in 2015
Again, they repeat
look
the
Americans of Middle Eastern descent have no interest in being members of the MENA
They have no interest in being members of a category
Most of them want to continue to be considered white
They have assimilated their normal, you know
they're the mainstream and they don't feel themselves to be marginalized and then
somebody a
an ethnic studies professor in this meeting says ah
but when they realize that they get ahead of the line for
For for school admissions they get ahead of the line for government contracts when they realize that there are benefits actual benefits
associated with category membership and
With with with the an official there were the official bestowing of marginalization
They will adhere to it
So do you see the same thing happening and in fact at that meeting just to close this off at that meeting?
they had people who were at the creation of Hispanics to explain how they did it in
In the in the 70s to explain to people then
You know 30 years later 40 years later
Look, this is how nobody wanted Hispanics either. We created it. It's stuck
This is gonna happen also with people of Middle East in North African descent in the United States
You know you hit on something interesting, which is that people had individual agency
And so they didn't want to be seen as marginalized and persecuted and I think I think this brings up an interesting point
Is that do you want to deal with your problems yourself and not really think it's that big of a deal
Which even when I was a kid was kind of how people dealt with stuff like this
Or do you want to have a government basically represent your interests?
Is this where it is this kind of issue between individual agency versus government representation?
Is this where it's at? It is exactly on that and and you hear this constantly
All of the people who proposed to the proponents of this ideology today
They admit and they say yes, you can succeed individually
You can succeed individually, but when you're doing that you're joining the system
You're joining a bad system. Angela Davis, who's a communist and who is the biggest intellectual mentor
to the the leaders of the Black Lives Matters organizations
Patrisse Cullors, Alicia Garza and Opal Tometi
She says this openly. She says when you succeed you and your family as
Individuals or as a family you're joining the system. It's a system that is heteronormative
It's a system that is systemically racist, a system that is awful, that is capitalist, that is unfair
What we need you to do is change the system, dismantle the system, overthrow the system
In order for you to do that you need to be upset
You need to realize that you're a victim, that the system victimizes you
And you can only you will then act collectively
So they don't want individual improvement
In fact, they militate against all the things that would help the individual
succeed in society
But what they want is collective action as a member of a category
To then ally with government, overthrow the system and demand the government that will
Think of group categories only
And act that way. In that sense, I am very concerned, and I have written a lot about this
About the Biden administration's stress on equity, not equality
Because equity, equality means equal treatment under the law
We haven't always lived that way, but we have aspired to it, we have succeeded
Equity means unequal treatment according to group category
Equity is the treatment called for under this monarchy
This mode of thinking that the government will dispense resources
And treat people unequally depending on what category they belong
As crazy as that sounds, that is exactly why the new Biden administration is using equity all the time
Why the executive order that Biden signed his first day in office
Used the word equity 21 times and did not use the word equality once
And the poor man, poor Biden, when he misspeaks and reads it off the teleprompter wrong
And uses the word equality, he backs up on himself, he corrects himself and says equity
They cannot even use the word equality anymore
You know, you're painting an interesting picture, which is
That the people advocating for these things are telling people that they need to change the system
But ironically, what you have is, you know, and this is something I've been seeing too
You have a lot of people who are convinced that they're fighting to change the system
They're fighting against the big businesses, while at the same time, the people
Pushing them to do this typically represent the big businesses
Really, you know, really, if you look at the corporate sponsors for this
And typically represent the institutions in the big government
And so what is, how does this really work?
Is it just getting them to surrender their own free will to this system
While telling them they're overthrowing the system by doing that, or is there something more to it?
Well, you're touching on something that is very much part of the debate today
There is no question that the Fortune 500, that the corporate world is becoming woke-ified
That woke ideology has entered American corporations and companies
Why that has happened and many explanations for that
What happened on campus, the takeover of critical race theory on campus
Was not going to stay on campus, these people graduate
And once administrators, not just nutty professors, but once school administrators
Begin to dispense university policy according to group membership
And according to grievances and all that
The student learns that that's how the world works
And when he enters, when she enters the corporate world
They demand that corporations behave in this manner
The left has also taken over the corporate world through HR
Pharma has played a role in this
What some people, some of the left says
That they have to make sure that this corporate co-optation of woke ideology
Is not just lip service
That it is real, that it is going to transform society
That the corporate world really wants to transform society
I think that a lot of what you see with the corporate giving to Black Lives Matter
The Black Lives Matter organizations is a lot of virtue signaling as well
But I have to tell you that after I and others began to spread the news last year
That the Black Lives Matter organization, the concept is unimpeachable
If you don't think Black Lives Matter, I don't want to talk to you because, you know, you're a nut
But the organizations that go under that name are Marxist
And they're demonstrably Marxist
The leaders are demonstrably Marxist
And we started picking up a very real pullback
By incorporating giving to the Black Lives Matter organizations
Whereas it was very much, it was something that was happening in June and July
By the time we got to August and September
Even the business roundtable was beginning to quietly move that money away
From the Black Lives Matter organizations into other social justice
Which can be, some of them, quite bad as well
But there is a little bit of discernment in the corporate world
As to what the Black Lives Matter organizations
And by that I mean the Global Network Foundation and the Movement for Black Lives
These are organizations that are, by definition, quite Marxist
It appears that corporate giving to them has dried up a little bit
Foundations do continue to give to them
Now, we of course see the surface issues
We see the Democratic Party now talking about equity
I think a lot of our viewers understand that, you know, this is basically saying
No matter how much effort you put in, you have the same outcome
And that the equal outcome rather than the opportunity to try and get the same outcome
Or the opportunity to try to achieve things is then equalized
And so individual effort no longer really means as much
We see this surface stuff happening
But what I want to talk to you about is why this is happening
And I know you've researched a lot of the foundational discussions that led to a lot of this
Now, I think we can start with the Frankfurt School, which you mentioned
Maybe we can start with critical race theory or critical theory in this case
You know, what was critical theory?
And what was the real thinking behind the creation of this?
So I have a lot of books
I have here the history of the Frankfurt School and critical theory by Martin Jay
An American academic who is quite sympathetic to the Frankfurt School
The Frankfurt School was basically the first outpouring of neo-Marxism
Of Western Marxism after the founding of the Soviet Union in 1917
And the failure of the creation of a German Soviet in 1919
That revolution failed
And German Marxists began to wonder why
Why was the proletariat not rising up and overthrowing the bourgeois overlords?
And they said, well, it's because the proletariat has accepted
All the givens of the oppressors
It has accepted religion, has accepted the economic model, capitalism
Accepted the family, the patriarchal family
So it has accepted everything
We need to approach the worker not just as an economic class, but culturally
Get them to stop accepting the nation state, the church, the family, and the capitalist system
Change their mind through struggle sessions
So then the Frankfurt School comes up with critical theory in 1937
In an essay by the director of the school, Max Horkheimer
And he says critical theory pretty much is an intense, unrelenting criticism
Of all these institutions of the West, the family, the church
In order to tear them down, to make them easier to tear down
And to replace them with the things that the Marxists want
Critical race theory is an outgrowth of this
First, we have critical legal theory
Which comes up in the American universities in the 1970s
And it pretends that, again, the law is used by the writers of the law
To protect their oppressor status
To protect their property, to protect their way of life
And that the law, as it's written, the statutes do not protect the oppressed
From that, we get critical race theory
Which begins with Derrick Bell at Harvard
Who was Barack Obama's favorite professor, by the way
And Richard Delgado, Gene Stefansik
I think Angela Harris as well, Kimberlé Crenshaw
Who began this philosophy, really
That looked at all of American life through the prism of race
In things that, all of these racial dynamics are oppressive
That everything in America is systemically racist
And structurally racist and institutionally racist
So we must change all the institutions, all the structures in the very system
That is the philosophy, it is a Marxist philosophy from the beginning
And it's really the philosophy behind the Black Lives Matter organizations
The 1619 Project and all the woke culture that we see today
Well, and this is interesting, because if we go back to Marxism
Really, you know, one of the ideas of early communist revolutions
Was convincing people there were two segments of society
The bourgeois and the proletariat, the oppressors and the oppressed
And really the narrative was you need to give us power to represent you
To destroy the oppressors
And then you end up creating a totalitarian system
By people handing over this power to them
Which then goes and persecutes different segments of society
And then, you know, we've seen how that turns out
And it seems that critical race theory and critical theory
Basically takes that same bourgeois-proletariat dichotomy
And just applies it to every social interaction
Whether it's race or gender or children
Is this an accurate description of this?
It's like, it's as though you've read my books
Yeah, that's the reason it's no longer called economic Marxism
It's called cultural Marxism
Antonio Gramsci, the founder of the Italian Communist Party
And one of the leading thinkers in this vein
Was thrown into prison by Mussolini in the late 20s
So his brain would stop working
Big mistake, you do a lot of good thinking in prison
So Gramsci began to realize that, hey, the worker is not a good revolutionary race
Because he needs to be instructed
And then that evolves into Marcuse noticing the riots in America
The many, many riots we had in America between 1965 and 1971
And saying, he also agreed that the American worker
Was never going to overthrow the system
The American worker was too contented, too happy
Capitalism had worked out too well for him
But actually, people of different races and colors, Marcuse says
They will be the revolutionary base that can be instructed by us
The vanguard, the intellectual vanguard
This is all very top-down
Leninism is all very top-down
You must have an intellectual vanguard
That instructs the potential revolutionary base
Into their oppression, into their servitude
And then they will rise up and overthrow the oppressive system
So that is exactly why we have this transference, this transition
From the economic Marxism of Marx and Engels
To the cultural Marxism of Gramsci, Marcuse, Angela Davis and so forth
Derrick Bell and so forth
And so it seems like what the case is then is that
These organizations are kind of using people
To destroy the parts of the institutions that they don't like
In other words, basically launching a Marxist revolution
To overthrow some of the system
While maintaining the parts of the system
That represent their own political interests
Is this accurate? How does this work?
I don't see it that way
I think that what we're seeing is exactly
It's an overthrow, but it's still the entire system
This is what we're seeing in America today
Whether it will succeed or not, I don't know
But it is an attempt to overthrow
And the people saying this, they don't hide it
They say, we need to change the entire system
The entire system is sexist, is racist, is heteronormative
Is unfair, capitalism produces wealth
Produces winners and losers
But winners and losers that are not based
On the traits that we think are valuable
So what they want, they see themselves
As playing a leading role in the new system that will emerge
But it's not just a part of the system they want to overthrow
They want to overthrow all the institutions
At the same time, they're nihilistic and utopian
They believe in the perfectibility of man
Which is the reason why communism was always ending coercion
Because man is not perfectible
Man is flawed
We're flawed
We have many vices
We need a system that understands all that
And that works without coercion
To get us to a good place
To get the greatest good for the greatest number
Which is what I think capitalism does
And the Enlightenment does
And Adam Smith with his famous phrase
Is not from the nobility of the baker, the butcher
That we get our bread or our beer
But it is from his understanding of his own self-interest
Capitalism and democracy use personal self-interest
To produce a common good
This is interesting
What is the end game for these movements?
You talked about the Census Bureau
And the recording of their actual discussion
In terms of how they created racial categories
For some of these purposes
You talked about Antonio Gramsci
You talked about the Frankfurt School
And Herbert Marcuse
And those guys who were there forming these ideas
What was the
What have you seen in terms of their actual statements
That they're real
Not the surface narratives
But the real goals they had with doing this
Well, they're very open
They're very open about what they want to do
This is
I use in my books mostly leftist sources
Not conservative sources
I urge anybody to go to the website
Of the Movement for Black Lives
Or the Black Lives Matter
Just type blacklivesmatter.com
Read the about
Go back and look at the comments
That Alicia Garza has made throughout the years
Her associations
Look at what Patrice Colores has said in her book
When they call you a terrorist
The foreword was written by Angela Davis
You know, at one time
The candidate for vice president
For the American Communist Party
Who remains an unrepentant communist
Who received the Lenin Peace Prize
From the East German government
One of the most repressive states
Of behind the Iron Curtain
In 1979 she received this prize
She writes the foreword for Patrice Colores' book
The book has a dedication to Assata Shakur
Who is Joan Chesimard
Who is hiding in Cuba
Because she's a cop killer
And she's on the FBI's top 10 list
This is who Patrice Colores
You know, the head of Black Lives Matter today
Of the Black Lives Matter Global Network Foundation
This is who she is
She doesn't hide it
And nor should we
And I think, actually
I prefer when people are honest
So you go to what Robin DiAngelo says
Or Ibram X. Kendi
Or Ibram X. Kendi, also a critical race theorist
They say capitalism is not good
That we cannot have racial equality with capitalism
And by equality they mean blocks
Not individuals doing well
They mean the racial categories
Or the ethnic or identity categories they have created
You know, having a numerical proportionalism
In all aspects of society
They no longer look at the individual as an individual
The main actor now is the category
The identity category
And so it seems essentially what they're doing is
Is they're creating these categories
Using narratives or enticement of interest
Like, you know, better access to schools and so on
To entice people to be willing to sacrifice individual agency
For the benefits of basically falling in line with those categories
And then using this
But there's also the creation of resentment
The creation and use of resentment based on that
Which becomes kind of the way that they manipulate
That category for different purposes
Now, why do they do this?
Why do they create resentment?
Because of what Marcuse said
That all liberation needs a consciousness of servitude
I often quote Maria Teresa Kumar
The head of Voto Latino, one of these groups
She actually said, and I quote her in the Wall Street Journal last year
She actually said that her problem at Voto Latino
Is that her constituents did not understand
The oppressive system that they lived under
And that she had to explain, that Voto Latino had to explain
To immigrants from Latin America and their children
How awful the American system was
And once they understood it, yes, they decided to act
And unite and act collectively
So you have to, what is being done then
Is that you're taking people who have immigrated here
For a better life, who all of a sudden got up one day
In Montevideo, Uruguay, or in Guerrero, Mexico
And said, this system is not working for me or my children
I want to immigrate to the United States
Where my children can have liberty and economic success
And you have to indoctrinate them into why that is a big lie
And this system needs to be changed root and branch
That is not good work
But it's done with a purpose that we have been discussing
To overthrow the system
Now I think a lot of people would recognize that
There are flaws in society
And it's interesting if you dig into the history of this
That one thing capitalism does
If you look at guys like Ludwig von Mises
And the Austrian School of Economics
They actually talk about the need for the possibility of failure
As part of the feedback system
To understand what doesn't work and what does work
That things that don't work fail
And things that do work benefit and prosper
And really only things that benefit society
And that have demand can function
Because failure is possible
What communism tries to do is
Eliminate the possibility of failure
But by doing that they institutionalize failure
And finance it through state subsidies
And so you have basically a zombie system
Like in China they have what they actually call zombie factories
That don't draw profits
Don't barely function
Don't benefit the society
But are maintained as just essentially, you know
Mindless systems that just trudge forward
Now I think when people see this stuff
They feel hopeless
They don't know what they can do about it
They feel that the institutions against them are too broad
They feel that if they speak out
They're going to get attacked
You know, what is the way out with this?
Solutions are the hardest thing
First of all, Joshua, you're absolutely right
Communism is perfect at only one thing
It has a perfect record of failure
It has failed everywhere
Every culture
Whether it's German culture
Or Cuban culture
Or Chinese culture
Or Congolese culture
Communism has failed everyone
Of all colors and of all cultures
Why is that?
Because it is a vain attempt
At making man perfectible, right?
They believe in the new man
Che Guevara is el nuevo hombre
You know, but the thing is though
If you read the, you read texts
That were written thousands of years ago
Like the Bible or the Iliad
People depicted there thousands of years ago
Like Sarah, Abraham, Agamemnon, Helen
They're just like you and me
They have the same vices
They have the same foibles
They have the same weaknesses
And aspire to the same virtues as you and me
Freedom works with that
Freedom works with that flaw
The flaw that we all have
And tries to create a greater good for everybody
How do we solve our way out of it?
We have to look at each individual way
That this is happening
You have to develop a matrix
You take a look at cancel culture
In Biden using only equity
In the spread of critical race theory in our schools
In critical race theory trainings
That are taking place in workplaces
And create individual reactions to that
For example, with cancel culture
Maybe you have these drives to have people
Fired and cancelled from society
And have their livelihood taken away
Because somebody said something at one point
That seven years later somebody else finds offensive
Well, you can have counter drives
If they have a list of a hundred, you know, rational people
People who care about enlightenment values
Can have a list of a thousand
Say no, no, Steven Pinker should not be fired by Harvard
By the way, I don't agree with anything
With a lot of things that Pinker says
I agree with him on his affection for liberal values
You know, for natural rights
And for that, there's a mob out there trying to cancel him
Have a counter drive
With schools, let's try to have
Let's try to say, no, you cannot use taxpayer money
To have critical race theory trainings
Or any of these diversity and inclusion and equity
Trainings that are nothing but a replication
Of the Maoist struggle sessions of the cultural revolution
You know, in order to change people's thinking and behaviors and habits
So, I think the approach needs to be all of the above
But society can, we can fight back
Speak, first of all, learn about this stuff
Read my book, The Plot to Change America
But read it, read everything that's out there
And immerse yourself in the meaning of these things
Read the left, too
I read the left all the time
So I can write my books
And find out what they're saying
Yeah, well, Gonzales just said that Black Lives Matter says this
I'm going to go on their website
And find out what actually they're saying
Do that, and then you can speak rationally
To your neighbors, to your friends, to your family
There are many things we can do
Great, Mike Gonzales, real pleasure having you on Crossroads
Thank you
Thank you, the pleasure is all mine