Din Tai Fung, often considered the best Chinese restaurant chain in the entire world, is also very controversial
amongst Chinese Americans. We're gonna talk about why and what maybe the underlying issue is, because it goes much deeper
than soup dumplings. Oh, man, the things that divide a community, man. First off, Andrew, R.I.P. to Bing Yi Yang,
passed away at 96 years old. He is the founder, along with his wife, of the Din Tai Fung empire. Andrew,
they're very famous globally for being the most famous xiaolongbao soup dumpling chain in the world.
He was from northern China. He left during the war, went to Taiwan, had an oil company, started selling soup dumplings,
you know, infused some Japanese techniques to get the paper-thin skin and make sure every single one was consistent.
I mean, and then the rest is history. Yeah, guys, we're gonna talk about it.
Why is this so heavily debated and often it becomes a little bit of an emotional,
possibly political and ideological
issue? So, please hit that like button and check out other episodes of the Hot Pot Boys. David,
let's take it out from the micro, mid to the macro. Yeah, I'm not gonna lie, Andrew,
the micro is always shocking, because even on the R.I.P.
Bing Yi Yang post, Andrew, some people could just not resist and be like, well,
I think the Din Tai Fung is overrated and overpriced.
So, this is a huge debate. If you're gonna say that on somebody's R.I.P. post, like,
clearly, you just really strongly feel that way. It's the internet. But yeah, David,
let's just tackle this real quick. Is Din Tai Fung in 2023 overrated?
No, but,
no, but, I will say this, the Taipei 101 version is 10 out of 10, the rest in Asia are 9 out of 10.
I think once it came into America,
it slipped to 8.5 out of 10, and some of the locations are, like, down at 8 out of 10 now.
So, you're looking at a 20% discount off the peaks already, just because they just can't make them as good in America.
So, you're saying it might be causing some confusion, because some people are going to the Glendale location, or they're going to this new New York
location, and they're like, it wasn't as good as I remember. Or, this is not worth the money, because they are kind of pricey.
So, but then, obviously, whenever you come back from Taiwan, everybody's like, oh my gosh, Din Tai Fung was so good, it was the best.
Yeah, I'm not gonna lie, Andrew, the one near our hometown in South Center, by the airport in Seattle, is like a 7 out of 10.
That's the worst Din Tai Fung I've ever been to.
Here's my opinion, after having eaten a lot of xiaolongbao, from Shanghai, to America, to Taiwan, and Southeast Asia, even.
It's like, I just think Din Tai Fung is still the gold standard. I'm not saying it is 100% always the best, and better than everything else,
especially per dollar, but it's the gold standard. And everybody compares their soup dumplings to them, so, I don't know.
Tell me another gold standard. Show me another one.
Yeah, I'm not saying there's not mom-and-pop shops here and there that, like, don't give you a better value for your dollar,
but as far as a multinational chain, no way. I mean, honestly, that's my honest opinion, not sponsored.
I'll say this, Andrew. What are the two camps of people who are inherently anti-Din Tai Fung in the Chinese-American community?
One of them, and shout out to, we're part Shanghainese, is Shanghainese people.
Oh, yeah, well, that want to claim the xiaolongbao, obviously.
Well, they don't want a Taiwanese chain to make the best xiaolongbao when, originally, Shanghai's taking credit for it, right?
Right, just like anybody from Philadelphia doesn't want to admit that there's a better Philly cheesesteak outside of Philly, possibly.
Like, which is very, very possible, by the way.
Right, that is totally human nature. I will say this, though, Andrew.
The xiaolongbao actually is originally from Nanshang, Jiangsu, or some people even argue Wuxi.
Wuxi and, you know, Nanshang, they're close to Shanghai, but you know how it is, Andrew, in that region.
Shanghai is like the big dog water town. It's going to pretty much take credit for everything around that zone.
Right, right.
So that's the nativist angle, right?
I guess, from me and my perspective, that's just pretty logical.
You're not going to change those people's minds, right?
However, Andrew, there is another crowd that thinks that Din Tai Fung is white people soup dumplings.
Right, and I think these are a lot of Chinese-Americans and a lot of people who associate the fact of Din Tai Fung's popularity
and the fact that you can go to Din Tai Fung's and there are, like, all types of people eating, non-Chinese people eating there.
And they're very clean. They're very fancy. The build-outs are expensive.
And very expensive. Yes, it's not cheap to eat at Din Tai Fung.
So then they associate that with, oh, this is white people Chinese food.
Oh, it's for white people. But I'm like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, guys, guys, let's just be clear.
The first locations at Din Tai Fung were all in Asia, Taiwan and Shinjuku.
Yeah, Shinjuku, Tokyo. So what? Is it because it's less greasy and it's cleaner?
Was that to cater to white people or was that to cater to Japanese?
Or was it because Bing Yi Yang actually really admired the Japanese, like, mannerisms?
Right. Yes. Guys, in this video, I'm trying to tell you it's not the white people's fault here.
It might be the Japanese, the Japanese. Yeah, because obviously Japanese taste there.
The way they look at food and art, they obsess about it.
It's typically right. They obsess about it.
The very such attention to detail, professionalism, cleanliness.
Right. That's kind of the Japanese way is right.
And I'm not saying there's nobody in China doing that, especially, of course, the imperial chefs like that and stuff like that.
But on a general basis, people are probably more like Chabudo or Tamdo, which means like, you know, close enough.
So, David, if and let's take it out to the macro now, if Din Tai Fung is super clean and super systemized,
like they're putting 18 pleats in each little xiaolongbao, we were in the back of the kitchen before.
I went I cooked xiaolongbao in the back of the Taipei 101 location.
It is very robotic, systemized and very everything out.
Yeah. They weigh everything. And it's so exact, so precise.
I guess like why won't more people admit that it's like the gold standard xiaolongbao?
Or what is it about this that gets people so emotional?
I see Chinese American foodies that are like, no, no, no, no.
Even like somebody like Freddie Wong. Nice guy.
But I don't agree with his Chinese food takes.
Right. He says, no, he does not know more than we do.
I get out of the Chinese restaurant or that's overdone.
Like it's not worth it. I'm like, no.
Yeah. Listen, guys, I mean, to me, it just is like a nostalgia for like the folksy sort of village way of running things.
I'm not saying there's not some great products out of the villages.
I've been to Chinese villages myself.
I've been to places run by people from the villages.
There's a very certain charm to it.
Oftentimes the service is more service is more personable.
And of course, it's much, much cheaper.
But we cannot think that that can be the only representation of Chinese food that Chinese people want to eat.
Right. And you're saying that because Chinese food was not only solely for like blue collar people.
First of all, there's great dishes that come from everywhere.
I think we did a hell of a job blue collar rising it or blue collar rising dishes.
There were always staple dishes or even blue collar rising imperial dishes for the American market.
But that doesn't mean that it's meant to stay that way forever.
And I do think that mindset within the Chinese American community is slowing some of the progress.
Right. Like obviously, like Japanese, they don't care.
They'll charge like six hundred dollars per person for dinner.
But they feel like they're so confident in providing that amount of value for six hundred.
Are you trying to say that possibly sometimes the Chinese pragmatism, the extreme Chinese pragmatism,
perhaps overly pragmatic, if you will, can prevent Chinese people or Chinese culture cuisine from moving to where it could be?
Yes, that is one hundred percent true.
And I don't know where people you know, I get it.
I think the pragmatism is very logical looking at where things were with the poverty and the austerity.
And I think people spend a lot of time with their grandparents and their parents and they learn that pragmatism.
But that pragmatism really is a huge impediment to moving the cuisine forward.
Two things like how noodle, two things like dollar shop.
Dalong Yi, you know, didn't have fun.
Timo won. I'm not saying all of these are 10 out of 10 home runs, but you got to keep trying.
Not everything's going to stay the little mom and pop forever.
Those are great. And those serve a different demographic.
But that demographic can't be like, oh, I'm getting these shallow boughs half off and they're 80 percent as good.
And then hate on this. Listen, no, no.
And if you say you don't want to go to Din Tai Fung because it's overpriced, I totally understand that.
I don't go to Din Tai Fung all the time, partially because it's just it's just very pricey.
Right. Right. So I get it.
I am price sensitive. Everybody like, you know, we are.
We do Chinatown cheapies. We love Chinatown cheapies.
There's a place for it. There's always a place for it.
But there's always a place for another level up.
And I think what happens is sometimes people see like a pricier, high quality Chinese restaurant opening.
It doesn't have to be Din Tai Fung.
It could be any high end hotpot chain, Da Long Yi, anything from China.
And we're not talking about those like fusion spots like, you know what I mean?
Like a Mr. Chow's or something. Yeah, I'm not talking.
Yeah, I'm not talking about that.
But I guess every time somebody kind of sees that open, some people are like, oh, they're trying to replace my narrative,
the narrative that I'm part of and that Chinese food is just can be very cheap and it's the best deal.
And it's extremely tasty. It's folksy.
And you don't have to care about the menus.
You don't have to care about like you can they can be a little bit sticky and the service isn't good.
And that's how it should be.
And I'm like, that's how some of it should be to keep it cheap.
It has to be like that.
And especially for people, they should run businesses, you know, to survive and feed their family.
One hundred. But it doesn't mean that that's who we all are or what we have to be,
or that's the limit of what we can sell our cuisine to to other people at.
Right. Yeah, I mean, I'm not going to lie.
Just looking at the design of a xiaolongbao, David, the fact that there's the gelatin that melts to make the soup
and then you have to fold it all together and and very delicately steam it.
I feel like that's that must have come from like the middle class.
And listen, man, you got to understand the dispossession of a narrative like that's the same thing
that a lot of people are going through in America right now, right?
Certain things that felt like they were for them or they fit the bulk distribution of a group.
But all of a sudden, this whole framework is changing on them.
It makes people feel very uncomfortable, right?
Yeah, yeah, yeah. And obviously this is something very trivial, right?
We're talking about the niceness of a xiaolongbao spot.
Guys, we're literally talking about dumplings here, but it is also kind of an analogy for what is happening around tribalism.
Listen, a lot of people in America and this is taking a super, super macro,
but a lot of people in America feel like their country is changing before their eyes.
Well, I can't turn on the TV and see Johnny Cash anymore.
I got to see people with Dracos with an extendo clips.
I don't know all these purple hair, all these different identities, man.
I'm not ready for it.
That's not how I see the world.
And then you got coffee shops serving lattes for $7.
I mean, you know, growing up, I didn't even have lattes.
We just drank black coffee for $2.
What's going on here?
And I do empathize.
I empathize with anybody who feels like their narrative is shifting on them.
I mean, I'll give them this and I'll end it on this on my part.
Life was simpler back then.
For sure.
Life got more complicated.
It's a more nuanced world.
I admit it.
I even grew up in the nuanced world, so I can feel your pain.
But anyways, taking it out back to Chinese food.
You know, I just don't think as people who love Chinatown cheap eats,
I don't think that Chinese food always has to be cheap.
And I don't think that there's expensive Chinese food is always overrated.
And it's not always overpriced.
Sometimes you want a high end experience.
You want to be served politely and precisely by a Chinese person
or somebody who works at a Chinese restaurant.
And you want that experience.
And you want to know that your culture can reach this level.
It's great to know that it's also at this level.
But it's good to know it's at this level.
Hey, guys, there's room for everybody at every level.
All right, everybody, we're going to wrap it up right there.
Let us know what you think about this whole thing.
Obviously, if you're a foodie yourself, like,
do you think Din Tai Fung is very overrated?
And why?
And what does it mean?
Like, where do you want to see Chinese food in the future?
Is it a free for all?
Everybody can just fuse it, do whatever, make it expensive and do it at your own risk.
Yeah.
And do you think that Asian-Americans or Chinese-Americans,
we kind of get attached to this, like, certain way we grew up?
And then once it starts changing on us, do we feel uncomfortable with it?
Or should we just change with it?
Let us know in the comments section below.
I don't think there's a wrong answer.
Keep it civil.
Until next time, we're the Hot Pot Boys.
We out.
Peace.