TÁR Movie Review -- Breakfast All Day

Movie Cinema Film Entertainment Studios
1K followers
149 Video Views·Mar 12, 2023
Yeah, this is riveting.
And I would say you could absolutely make a case.
This is the best Cate Blanchett performance to date.
Hey everybody.
It's the latest from Todd Field, starring Cate Blanchett.
Tar, but first, have you subscribed yet?
Have you?
Maybe you should.
You might enjoy it here at Breakfast All Day.
It's fall movie season.
So we got Tar and Triangle of Sadness and Decision to Leave and Banshees of
Innishirin and all the good stuff is coming.
So stick with us.
If you've not hit the button yet.
We'd love to see you.
Um, yes, Cate Blanchett is Tar and this is just a tremendous
performance, like maybe the best ever from Cate Blanchett.
And that is saying something.
You want to dance the mask, you must service the composer.
You gotta supplement yourself, your ego and yes, your identity.
She plays this like prolific maestro, Lydia Tar, incredibly
accomplished and acclaimed.
She's at the absolute height of her acclaim and her abilities
at the beginning of this film.
She's an EGOT, which like is an impressive thing to be for
anybody, but for somebody who was an orchestra conductor, it
seems especially rare.
She's doing one of those New Yorker conversations where Adam
Gopnik tells you, that's one of the most elegant exposition
dumps I've ever seen in a movie.
Oh, it's riveting.
And like each new thing, each new accolade, it's like, come on,
really, she's all these things, but she is.
And so we see her as she goes about preparing to do
Mahler's fifth symphony.
She has conducted all the other ones, but like the fifth is
apparently incredibly complicated.
And so she's preparing to do that.
But a series of things is threatening to topple her and
her just incredibly impenetrable sense of self.
Like she is a total megalomaniac and a total control freak, but
also can be charming as hell and warm and seem to offer her
mentorship to people.
And she's just so incredibly good at what she does and has
been a prodigy for so long that it's impossible not to want to
be around that level of extreme greatness.
And so we watch as she tries to navigate a series of scandals
and also a series of internal struggles she is having.
Like she's one thing she's famous for is having an incredible
ear, but that haunts her as the film goes on.
It begins life as this very sharp, biting satire of the formality
and the conceitedness of the fine arts world, right?
How elitist it is.
But it slowly but surely becomes like a Gothic horror film in
terms of its sound design, in terms of the use of lighting.
And Cate Blanchett, the whole way, like watching her struggle
to keep it all together, like maintain that facade while
everything is crumbling around her is a totally fascinating
sense of tension.
Great supporting cast, including Noemi Merlant as her long time,
very loyal, but increasingly frustrated assistant who is
supposed to be next in line to be the assistant orchestra
conductor. Yeah, just watching her manipulate and gaslight
everyone around her so shrewdly and so brilliantly is like
darkly hilarious and terrifying at once.
She has to speak perfect German in this film and play the piano.
There's a whole long single take where she like teaches this
class at Juilliard that's just mesmerizing in like the peaks
and the valleys and the places she goes with it.
And it's just an incredible piece of filmmaking here.
Yeah, it's a it's an extraordinary sort of portrait of arrogance,
but also of accomplishment.
I've seen it described as a post post Me Too movie, which I
thought was interesting observation just in terms of the
more established you get, the more that maybe you can get away
with until you can't, you know, and that's the thing that we
sort of see kind of a lot of examples in the world right now
of people who's sort of well constructed barriers of
achievement and of power and of reputation and famous
friends. You know, where does that then end?
And suddenly you have to kind of face up to things that have
happened. Yeah, I think that you're right.
This movie does kind of take a turn into horror movie territory
in a way, but never in a sort of luridly obvious way.
Just very, very subtly and very much in the way that it's
constructed, the way the lighting shifts, the way the sound
design changes. Yeah, this is riveting.
And I would say you could absolutely make a case.
This is the best Cate Blanchett performance to date, and that's
no small feat. But I think what she is called upon to do here
and the granular level of this performance, the little details
about this character that kind of add up to all the things that
you learn and discover about her.
But then, yeah, she's surrounded by the likes of like, you know,
Nina Haas as her, as her, you know, long-suffering wife.
I think she's really great in this.
The woman who plays the sort of the cello virtuoso,
who's kind of potentially going to be her latest protégé.
Sophie Cower. So, yes.
And she's this Russian cellist in the film.
And she actually is a musician, but has to hold her own
opposite Cate Blanchett in all these scenes and does an incredible job.
Wow. I believed her as a musician.
I didn't know that she was not previously an actress.
But yeah, she's dynamite in this.
Yeah. So this is I think this is the kind of movie that will benefit
from repeated viewings, because once you know everything,
you know, at the end of this and you want to go back and sort of watch
how it all unfolds and what do we learn when and and just so much.
There's so much detail to take in here in terms of the performance,
in terms of how the music is presented and discussed in a very kind of heady way.
But yeah, I definitely look forward to seeing this.
The script is so complicated.
It really it's so rich in detail as far as this absolute high level of like
knowledge of specific composers, how classical music works.
I did not get a lot of it because I am not in any way an expert on that kind of stuff.
I'm sure people who are like serious music aficionados will get a lot of this
and appreciate the work that Todd Field put into the script to get all that stuff right.
Because it's the kind of thing that like if you've got it wrong,
you get called on to care really, really deeply.
And he gets granular is a good word for granular is the word you use to describe
the level of detail in the script in this world to make it all seem authentic.
And yet there's also a big picture relatability to the arc that she undergoes.
And when you find out what happens in the end, it makes her character
seem more human, seem more understandable.
This is not a spoiler.
Yeah, I have long felt like all of us, you, me, everybody, like we are all still
the 12 year old versions of ourselves, right?
All the insecurities that drove us, all the ambitions that motivated us
that pivotal time in our lives.
They are still there driving us to this day, no matter who you are, how far you go,
what accomplishments you achieve, like that thing is still in you.
And I feel like that is still in her.
And that's why she goes out of her way to show how incredibly knowledgeable she is
and how she'll command a room and tell these long stories, long name, droppy
stories, and, and it's all a desire to be adored, be taken seriously.
Um, in fact, she was a prodigy from a very young age, probably fucked her up in
terms of her sense of self and having to like over compensate in other areas.
You come to see the self she has created for herself, you know?
Yeah.
I love how the detachment of tone here, like the performance is passionate.
The music is incredible, but Todd field does not judge her.
And as you mentioned, like it's a me too movie, but from the.
Perpetrators perspective.
And he does not, he's not condemning her.
He's just like showing this incredibly complicated, flawed woman and
letting us decide for ourselves.
The same kind of cool detachment that exists in her, like chicly brutalist
bunker of an apartment exists everywhere in this film and just like let the drama,
I let the performance and the art of it speak for itself.
Yeah.
I look, I'm with you that a lot of the classical music talk went right over my
head, but it was, it's sort of like when.
Dan Aykroyd slips into jargon, scientific jargon in, in Ghostbusters.
I was like, okay, this is the, this is the air we're breathing now.
Fine movie.
You just say things and I'll, I'll nod and pretend like I know what's going on.
I believe you.
Yeah.
So I'm saying 9.8, this is one of the absolute best movies of the year.
There's a tiny, teeny little thing at the end that I don't love, but
then that's pretty much perfect.
I say eight and that's from one viewing.
So it's quite possible that like with subsequent viewings, I will love it even
more, uh, I think there are, there are some, like a few, I could pick at some
things if I wanted to, but, uh, it's absolutely a powerful film and one
that I will be thinking about a lot.
