When you look at the endings of the representatives of Legalism, you will be surprised to find that they all died horribly, without exception.
#gjwpluswatchparty Good news! Gan Jing World recently launched GJW+ streaming, a platform dedicated to presenting a wide array of clean, uplifting, traditional, and educational film and television works. Subscribe to GJW+ now for only $6.99 per month, the price of just two cups of coffee, and enjoy a top-notch viewing experience with your family. Click the link below and by using the exclusive discount code SARA, you can enjoy a 15% discount. https://www.ganjingworld.com/gjwplus/premium?utm_source=GJWEX&utm_medium=SARA
Support Sara and help keep the channel running! You can donate via the following: Email: [email protected] PayPal donation link: https://www.paypal.me/KSJChina Thank you for your support and encouragement! 🙏
In our previous episode, we talked about Mencius' most famous claim
that humans were by nature morally good, while Xunzi, the last of the great pre-Qing Confucians,
challenged him with the counterclaim that humans were by nature morally bad.
Xunzi admired Confucianism the most and was a loyal follower of Confucius. However,
his concept of benevolence and righteousness is no longer the traditional Confucianism
pursued by Confucius and Mencius. He declared,
nothing is better than integrity for the gentleman's cultivation of his heart.
With this personal integrity, the wise man could then adapt to the world around him.
He believed that the heavenly virtue of wisdom included the ability to adapt to the world
around us. He regarded some unexplainable natural phenomena as coincidences and disapproved of what
Communists considered to be the work of God. So his thoughts are considered to be simple
materialism and highly praised by scholars from the Chinese Communist regime.
Xunzi had two students, Han Fei and Li Si. The two learned Confucianism from Xunzi,
accepted his idea that human nature was inherently evil, but eventually gave up the concept of
benevolence and righteousness. They became representatives of Bajia, or legalism, later.
As we know, during the Spring and Autumn period and the Boring States period,
righteous clubs, the music was destroyed, and society was in turmoil.
According to Confucianism, social problems are mainly moral problems.
Legalists, on the other hand, believe that social problems are due to the lack of rule of law.
They sought to attain a rich state and a powerful army through severe punishments and strict laws,
rather than benevolence and morality, because they believed that human beings,
Communists and elites alike, will forever remain selfish and covetous of riches and fame,
and one should not expect them to behave morally.
Three groups of thinkers during the Boring States period, each with separate but related concerns,
merged during the Han Dynasty into a single school known as Legalism.
These thinkers had been known as the scholars of Fa, Shu, or Shi, respectively.
Sheng Dao is the representative of Shi, or power of possession.
Sheng Bohai is a representative of Shu, or statecraft.
Shang Yang is a representative of Fa, or law.
Han Fei pays equal attention to Shi, Shu, and Fa. He completes the rigorous Legalist theory
by integrating and combining the strengths of the three.
They first used the term Fa Jia or Sima Qian's father, Sima Tan,
in an essay on the Essence of the Six Schools of Thought.
Sima Tan notices that Fa Jia are strict and have little kindness,
and do not distinguish between king and stranger, nor differentiate between noble and base.
Everything is determined by the standard, or law, Fa.
A century later, the bibliographical category of Fa Jia was created by the Han librarian Liu Xiang.
Under the category, there were ten Legalist texts.
But only two arrived at our days relatively intact,
including Shang Jun Shu, or the Book of Lord Shang, and Han Fei Zi.
Shang Jun Shu is attributed to Shang Yang, or Gong Shu Yang,
prime minister of the state of Qin, a major reformer who orchestrated the rise of the state of Qin.
Shang Yang, the first of the fathers of Legalism, lived during the 4th century BC.
He had originally served as an official in the state of Wei,
one of the stronger neighbors of Qin in the east that took land from Qin.
Duke Xiao of Qin came into power in 362 BC.
He realized that Qin was weak and ashamed
because of political instability for generations in the past.
Therefore, he proclaimed that anyone who could contribute unusual strategems to make Qin great
again would be rewarded with prominent possessions and land.
Thus, Shang Yang went to Qin and soon found favor with Duke Xiao,
eventually being appointed to the office of minister in 357 BC.
Shang Yang implemented a range of reforms in Qin which were known as a change of law.
An area that Shang Yang paid special attention to was criminal law,
particularly the system of punishments.
Shang Yang believed that nothing is more basic for putting an end to crimes
than the imposition of heavy penalties.
He stated that punishments should know no degree or grade,
but that from ministers of state and generals down to great officers and ordinary folk,
whosoever does not obey the king's command,
violates the interdicts of the state,
or rebels against the statutes fixed by the ruler,
should be guilty and not be pardoned.
Merit acquired in the past should not cause a decrease in the punishment for demerit later.
In the past, there had been a Confucian idea
that rules of ceremony do not go down to the common people,
that penal statutes do not go up to great officers.
He also implemented a system that involved the organization
of the population into groups of ten and five families.
This form of organization was known as the Shi Wu system, or clan punishment.
Those who were members of the group of five or ten families
would end up sharing in the responsibility
for the crime of another member of the family unit.
It is an extreme manifestation of severe punishment.
He abolished hereditary institutions
and recognized the private ownership of land and allowed free trading.
Titles and views granted according to military merits
and the privileges of old nobles without military merits were abolished.
He established a county system, divided the kingdom into 41 prefectures,
and the monarch directly sent officials to govern.
After Shang Yang's reforms, Qin's economy developed
and the military's combat effectiveness continued to increase.
Qin developed into the most powerful state in the late Warring States period
and soon ended the Warring States period.
But Shang Yang made a lot of enemies during his day of power.
So as he fell from grace, when Duke Xiao died,
he was made to experience his legacy firsthand.
A mere few months after the death of the duke,
he became a wanted man by King Hui Wen.
As he fled from the Qin capital,
no one dared to house him due to the collective punishment laws he instilled,
and he could not produce the identity papers to stay in local inns.
In the end, he was killed during battle
and his corpse was taken to the capital and publicly portrayed.
Sadly, even his death became a legacy,
an example for subsequent regimes to persecute their opponents.
Han Fei Zi is attributed to Han Fei, also known as Han Fei Zi,
a prince of the state of Han.
Sima Qian said in Shi Ji that Han Fei could not properly present his ideas in court
because of his stature, his advice being ignored.
He developed one of the most brilliant writing styles in ancient China.
Seeing the state of Han was on the decline,
Han Fei often remonstrated with the king of Han by submitting papers,
but the king did not agree to employ him.
His papers ultimately ended up in the hands of the thrilled king of Qin,
Ying Zheng, who later became the first emperor of China.
Ying Zheng commented,
If I can make friends with this person, I may die without regrets.
In 234 BCE, Ying Zheng launched an attack on Han.
The ruler of Han dispatched Han Fei to negotiate with Qin.
Zheng was delighted to receive Han Fei
and planned to offer him a high position.
Li Si, the chief minister of Qin and a former schoolmate of Han Fei's,
presumably afraid that Han Fei might gain the king's favor by virtue of superior erudition,
he had Han Fei imprisoned.
Soon, Han Fei died in prison by taking poison that Li Si sent him.
Han Fei is often considered the most significant representative of legalism.
His thoughts on governing the country can be summed up as
heavy reward, heavy punishment, heavy agriculture, and heavy warfare.
Legalism has played a major role in the history of the Chinese legal and governmental tradition,
but legalists exaggerated and superstitiously believed in the role of punishment,
emphasizing the use of severe punishment to govern.
In addition, although Shang Yang and Han Fei have much to say on matters of culture and learning,
their message is predominantly negative.
Shang Yang is particularly notorious for his comprehensive
thought on traditional culture and moral values.
Han Fei's views of traditional culture and of learning echo Shang Yang's.
He said it was folly to cling to outmoded ways of the past, as the Confucians did.
He leaves his rivals no illusions.
Internationals can pursue their ideas only insofar as they are part of the state-ordained
system of power.
Otherwise, their ideas will be cut off.
He ended up eating his own fruit and was framed by Li Si.
Li Si persuaded Qin Shi Huang to suppress international dissent,
known as burning of books and burying of scholars in history.
When you look at the endings of the representatives of legalism,
you will be surprised to find that they all died horribly, without exception.
Sarah's History of China.
See you soon.