Silence & Apocalypse Now - The Thematic Link

Jack's Movie Reviews
15 followers
9 Video Views·Mar 8, 2023
Silence & Apocalypse Now - The Thematic Link
On a narrative level, there are a lot of similarities between Silence and Apocalypse Now.
They both follow Westerners going into Eastern lands in search of a once well-respected man.
Silence sees Father Rodriguez in search of Father Ferreira, someone who helped train
him and shaped him into the way he is today.
Apocalypse Now follows Captain Willard going deep into the heart of Vietnam in search of
Colonel Kurtz.
Both Ferreira and Kurtz betrayed what they once stood for.
It is rumored that Ferreira apostatized or renounced his Christian faith and that Kurtz
has betrayed the will of the U.S. military and has seemingly gone insane.
Our two protagonists, Rodriguez and Willard, both struggle with the idea of these two men
changing so drastically.
Rodriguez thinks that Ferreira's faith is too strong and Willard is convinced that Kurtz
isn't insane but instead just shaped by an insane war.
Along their way towards the two men they seek, Rodriguez and Willard are met with dehumanization.
All morals seem to be stripped away and Apocalypse Now, the U.S. military shows no humanity towards
the Vietnam people, willing to kill anybody for seemingly little gain.
In Silence, the Japanese government attack, torture, and kill anyone who practices Christianity.
When Rodriguez and Willard reach Ferreira and Kurtz, they realize that the stories are true.
Ferreira has apostatized leaving behind his faith and instead living a traditional Japanese life.
Kurtz has left behind the wishes of the U.S. military and instead lives as a god amongst
the native people.
I've never seen a man so broken up, ripped apart.
At this point the two protagonists are given a choice, to either join or renounce the other.
Here is where the most narrative deviation occurs.
Rodriguez chooses to follow in the literal footsteps of Ferreira and renounces his faith
and lives out the rest of his life in Japan, whereas Willard kills Kurtz and leaves Vietnam.
There are also a lot of parallels between the two on the production side.
Both are based on historical fiction novels, both are directed by two very highly respected
filmmakers known for their mafia films, and both had very long and very tricky productions
that were shot on location.
Apocalypse Now was shot in the Philippines and Silence in Taiwan, however where the two
films start to deviate from one another is thematically.
Apocalypse Now is among other things about insanity and what can cause someone to go insane.
The film's answer is war.
As we follow Willard through the madness of the United States' involvement in Vietnam,
we are constantly reminded that what we are seeing is also what Kurtz experienced.
The film tells us that the Vietnam War was one of hypocrisy, and Willard's mission exemplifies this.
He is tasked to kill someone because that person has killed others.
Charging a man with murder and expanding out speeding tickets at the Indy 500.
On his way towards Kurtz, Willard sees in full effect the dehumanization of war.
He watches innocent people die, he watches people humiliate themselves and sees death
and destruction for seemingly no reason at all.
When Willard reaches Kurtz, he does what he is told and he kills him.
However, in doing this, Willard becomes what Kurtz had become.
He doesn't value human life and he is a cold-hearted killer.
His journey up the river is his journey towards insanity.
It may wear a different mask, but by the time that he is done with his mission, he has become
what he was tasked with killing.
In Silence, we follow Father Rodriguez, someone who has not had anything too challenging in his life.
He is deeply devoted to his faith, but he has spent most of his life surrounded by people
who all practice his same faith.
It isn't until he reaches Japan does he really have it challenged and really realize what
his faith means.
In a country where people are prosecuted and killed for practicing Christianity, the people
who choose to still practice Christianity have true faith.
They are willing to give up everything they have because the sense of purpose that their
religion gives them is worth more than anything material.
Rodriguez is willing to give up comfort and food to find Ferreira, but it isn't until
he is faced with a choice does he understand faith.
He can either renounce Christ, something that he has been conditioned his entire life to
believe is the worst thing imaginable, or watch these five men die.
He realizes that faith isn't defined and restricted by a book or a set of teachings.
He saves the lives of the followers and his faith is taken to a whole new level because
of that choice.
He failed his mission, he wasn't able to save Ferreira and became what he feared the most.
But in doing so, he gained a new appreciation of religion and truly understood it.
Both of these movies have a similar narrative structure and both films follow a protagonist
undergoing total change.
But Apocalypse Now is a movie about our protagonist losing everything that he has, whereas Silence
is about our protagonist sacrificing so much to gain so much more.
Undeniably, Silence pays homage to Apocalypse Now, look no further than the color palette.
But I think it goes beyond that.
I think Silence answers the call of Apocalypse Now.
It takes the message presented, but looks at it in a brand new light.
To provide different insights and reimagine a great story.
Hey everyone, I hope you enjoyed.
I really love both of these films and I'm interested in knowing what your thoughts,
so be sure to drop a comment and get your thoughts out there.
If you haven't seen it yet, be sure to check out my last video where we looked at John
Belushi and his acting style and what makes him so great.
I've got another video going up next Saturday that I'm really excited to share, so hit that
subscribe button and I'll see you next week.
Thanks for watching.
