Hot Sauce Expert Guesses Cheap vs Expensive Hot Sauce | Price Points | Epicurious

Foozzt Do'food
956 followers
2 Video Views·Mar 6, 2023
I'm Noah Chamber and I'm a hot sauce expert.
Oh yeah. Let's take a look at what we got here. Ruddy brown color, very consistent. Some hot
sauces you'll have more chunks, you have more body to them. This looks like it's been blended
thoroughly. Little seeds here and there but pretty sparse. Seeds would be coming from the chili
peppers themselves. This guy here, a little bit of flex that could be some spice or maybe some
black pepper but looks very consistent and uniform. Let's see what they smell like.
Lots of aroma here. Definitely cumin and little hints of chili pepper. On this guy,
not as much going on. Smells a little bit like a michelada. Seems like the type of thing you'd
mix with a beer to make a michelada. Let's give these a taste. Nice speckling throughout.
Guessing a bigger variety of ingredients here. Lots of flavor right off the bat. Definitely
tasting that cumin. Getting onion. Nice heat right away at the front of the mouth. Pretty mild
but slowly building in heat. So I'm guessing more than one type of chili pepper in there.
Different types of peppers will have different heat profiles. So some might get you right at
the tip of your tongue and fade quickly. Some like a habanero will get you at the back of the throat
and some like a ghost pepper take a little bit of time to build. So I'm guessing there's probably
some ghost pepper in here. Let's give this guy a try. Looks perfectly uniform. It's all one color.
Seeing very little variation in there. That's a very simple and straightforward. Arrives in one
way and it leaves the same way. It doesn't stick around for too long. When you're buying hot sauce,
you're paying for two things. The flavor and the heat. The capsaicin that's in chili peppers
triggers this reaction in your brain that actually makes your body think that your mouth is on fire.
So your brain releases all these great chemicals and compounds and adrenaline to help you deal
with the situation it perceives as being really dangerous and all that stuff makes you feel great.
So if I had to guess which one is more expensive, I would definitely go with the one that has a lot
more complexity, a lot more depth of flavor, different ingredients, and the more expensive
chili peppers. These ghost peppers tend to be pricier, which is what I'm guessing is in there.
My guess is definitely that A is the more expensive. Let's take a look.
Yeah, without a doubt. So when you're shopping for a Mexican style sauce, definitely check the labels.
For one, is water an ingredient? And water can be okay, but is it right at the top of the ingredients
list? Also be on the lookout for salt. Sometimes with Mexican sauces, they'll use a lot of salt to
replace some of the other flavors that you could otherwise get and that sodium can add up really
quickly. So just be sure to check the label. In terms of color, nice bright color can be really
attractive, but is it filled with stabilizers and artificial preservatives that are keeping the color
that way? For me, I'd prefer something that looks a little more natural because it's probably going
to taste a little more natural. All right, let's see what we have here. I'm seeing some nice
separation here. Got a little bit of oils floated to the surface. Lots of seeds settled at the
bottom. A little flex here and there of something. No settling or separation. Let's see what they smell like.
So I'm going to shake it up, especially with these vinegar-based sauces where you're going to get
some settling. So when you see it at the grocery store, it might be a little clear on the top.
Totally natural and just know to shake it. So aroma-wise, it's a vinegar-based sauce, so you
definitely pick that up right away. But you don't get the burn in the nostrils that you'll get with
the standard distilled vinegar. This has a little more warmth to it, a little more pungency.
Some types of natural vinegars where it's a little closer to the fermentation,
you'll get a little bit of that funkiness to it, which I think makes it really interesting.
Let's take a look at this guy here. Give it a shake too. I'm not sure as necessary here.
Sweet aroma, definitely. Getting, yeah, lots of chili pepper smell. Smells almost faintly
like strawberries. I'm curious about the type of pepper in there. Let's give these a try.
I love that. So taste-wise, these vinegar sauces, picking it up in the cheeks right away. Heat-wise,
not super hot, not picking up a ton of heat. Sweet on the back of the tongue though,
so that's interesting. It's hard to put the finger on exactly what type of pepper is in there,
but nice vinegar tones. You can tell it's a quality vinegar in there. Let's give this other guy a try.
Definitely a lot more saltiness right off the bat. You get salt on the tip of the tongue.
Nice chili peppers though. I'm thinking cayenne or anaheim pepper. Overall though,
the salt kind of dominates the flavor. So guessing which of these is more expensive,
I'd have to go with A on this one. Just based on the look of it, I'm guessing it's a smaller
batch process that went into making this product. I can see the ingredients. I see the seeds from
the peppers that are in there. Definitely more nuanced. Tasting the vinegar, it's not
standard distilled white vinegar. It's something with a little more interest to it and fermentation
that's a little more active. The sauce over here, while still really tasty,
add a lot of salt to it and that always makes me a little bit questioning. When I taste a lot of
salt in a product, what's that salt covering up? Also the consistency that we see here,
perfectly uniform throughout, tells me there's a very commercialized process. So the types of
machinery that they use to make a sauce with that type of consistency on the shelf is not something
that's really going to have a lot of involvement by hand. My guess is that A is more expensive.
Let's take a look. Yeah, that makes sense. So when you're shopping for a vinegar-based sauce
at the grocery store, just look at the type of vinegar that they're using. The most common that
we see is distilled white vinegar and that's been used for a long time and people use it for
cleaning around the house and for cooking and preserving. Apple cider vinegar, which I suspect
is what's in here, has become really popular in the last few years. People like it for its
supposed health benefits, but I really like it for its flavor. It has a little more pungency to it,
a little more funk, but vinegar can be fermented from all kinds of different things. So as you
travel around the world, in China they have black vinegar fermented from rice and in South Korea
they have persimmon vinegar. It's all kinds of fun stuff going on. So there's a big variety and
we're seeing more and more hot sauce makers leveraging that variety. All right, let's take
a look at what we have here. Rich red color, not a lot of movement at all. I can turn it totally
upside down, it's really taking its time. Very uniform consistency throughout, not seeing much
of anything colored here, little flecks of pepper flesh here and there. Whereas over here, definitely
faster movement and sometimes that can be related to the content of the sauce and sometimes also
a lot of hot sauces that are out there, you're going to see artificial thickeners or things like
xanthan gum designed to make them not move around as much. So usually if something's moving pretty
easy, that could be a good sign that it's natural. To me it looks almost creamy and normally when we
see that in a hot sauce, it's usually because there's oil in there and when the oil is whipped
or blended as part of the sauce making process, it'll emulsify a little bit and give it almost
this creamy look to it that almost always is not dairy. Let's see how they smell.
Definitely getting healthy notes of garlic in there and a little bit of funk, maybe something
like fish sauce or some type of fermentation. Almost a little bit of a pickley smell.
Appealing though. Whoa, that's different. Smells definitely like peppercorns. So not
chili peppers themselves, but peppercorns like black pepper that we think of that will have a
much more floral aroma, but really appealing and nice too. Let's give them a try. Okay,
that's sriracha. You would know it anywhere. Really tasty. So anybody's free to call their
sauce is sriracha and some people will do it as an homage to some original sauce. Some people do
it as referencing a place in Thailand and some people do it just because that term has become
so synonymous with hot sauce where they are that they thought that that's just what you call hot
sauce. The classic elements I picked up in here told me right away what this is. It's a little
bit of that pickled flavor paired with the overt sweetness and that medium heat really indicates
to me that this is sriracha. So let's give this other one a try.
Right away, super bright up front. The front of the mouth getting flavors of
lemon and ginger. Super floral. This is loaded with those peppercorns. And then just a hint
of sweetness towards the back. And now a heat that is slowly building and building. This is
actually a pretty hot sauce. Really tasty though. This is for people who are well versed in hot
sauce and who like it at the spicier end of things. I might actually have some more of this one just
to cool off. Hot sauce to cool down. I'm thinking Asian for these sauces because the sriracha
flavors, the garlic that's in there, the pickled flavors, it's a strong indicator. And in this
sauce here, the ginger and the very floral peppercorns that are in there really give a
strong Asian vibe to it. So definitely considering the amount of heat that was in this one,
the mouthfeel, the different types of ingredients and aroma, I'm definitely going to guess that this
is the more expensive sauce. This one tastes really high quality, but a lot of sugar in there.
It's a little more day-to-day and pedestrian. You could use a lot of it. So I don't imagine
it would be too pricey, but let's take a look. Yeah, definitely more expensive over here.
Important to keep in mind when evaluating the price differences with different things that
they each have their place. If you want to go nuts and use a ton of sauce, something like this might
be a better bet. That being said, I imagine that this bottle for $18 is going to last you a lot
longer than this one over here, because with this sauce, you really only can be using a small amount
at a time. When we talk about Asian sauces, we're talking about a big geographic area, a lot of
different cuisines, a lot of different cultures. So when you read that ingredients list, there might
be some things on there that you've never heard of before, but it's a really fun area to experiment
with. All right, let's see what we got here. This rich brown color and strong consistency tells me
that we're looking at barbecue hot sauces. So taking a look at this one, we see it really is
sticking in its place, nice and thick. Not a bad trait when it comes to a barbecue type sauce
like this. Pretty even, rich chocolatey brown color throughout. Little bits of chili pepper
seeds here and there. Taking a look at B, some flecks and some different coloration. Got some
different things going on, so that'll be interesting. Body-wise, you see similar. Color-wise, it's got
kind of a more caramel-y color than the other one. Getting smoked right away, which is a good sign.
That's what you want in barbecue. Getting almost a bit of a citrus note, so maybe something like
lime in here, which would be nice for a barbecue sauce. Nice amount of complexity. Smells like
there's interesting things going on. That doesn't smell great. This one has an interesting smell.
Can't pick out anything too particular. Something faintly chemical about it, almost like a room
that was painted a couple weeks ago and you walked in there. Not the most appetizing smell, but
we won't hold that against it just yet. We'll see what it tastes like. But first, let's do this A.
Wow, a lot of flavor going on there. Definitely some type of citrus. I'm thinking lime.
Healthy sweetness, almost tamarind type of flavors. And then in the back, you get the smoke.
Not a lot of heat, a little bit of heat. So I'm guessing something like maybe
chipotle or an ancho chili, something like that. Definitely smoked pepper, but that citrusy sweet
fruit flavor is a really nice balance, a really nice tasting sauce. Let's move on to B here.
So B, if you can see, kept the shape of a droplet. Maybe even a bit more stiffness than we want.
And yeah, it's not going anywhere. So that suggests to me, possibly there's some additives
in here, not due to the process of cooking it down over a long period of time, like if you
made barbecue sauce at home, but just more of a chemical way of achieving that effect.
Let's give it a try. Like a sweet bomb right away in the mouth. It's not feeling quite like
natural sugar. It feels to me like some type of processed sugar, like a corn syrup or something
like that. You can feel it a little more towards the back of your throat as it's going down.
Not a ton of flavor overall, though. Passed pretty quickly. In terms of which one I think
would be more expensive, I'm going to have to go with the one that tasted a lot better.
I can tell from the taste of it that this one took more time, that this one had higher quality
ingredients, and that a little more care was put into the production of it. But let's find out.
Yeah, so makes sense to me. And if you're going to the trouble of doing something like barbecue,
let's say you're going to be smoking some ribs or something like that. To me, it's worthwhile
to spend a little bit extra to complement that with some amazing flavors that your guests are
definitely going to appreciate. Versus something like this, which feels a lot more fast food,
almost the store-bought, whereas this tastes like the quality of homemade. This sauce seems
really reminiscent of a Texas-style barbecue, and they share a lot of the same chilies that
you'll see from Mexico. So jalapenos, serranos, poblanos, and natural wood smoke is always going
to be the best. Some less expensive products you'll see with artificial smoke, and I suspect
that's what's happening here. And that's where a smoke distillate, just like from a jar, a little
liquid smoke is added to give it the flavor, but it never comes across the same way as when
the chilies themselves are smoked using real hardwood.
Let's see here. Dark color, seeing a couple seeds, otherwise pretty uniform throughout. Let's take a
look at this guy. So this one is what we'd call pepper dense. You can really see that there's a
lot of pepper in here. I'd expect that pepper would be the number one ingredient. This looks
like somebody just mashed up some peppers and put them in a bottle. Let's see how they smell.
Getting some nice nostril burn, mild sweetness almost. Definitely smells very hot. When you're
smelling a super hot sauce, which I'm expecting this is, you'll get that feeling in the nostrils
right away. The nose tells you, the pepper wants to warn you that it's hot. Peppers develop
capsaicin as a defense mechanism so that animals would need them, specifically mammals, because
mammals have teeth and molars and will chew up the seed. So peppers don't want to be eaten by
mammals because then their seeds are destroyed. Interestingly, birds aren't affected by the heat
and chili peppers at all because peppers actually want to be eaten by birds because birds don't have
teeth. So they'll ingest the seeds and then they'll fly away, crap them out somewhere into
a nice little pile of fertilizer and the pepper then spreads its domain that way and its offspring.
So the capsaicin in the chili peppers is a natural defense mechanism. So let's take a look at B.
So that has just chili pepper scent up and down. This smells like somebody just cut open a super
hot pepper. It's a really distinct nostril burning, kind of acerbic type of smell. Almost a
citrus undertone to it. Interesting. A bit scared to try these too, but glad we saved them for last.
Only going to take a little bit so don't judge me. That does not taste good. It tastes like
like a car just did a burnout and you took a bite of the tire.
The heat's spreading on the tongue. This is a really very hot sauce.
Can I yell cut or...
That water made it worse. I should have known. So yeah, flavor-wise leaves a lot to be desired.
This kind of what I would call a prank sauce is what you use to pull a trick on a buddy
when you're in college. Not really food. Nobody would buy this for nutrition or sustenance or
flavor. Got a little tear going so that's fun. So level of heat in there, flavor.
Telling me that's not a lot of chilies. Telling me there's extracts in there. Extracts are a chemical
distillation of the capsaicin compound. So it's normally a clear substance that you can use to
add to a sauce to add a lot of heat without adding any flavor. I'm not a big fan if you couldn't
tell. Let's check out the other sauce. Whoa. That is very sweet. Not sugary at all but sweet on the tip
of the tongue like a tropical fruit almost. Keeping in mind that peppers are fruits. So
confirming what I thought that this is a really pepper dense sauce.
This particular sweetness and the level of heat that I'm getting from it. I have heat that starts
in the center of the tongue is spreading outwards spreading backwards down the shoulders.
The sweetness and the heat profile make me suspect pretty strongly that this is a Carolina
Reaper based sauce. Carolina Reaper was made the hottest pepper in the world in the Guinness Book
of Records in 2013. Developed by a pepper breeder named Smokin' Ed Curry down in South Carolina. He
will have this very sweet fruity profile to it. Nice flavor but lingering burning heat. I'm still
feeling it quite hot on the tongue. Not in a way that feels like I regret my decisions. If I had to
guess which one of these was more expensive I would definitely say it's the sauce that's full
of natural peppers. Peppers cost money and this sauce is full of them. So knowing what I know
about peppers and the way that sauces are made. If this sauce is primarily peppers with the
density that it looks like. I'd say there's at least 20 whole peppers in here. Over here
is definitely extract and with that stuff a little goes a long way. They used a little
bit more than a little so I don't think this stuff is going to be free either. Let's find out.
Yeah that makes sense. High quality delicious chili peppers with tons of heat are gonna have
a certain cost. Whatever this was it's gonna have a different cost. In my opinion hot sauce should
always be thought of as food. We like to say food that goes on food and food has to have good flavor
so I'm never gonna approach a sauce that doesn't have good flavor as the first check mark on my
list because otherwise I'm not going to want to put it on my food. So when you're at the grocery
store looking for a super hot sauce though to be honest you're not going to find anything like
either of these two at a normal grocery store. When you're at a specialty hot sauce shop looking
for a super hot sauce read the ingredients list. Your super hot pepper should absolutely be the
number one thing on that ingredients list. So some super hot peppers to look for will be things like
Carolina Reaper that I think is in here. The ghost pepper is a popular one. The Moruga scorpion
pepper. Pepper X. There's a good variety of them. Things you want to avoid in my opinion
are going to be extracts. So on labels you'll see those listed as something like oleurosin extract,
capsaicin extract, things like that. Something that suggests that it's not whole
ice peppers that are going into that bottle. When you're thinking about hot sauce and thinking about
spending a little more 10 or 12 dollars on a bottle of hot sauce think about how much value
you're going to get out of that and if it's going to sit in your fridge for two or three months then
you might get 20 or 30 or 40 meals out of it so it's worth investing in some better ingredients
a fresher higher quality product.
