Top 5 Defensive Infields in Baseball?

sports and sports
111 followers
1 Video View·Feb 12, 2023
Top of the hour on a Friday J.P.
Morose back with us sleeping on
the sweater either man that's
nice it is nice nice sweater and
to talk about nice defenses J.P.
has ranked the best infield
defensive units in the game
appropriate J.P.
as we're counting down the top
100 players on the network
currently you're talking about
units here groups take it away.
Yes Matt and Bill and I also
rank as the most likely MLB
network broadcaster to wear an
Argyle sweater on the air.
Just yes you do.
So with no further ado the
number five team and the best
infield defenses in major league
baseball the Arizona Diamondbacks
the team that we don't give
enough credit to I believe for
how much they've improved.
They're just in a tough division
right now.
I think Walker is a very
underrated defensive first
baseman can tell Marte as we saw
earlier likely to be the second
baseman for the Dominican
Republic.
You consider Rojas is a really
good defensive profile at
shortstop Nick Ahmed.
I still believe one of the very
best defensive shortstops in the
sport.
So again the Diamondbacks
continuing to improve with Tory
Lovell there as the manager.
They are number five on my list
number four.
I'm going to stay in the
National League West team that's
had a bit of a remake of their
infield with the arrival of
Xander Bogarts and let's be
honest guys you think about
Bogarts and Manny Machado on the
left side.
How could you do much better
than that on both sides of the
baseball Hassan Kim can play now
on the right side.
Jake Cronenworth the very
versatile player of course.
And why wouldn't he be.
He's a two sport athlete growing
up in the great state of
Michigan.
So I like the way the Padres fit
right now in terms of being the
fourth best team in terms of
infield defense in the major
leagues.
Now going back to the number
three spot the Cleveland
Guardians the youngest team in
baseball this past year also one
of the most athletic for my
money especially on the infield.
You think about Andres Jimenez
he will likely play shortstop
for Team Venezuela at the World
Baseball Classic but he's
playing second base on this team
because you've got Ahmed Rosario
playing short.
I still believe Jose Ramirez
could basically play anywhere on
the infield and be an MVP level
defender.
Of course they've got Josh Bell
now arriving to play first base.
He continues to improve on the
defensive side of the ball.
Now for manager Terry Francona
the number two the second best
defensive infield in the major
leagues the New York Yankees
still a great depth of talent in
their infield right now they're
potentially adding in some more
talent.
We saw Oswaldo Cabrera he could
now play infield there depending
on where he's most needed for
the Yankees.
Oswald Peraza as well.
I really like the way he played
especially under some pressure
situations there in the post
season.
I really like Peraza's potential
at some point they'll have Volpe
there still Gleyber Torres as an
option.
They've got D.J. LeMahieu to move
around Anthony Rizzo still one
of the very best defensive first
baseman in the major leagues.
Now the number one best defensive
infield you've got to love the
St. Louis Cardinals.
They've got a pair of MVP
players on both sides of the
ball on the corners the pillars
of the organization Paul
Goldschmidt Nolan Arnold and up
the middle Tommy Edmond now
moves over to shortstop.
Of course when they need him
they can still bring Paul De
Young back.
They've got Donovan to play some
second base.
They've got Nolan Gorman there
as well.
So both because of the depth and
the talent Bill I love the way
the Cardinals play defense.
And now for the further
examination of my list and I
welcome all scrutiny to the
great Bill Ripken.
Well I'm not going to throw
scrutiny at you because I
applaud the number one team the
Cardinals in that mix.
And I had a conversation with
Keith Costas being the resident
Cardinal fan and Savant as far
as that club goes.
But here's the thing too because
for some reason in this world of
measuring this measuring that
we've placed first base at a
very low like defensive value.
And I'd like to point back when
the Cardinals went out there and
got Paul Goldschmidt the year
before they got him they led the
planet making errors the year
after they got him for one year
they led the planet in least
amount of errors.
And it was basically the first
baseman that came into play.
And truly when you're in this
mix Keith if I can bring you in
he was the only one from outside
that group that came in.
And when you post one hundred
and sixty times like he does and
plays first base really well the
first baseman at all levels of
baseball if you think about it
truly has the ability to make
the second baseman shortstop and
third baseman better being able
to handle the bag.
And Keith am I wrong with he was
the only outsider coming into
the group.
Yeah I mean they had some moving
parts.
Tommy Edmund made his debut that
year but he was an internal
promotion guy.
So he was really the big change.
And I agree with you Bill if you
look at some of these advanced
metrics he's been worth twelve
defensive runs saved for his
entire tenure with the Cardinals.
That's about half of what the
league leader in a given season
usually has.
And that just does not stack up
to me for all the reasons you
just said.
He transformed the entire
defense this past year as
defensive metrics were
particularly low.
He didn't really line up with
the eye test watching the team
every day for me.
So I agree with you.
He completely transformed the
entire look of the team
defensively let alone what he
does as an MVP caliber
offensive player.
Yeah.
JP where was Atlanta in your
thought process.
Would did the Swanson thing with
him leave him because there's
part of this when you talked
about the overall defensive
unit.
I will still go to my grave
saying I don't want multiple
people playing multiple
positions because I think the
only way to put your best foot
foot forward truly defensively
as a unit is have familiarity
and consistency throughout the
diamond and a team like Atlanta
if I always didn't get hurt
those four guys play 160 games
a year and they can all flash
the leather.
So I like the consistency that
goes on as far as an infield
unit goes.
I had them at number six and it
was a tough call for me D-Box
and Braves.
I'm going with the D-Box and the
continuity and consistency with
Nick Ahmed versus the unknown in
Von Grissom.
I believe that he can handle it
but we don't know yet.
He hasn't done it yet for one
sixty two.
He's worked tirelessly already
this offseason with Ron
Washington.
I believe that Von Grissom is
going to prove it but he has to
prove it.
And to your point you look at
third base.
Riley I think really profiles
well defensively.
Olson I believe is a well above
average first baseman and all
these to your point when he's
when he's healthy and available
is is one of the very best
defensive second baseman.
I also think that Bill everything
you said about Goldschmidt and
the Cardinals also applies to
Rizzo and the Yankees.
Great athlete.
We know how well he defends the
bunt as well.
The athleticism that he brings a
great target at first base and
this now.
And for me Bill I'm going to
really want to check back with
you during the course of the
year just in talking about the
game that we love about how
athleticism durability and range
are going to now come into play
without the shift because you
want to have a shortstop and
second baseman in particular who
have range.
We've seen for a long time the
shift and the ability to
reposition players has really
allowed second baseman in
particular who don't have a ton
of range to stay in the game and
play that position longer and
longer.
You can't fall back on that
anymore.
And so now it is it is the
domain of the athletes and the
guys that stay on the field.
And I think we're going to have
a by about the middle part of
this year a real truth test as
to who the truly great rangy
athletic middle middle
infielders are.
Yeah a lot of good points there
man.
Goldschmidt made the Cardinals
better.
Rizzo made the Yankees better.
Rizzo.
No no.
Anthony Rizzo made the
Cardinals better.
JP thank you.
Good stuff.
