🔴TRY IT NOW just by signing up with your email at Epoch TV👉 https://ept.ms/30uibGS Michael Shellenberger says that "the initial impetus to get people into psychiatric hospitals was very humanistic," adding that "treatment of the mentally ill has always been extremely difficult." Shellenberger says that at one point, the US "started literally dumping people from the psychiatric hospitals onto the street," leaving many without the care they desperately need.
Harvard Epidemiologist Martin Kulldorff: Hospitals Should Hire Nurses with Natural Immunity, Not Fire Them https://ept.ms/1026MartinKulldorff1
Victor Davis Hanson: The ‘Era of Intimidation,’ Tribalism, and Elite Contempt for the Middle Class https://ept.ms/TheDyingCitizen1
Nicolas Chaillan, Former Pentagon Software Chief, on What U.S. Must Do to Win China AI Battle Before ‘Point of No Return’ https://ept.ms/USChinaAIRace1
Dr. Robert Malone on Ivermectin, Escape Mutants, and the Faulty Logic of Vaccine Mandates (PART 2) https://ept.ms/EscapeMutants1
Dr. Robert Malone, mRNA Vaccine Inventor, on Latest COVID-19 Data, Booster Shots, and the Shattered Scientific ‘Consensus’ (Part 1) https://ept.ms/VACCINEQUESTIONS1
Clyde Prestowitz: How Communist China Entrapped America’s Elite, from Washington to Wall Street https://ept.ms/TheChinaTrap1
North Korean Defector Yeonmi Park on Communist Tyranny and ‘the Suicide of Western Civilization’ https://ept.ms/382FHeA
Just to talk about the incarceration, the flip side is, as a Canadian looking in,
it's unbelievable how many people are incarcerated. You describe in the book,
and this has been documented on this show a number of times before, that people with mental illness
end up in prison or they're in these open-air drug markets, but they're not
in the sort of scenario that would actually help them, because neither of those scenarios
necessarily help them. That's right, and it's an issue I'm
sensitive to. My aunt suffered from schizophrenia. She was pretty well taken care of. She lived in
residential care in Denver, Colorado. She had her own bedroom, a shared living space,
shared kitchen space. She was too disabled to work, so she was cared for by taxpayers,
but in a really positive way as possible. A lot of people remember how terrible our psychiatric
hospitals became around mid-20th century, and that's true. But it's important to remember
that the treatment of the mentally ill has always been extremely difficult and often really terrible.
So in the 19th century, the 18th century, people with mental illness were locked up in
basements and barns, literally in chains. Many people were killed.
So the initial impetus to get people into psychiatric hospitals was very humanistic.
We then had the Great Depression. We had World War II. They were short-staffed in those hospitals,
and the activists that were trying to reform the hospitals took the story to Life magazine and Look
and these other big magazines and newspapers. We saw photos of how terrible the hospitals were.
At the same time, progressives were pushing for a very humanistic response, at least they thought,
to treat the mentally ill in communities. But what ended up happening, and this occurred,
starts under President John F. Kennedy and accelerates after that, is we just started
literally dumping people from the psychiatric hospitals onto the street.
Some people did get the care that they needed, like my aunt. Other people ended up homeless
and often addicted to hard drugs, and then many other people ended up in jail and prison.
I point out that the institution that has the most seriously mentally ill people in the country
is Los Angeles County Jail, kept in absolutely terrible conditions, at least for this
population. It's much easier to deal with somebody with depression or mild depression
who becomes addicted to heroin. That's someone who we have a better experience dealing with.
But people with schizophrenia or severe bipolar disorder, sometimes it's hard to tell them apart,
that's a group of people that are extremely difficult to deal with, and it requires
some amount of sophistication, but it certainly requires engagement and some amount of coercion.
Otherwise, people end up getting hurt. We don't allow people with dementia,
our grandparents suffering from Alzheimer's or dementia, we don't allow them to wander the
streets and live on the streets. One of the questions I wanted to ask was, why then do we
allow people that are suffering from psychosis, whether from schizophrenia or from chronic meth
use, to be on the streets? You get the impression that it's a combination of
good intentions and very specific ideology, like Foucault's ideology, I guess, or something that
came from him. Michel Foucault is this incredibly influential intellectual. It's interesting,
a lot of people that did not get graduate degrees in the social sciences or the humanities are not
familiar with Michel Foucault, but his ideas—he's a French historian,
wrote widely in the 60s and early 70s—was hugely influential. Many of the ideas today that we take
for common come from him. One of his first big books was on the treatment of mental illness,
and in it, first of all, it turned out it was an inaccurate history. But basically,
he celebrated this idea. He promoted this idea, which was very popular in the 60s and also very
wrong, which was that there is no such thing as mental illness. They promoted the idea that
basically, these are people that were just, we say today, neuroatypical. They're sort of quirky
or slightly different, and that the mistreatment of those folks is just a kind of prejudice, or
according to Foucault, it was actually a way to enforce standards of the Enlightenment and of
reason on people. And so there was a sort of romantic view that if these folks were just
allowed to be free in society, everything would be fine. It didn't turn out that way.
Seriously mentally ill people that are not properly taken care of can get into a lot of
trouble, including committing acts of violence. They can be in psychotic states for a long time
and end up hurting other people or hurting themselves. Then Foucault had a similar take
on prisons, which is that he was actually against rehabilitation. He viewed it as too insidious,
as a power trip, and so also was a big critic of basically any kind of incarceration or any kind of
really the whole criminal justice system was suspicious from his point of view,
because we needed something that looked a lot more like what we would call anarchism
or much more decentralized government or no government at all.
So how does this manifest in the opposite, which is mass incarceration and the other side being
lack of treatment for people?
One way to look at these two waves where we had a huge increase in homicide and other crimes
starting in the late 60s, 1970s, all the way through the early 1980s, then we then had a big
backlash, a lot of mass incarceration in response to that in the 1980s and 1990s. Then we started
to come back from that. A lot of us were like, we really went too far in the other direction.
I think we're at a very interesting moment right now, because my book,
certainly some people on the left will try to dismiss it as conservative. But I do think when
people read it, they'll see that really I'm arguing for a system much more like what they
do in Amsterdam or what they do in Europe, which is universal psychiatric care, shelter first,
treatment first, and then housing earned. The left has promoted this idea that people
on the street should just be given housing, no questions asked, that housing is a right,
that everybody has a right to their own apartment, no matter the circumstances.
We know that's actually really dangerous. It's irresponsible to give people suffering from
addiction or serious mental illness cash or their own apartment without any restrictions on how they
spend it. It often feels cruel to people to not give money to the homeless. But we know that
when you're supporting people and their addictions, it can actually result in very destructive
behaviors. But that is the basic idea, is this really bad idea that the people on the street
suffering from addiction and mental illness are victims, and nothing should be required of them.
Requiring anything of them is a kind of oppression. It's not something that mainstream
psychiatrists believe. It's not something that addiction specialists believe or agree with.
In San Francisco, one of the main characters is a leading addiction specialist at Stanford
University. He's somebody who supports harm reduction measures, including giving addicts
clean needles so they don't get HIV AIDS. But he says very clearly, look, you need interventions.
This is obvious. So in some ways, I think that America, where it all ends up going, is I think
America needs to mature in its own relationship to freedom, and that these things are justified
out of a kind of freedom for victims. But also, I think for non-lefties, you kind of go, well,
you can't tell people what to do. And my view is, yeah, that's fine. You can't tell people
what to do. And I don't think we should put any resources into, say, making addicts who are
killing themselves in the privacy of their own homes, some sort of a law enforcement priority.
But we have a situation here where we're literally paying people in the form of cash welfare,
housing, and other services to live in tents on the street, use hard drugs,
defecate publicly, and commit crimes. So clearly, something's not working. We need to have some
accountability, and that includes from the people that we label victims.
Well, so let's talk about Europe a little bit, because people will often say to this,
okay, well, but look, in Portugal, for example, all drugs are legal, or at least decriminalized,
if people know better, at least they're decriminalized, right? But that isn't the
whole story. But that's what you keep hearing, to justify why so many things aren't working.
That's what I've heard many times.
Yeah. And when you ask progressives what the solution is to all the drug overdoses
in San Francisco—we have one of the highest rates of drug overdose in the country,
712 drug overdose deaths or poisonings last year—they say, we just need a safe place
for people to use drugs. And they claim that that's what Europe did. They claim that Europe
simply decriminalized. That's just false. And in Amsterdam, I saw it myself at work.
But I also interviewed the head of Portugal's drug programs. One of the main talking points
is that Portugal just decriminalized all drugs, and it's fine. I asked the head of Portugal's drug
program, if I were shooting heroin in Lisbon, in public, what would happen to me? And he said,
you would be arrested and brought to the police station. And they have decriminalized a certain
amount of drugs for personal use. But if you're caught breaking other laws as a result of your
addiction, including using drugs publicly, shooting heroin on a park bench, you are brought
before something called a Commission for the Dissuasion of Addiction, which is just as scary
as it sounds. Usually, it's a defense attorney, a prosecuting attorney, a social worker, a
psychiatrist, and your family members. So basically, it's an intervention with the power of the state
behind it, so that if you're a repeat offender, you're arrested again, something else happens,
they will come after you and increase the punishment and the consequences of your behavior.
But the idea is that because of this accountability, you can have a chance, right?
That's right. Interventions are liberating for the person that's being intervened upon.
Addicts are in the grip of a mental illness. That's the first thing you have to understand.
In the book, I describe three recovering addicts, two of whom were homeless at one point,
and they just say straight, I had to be arrested to quit drugs, and I'm glad I was arrested.
I interviewed many people, including people that were actively addicted and actively homeless,
who would say, I wish somebody would do something. They wouldn't necessarily say,
I wish I were being arrested, but they would ask to be on probation.
They need some sort of structure to keep themselves healthy and clean. It used to be that
even addicts would be arrested every once in a while and would find themselves in jail or prison,
where they would have to detox and kick their addiction, at least for a period of time.
We're not doing that now. There's a lot of what we call poly-drug use. There's a lot of people
using multiple hard drugs in a single day, day after day, meth at night often, and then heroin
or fentanyl during the day. It is very hard on the body to live like that. We see people in
San Francisco with open wounds, open sores. People are becoming deeply sick. Obviously,
they're dying of drug overdoses. So the popular idea that we should just simply help people to
remain heavily addicted, but in a slightly safer way, I find it just offensive and quite cynical.
Many people need the intervention, and the Portuguese know that. Yes, you don't necessarily
need to arrest addicts and put them in prison, but they do need the intervention so that they can
get clean and move on with their lives.