Check out the full episode 1744 here: Video - https://youtu.be/uTSeRcdiuns LIKE this video if you learned something new! COMMENT your thoughts on this topic. SUBSCRIBE for more valuable fitness content
Electronic muscle stimulation and intermittent fasting, do they have
benefits or are they just fads? Watch this. Our first caller is Colin from
Washington. Hey what's up Colin, how can we help you? Hey how's it going guys? Good.
So I had a few questions but my first one is, is EMS electro muscle
stimulation training safe and effective? Okay so first off why are you asking
this question? Are you using this to rehab an injury or build muscle? Yeah
like what's what's the context? Do you see a cool ad? No so I was actually I just saw
the new Spider-Man movie and I afterwards looked up what Tom Holland
had done to prepare for the movie and it looked like part of his regimen was
doing that EMS training where you you know you hook up to one of those systems
and hold a pose and I was just kind of wondering about it. I had only you know
heard of people doing it. Save your money bro. Yeah well so there's a lot of
stuff I'm sure he did to get ready for the role. It's probably one of that
probably had the least impact on his physique. So EMS has been around for a
while. It's been studied for a long time. I mean I remember reading articles about
Bruce Lee using EMS devices. You could buy them you know through catalogs back
in the day and every five years or so you'll see EMS. Cyclical. Yeah like ab
devices like wear this ab belt and it's like doing 10,000 crutches while you
work at your desk and that kind of stuff and you know put this on your butt and
makes it grow. So EMS basically forces a muscle to contract by sending an
electrical signal to the muscle. Here's what the studies show. The studies show
that it does help prevent some amount of atrophy when you're injured and not
moving the muscle. In other words if you're if your legs broken and you can't
do anything with the leg at all so you can't contract the muscle at all really
then EMS may help prevent some level of atrophy but not an entire level of
atrophy. There's also you know might help connect to muscles that maybe
you've lost some connection to but that's more of a kind of a medical issue.
Now as far as like advanced training and building muscle no you're gonna you know
isometrics will do that for you. In fact you know generating kind of intrinsic
force is gonna be way more effective than kind of this external source of
force. I know that the selling point right the selling point is you know use
this device. When you're passive right so there's a passive way to stimulate the
muscle which then you know they're they're attributing to muscle growth
which it's really not moving you forward as much as preserving muscle loss from
occurring like for you know again for rehab purposes but like trying to sell
it as a performance device is kind of ridiculous. Yeah even even in the
atrophy aspect it really has a small effect. I was gonna say yeah even that
it's still yeah I mean I would use it like so if I broke like you said if I
broke my leg these things these tools are relatively inexpensive right so if I
knew I couldn't be on my leg for maybe three months or whatever the time it
would be to heal I would hook it up to my quads you know why not I'm sitting
there watching TV anyways and it's like if it's gonna slow down atrophy a little
bit so it's a little less but I mean I wouldn't expect my quads to stay the
same or build by any means and so you know I see some people pitch it to as
recovery yeah so you know you got sore the day let's say you train I guess if
you compare it to like sitting laying on the couch and doing nothing right then
maybe there's some benefit so I think that's good to tell Colin right so like
that and that's where and by the way after after we do do this I was gonna go
on a rant anyways on because I always whenever I trash something like this I
always get somebody who's like attached to it that wants to defend us listen I
can sell this ---- too yeah you know saying like so I could take I could take
the information around it and still sell it to people I just when we talk to
people we're trying to help people with like real good advice here's the thing
if it's like where Sal was just going if I'm sedentary I'm doing nothing and I
just trained the day before putting that on my putting that on my legs versus not
doing anything at all I can show markers of improvement like
recovery speeding up recovery right but I would take that and I would say okay
you get to you get your guy who was hooked up to the EMS I'm gonna take that
same guy and I'm gonna take him through a 30-minute mobility session yeah and
I'll show you better results with not even a five-minute trigger session yeah
yeah let's just say but I mean I will blow those results away with a 30-minute
mobility session on that person then that guy is hooked up to a machine that
cost him a couple hundred bucks to buy so that's where we will ---- on things
like this is that it's like well there's a freeway to get better results than
that thing will provide yeah and in there's you know I know I see how some
people are using them now to we'll look at these really strong ones and they'll
attach it to a muscle I seem like a workout now yeah they'll put on your
lats while you do like a lat pulldown or just it creates this intense muscle
contraction like an intensity amplifier but there's so many non you know external
ways to do that that and I have yet to see anything that really shows that it's
got tremendous value it's also not very pragmatic you know hook yourself up to
a big machine while you work out so I don't see lots of applications so I hope
that helped you out Colin yeah definitely I appreciate it and then my
other question was what are the benefits and drawbacks of intermittent fasting
and does eating in a small window affect the absorption of protein in your body
yeah maybe a little bit you know some divided divided doses of protein within
a reasonable amount right so maybe every four hours or so you'll see in studies
will show an increase in muscle protein synthesis so it's probably a little bit
better I would say it's splitting hairs when you consider the context of you
know what works better for the person and their lifestyle and all that other
stuff as far as intermittent fasting is concerned the benefits really boil down
to helping people develop a better relationship with food and I remember
that's there's that's a double-edged sword I would challenge that for
intermittent fasting I would say I would agree to that with fasting but
intermittent fasting is turned into more of a fad and it's a window you're still
eating so you could technically you could have an adverse effect for
relationship with food instead of you instead of you eating throughout the day
sporadically now you eat in this four to six hour window and now you binge
because of that so it could promote bad relationship but what we do promote on
the show and talk about is the benefits of doing like a day fast right like
fasting from food entirely for the day and not for the benefits of what
everything it does for you know regenerations of neurons and growth
hormone production and blah blah blah that there's a bunch of stuff that mark
the real benefit is disciplining yourself to detach from food to know that
I can go 24 hours my body is not gonna starve I'm not gonna lose muscle I'm not
gonna die and go wow I don't I didn't really need as much as I thought I
needed and and what what am I doing with my time now that I don't have to eat for
those three meals a day we think there's tremendous value in a practice like that
and incorporated in fact if you go back self-reflection yeah if you go back far
enough on mind pump maybe three years ago or so Sal went on a kick for a while
and I you remember this when you're promoting your two to three day fast
every month yeah so I think that's extremely valuable but he wasn't doing
it to get more shredded or build more muscle or to get growth hormone
production all the things that is touted around intermittent fasting right and
that's not to say that those things aren't true there are good health
markers and benefits that are improved by incorporating fasting I just think
the way it's been promote or we think the way it's been promoted I think it's
it's used like a diet and we don't use it that way with clients yeah from a
medical perspective there's investigating fasting like legit fasting
for potential cancer treatment or at least in combination with with
chemotherapy so that's kind of interesting but you know we're talking
about what the food relationship thing it totally can go the opposite direction
if I'm dealing with someone whose battles with an eating disorder where
they restrict themselves fasting is the worst possible thing I can possibly do I
mean an extreme case I could take an anorexic or a recovering anorexic be
like yeah we're not gonna eat for two days and what a terrible way to approach
food relationship really it works well with people who are afraid to be away
from food the person that feels like they need to feed themselves every two
hours are afraid of being skinny and they overfeed themselves and stuff
themselves then a fast can can maybe be beneficial if they go into it in the
right way but a lot of the health benefits by the way calling that come
from fasting cell autophagy and you know the hormonal effects anti
inflammatory effects you see also from a restricted calorie diet so it's not
unique specifically to fasting so it's definitely been turned into the new fad
diet excuse me if you will but yeah for the average person I would never promote
fasting as a way for fat loss the clients the clients I used it most with
were competitors were and what I found was when I coached competitors so bikini
men's physique bodybuilders they had they had become so addicted to measuring
and weighing and tracking their food and eating six times a day that they just
they carried their Tupperware everywhere religiously wouldn't miss any that in
fear of muscle loss or whatever or not having enough fuel for the workout like
those clients I saw I saw a poor relationship with food even though they
thought they had a good relationship because they were fit and ripped I saw
them so attached to food that I would disrupt that by telling them hey next
week we're gonna go on a 24-hour fast and I thought there and then I would
show them look at you're not gonna lose a bunch of muscle you're gonna be just
fine in fact you're gonna see these other health benefits watch your mental
clarity watch these other things and so I liked to use it to interrupt somebody
who's attached to food other than that I think it's it's I think it's been overly
used or or prescribed to people for that and by the way the people that get
most upset about this conversation are people that sell ---- related to
intermittent fasting like whenever we go on this rant which this YouTube channel
for sure we'll get some bullshit so be somebody to talk ---- underneath in the
comment section and it's always some ************ that has made their living
off of selling intermittent fasting to people Colin we lose you oh you got me
great all right all right well so does that answer your question all right yeah
I did I really appreciate it guys all right man awesome have a good one
appreciate it yeah you too bye-bye yep yeah God forbid could you see his face
Doug did we ruin his day right there oh he's like **** all the things he's like
I just ordered this I just got my intermittent fasting I guess I'll send
it back you know God forbid there's a study that shows any benefit at all to
some diet leave it to the fitness industry we'll make a boy make a market
out of it they will turn it into something completely different and and
market it and sell it and make people believe it's the next well watch watch
the comment section on this watch the YouTube comment section exactly there
will be somebody in here it changed my life or somebody who may and maybe it
did maybe you're that person that needed to detach from food and learn how to
deal with hunger cues and cravings or maybe it just worked incredibly well
with your schedule maybe you had bad habits first thing in the morning maybe
you were a four donut you know Starbucks 900 calorie drinker and because you no
longer can eat now you know you don't need that many calories right for one
thing right it's like oh wow it just brought a lot of awareness to your to
your daily habits and it was like very beneficial in that sense so there's a
lot of benefits to it but it's not like the end-all be-all no intermittent
fasting really should be viewed more as a spiritual practice it really should
that's how it was it's how it's existed it's been it's in every major religion
precisely for that reason then the intent is right yeah by the way it's no
different the only difference is we're dealing with food but the spiritual
practice would be like if you fasted from electronics for a few days or
fasted from you know maybe from the city you won't camping how many times people
go camping disconnect come back like oh my god I feel so rejuvenated I feel so
right centered so that's the way I think it should be viewed it should not be
viewed like a diet if it's viewed like a diet you're only really you're using
it wrong in my opinion well and the EMS thing is just like that right they took
a little bit of science and positive benefits that are surrounding it and
built it into this whole thing it's nice and that's what it's this is another one
like I see a lot of it right now it's really popular in the making its way big
time into the men's physique and bodybuilding world because I still am
connected to a bunch of those people and now they're like doing it while they
work out like they hook them up to these machines and it's just like it's that
same pattern right look they were dealing with rubber bands attaching
machines on top of already having yeah exactly let let let some study come out
to show that what you manipulate the strength curve with using the bands on a
hammer strength now every ******* guy is doing it inside the gym like it's the
next best thing so I feel the same way about this if I had a product that was
connected to this absolutely you could hear me sell it I could sell it to you
for three different ways it's also how how like we always have to look at new
techniques and are they pragmatic like yeah okay there's this new EMS machine
super powerful and we're watching bodybuilders and strength athletes be
hooked up to it in a gym there's this computer and wires and pads hooked to
their back and then they do it like who's gonna do that right and is that
even is that the same machine that you order online that you get sent to your
house it's not so it also how long you would you be applying that yeah well it's
gonna last and also the unintended consequences okay I feel like one of the
things that we're in the middle of right now with technology is we're
trying to promote people being more active and walking more not trying to
find more hacks on how they don't have to move and still be able to get the
benefits lazier ways to promote work right so even if it did have some pretty
good benefits from it I'd be I'd still be cautious with promoting it because I
know that's one of the biggest problems is we just don't move enough no so I
would much rather teach my client hey listen not only will I give you more
benefits by having you go do this flow session of mobility work or yoga
practice you'll get the same you know you know muscle atrophy or the not
atrophying benefits that you would get from this machine plus you're now moving
so we're burning some calories right we're promoting other health benefits I
would I'm thinking of that also so it's not just hey what does this help work or
not work or is it practical or not practical but it's also like man what
right now we're in this like people don't move anymore and we're heading in
this direction where we talk about all the time the Wally look you know before
you know it we're not gonna be moving around at all and this is just another
tool oh hey guess what you don't gotta move you know it might sit still and
build muscle you know reminds me of number total recall we're like you know
if you can't afford a vacation how about if you just give you the memories of a
vacation that's cool I'll just remember that I went some easier I did it hey if
you enjoyed that clip you can find the full episode here or you can find other
clips over here and be sure to subscribe