What It's Like Hitting Greg Maddux and Bartolo Colon 2 Seamer

Antonelli Baseball
48 followers
Jan 15, 2023
Hey, what's going on everyone?
Today, we're answering your questions.
I'm here in Georgia for the 17U WWBA National Championship.
Uh, we come here every year, a great tournament.
And so I'm here in my hotel room, just answering questions, going
through YouTube, reading comments.
I put a video up on Instagram a couple of days ago, um, showing
Greg Maddux and his two seamer.
And it was ridiculous.
The ball moved, looked like seven feet.
And I said, did Greg Maddux have the best two seamer of all time?
Now I had the opportunity to face Greg Maddux, so we'll talk a little
bit about what it looked like to stand in the box and see that two seam pitch.
Um, but the responses that I got, most people said Maddux, yes, had the best one.
The other pitcher that was named a lot was Bartolo Colon.
I had the chance to face Bartolo Colon a couple of times, twice.
He struck me out both times, both times on two seamers.
So I thought it'd be a cool opportunity to talk a little bit about facing
Bartolo Colon, facing Greg Maddux.
What those pitches look like in the batter's box.
What's your approach?
You know, back then I was a really young player.
When I faced Colon, I was 22.
When I faced Maddux, I was 23.
And so I probably would have a better approach now that I've been
around the game for a lot longer.
But I'll give you my approach probably back then, what I would do differently
now, and just take you through some of the stories of facing both of those guys
and put in the comment section below who you think has the best two
seam fastball of all time.
So let's start with Bartolo Colon.
So I faced Colon, well I faced both of these pitchers later in their career.
I'm a decent amount younger than both of them.
But the first time that I faced Colon, um, I will say without a doubt, because
I faced Colon before I faced Maddux, that was by far the best two seam
fastball I've ever seen.
And by two seam fastball, for you that maybe don't know exactly what it looks
like, a two seam fastball is going to run into a right-handed hitter.
So if I'm hitting here and I'm a righty, the ball is going to be coming into
me and also typically sinking.
So you get this sinking, running action.
Um, and it can be very difficult to hit, especially nowadays, guys
are throwing it very hard.
Colon threw it hard back then as well.
Maddux, not as much.
Um, but you know, the more that a ball moves, well, the tougher it is to hit.
I think most people realize that, but the hard thing about a two seam, especially
to a righty is that the ball just continues to come down and into you.
And so you go to hit the ball and it just keeps coming at you and it's difficult
to keep your hands inside the ball and get the sweet part of the bat to the ball.
Um, and what I noticed the first time that I faced Colon was that not only
again, was the ball running into me a lot, but it was also going down a lot.
And what I kept doing was swinging over it.
And so the pitch would come in and I'd be like, Oh, I'm going to hit that ball.
And I'd swing and I'd swing and I miss.
And I never swing and miss most, most of my career, at least up until that point,
I almost never swung and missed.
And so it was really weird.
Here comes the ball.
And I'm like, okay, I'm on it.
I swing and I miss, step out for a second.
And I'm like, what just happened there?
That ball seemed to disappear.
And then next one would come in and I would swing over it and miss again.
And I did that two at bats in a row.
I just kept swinging and missing and I couldn't figure it out.
And that's part of the learning process, right?
Um, learning how to adjust to pitches that move more than pitches that
you've ever seen before in your life.
And so what do you do against a two seamer?
You've got to really see the ball up.
You've got to see the ball out over the plate more.
I didn't learn it that day, but eventually I did because you can't look for a ball middle.
If you look for a ball middle, it's going to probably end up way in unless you're
really good at hitting the ball inside.
You definitely can't look for the ball in because if you look for the ball in and
you see it in, you go to swing, the ball is going to almost hit you.
So you've got to look for the ball out over the outer, pretty much over the
outer half of the plate.
And those balls are going to run back to the middle of the plate.
Now, Cologne has such great command that he tricks you and he fools you.
And he can put that ball right on the corner, right?
Or if he realizes that you're chasing, then he's going to start it on the corner.
He's going to run it really far into you.
And he can almost put the ball where he wants every single time.
All right.
And then he also has the ability to throw kind of like a backdoor two seamer to a
righty where he starts it way off the plate.
And then he brings it back to the outside corner.
Now, he didn't throw that to me very much because he probably said, this young
idiot doesn't know what he's doing.
He's going to continue to swing over it every single time.
And so I'll just keep doing that.
So that's what I did against him.
Now, the interesting thing about facing Cologne that day is that we actually had
a ball that was fouled off into the dugout.
And this probably happened from the foul ball.
Sometimes if you hit a foul ball off the cap of the bat, so the very top of the
bat, sometimes you can put a little gouge in the ball.
But I remember the ball on the dugout.
And when we went into, we started talking and we kept the ball.
And there was a big, like literally like a slice in the ball.
And everyone started saying that, you know, Bartolo was cutting the ball up.
You know, if you can scuff a ball or if you can put a little bit of a cut or a
gouge in the ball, you can really use that if you know how to.
You can use that to make the ball move more.
And so it's not uncommon for pitchers to try to mark up baseballs or get balls to
be kind of scuffed up a little bit.
Some pitchers will grow a fingernail a little bit long, and when they're rubbing
up the baseball, they'll kind of, you know, put some scuffs or take a little
nick out of the side of a ball.
You know, some catchers, I've seen catchers over the years, I haven't seen
this in a while, that would use the metal on their shin guards and they would take
a ball, if a pitcher wanted the ball kind of scuffed up, they would catch the ball
and before they throw it back, they would just kind of bring the ball down and just
kind of nick it on their shin pad and throw it back.
And pitchers were able to use that little scuff or marking to get the ball to move
more.
Not saying he was doing that, but I am saying I thought it was crazy.
I saw the ball, there was a huge gouge in it.
So I'm assuming it's from the foul ball, but it was interesting.
The ball moved like a wiffle ball.
That's all I'm going to say.
It was the best two-seamer I've ever seen in my life.
Okay, now fast forward a year later, I faced Greg Maddux.
Now, Greg Maddux, same thing, ball moved a ton.
I faced him at the very end of his career.
He was throwing very slow.
He was throwing, I think, probably like mid 80s to high, probably mid to high 80s.
It kind of felt like 70 because you get used to seeing 90 plus all the time.
I remember it was my first at-bat ever and it felt super comfortable, which is odd.
He's probably a great guy for me to face first at-bat because he doesn't really
have anything to quote-unquote beat you with.
He's not going to throw 97 or anything like that.
And with him, again, my approach was to kind of see the ball up, just get the
ball up and over the plate a little bit more.
That's your typical, what you're typically going to do.
And I'm in the major leagues at this time and get a little bit
better scouting report.
Obviously, I'd seen Maddux throw a thousand times before then.
But he threw me a little fastball that kind of did exactly that.
I kind of saw it away, kind of ran back towards the middle of the plate and I
had a single up the middle for a hit.
Out of those two guys, Colon's two seamer was better at that time because
Colon was throwing the ball harder and Maddux was at the very, very end of his
career.
When Maddux was younger, the ball was thrown even faster than it was when I
saw it, much faster, ball moved a ton.
He did have amazing command, right?
So he could start the ball way off the plate and bring it to a back door.
Against a lefty, he could start it at your hip and bring it over the plate.
He could do what Colon did and throw the ball in and have it run in off of the
plate.
And so he was able to do that really well.
Unfortunately for me, I was able to get a pitch that really wasn't commanded
super well.
It was kind of thrown over the middle.
Again, he's facing, I was hitting eight, I think, that game.
He probably said, I don't care.
I'll throw this ball down the middle and see if this, you know, bum can hit the
ball.
And I, and I hit it.
Um, and then the next step bad, I believe I grounded out the ball, ran more in and
I kind of rolled over it and ground it out to the left side.
So that's what he usually gets guys to do.
So those are my two stories.
Um, I'm going to give Colon the nod, at least when I was facing them, but all
time at Greg Maddux, I think probably had combination movement, um, and
command probably the best of all time when it comes to two seamers.
And, but today's game guys are ridiculous.
Guys are throwing like a hundred miles an hour and the ball's moving this much.
I haven't faced those guys in the game.
So it's a little bit tougher for me to say, but I'm going to go with Maddux
because I faced him and got to see it firsthand and watched him as a kid, a
thousand times throwing those two seamers.
So that's all I got.
Let me know what you think of the comment section below, subscribe to the
channel, hit the notification bell, give it a thumbs up, all that good stuff.
We'll talk to you later.
If you've got hitters that you're looking to improve before the start of next
season, this is essential for you.
Matt Antonelli here, former major league player, first round pick and college coach.
With this course, we're going to show you exactly step-by-step how to generate
power, develop at speed and enhance swing mechanics, regardless of your hitter's
age, this course is going to deliver advanced hitting techniques that will
allow any hitter to get better and make an impact at the plate this spring.
We have a full catalog of training content that you can
This course is perfect for players, parents, coaches, instructors, and more.
It offers a comprehensive package of drills and techniques
that you can directly implement.
Our course has helped hitters all over the country at different competition
levels and the feedback that we've received has been outstanding.
The work you put in now will drive your success at the plate this spring.
Get the essential knowledge that you need to take your game to the next level.
