In this video I explain exactly what a Roth IRA conversion is, when it makes sense to convert, how to convert and when you should not convert. I also explain what a Roth IRA conversion ladder is and why so many financial independent, retire early followers are using this strategy.
Also in this video, I explain what a backdoor Roth IRA contribution is and how to go about doing it.
Thanks, Rich McCormack, CFP® School of Personal Finance
School of Personal Finance is an Investment Advisor registered with the State(s) of New York. All views, expressions, and opinions included in this communication are subject to change. This communication is not intended as an offer or solicitation to buy, hold or sell any financial instrument or investment advisory services. Any information provided has been obtained from sources considered reliable, but we do not guarantee the accuracy, or the completeness of, any description of securities, markets or developments mentioned. We may, from time to time, have a position in the securities mentioned and may execute transactions that may not be consistent with this communication's conclusions. Please contact us at 914-299-3843 if there is any change in your financial situation, needs, goals or objectives, or if you wish to initiate any restrictions on the management of the account or modify existing restrictions. Additionally, we recommend you compare any account reports from SPF with the account statements from your Custodian. Please notify us if you do not receive statements from your Custodian on at least a quarterly basis. Our current disclosure brochure, Form ADV Part 2, is available for your review upon request, and on our website, www.schoolofpersonalfinance.com. This disclosure brochure, or a summary of material changes made, is also provided to our clients on an annual basis.
Hey, what's up everyone?
And welcome to the School of Personal Finance.
In this video, I'm gonna teach you
all about Roth IRA conversions
along with what a backdoor Roth IRA contribution is.
Let's get to it.
So before I get into it,
this channel is all about teaching you personal finance.
If you enjoy these types of videos,
make sure to hit that subscribe button
and hit the little notification bell
so you get notified every time I upload a new video.
If you haven't watched my video from last week
where I go over the differences
between the traditional IRA and the Roth IRA,
you should go back and watch that one first
so you have a good understanding
of why you'd even want to convert your Roth IRA.
So all a Roth IRA conversion is,
it's the act of taking money out of your traditional IRA,
an account that you've yet to pay any taxes on,
and converting it over into your Roth IRA,
an account that you will never pay taxes on again.
So by doing this conversion,
you're creating a taxable event.
Any amount that you convert is taxed as ordinary income
in the year that you make the conversion.
So now, anybody could do a Roth conversion at any time.
It doesn't matter how much money you make
or if you make no money,
you could always do a Roth conversion.
And you don't have to do the full account value
if you don't want to.
So if you have 100 grand in your IRA
and you decide that you only want to convert $10,000 of it,
you could totally do that,
or you convert the whole thing.
You can pick and choose each year
how much you want to convert
or if you want to convert at all.
So how do you decide if converting some of your money
to a Roth IRA makes sense for you?
And it really comes down to your income
and your tax brackets.
So if you have a high income
and you're in the high tax bracket,
most of the time it does not make sense
to convert to a Roth IRA,
because what you're doing
is you're creating more taxable income
that's going to be subject to those high tax brackets.
So usually that does not make sense.
Where it does make sense is if you're the opposite.
If you have a lower income,
if you're in a low tax bracket
and you could convert and pay these low tax rates now
and let that money grow tax-free forever.
So a saying in the financial industry
is don't let a low tax bracket go to waste.
And what we mean by that is that if you have a low income
and you're in the low tax bracket,
you should fill up that tax bracket by converting money,
by making more taxable income,
by taking money from your traditional IRA
and converting it to your Roth.
So let's just look at a quick example
of what I mean by that.
If we look at this simple tax return here,
this individual has $39,000 of salary, of W-2 income.
And let's just say that they're single
and they have one child, all right?
So 39,000 of income.
Now everybody gets a standard deduction.
So in this case,
this person is not itemizing their deductions.
They're taking the standard deduction,
which in 2020 is $12,400.
So their taxable income is $26,600.
And now that would put them in the 12% tax bracket.
So they would owe $2,994 of taxes.
That's what their tax obligation would be.
But now because they have one child,
they get the $2,000 child tax credit.
So that reduces that amount by 2,000.
So their tax liability would be $994.
But now their taxable income,
that's the important number here, this $26,600.
If we go back and we look at the tax brackets
for somebody that is single,
they are allowed to make up to $40,125
and still be in the 12% tax bracket.
So that means that we have some room here,
that we're able to add additional income
to fill up that 12% tax bracket.
If you can convert money at 12%, that is a win.
Because if you think about it,
having that money then be tax-free in retirement,
the odds are that we are gonna be
in higher tax brackets at that time.
We are in historically low tax rates right now.
So to be able to convert at a 12% tax rate
and then it's going into the Roth
and it will be tax-free forever.
It's gonna grow tax-free
and then when you take it out in retirement,
you take it out tax-free.
That would be a very good case
where doing a Roth IRA conversion would make sense.
Now if we look at another very simple example,
if we have somebody who has $100,000 salary
and say they're married, so they're filing joint,
and their taxable income after the standard deduction
is $75,200.
Now in this case, if they say,
you know what, I have all this money in my traditional IRA,
I wanna convert it over to a Roth.
They say, I'm gonna convert $40,000 over to my Roth IRA.
So now this would bump up their taxable income
from 75,200 up to 115,200.
So if we go back and we look at these tax brackets,
so married, filing joint,
you're in the 12% tax bracket on taxable income
up to $80,250 and then it jumps up from 12% up to 22%.
So in this case, they would be going from taxable income
in the amount of 75,200 and going up to 115,200.
So a bulk of that 40,000 that they decided to convert
would now be subject to this 22% tax bracket.
So in that case, it just doesn't make any sense
to take money and pay it at a higher tax bracket,
at a higher tax rate to do this conversion.
They're better off just leaving it in the traditional IRA
and deferring the taxes.
Maybe they'll get another opportunity later on in life
to do a conversion where it will make sense.
So now as you could see as I'm going through this,
understanding the tax code and the tax rates
and where you fall, it is a big part of using this strategy.
So having the CPA that could run these numbers for you,
somebody that you could trust,
along with a good financial advisor
might come in very handy for your situation.
You don't wanna mess this up.
You don't wanna make a huge mistake
and jump yourself into a higher tax bracket
and pay much more in taxes than you have to.
So having people that you could work with
and people that you could trust that know their stuff,
it makes a lot of difference with this strategy.
And again, for full disclosure, I'm throwing things
out there, I know nothing about you.
Do not take this as personal recommendations
or personal advice.
I don't know anything about your situation.
As always, consult with your own tax advisor,
your own financial advisor to see
if this strategy might work for you.
Whenever you make a Roth IRA conversion,
you always wanna have the money that you're gonna owe
in taxes in another account.
You don't want to use the IRA to pay the taxes
that you're going to owe,
especially if you're under 59 and a half.
Because then not only are you gonna owe taxes
on the amount that you're using to pay taxes,
but you're also gonna have a 10% penalty on that amount
because you're not converting that amount.
You're taking a withdrawal from that amount
to go ahead and pay the taxes that you're gonna owe.
So you don't wanna use the IRA itself
to pay the taxes on the conversion.
You wanna have outside money saved
in order to pay the taxes that you're gonna owe
for doing the conversion.
And you never know when life is gonna give you
a great opportunity to make a Roth IRA conversion.
A simple example would be if you worked for a job
for 15 years and you did a great job saving
in the 401k plan, but you decide that you had enough
and you wanna go maybe travel the world for a year.
So now you have a year of no income.
That is a great opportunity to take a chunk of that money
and convert it over into a Roth IRA.
And you could control just how much you wanna convert.
You could decide that you only wanna do 20,000
and pay very little in taxes on that conversion.
Or you could decide that you wanna do 60,000.
It depends how much money you have saved.
But that's a great opportunity.
Or if you're gonna start a small business
and you're gonna have a couple of years
where you really don't have much income.
That could be a great window of time
where doing Roth IRA conversions are a great idea
because you're gonna be in a lower tax bracket.
So you could convert amounts that are gonna keep you
in those low tax brackets.
You'll be able to convert it over at those low rates
and then have it grow tax-free forever.
So you never know when opportunity will knock,
but you have to be aware of these things
so you could seize the moment
when it does come in your life.
So as I discussed in my last video,
any contributions that you make into a Roth IRA,
you could take back out at any time
without taxes or penalty.
So with converted amounts into a Roth IRA,
it's very similar with one caveat,
with one additional rule.
Any money that you convert,
you have to wait five years
before you could take it back out of the Roth IRA
without taxes and penalty.
And it makes sense why they would do this.
Let's just look at a quick example.
So if you have 100 grand in the traditional IRA
and you convert 20,000 into a Roth in 2020,
five years later, you could actually take that 20,000
back out of the Roth IRA
and use it without any taxes or any penalty.
Any of the growth would have to stay in the Roth IRA,
but the amount that you converted,
you could take out with any tax or penalty.
And the reason why they make you wait five years
is because they don't want to allow people
to just do a conversion and then take a withdrawal
to avoid the 10% penalty
that is involved with a traditional IRA.
With a traditional IRA,
if you take a distribution out of it
and you're younger than 59 1⁄2,
you have to pay income taxes
and you have to pay a 10% penalty.
So they don't want to allow people
to just make a conversion, pay the taxes,
which they would have to do anyway,
but then not have to pay the 10% penalty.
It would be a way to circumvent that.
So they put this rule in, the five-year waiting rule,
where you have to wait five years,
but then you could take your contributions out
without any taxes or penalty.
But that could come up big for you
if you do start your own business
and you don't know what the future looks like,
where five years down the road,
you would have access to that money.
And this is called the Roth Conversion Ladder.
And people use this strategy to actually retire early
or to leave their job before retirement age
and do something different.
They start making Roth IRA conversions
and they ladder the conversion.
So maybe they do $20,000 a year.
And then five years later,
that 20,000 becomes available to take a distribution from
without any taxes or penalty.
And then the next year, another 20,000.
The next year, another 20,000.
So they ladder the conversions
so that five years out in the future,
every year after that,
they're gonna have money falling off of this five-year rule
that they'll be able to take out without taxes or penalty.
So that's called a Roth Conversion Ladder.
And it's another good strategy that people use out there.
And the process of making a conversion is very simple.
You could actually just call whichever broker
you have your traditional IRA with.
So if you have it at Vanguard or Fidelity or Schwab or TD,
whoever it is, you could call them up and say,
listen, I wanna make a conversion.
Can you help me do that?
And they'll walk you right through the process of doing it.
And another thing to check out is
this doesn't only apply to IRAs.
So if your employer offers a Roth 401k,
they might allow for in-service conversions
where they'll let you take money
that you have in your traditional 401k
and convert it into the Roth 401k
while you're working there.
So that's something that you should definitely look into
if this sounds appealing to you.
And Roth IRA conversions,
it's also a great estate planning strategy.
So even if you're in retirement,
or if you're watching this
and your parents are in retirement,
and you want them to leave you some tax-free money,
converting to a Roth might be a great idea for them.
So if they have a lot of money
in pre-tax retirement accounts like 401ks or IRAs,
if they start converting a little bit each and every year,
trying not to bump themselves into a higher tax bracket,
when they pass away and leave that money to their heirs,
their heirs will receive that tax-free,
as opposed to the traditional IRA
where when your heirs receive that money,
they're going to owe taxes on it
as they take distributions from it.
So it's a good strategy for people
who are doing estate planning as well
and want to maybe bite the tax bullet for their kids
or for their beneficiaries
before they actually inherit that money.
All right, so now let's talk about
what a backdoor Roth IRA contribution is.
So now if you make more than a certain amount of money,
then the IRS says, we're sorry,
you are not eligible to make a Roth IRA contribution.
In 2020, those amounts are, if you are single,
it's over $139,000,
where if you are married, it's over $206,000.
But there's a little workaround to this rule
that's called the backdoor Roth contribution.
And now the way that it works
is that you make a non-deductible contribution
to a traditional IRA.
So if you remember from my last video,
you could make a non-deductible contribution
to a traditional IRA no matter how much money you make.
They have limitations on whether or not
you could actually deduct that contribution,
but there's no limitation
on just making a non-deductible contribution.
And then you immediately convert it over into a Roth IRA.
Now there's definitely some steps
that you need to take to do this,
and there are some nuances and rules
that you have to follow
to make sure that you do it correctly.
I actually, on my website, I have a workflow,
a PDF that you could go and you could download,
or you could just go check it out
where it walks you through all the steps.
So go check that out and download it.
So in an ideal situation,
if you wanna make a backdoor Roth IRA contribution,
you would not have an existing traditional IRA.
If you do, it makes it more complicated.
You definitely wanna make sure
that you know what you're doing.
Let's say that you already have a traditional IRA,
and it has 54,000 of pre-tax money in that IRA,
and you wanna execute this strategy.
So now if you contribute $6,000,
that money would be non-deductible.
So now in your traditional IRA,
you have 54,000 of pre-tax money,
and you have 6,000 that you just contributed
that's after-tax money,
because you're not able to take a deduction for it
because you make too much money.
So this is where things get a little bit tricky.
You wanna just convert that $6,000 over
into your Roth IRA,
but the IRS does not allow you to do that.
They have what's called a pro-rata rule.
They're gonna look at the aggregate amount.
They're gonna look at the entire amount
in your traditional IRA,
and they're gonna say,
well, now you have $60,000 in that.
54,000, you haven't paid any taxes on yet.
6,000, you've already paid taxes on.
So the percentage of that,
it would be 10% of your account
is after-tax contributions,
and 90% of the money in there is pre-tax contributions.
So if you convert 6,000 bucks,
10% of that, only $600 of it would not be taxable
during the year of the conversion,
where 5,400 would be taxable in that year.
So it's not as clean and easy
if you already have an existing pre-tax traditional IRA.
One thing you could look at doing
if you find yourself in that situation
is seeing if your employer will allow you
to roll in your traditional IRA into your 401k.
Now, you wanna make sure that you have a good 401k
because now that money's gonna be subject
to the 401k rules,
so you wanna make sure that it's low-cost,
you have very good investment options,
and that it makes sense for you,
but that would be a workaround
because if you did that,
you would no longer have the money in the traditional IRA,
and then when you go to do this backdoor strategy,
all you would have is a $6,000 after-tax contribution
in your IRA,
and you could go ahead and convert 100% of that money,
the $6,000, into your Roth IRA
and not have any taxes due in the year of that conversion.
So that would be the workaround for that.
All right, that's it for this one.
I hope you enjoyed this video.
These are some higher-level strategies
that we're talking here,
but they could be life-changing.
If you take advantage of these situations
and you use these,
they could really have a big impact
on the bottom line for you later on in life.
Please, if you've not done so already,
subscribe to this channel,
like this video.
It helps so much with the YouTube algorithms
as far as them showing these videos to more and more people.
I will see you again in the next one.
Thanks a lot.