Why Hitler adored Richard Wagner | DW History and Culture

Culture and History
201 followers
216 Video Views·Dec 28, 2022
Adolf Hitler, a murderous dictator driven by hatred and megalomania.
But he could be soothed by Richard Wagner.
The German composer was famous for revolutionizing opera and infamous for his anti-Semitism.
What exactly was behind Hitler's great admiration for Richard Wagner?
Why was the German Nazi dictator such a huge Wagner fan?
To be sure, in German culture, there's not really any getting around Wagner.
To this day, his works are celebrated by thousands every year at the legendary Bayreuth Festival.
And his fans, known as Wagnerians, pay him homage worldwide.
But Hitler's love of Wagner and his work was extreme.
Why did Wagner fascinate him so much?
Here are seven reasons.
Hitler loved heroic tales.
Wagner's dramatic operas reflected Hitler's view of himself as an all-powerful victor.
Hitler's own dashed dreams of becoming an artist.
Hitler, who always saw himself as an artist,
felt a kind of aesthetic affinity with Richard Wagner.
Hitler and Wagner were both anti-Semites.
Wagner demonized Jews, blaming them for everything.
That only reinforced Hitler's own anti-Semitism.
Wagner's Bayreuth Festival energized Hitler.
He considered the Bayreuth Festival the only vacation he had during the year.
Hitler apparently drew strength from Wagner's works.
The Wagners were a surrogate family for Hitler.
To us, he wasn't the Führer at all.
Wagner's operas became the soundtrack of dictatorship.
Nazi party rallies and air raids.
In the newsreels of German propaganda, they were accompanied by Wagner's operas.
War as a theatrical production.
Wagner encouraged Hitler's megalomania.
Huge orchestras and riveting harmonies.
Has there ever been better background music for megalomania?
But first, who was Richard Wagner anyway?
Born in 1813 in Leipzig, he's considered both a genius and an egomaniac.
His ambition was to recreate opera as a total work of art.
What he called Gesamtkunstwerk.
Unlike most opera composers,
he insisted on writing his own libretti along with the scores.
And he created bombastic productions.
He was the first to hide the orchestra down in a pit
and to put the audience in darkness,
listening to operas that ran for up to 16 hours.
Wagner had an imposing festival hall built in Bayreuth, a temple for his music.
His operas set new standards and became world famous.
Richard Wagner died in 1883,
but to this day the composer is still revered by millions.
The festival hall in Bayreuth is the place of pilgrimage
for Wagnerians from around the world.
For a month each summer, only Wagner's works are performed.
Wagner, Wagner, Wagner.
Nothing but Wagner.
So back to our question.
Why did Hitler idolize Richard Wagner?
Let's take a closer look at those seven reasons.
Hitler loved Germanic heroic sagas
and thought that no one explored them as well as Richard Wagner.
On the one hand, of course, there is the music,
that overwhelming tonal language of Richard Wagner,
which can penetrate very deeply into the soul.
But then there's also the subject matter,
which is rooted in Germanic myth,
that in itself spoke to Hitler.
But there was also the idea of redemption,
of overcoming adverse realities.
Ancient Germanic heroic sagas staged with powerful imagery.
In the legendary 16-hour Ring of the Nibelung,
gods and men fight over the Rheingold,
a material that imparts absolute power.
The opera Lohengrin revolves around a legendary knight
fighting for the trust of his beloved, Elsa.
It made Hitler a Wagner fan in 1901.
In his book Mein Kampf,
he related the sense of awakening at the age of 12.
As the first opera of my life, Lohengrin captivated me immediately.
My youthful enthusiasm for the Bayreuth master knew no bounds.
Again and again, I was drawn to his works.
In 1905, Hitler attended a production of Rienzi,
Wagner's opera about a brave Roman politician
who wants to save his people.
It encouraged Hitler's tendency towards megalomania.
Adolf Hitler's childhood friend Kubitschek
said that after a performance of Rienzi
at the Linz Municipal Theater,
the two climbed up Freinberg Mountain at night.
And Hitler, in a kind of rapturous vision
under the influence of that performance,
described his idea for Germany's future.
A simple man of the people
who wants to save the Roman Empire from decadence.
Hitler saw himself in a similar role as the savior of Germany.
How someone manages to get at least part of the population behind him
through speaking, rhetoric, charisma or whatever,
that was inspirational for him.
But Rienzi's rise ends in an inglorious fall.
The people turn against him and the hero dies tragically.
Is that a suitable role model?
So Hitler said, I have learned from Rienzi's fate,
because Rienzi failed.
He had no power structure, no party behind him.
He didn't have a powerful force behind him,
like Hitler later had the brown shirts.
He had the party, the Nazi party and then the brown shirts.
So he does exactly right what Rienzi did wrong.
And that's why it can't happen to him.
Interesting argument.
Hitler loved heroic figures like Lohengrin and Rienzi.
And Wagner's operas fueled Hitler's quest for power.
Hitler's dashed artistic dreams found refuge in Wagner.
Long before he plunged Europe into war,
Hitler tried his hand as a painter.
Hitler saw himself primarily as an artist
and not necessarily as a politician.
Hitler twice applied unsuccessfully
to the Academy of Fine Arts in Vienna.
He made ends meet by selling his own watercolor paintings.
Maybe if he'd gotten into art school,
history would have turned out differently.
It's useless to contemplate, really.
But sometimes you do wonder what would have happened if.
In 1908, he tried his hand as a composer,
attempting to complete Wagner's unfinished opera
Wieland der Schmied.
Hitler said, I will complete what Wagner could not.
Of course, he failed right from the beginning
because he had no craft.
He didn't know how to write music
or how to develop it at all.
With no artistic success,
a frustrated Hitler devoted himself to politics.
The failed artist now lived out his passion for culture
as a Wagner fan.
Hitler and Wagner were both anti-Semites.
Was it wounded pride or simply envy
that fueled Richard Wagner's anger toward Jews?
As early as 1850, he wrote a hate-filled pamphlet
titled Judaism in Music,
lamenting what he called the corrosive influence
of the Jews on German culture.
The accusations were that there had been
a terrible development in Wagner's opinion,
that the Jews had gained too much power.
And he claimed it was obvious that Jewish composers
were innately unproductive,
that they simply copied what others did
for lack of their own creative productivity.
Wagner's wife, Cosima, herself a bitter anti-Semite,
noted Wagner's hatred of Jews in her diaries.
He says in violent jest that all Jews should burn
in a performance of Natan.
Is this anti-Semitism reflected in Wagner's works?
Jens-Malte Fischer hears clear indications,
especially in the opera Meistersinger.
In a singing competition,
the character of Beckmesser sings especially poorly
and also steals the other singers' songs.
In Judaism in Music,
Wagner identifies what he calls wailing
as a hallmark of synagogue music.
And he says,
how can anyone sing like that?
That's just awful.
I think that's what Wagner is parodying here.
In 2017,
the Bayreuth Festival saw its first-ever production
by a Jewish director.
Australian Barry Kosky honed right in
on the difficult subject matter.
In his Meistersinger,
a Jewish singer is hunted down.
I'm not dealing with Jewish culture.
I'm dealing with the parody of the anti-Semitism.
In the case of Beckmesser,
this idea of the Sündenbock,
the person who bears all the responsibility
or all the trauma of the folk,
is what I think is the important thing.
They make him the Jew in my production.
And Kosky's production holds Wagner accountable.
I believe Wagner has created his own personal hell.
Now, he's not like Sisyphus
rolling that stone up that hill
and rolling his personal hell,
is that he is permanently in a witness box,
having to justify what he did say
or what happened to his music.
And that's the position that I think Wagner is in.
And I'm not sure whether he can get out of that position.
Yet Wagner continues to be celebrated on a grand scale
every year at the Bayreuth Festival,
an important social event for the rich and famous.
An anti-Semitic propagandist celebrated as a German genius?
For many Jewish musicians, that's a provocation.
Yuri Gurgi of the band Rotfront was shocked
when he came across Wagner's anti-Jewish pamphlet.
Strange.
I thought I must have misunderstood something.
Is this really the same guy?
Is this the composer, the Wagner?
Or a sick person with the same name?
Well, it was the same person.
Wow.
Gurgi's response was to reshape musical motifs from Wagner
into a cynical klezmer song about the love of an Israeli
for a girl from Bayreuth.
For me, Wagner is a symbol of German anti-Semitism.
Klezmer is also a stereotype.
And we Jews in Germany, we Jewish musicians,
move somewhere in between.
We have to live with it somehow.
Wagner on the one hand, and klezmer on the other,
as THE Jewish music.
The fact that Wagner is still celebrated in Germany today,
I find that very problematic.
In Israel, Wagner's music was boycotted for decades.
But in 2001, conductor Daniel Barenborn ignored that
and played the overture to Tristan und Isolde
as an encore in Jerusalem.
A scandal.
Now, a group of opera musicians in Tel Aviv
has ventured its very own exploration of Richard Wagner's work.
I was speaking with another conductor, an Israeli conductor.
I said, oh, I'm going to Israel soon, my first time in Israel.
And he said, oh, well, what are you doing there?
I said, it's an opera called Kundry.
And he said, do you have security?
Do you have a bodyguard?
Kundry from Wagner's opera Parsifal
is a heathen who is damned to seduce men for all eternity.
Here, she becomes a goddess.
It's a courageous and contemporary approach to Wagner.
Once I got there, everybody was definitely open to the idea
because it started a dialogue about what Wagner really means
and why he's boycotted.
And everybody had an opinion in Israel.
Some people think they absolutely should play it.
And some people think absolutely not.
But Kundry was a nice way to sort of start a dialogue.
Wagner, the rabid anti-Semite, was a role model for Hitler.
Wagner's Bayreuth energized Hitler.
The epicenter of the cult of Wagner is Bayreuth in southeastern Germany.
Of course, Hitler had to be there.
Richard Wagner had his own festival hall built here exclusively for his operas.
He created a family home here named Haus Wahnfried.
And here he found his final resting place.
Bayreuth is to a Wagnerian what Mecca is to a devout Muslim —
a place you have to go at least once in a lifetime
to participate in the authentic performance.
Here one has the feeling of being at the heart of the matter itself.
The Wagnerian Adolf Hitler came to Bayreuth for the first time very early in 1923.
From then on, Hitler regularly came to Bayreuth in the summer,
immersed in a Wagnerian frenzy lasting several days,
surrounded by the composer's descendants.
Wagner's daughter-in-law Winifred Wagner remembered Hitler's visits fondly.
He considered the week in Bayreuth as his only vacation days in the whole year.
He enjoyed the time in Bayreuth
and generally tried to delegate any tasks that came his way.
Here he was celebrated.
From Haus Wahnfried to the festival hall, nothing but jubilation and triumph.
He usually stood in the car and at the entrance to the festival hall, where I greeted him.
Dear Führer, be so kind and come to the window, shouted the euphoric crowd.
Then Hitler stepped up to the side window of the royal portal and greeted his onlookers.
Hitler last visited Bayreuth in 1940.
I hear the wings of the goddess of victory, Russell.
Those were his words of farewell.
Then the war dominated everything.
Europe was in ruins.
But Hitler decided the festival should continue.
The performers were exempted from war service,
the audience made up of the war-wounded.
Wagner for consolation, Wagner for war morale.
The Wagners were a surrogate family for Hitler.
The Wagner family was entranced by the Führer.
Richard Wagner's son-in-law, Houston's steward Chamberlain,
introduced Adolf Hitler to the Wagner family.
Hitler admired Chamberlain's racist and anti-Semitic views.
Beginning in 1936, Hitler moved into the composer's estate for the festival season
in Haus Siegfried, built by Wagner's son.
Here, Hitler could spread out and relax.
Here he was completely autonomous, but still close to Haus Wahnfried.
Richard Wagner's son Siegfried died in 1930.
His wife, Winifred, took over as festival director.
Hitler continued to find a warm, free place to stay.
He actually came here to, I almost want to say to enjoy family life.
Actually, just to see the children.
He so enjoyed being around the children.
And they called him Uncle Wolf.
Especially for the sons Wolfgang and Wieland,
the dictator was a kind of surrogate father — with visions for the opera,
for the festival, and for all of Germany.
And he demanded a lot from his surrogate sons.
Here, the fireplace behind me.
Hitler was a bit of a pyromaniac.
He liked to sit there until the early morning hours.
Wieland and Wolfgang always had to listen to his endless monologues,
as Wolfgang Wagner told me.
They actually wanted to go to bed and sleep,
but they had to keep him company here.
And Winifred?
The ardent supporter of National Socialism
was simply enchanted by her prominent friend.
For us, he wasn't the Führer at all.
I never experienced anything forbidding about him.
That's the strange thing.
You know, he had this absolute Austrian sensibility and warmth.
After 1945, Winifred Wagner was put on trial in denazification proceedings
where she had to justify her closeness to Hitler.
The management of the festival passed to her sons.
They tried to salvage what they could
and distanced themselves from the dark chapter.
Winifred remained true to her beliefs,
unapologetically inviting old Nazi leaders to her house.
We old National Socialists found a new codename after the war,
because you couldn't talk about him in public.
So if we wanted to talk about him, we called him USA,
which stood for unser seliger Adolf, our blessed Adolf.
The Wagners — a true surrogate family for Hitler.
Wagner's music — the soundtrack of dictatorship.
Wagner's bombastic music could be used perfectly for Hitler's political goals.
This enormous impact — of the music, the lyrics, the storylines —
with which you can overwhelm the listeners.
That was, after all, at the heart of Nazi propaganda.
For the opening of the annual party conference,
the overture of Hitler's beloved Rienzi — pathos and bombast.
If you look at the infamous party congress film by Lenny Riefenstahl,
Triumph of the Will,
or what Albert Speer did with the Cathedral of Light back then —
those were opera productions.
Newsreel footage of an air raid becomes a heroic performance
with the addition of the Ride of the Valkyries.
All this insincere, exalted and melodramatic stuff,
which the Nazis used for their propaganda in a clever way,
can all be combined quite well with Wagner's operas.
Wagner composed music with great pathos —
for Hitler, the soundtrack of dictatorship.
Wagner encouraged Hitler's megalomania.
Hitler's fantasies of redeeming the German Reich
were really stirred up by Wagner's music.
Listening to Wagner's music can sometimes touch deep parts of your soul
that you perhaps weren't aware of until then.
I think it's like any drug — and Wagner is a drug.
Enjoyed in moderation, it can make you healthy.
In excess, it can make you sick.
Doctors in the 19th century had already suspected this,
and they attributed a devastating effect to Wagner's music.
Hysteria, madness and even death.
Indeed, Tristan and Isolde in particular led a few people to their graves.
The first Tristan singer died in 1865 in a so-called Wagner delirium.
In 1911, there was another Wagner victim, conductor Felix Mottl.
He suffered a heart attack during a performance of the opera and died.
Fifty years later, conductor Josef Kaibert collapsed and died on the same spot.
Did Wagner's music reinforce Hitler's pathological side?
A kind of accelerant for Hitler's sick brain?
And how can music be life-threatening?
I think it's because of the harmonies, basically.
The whole of the five-hour-long opera is in some ways a kind of
heavily sexualized kind of harmonic trick.
The whole of the second act makes you absolutely desperate
for the musical climax, and then it's taken away from you.
The lovers who cannot reach each other.
So you've got that again, that...
So again, you get the same tension as before.
You get the tonic that you've basically been waiting for for five hours.
At which point, everybody just has a little swoon.
Five hours of delayed gratification.
And when release finally comes, it's in the form of death.
It's this kind of rather morbid combination of eroticism and death wish
that makes Wagner kind of potent and a little bit scary.
The hope for release from earthly suffering — a yearning that Hitler also knew well.
He always had suicidal thoughts.
When he was at difficult points, when he was in danger of failing,
he would say that he would end it coldly and brutally, shoot himself.
That was always one of his leitmotifs.
And he finally carried it out in the bunker in 1945.
And even then, Wagner played an important part.
Accompanied by the strains of Siegfried's funeral march from Götterdämmerung,
the Führer's miserable end was announced on the radio.
There truly is a dangerous closeness between the two men —
an association you should be aware of.
You can only be a Wagnerian with a clear conscience
if you're also willing and able to look at the other side of the coin, which does exist.
I can imagine dealing with Wagner like with cigarettes — with a warning on the pack.
What do you think about the connection between Hitler and Wagner?
Has it ruined Wagner's music for you? Let us know!
