Aging Insight

KLFItvTexarkana
38 followers
50 Video Views·Mar 5, 2020
Welcome to Aging Insight with your hosts,
John Ross and Lisa Schulmeier.
This program is made possible by.
Welcome to another edition of Aging Insight.
I'm John Ross here with Lisa Schulmeier
and we're gonna have a pretty interesting topic for you.
One that comes up a lot, but you know,
we do this program to bring you that good information.
Try to answer the questions you have out there.
We get questions all day long,
every day from actual clients.
And that kind of gives us an idea of the information
that is needed out there in the community.
And that way, when we get an opportunity
to come into the studio and do a little TV recording,
we know what kind of information
you probably wanna know about.
And that's why we do the show.
That's right.
Well, you know, John, there's a,
we're elder law attorneys, but in part of our practice
includes preparing wills, probating wills,
you know, helping families deal with property
and things like that after the death of a loved one.
And that's all very technical stuff
because we're dealing with money and real estate titles
and then sentimental items.
It's, and families.
Yeah, absolutely.
So, which we really enjoy doing that,
but we often, you know, John,
I know you're, it's hard to believe,
but not every family is just a lovey-dovey,
all on the same page kind of family.
No, not everybody gets along.
Unfortunately, they don't always get along.
And particularly when somebody has died,
when there has been a loss,
a lot of times the tensions are high,
the emotions are high and old wounds get reopened
and you get some anger in all of that.
And some of that can be compounded
once people get an idea of how assets
are gonna pass at death.
Right, so, you know, so we're lawyers,
we're not psychologists or counselors.
So the emotions running high and all that stuff,
you know, maybe we should get Dr. Phil on here
to talk about that.
But what we're gonna talk about today
is what happens when someone in the family
threatens to contest a will,
or if maybe you believe that the will
is not what you expected it to be
and you are trying to decide
whether or not to contest a will.
So we're gonna talk about the very drama-filled area
of will contests today.
That's exactly right.
So first things first,
I saw an article, it's actually in the news this morning,
and it was from somebody that said,
you know, my stepfather has not probated my mom's will.
And it's been six years and he hasn't done anything.
And I've seen the will
and it left half of everything to the kids,
but he hasn't done anything about it.
And then the person that was answering this,
you know, kind of a Dear Abby sort of thing,
basically got everything wrong after that.
So no point in going into everything that they were saying.
But here's my guess of what happened in that situation.
Everything the couple had was probably things
like bank accounts that were in both of their names,
investment accounts that were in both of their names.
Maybe this person's mom had a retirement account
or an IRA or something like that,
that she had named the husband as a beneficiary on.
And it's possible,
I don't even know what state this was in,
but let's say that they lived in a state like Arkansas,
where real estate that is owned by a husband and wife
passes to the surviving spouse automatically
whether or not the person has a will.
And so it would not surprise me at all, Lisa,
that the reason he has not probated the will in this case
is because there's no need to.
Everything passed to him outside of the will
and outside of the probate process.
So whether this young lady wants to challenge the will
or force it to be probated or it gets it probated,
none of that is going to change the fact
that everything passed to him outside of the will.
Right, and that is an area of confusion
because many people,
if they've never been through this process before
with the death of a loved one,
all they know is maybe what they've seen in the movies.
And all they know is in the movies,
when someone dies and there's property,
there's a reading of the will and there's an attorney
and there's this, you may go to the courthouse.
But in many, many estates, that's not required.
And so the situation you were just describing
could very well be that situation
where there was no need,
there was no necessity to probate a will.
So if you are the person thinking that things aren't right,
and I might jump in here and force a will probate
or file a will contest,
first thing you need to figure out is,
are there any assets that would even be governed by a will?
Because if not, then you're just throwing your money away
by filing a contest or probating a will
that doesn't need to be probated.
That's right.
All right, we're gonna take a quick break
and we're gonna come back and talk some more
about what you do if you do actually wanna contest the will.
So stick around.
Oh, so luxurious,
but just a little too soft.
Just a little too hard.
This one's just right.
Welcome back everyone to Aging Insight.
I'm Lisa Schallmeyer here with John Ross.
And today we're talking about a topic
that a lot of people ask about, but it's very dramatic.
It's about will contests.
Yeah, we just went and saw a movie about it the other day.
That's true, we did.
They even make,
they still make Hollywood movies about will contests.
So there's plenty of drama.
So in our first segment, we talked about in many estates,
there's no need to probate a will at all.
So there's no will contest to be had in such a case.
But John, let's go back to the more traditional estates
that people think about and that there's land,
there's money, cars, maybe we even have,
sometimes it can be a blended family
where it's step-parents.
It can even be a intact family,
but maybe one of the kids is kind of a black sheep
and mom and dad didn't like them too much.
So family dynamics and personalities
absolutely come into play.
But what happens most often when someone dies,
now, remember, a will means nothing.
It doesn't mean a thing until a person is deceased
that has made that will,
and it is determined that that will needs to be probated
and taken to the courthouse
and entered into the probate process.
Until those two things happen,
there's no will contest to be had.
You certainly don't contest a will
prior to someone's death,
because as long as you're living,
you can change your will at any time.
So it's not set in stone.
But let's say that we are in a situation
where a will has been offered for probate at the courthouse
or is anticipated to be offered,
and the provisions in that will cut you out.
Okay, John.
So now we have a family member
who may be what we call a natural heir,
perhaps a child,
who maybe that parent has cut out of the will,
or sometimes I'll see that they leave them
a very little amount.
Right, a disproportionate distribution
in some way, shape, or form.
So yeah, if you're wanting to contest it,
first of all, you gotta figure out what are your options.
Well, the first thing,
and when I'm analyzing,
somebody comes in and they say,
here's this will, I wanna get this will probated,
or I wanna contest this will, or whatever it is.
But if it relates to the will,
the first thing somebody like me is looking at
is to determine, is it actually a valid will?
You know, in order to be a valid will,
it's gotta have certain formalities.
You know, was it, for example, a holographic will,
meaning that it was entirely
in the person's own handwriting and signed?
And when I say entirely, I mean entirely.
So if the person went and got
one of those little fill-in-the-blank forms,
and in their handwriting, they filled in the blanks,
but the rest of the document was typed,
well, that's not a valid holographic will.
It's not entirely in their own handwriting,
in which case, there is no will to contest
because the will's invalid.
Or maybe if it's not a holographic will,
it's gotta have two independent witnesses,
and those two witnesses, if it's a Texas will,
have to be 14 years or older at the time they signed the will
or if it's an Arkansas will,
they've gotta be 18 years or older.
So the next thing I'm looking at is, you know,
if it's not a holographic will,
was it signed in the presence of two witnesses?
Were those independent witnesses?
And so, you know, just some of these basic formalities.
In fact, one of those basic formalities is,
is it even a will?
Right, you know, a will's a document
where the document on its face
is contemplating the death of the testator.
You know, upon my death,
I want this property to go to these people.
That's a will.
Right.
But just a list that has John, pickup truck,
Lisa, pearl necklace, that's just a list.
That's just a list. That's not a will.
That's right.
It lacks what we call testamentary intent.
It's not obvious from the document
that that was intended to be a will.
Those could have been lifetime transfers.
They could have just been a list of things
that people have said they wanted, who knows,
but it's not actually a will.
So the first thing you have to determine is,
is this actually a will?
If you get past that though,
then you're gonna have to find another way.
So if on its face, it looks like a valid will,
but you still want to make it invalid.
Right, that you would like that that will to be thrown out.
That's right.
You're gonna have to have a reason for it.
And generally, that reason is gonna come down
to a lack of testamentary capacity.
Yes, or that's one reason.
The other reason is undue influence.
So I guess we'll kind of take these one at a time, John,
but when you make a will,
you have to have sufficient mental capacity
to know what you're doing,
to know that you are contemplating death
and you want this document to reflect
that these are the beneficiaries
you want to receive your property.
You also have to, you have to know
who the natural heirs of your bounty are.
That's a kind of an old phrase,
but it just means you know who your family members are.
You know who your friends and those closest to you are.
Also, you have to know what property you actually own
and that you actually have and what debts you might owe.
By knowing all of these different things,
the law presumes that if you know these things
and you complete a document
that purports to give away the property that you own
to the heirs and beneficiaries you select
in a document that contemplates
that when I die, I want this to happen,
that is testamentary capacity.
And many people in a will contest,
a common challenge is that the testator,
the person who made the will,
didn't understand all of those things
when this will was made.
And John, that testamentary capacity or the lack of it
can be a very tough claim to show.
It is, it's very difficult
because you're often going back in time
to sometime when they executed that will
and you're showing that they lacked one or more
of those three things,
the ability to know who their people are,
to know what their stuff is
and to hold all of that information in their mind
long enough to make that document
and proving that that was the circumstance a decade ago
can be very difficult.
And so that is a very high bar to get over
if you wanna prove that that person is incapacitated.
It can be done, but you've gotta have some,
you gotta have some pretty good facts.
Yeah, if you're the one that wants to contest that will
and have it thrown out
and you didn't think mom had testamentary capacity,
then the burden is on you to show that,
to bring evidence that mom lacked testamentary capacity
at the time she made the will.
So you're gonna have to do a lot of digging.
That may include digging into medical records,
talking to witnesses,
can be an expensive litigation process.
And also the more time has gone by,
the more difficult that is to prove, so.
That's right.
The other one is undue influence
and we'll talk about that one
as soon as we come back from this break.
Stick around.
I'm so glad we found the Wadley Senior Clinic.
Their team specializes in caring for older adults
and their doctors listen and work with me
to keep me healthy and independent.
With monthly educational programs,
x-ray and lab and state-of-the-art exam rooms,
I get expert care and understanding
about what I'm going through.
Best yet, they're easy to get to
right off the interstate at Jefferson.
See what Wadley Senior Clinic could do for you.
Wadley Senior Clinic, where healthy relationships begin.
Welcome back to Aging Insight, everybody.
I'm John Ross here with Lisa Schollmeyer.
And today we're talking about will contests
and kind of from the standpoint of
if you want to contest a will,
what are your ways?
Is it even a will at all?
Does it meet the basic requirements for a will?
Because if it doesn't have the right signatures
or things like that,
then it doesn't matter if the person made it out or not.
It's out.
The person had to have the mental capacity
to understand what it was that they're doing.
Although that's very difficult to prove,
especially if it was done many, many years ago.
The last one and one that we actually hear
probably the most often is the claim of undue influence.
And basically what this means is that
somebody pressured this person to such an extent
that they overrode their free will.
And so this will that they signed,
they were not under their own free will when they did it.
They were under such duress that they had no real choice,
but to sign the will.
And the classic example of this is,
you know, the holding the gun to somebody's head
and saying, if you don't sign the will,
I'm gonna pull the trigger.
Right.
That will's invalid.
Certainly.
You know, I've never had that case come up,
but that is the example of how that law professors
often describe how extreme the pressure has to be
on someone to prove a claim of undue influence.
So if you're trying to throw out the will,
and it appears to be a valid document on its face,
you know that 10 years ago when mom wrote the will,
you know, you don't have any good claims
that she lacked capacity,
but if the will says your sister gets everything,
and you know, you feel in your heart
that your mom loved you too,
and that mom would never have cut you out of the will,
but for your sister's exerting her influence on your mother.
That is a claim for undue influence.
But John, the law makes it very difficult to prove
because what we hear most often from someone is,
well, you know, I got married.
I moved to Little Rock.
My sister, she never married.
She bought a house right next door to mom,
and you know, she was there morning, noon, and night,
and you know, I would visit for holidays and all,
but you know, I know that my sister
just really bad mouthed me,
and made it to where she told all these lies to my mother
about how I didn't care about her,
and because of those lies that my sister told to my mother,
my mother wrote me out of this will,
or she left me very little,
and I want to contest this will
because if my sister hadn't been there
always talking in her ear, she wouldn't have done that.
John, is that an undue influence case?
No.
Is it influence?
Yes, but did that influence rise to the level
that it overrode the free will of mom?
And the fact is, lying to mom doesn't get you there.
In fact, even things that might seem like undue influence,
you know, actual stories that we have heard
and have been told, for example,
where the kid says, you know,
if you don't sign this will, mom,
or if you don't give me the house in the will,
or if you don't leave me everything in the will,
then I'm not gonna bring the grandchildren
to see you anymore.
Is that influence?
Yes.
Is it undue influence?
I mean, was mom still perfectly capable
of hauling her cookies up to a lawyer's office
and doing a will in any way, shape, or form she wanted?
She sure was.
Maybe she made a choice that access to the grandkids
was more important to her than some will contest
after she was dead.
But she still retained the free will.
Was that dirty?
Was that-
Right, is it completely distasteful
and unethical and despicable?
Yes.
Absolutely.
Is it undue influence?
Probably not.
Now, there's some things, though.
What if, you know, what if that kid,
you know, you use the sister that's there with mom.
And what if the sister that's there with mom,
she's the one that's taking care of mom in the home.
And, you know, yeah,
she's telling these lies about the sister.
Oh, she doesn't care about you.
She never comes and sees you.
I'm here all the time.
That's probably not undue influence.
But what if she says,
and if you don't do this,
I'm gonna put you in a nursing home.
Ah, okay.
So-
And maybe, maybe mom has always professed
that one of her greatest fears was to be in a nursing home.
She had seen her mother in a nursing home
and had a very bad experience with it.
And this is something that she's always fretted about.
And now this sister,
not only is she lying and doing these other things,
but now it's, if you don't do this,
I'm gonna make your worst fear come true.
Right.
I'm gonna put you in that nursing home.
And we've heard these stories before as well.
That I think is probably gonna rise to the level
of not just influence, but undue influence.
But John, with all of these things you're saying,
oftentimes that influence is exerted in private.
That's exactly right.
So if you're the sister that's been written out of the will
and you know in your heart
that it's because of your siblings, what they've done,
you've got to prove to the court that these things happened.
That your sibling threatened to put mom in a nursing home
if she didn't sign this will.
And that too can be very difficult.
That's right.
So generally speaking,
it is very, very hard to contest a will.
Despite what you see in Hollywood
and all of these sort of things,
the actual process of contesting a will is very difficult.
It's also very expensive
because it's gonna take a lot of time
developing this evidence.
And particularly if you're talking about going to trial
and all of these other things.
That's a very, very expensive process.
And if you're the one wanting to do the contesting,
it's expensive and a gamble.
And not a gamble with great odds
because it's hard to prove whether or not
mom lacked mental capacity a decade ago.
Or that your sister, in private,
where nobody else heard it,
threatened mom to a level that rose to undue influence.
So all of that stuff's very difficult,
very hard to prove.
Which all goes back to the point of,
get your stuff in order.
People like us, when we anticipate a future contest,
there are things we know how to do
to make it much more difficult to contest it later on.
So if you're expecting a contest, get in touch.
Hey, if you're the one who wants to contest it,
if you wanna know what your options are,
we can answer that too.
So anyway, we appreciate you watching the show today.
If you've got other information that you want,
you can always pick up a copy of the Aging Insight magazine,
listen to our radio show, Aging Insight,
live every Saturday on 107.1.
Or you can just stick around next week
for another episode of Aging Insight.
Bye-bye.
Bye.
Thank you for joining us
for this week's Aging Insight program
with John Ross and Lisa Schollmeyer.
This program is made possible by.
