In Joe Biden's first address to congress he laid out his proposal for the American Families Plan. This plan comes with a $1.8 trillion dollar price tag that will be paid for by increasing the top tax bracket along with an increase in the capital gains tax for people making over $1 Million per year.
The main pieces of the plan are education, child care costs, paid family leave and extension of the tax credit.
To Becoming Great with Money, Rich McCormack, CFP® www.schoolofpersonalfinance.com
Hey, what's up everyone and welcome to the School of Personal Finance. So Wednesday night in his
first speech to Congress, Joe Biden laid out his 1.8 trillion American Families Plan. So in this
video, I'm going to go through the details. I'm going to talk about how it might directly impact
you. I'm also going to talk about the revenue raising side of the equation, how he plans to
raise taxes. And even though it's really targeted at people that are considered wealthy, that make
over $400,000 a year, or people that make over a million dollars a year, there are some pieces of
it that does really hit the investor class, the middle class looking to build wealth in this
country. So I'll talk a little bit about that as well. All right, let's get to it.
All right, so the American Families Plan. So now this is the third proposal that Joe Biden is
looking to put through Congress in just, you know, the first four months of his presidency. The first
one was the American Rescue Act where, you know, everybody got stimulus checks during the pandemics.
That was the pandemic relief bill. The second one is the infrastructure bill, which has not yet
passed through Congress. And now this one, the American Families Plan. So if you take a step
back and you look at the plan, the whole point of it is to help those lower income families,
even those middle class families that are on the lower end of the middle class, because the cost
of living in this country, it is becoming very expensive. If we look at education, child care,
the increase in prices is much more rapid than what we've seen in inflation. So it's harder for
young families to pay for everything. Nowadays, you need two income households, right? Both spouses
need to work in order to make ends meet. And it's getting harder and harder. Then you throw in the
pandemic where millions of people lost their jobs and it's been a struggle. So the whole point of
this plan is to help those families and to give them some support and give them a little bit of
breathing room. Now, how do you raise money for this? Biden's plan is to go after the top. And
we all knew it coming into this presidency that Joe Biden was looking to raise taxes on the
wealthiest Americans. All right, so let's dig into some of the details of this plan. So the first one
is education. So what Biden is looking to do is to add two years to the front and two years to the
back of public schooling. And he mentioned in his speech that it was a very long time ago that the
U.S. decided that 12 years of public schooling would be enough. But here in the 21st century,
we need to extend that. So he's talking about two years ages three and four for pre-K that would be
universal and then two years of community college that would also be universally paid for. So,
I mean, that would help a lot of young families. It would help them on the front then when their
kids are in school. Like I have a three-year-old that's in pre-K right now where we pay $600 a
month for. And it is what it is. And then for community college, we're all saving in 529 plans
and trying to save for our kids' education. So that would take some of the stress off as well,
especially for kids whose parents might not be able to save for them to go to college,
and they're taking out loans. And you can have those first two years of no college expenses.
It would definitely be a help to a lot of middle class and lower income families in this country.
All right, and then the second thing is on childcare. So this plan would guarantee that
lower and middle income families would pay no more than 7% of their income on childcare. So
they're saying that that could save families an estimated amount of around $15,000 per year,
and that the average right now is somewhere around 16% of their income getting paid for
childcare. All right, and then the third one is the paid leave program, which will provide up
to $4,000 a month, up to 12 weeks of paid leave for parent, family, or for personal illnesses.
And then the fourth part of this is to extend the child tax credit that was just passed in the
American Rescue Plan a few months ago. It was only for one year. So they're looking to extend
that now through 2025. So those are the main pieces of the $1.8 trillion American Families
Plan. So now the question is, how are we going to raise the revenue to pay for this plan?
So for Biden's infrastructure plan that he recently introduced, for that, he's looking
to pay for it by raising corporate taxes. So he wants to go from 21% corporate taxes up to 28%
in corporate taxes. And he says that that will raise $2 trillion in revenue in order to pay for
the infrastructure plan. So now for this plan, he's going after people that are making over
a million dollars. I mean, it really starts with people that are making over $400,000 where the
highest tax bracket will be increased from 37% up to 39.6%. But then beyond that, there's some big
changes for individuals that make over a million dollars a year. So now the big one, and this was
leaked earlier this week, and you saw the stock market drop 300 points just like that when the
broke. And that is the capital gains for anybody earning more than a million dollars in a year
will be taxed as ordinary income. So there will no longer be a lower capital gains tax bracket
for people making over $1 million. So this is a tremendous increase in the capital gains rate.
Currently it is 20%. That would bring it all the way up to the top bracket of 39.6% plus the 3.8%
surtax on investment income. So between those two, you would be looking at 43.2%
on capital gains tax if you make more than a million dollars. Now you might be thinking that
that really doesn't affect you, but I can think of a lot of instances where it actually could
affect you. I mean, the first one being that it just discourages investment in general, right?
So if you're going to be paying 43%, plus if you live in a state like New York or California,
you'll be paying over 50% on long-term capital gains, which it just discourages investment in
general. So that could take some money out of the stock market. People could be looking for other
ways to invest money instead of taking a risk in the stock market if you have to give up half of
your gains when you sell out of a position. But other than that, what about people who start small
businesses? What if you decide to take a risk in life and to start a small business from the ground
up? You pay yourself a reasonable salary, you have the business for 25 years, and your retirement
plan is to eventually sell the business. What happens if you're able to sell that small business
for $3 million in retirement and that is your retirement plan? At that point, if this were the
case, you would owe pretty much half of that in capital gains. So that really makes it much less
appealing to take a chance and to try to start a small business where eventually you could have
a nice payday and have a nice retirement. If you have to give up half of the value of the business
when you sell it to taxes, then why not just get a W-2 job or even for real estate investors?
So if you own a ton of real estate and you carry it through your life and then you decide to sell
something and it puts you over a million dollars in income for the year because you've held real
estate for 30 years, why would you sell it? Why would you give up that real estate if you're going
to have to pay 50% of it in taxes at ordinary income rates where now when you sell on any of
the lower capital gains rates? So that is another consequence of this where it could hit people,
and maybe you don't think of that as middle class, but in America, people are trying to build wealth.
So if you want to build wealth and you're trying to do it through building a business or through
real estate where you're taking a chance, then it gives you less incentive to do that.
Another part of this plan is beefing up IRS enforcement and going out and auditing people
who make over a million dollars a year and trying to raise tax revenue that way, not letting people
get away with not reporting all of their income where audits have been down so much over the last
decade as the IRS has not had the resources really to do it. So they're looking at beefing that up
and going out and auditing people that make a million dollars or more to raise revenue.
All right. And now another part of this is limiting the amount of tax-free exchanges
in investment properties. So investment real estate. So right now, if you sell a building,
let's say you buy real estate for $500,000 and it grows to be worth a million dollars.
What you could do is you could do a like-kind exchange. You could sell that property and then
parlay it, invest it into a bigger property, and you could defer the taxes into that new property.
So you won't actually owe any taxes on the sale of that building as long as you go ahead and you
purchase a new building. And there are a bunch of rules around 1031 exchanges. And then that new
building, you carry over the cost basis. So eventually you pay taxes on it when you decide
to fully cash out of it. But that is a way that real estate investors, they buy property and they
keep on building up and buying bigger properties and building their real estate wealth. So what
this is going to do is limit the amount of that 1031 exchange to $500,000. And what this is
indirectly doing, it is going to force these big hedge funds and big corporations that invest in
these big multifamily properties to look at single-family homes. Because if you now just
purchase single-family homes on the lower end of the price scale, then that $500,000 exchange won't
have as big of an effect on you. So now there's going to be more competition out there for people
who are first-time homebuyers. So I don't think that this is a great thing for the real estate
market. And then another tax loophole that they are taking direct aim at is the step-up in cost
basis. So the way that it works right now is when you own an asset and you pass away and you leave
that to your family, they get a step-up in cost basis. So when they inherit it, they inherit it
at the price at your death. So if they go ahead and they sell it the next day, there'll be no taxes
owed on that. So for example, let's say that your parents, they've owned Apple stock for the
last 20 years and they bought it for $100,000 and now it's worth $5 million. If they pass away
and they leave you that money, then you get a step-up in basis. If you sell the stock the next
day, you will own no taxes on any of that tremendous gain. But what they're looking to do in this
proposal is limit the step-up in cost basis. They're throwing around numbers, but right now
they're saying maybe to $1 million per individual. Now, some of these tax increases, they've been
presented before and they really haven't gone anywhere. And right now with the Senate being
50-50, it might be hard to get all these things through. I mean, people are making the assumption
that this is not going to get passed in the current form, that there'll be some negotiation,
but some of it's definitely going to get passed and we don't know what it will look like in its
final bill, but it'll be interesting to see how it all goes. And one thing that I've learned
through different administrations and watching this throughout the years is they call things
permanent and they make all these changes, and then the next administration comes in and changes
it again. So I do believe that if these changes do go through, that you're not going to see people
selling anything. People are going to be holding. Real estate investors, they're not going to sell
their real estate and pay ordinary income tax on their capital gains. Or if you own large stock
positions that have gone up, I mean, the stock market has been ripping. So if you have big
amounts of capital gains in there, you're not going to sell during a time where you're going to
pay ordinary income tax. At the end of the day, I think that we all could agree that it would be
great if we could give lower income families a chance in this country to do great and to be
successful. So that is the point of this bill, is to help those people do better, to help give them
a chance to really get ahead and give them a little bit of breathing room in their lives.
The question is, is this the best way to do it? Is this going to stop people from starting small
businesses or taking a chance and investing in real estate or investing in the stock market?
Are people going to take a step back and say, you know what, is there a better way for me to do it
and find a different method that might be a little bit safer? Are people going to say,
you know what, I should just go work for one of these very big corporations that are going to
give me great benefits and a great salary and not worrying about the stress and taking on the risk
of trying to start my own business and building all this wealth. If I actually make it, if I
actually hit a home run with it, and the government is going to take half of it when it's all said and
done, it might not be worth it. Alright everyone, that is it for this one. I hope that you found
that helpful. Please make sure to hit that like button if you enjoyed this one. Hit that subscribe
button if you are not subscribed to the channel yet, and I'll see you again next week. Thanks.