The Atlantic recently released an article titled “Let’s Declare a Pandemic Amnesty” that called for forgiveness from the public for any perceived missteps in the public health establishment’s handling of the COVID pandemic. In this episode, we speak with Dr. Aaron Kheriaty, former director of the medical ethics program at the University of California–Irvine and author of the book “The New Abnormal.” Kheriaty believes that reconciliation is obtainable, but only under certain circumstances. He also makes some alarming ties between the Third Reich’s use of emergency executive powers and those currently being used in the United States by both political parties. He explains how if we’re not careful, we can easily go down a path that leads to an unrecognizable United States, something that COVID has given us a sneak peek into with several examples of tyrannical governmental overreach.
The Atlantic triggered an online debate with an article titled,
Let's Declare a Pandemic Amnest. It called for forgiveness rather than accountability
for the public health and political establishment on the way they handled the COVID-19 policies.
According to Dr. Aaron Cariarty, however, accountability is needed. Dr. Cariarty is
the former director of the Medical Ethics Program at the University of California, Irvine,
and author of the new book, The New Abnormal. We speak with him about where the medical
establishment is heading with new powers created under COVID-19, historical examples of how the
Nazis used similar policies under the Third Reich, and where the world is heading if nothing is done
Hey, Dr. Aaron Cariarty, thanks for being here.
Thanks, Josh. Great to be with you again.
Yeah, it's been a while. I think last time we talked was when you were having this whole spat
with the University of California, and it's been a long road for you, actually.
It's been an interesting year.
I want to talk to you. Yeah, for all of us, but I think for you especially.
You've been kind of the canary in the coal mine when it comes to what we risk with the whole
COVID-19 pandemic. I know you did this new book about the biomedical security state.
It's called The New Abnormal. It seems that everything you warned about previously is,
in fact, coming to pass. I want to go into this with you. I mean, just kind of laying out the
stage. We recently saw this Atlantic piece calling for amnesty over the pandemic. A lot of people
came out, and they were very unhappy about it. They said, no, we do not need amnesty.
We need people held accountable lest this happens again. It looked for a bit like the pandemic was
done. It looked like everything was over. Then all of a sudden, they're coming out with all
these new announcements suggesting they are going to do it again. I want to ask you,
I guess just from the top, what's going on right now?
Yeah, so this question of pandemic amnesty, which was a proposal published in the Atlantic
Monthly saying, look, we didn't know, especially early in the pandemic, what we were doing,
and so it's time to forgive and forget and move on. There's something very appealing about this
proposal. Certainly, we're now living in a society where people are deeply divided,
and many of those divisions have to do with families divided or friendships ended over
disputes about COVID pandemic policies, essentially, whether someone was going to be
invited to Thanksgiving dinner if they hadn't been vaccinated or refused to wear a mask,
this sort of thing. So society is hurting in the wake of basically everything that we've been
through in the last three years from lockdowns to mask mandates, vaccine mandates, vaccine
passports, and of course, the fear of the virus itself. And so it's a really important question,
how do we heal and reunite the social divisions that have come about because of our response to
COVID? So I'm in favor of reconciliation, and I'm in favor of forgiveness, but it has to be done
with integrity, it has to be done right. And so my worries about the proposal for amnesty,
as it's been articulated, is a plea that, first of all, we didn't know what we were doing. But
the fact was, there were a lot of people that did very early on call into question many of
these policies from lockdowns to school closures, there were critics, but those critics were
sidelined, were marginalized, were vilified. And, you know, in some cases, many of those people
actually lost their jobs, their livelihoods. So it wasn't just a matter of ignorance, it was a matter
of a very deliberate effort to censor certain voices that were not going along with the mainstream
public health narrative. So people didn't have access to one side of the debate, we ended up with
a false scientific consensus or a false appearance of a consensus projected toward most members of
the general public, unless they were digging deeper and reading the Epoch Times or watching
your show or looking, you know, to various voices on Substack to get a, you know, get a different
view of what was happening. So amnesty, no. Forgiveness and reconciliation, yes. But with
forgiveness and reconciliation, I think we could take a cue from the truth and reconciliation
commissions that society engaged in after South African apartheid, for example, or following the
Rwandan genocide, obviously situations in which there were deep wounds, deep social divisions,
various serious wrongs had been done and people had genuinely suffered, you know, massive injustices.
But the truth and reconciliation commissions, to be done with integrity, had to begin with truth.
There was no reconciliation without a public acknowledgement and a public
owning of responsibility for the harms that were done. And that's what we didn't see in the
commentaries. What we saw instead, I fear, was not a request for forgiveness following an apology
for harms that were done, but we saw an attempt for many in our public health establishment to
sort of forgive themselves and to sweep the harms under the carpet. Right. So for authentic
reconciliation, you have to begin with truth and acknowledgement that wrong was done. You also have
to make efforts to rectify those harms.