Full Committee Markup 12/06/2022

Oversight Committee
67 followers
3 Video Views·Dec 11, 2022
Full Committee Markup 12/06/2022
The committee will come to order. Without objection, the committee chair is authorized to declare a recess HR Res 1479.
Recurrent to notice, I now call up HR Res 1479, a resolution of inquiry.
The clerk will report the resolution which was distributed in advance.
House Resolution 1479 of Inquiry Requesting the President Transmit Certain Documents in His Possession
to the House of Representatives relating to the surveillance or monitoring of pro-gun, pro-life, or conservative groups
under the Internet Covert Operations Program operated by the United States Postal Inspection Service.
Without objection, the resolution is considered read and open to amendment.
At any point, the chair recognizes herself to offer an amendment in the nature of a substitute,
copies of which have been distributed electronically to all members in advance.
The clerk will report the amendment.
Amendment in the nature of a substitute to House Resolution 1479 offered by Mrs. Maloney of New York.
Without objection, the amendment is considered read and will be served as a base text for purposes of amendment.
I recognize Representative Clyde to explain the resolution.
Representative Clyde, you are now recognized.
Thank you, Chairwoman Maloney.
I introduced H.R.S. 1479 after learning of records that show U.S. Postal Service inspectors
targeted Americans for advocating for conservative causes.
I would like to request unanimous consent to submit for the record an article from The Washington Times
from September 22, 2022, titled, The Postal Service Surveilled Protesters with Pro-Gun and Anti-Biden Agendas.
Without objection.
Thank you, ma'am.
The article also outlines how it was not just conservatives being surveilled,
but also people preparing to demonstrate against the police after the shooting of Breonna Taylor
that were also being surveilled.
My question is, what does that have to do with the United States Postal Service?
Most Americans are not even aware that the organization that delivers their mail
also runs a surveillance operation called the United States Postal Inspection Service's
Internet Covert Operations Program, also known as ICOP,
that tracks and collects Americans' social media posts.
The Postal Service Office of Inspector General launched an investigation into the ICOP program
at the request of this very committee.
And I must say that it was at the request of the top Democrat and Republican.
So thank you, Madam Chair, for working with us on that.
And with that precedent of working together,
I hope that we can all agree to favorably report this to the House of Representatives for consideration.
The resulting report clearly stated that the Postal Inspector's surveillance
overstepped its law enforcement authority.
And I quote,
We determined that certain proactive searches, that's proactive searches,
ICOP conducted using an open source intelligence tool from February to April 2021
exceeded the Postal Inspection Service's law enforcement authority.
Furthermore, we could not corroborate whether other work analysts completed from October 2018
through June 2021 was legally authorized.
It is very disturbing that in over eight months since this report initially came out,
Democrats have not requested more information or even had a hearing on this matter.
This is the Oversight Committee.
How much money has the Postal Service squandered on this program, this ICOP program?
We know the U.S. Postal Service is in financial difficulty.
We have certainly had hearings on that.
We are the committee charged with oversight of the federal government,
specifically the U.S. Postal Service,
and the Democrat majority has yet to fulfill that duty.
Why would any of my Democrat colleagues oppose this ROI?
I hope they don't.
I hope that you will work with us on this.
My ROI simply requests documents about the Internet covert operation programs
monitoring of pro-gun, pro-life, or conservative groups.
What are in these documents that Democrats refuse to allow Americans to see?
I hope nothing.
I hope that we get every document.
We need answers and we need them now.
The United States Postal Service should not be abusing its power
with a program more fitting for a police state than the United States.
Furthermore, it should not be targeting Americans
because they believe in the constitutional right to bear arms
or because they disagree with the President.
I urge all my colleagues from both sides of the aisle to support my resolution
because it protects all of our constitutional rights,
especially our First Amendment rights.
Thank you, Madam Chair, and I yield back.
The gentleman yields back.
I now recognize myself.
I believe strongly in protecting Americans' First Amendment rights,
and I also believe that we cannot accept inappropriate surveillance
of peaceful protests and other First Amendment activity.
But the highly partisan resolution we are debating today is unnecessary and misdirected,
and it would do nothing to protect the First Amendment.
This resolution would request documents from President Biden
about the surveillance activities of the Postal Inspection Service,
a unit of the Postal Service,
with respect to, quote, pro-gun, pro-life, or conservative groups, end quote.
In other words, this resolution seems to be suggesting
that President Biden somehow used the Postal Service
to spy on conservatives and other people.
But nothing could be further from the truth.
The truth is the Postal Service is an independent agency,
which is not subject to direction from the President or the White House.
Instead, the Postal Service is overseen by an independent board of governors,
which happens to be chaired by a Republican appointed by former President Trump.
And the Postmaster General, Louis DeJoy, is a major Republican donor.
Reports also make clear that the Postal Inspection Service
focused on protest activities on both the right and the left,
including demonstrations following the death of Breonna Taylor
in Louisville, Kentucky.
In contrast to this partisan resolution,
the committee addressed this issue last year
in a serious, professional, bipartisan way.
Last April, Ranking Member Comer and I sent a bipartisan letter
to the Postal Service IG,
requesting evaluation of the program, known as ICOP,
because we were concerned about reports
that the Postal Inspection Service may have stepped over the line
in gathering information on First Amendment activity.
The Inspector General accepted that request and conducted an investigation.
They reviewed 160 cases and 70 reports related to ICOP.
They interviewed employees,
and they reviewed policies, procedures, and contracts.
This March, the IG released a report,
and I asked unanimous consent to place the report in the record,
seeing no objection.
The report found that in some instances,
ICOP, quote,
exceeded the Postal Inspection Service Law Enforcement Authority, end quote,
by using open-source tools like social media
to gather information on First Amendment activity.
The IG also said it could not confirm the legal authority
for certain work done from 2018 to 2021,
a period that cut across multiple administrations.
Although the Postal Service disagreed with some of the IG's findings,
they agreed to address the IG's key recommendations
and to conduct an internal review.
I would strongly support efforts to learn more from the Postal Service
about the outcome of its internal review
to ensure that the agency is carefully protecting First Amendment rights.
And as my good friend Ranking Member Comer knows,
given our close work on the Postal Service Reform Act,
I have continuously worked with him to ensure that the Postal Service
has the resources it needs to support itself.
In fact, I strongly supported the requirement
for a public-facing tracking system for Postal Service performance,
which was Ranking Member Comer's idea and which strengthened our bill.
But I cannot support a resolution that ignores the facts
and tries to turn this issue into a partisan battle.
I urge all my colleagues to vote to report this resolution unfavorably.
Thank you.
And I yell back, and I now recognize Ranking Member Comer.
Thank you, Madam Chair.
Last year, Americans and members of this committee were alarmed by news reports
claiming the Postal Service was potentially spying on their social media activity.
It came to light that the U.S. Postal Inspection Service
has monitored social media as part of their Internet Covert Operations Program, or ICOP.
The Postal Inspection Service explained to committee staff
that the reason they were monitoring social media
was to identify potential areas of social unrest or violence,
such as the Black Lives Matter riots in the spring and summer of 2020,
in order to protect postal facilities and workers.
The Postal Inspection Service also used the program to identify threats
against the life of Postmaster General DeJoy.
Such threats were the direct result of the inflamed and baseless rhetoric
of congressional Democrats who accused him of trying to steal the 2020 election
by upending postal operations.
But concerns about ICOP have arisen again due to recent reports
that the program was used to specifically target conservative groups
and events such as a Second Amendment rally and pro-life marches.
The Postal Inspection Service is only authorized to conduct activities
directly related to the integrity of the mail
or protecting postal employees and property from harm.
While I appreciate the need to protect postal workers and property,
it's also important to both maintain public confidence in the Postal Service
and protect civil liberties.
I know the Chairwoman shares this concern,
since we co-signed a letter in May 2021 to the U.S. Postal Service Inspector General
requesting an audit of the U.S. Postal Inspection Service's
intelligence-gathering activities.
It's important to determine whether particular groups were targeted over others.
The documents covered by this Resolution of Inquiry will help determine
if this was the case.
I urge my colleagues to support this resolution and yield back.
Who else seeks recognition?
Thank you, Madam Chair.
I appreciate my dear friend Representative Clyde for introducing this resolution
and his efforts to ultimately protect the interests of American citizens,
regardless of their political leanings.
I'm incredibly concerned, as many others here today are,
at the actions taken by the U.S. Postal Inspection Service
for potentially, allegedly, targeting conservative-leaning individuals
in the pro-life groups, various pro-life groups or Second Amendment groups.
And look, too many of us have great concerns with federal law enforcement agencies,
be it the Department of Justice, FBI, now considering the Postal Service,
seemingly being weaponized to target conservatives in this country.
And when you have a swath of the American people who feel as though their voice
and their opinion is being targeted, then we have a problem as a republic as a whole.
We cannot allow our federal government to be weaponized against any political group in this country.
And I'm incredibly concerned and worried about the ultimate fate of our country
if agencies continue to target Americans simply for voicing their opinions
or exercising their constitutionally protected rights.
This inquiry, this resolution of inquiry by Mr. Clyde is simply searching for the truth.
And Congress and the American people need to know the truth.
They need to know if the Postal Service has been,
the Inspection Service has been targeting individual groups.
We need to know that, and that's all that is being sought for here.
The Postal Inspection Service has a mission,
and quite frankly they are far outside of their mission if these accusations at all are true,
and we need to find out.
So I encourage my colleagues to support this resolution, and with that I yield back.
Who else seeks recognition?
The question now occurs on the amendment in the nature of a substitute to H.R. 1479.
Mr. Falun.
Okay, Mr. Falun.
Oh, he's on the computer.
He's on the computer.
Mr. Falun, you're now recognized, Mr. Falun.
Okay, the question now occurs on the amendment in the nature of a substitute to H.R.
Mr. Falun, are you on?
Yes.
Where are you?
Thank you, Madam Chair.
I'll be very brief, but thank you.
I appreciate it.
Apologize for that quick technical difficulty there.
But, you know, I just wanted to speak very quickly.
And, you know, for our friends across the aisle, this is chilling.
When you have a government agency like the U.S. Post Office Inspector Inspection Services,
and they're investigating things far beyond their purview,
because this may have been directed toward conservatives today and yesterday,
but it certainly could be targeted in other folks, including our friends across the aisle,
could be targeted tomorrow.
And I want to thank Representative Clyde for bringing this to our attention.
And I think this should be, honestly, quite frankly, it's a bipartisan issue.
And it should be a unanimous vote in favor.
So, Madam Chair, thank you very much.
I appreciate it.
I yield back.
The gentleman yields back.
The question now occurs on the amendment in the nature of a substitute to H.R. 1479.
All those in favor say aye.
Aye.
All those opposed say no.
And the opinion of the Chair, the ayes have it.
And the amendment in the nature of a substitute is agreed to.
The question now occurs on unfavorably reporting H.R. 1479 as amended.
If you share my opposition to this resolution, you should vote aye.
All those in favor of unfavorably reporting the resolution say aye.
Aye.
All those opposed say no.
No.
Well, in the opinion of the Chair, the ayes have it.
I request a recorded vote.
Okay.
A recorded vote has been requested.
A recorded vote is so ordered and pursuant to Clause 2 of Rule 11 and Committee Rule 5B,
proceedings on the amendment are postponed.
And now we will now consider postal naming measures.
Pursuant to notice, I call up the following postal naming bills which were distributed in advance.
H.R. 8622, H.R. 9074, H.R. 9251, H.R. 9335.
Without objection, the bills are considered read.
And I request unanimous consent for their immediate consideration and passage en bloc.
Without objection, the bills are passed.
The bills considered en bloc shall be favorably reported to the House.
Without objection, a motion to reconsider is laid on the table.
Staff is authorized to make technical and conforming changes to the matters considered by the Committee in this markup.
The Committee will now recess before reconvening to take outstanding roll call votes at a time to be announced by the Chair.
The Committee stands in recess.
Let's call the vote right now.
The recorded vote was previously requested.
If you share my opposition to this resolution, you should vote aye.
The Clerk will call the roll.
Ms. Norton.
Norton votes aye.
Ms. Norton votes aye.
Mr. Lynch.
Mr. Lynch votes aye.
Mr. Cooper.
Mr. Connelly.
Mr. Christian Murphy.
Aye.
Mr. Christian Murphy votes aye.
Mr. Raskin.
Aye.
Mr. Raskin votes aye.
Mr. Connelly.
Aye.
Mr. Connelly votes aye.
Mr. Mfume.
Ms. Ocasio-Cortez.
Ms. Tlaib.
Ms. Tlaib votes aye.
Ms. Porter.
Ms. Bush.
Ms. Bush votes aye.
Ms. Brown.
Ms. Brown votes aye.
Mr. Davis.
Mr. Davis votes aye.
Ms. Wassermann-Shults.
Mr. Welch.
Mr. Welch votes aye.
Mr. Johnson.
Mr. Johnson votes aye.
Mr. Sarbanes.
Mr. Sarbanes votes aye.
Ms. Speier.
Mr. Speier votes aye.
Mr. Heiss votes no. Mr. Grofman. Mr. Grofman votes no. Mr. cloud. Mr. Cloud votes no. Mr. Gibbs
Mr. Gibbs votes no. Mr. Higgins. Mr. Higgins votes no. Mr. Norman. Mr. Norman votes no. Mr.
Sessions. Mr. Sessions votes no. Mr. Keller. Mr. Keller votes no. Mr. Biggs. Mr.
Biggs votes no. Mr. Clyde. Mr. Clyde votes no to unfavorably reporting the
good chairwoman's amendment to my bill. Mr. Clyde votes no. Ms. Mace. Ms. Mace. Ms.
Franklin. Mr. Franklin votes no. Mr. LaTurner. Mr. LaTurner votes no. Mr.
LaTurner votes no. Mr. Falun. Mr. Falun votes nay. Mr. Falun votes no. Ms.
Harrell. Ms. Harrell votes no. Mr. Donalds. Mr. Flood. Mr. Flood votes no. Ms.
Maloney. Ms. Maloney votes aye. Madam Chair how am I reported to Debbie
Wasserman Schultz. Ms. Wasserman Schultz you are not recorded. Mr. Schultz votes aye. Ms. Wasserman Schultz votes aye.
How is Representative Presley recorded? Mr. Connolly. No, I was here present. Mr.
Connolly, you are not recorded. I vote aye. Mr. Connolly votes aye. How is Mr. Cooper
recorded? Mr. Cooper, you are not recorded. Cooper votes aye. Mr. Cooper votes aye.
How is miss Presley recorded? Miss Presley is not recorded. Presley votes aye.
Ms. Presley votes aye. Madam Chair, how is Mr. Mfume recorded? Mr. Mfume is not recorded.
Mr. Mfume votes aye. Mr. Mfume votes aye. How is Mr. Desaulnier recorded? Mr. Desaulnier
you are not recorded. Desaulnier votes aye. Mr. Desaulnier votes aye. How am I recorded
Mr. Welch? Mr. Welch you are not recorded. I vote yes. Mr. Welch votes yes. Is there
any member who has not voted? Is there any member wishing to change his or her vote?
The clerk will report the tally when ready. Ms. Chairwoman, I have 23 ayes and 18 nays.
HR Res. 1479 shall be unfavorably reported to the House without objection. A motion to
reconsider is laid on the table. Staff is authorized to make technical and conforming
changes to the matters considered by the committee in this markup. Members will have the customary
two days in which to submit additional views. There being no further business, I want to
thank you all for participating with that. And with that, the committee stands adjourned.
