You're watching a feedback session for the Spungella Animation Workshop. Topics that are covered: body mechanics, maya animation.
What experience do I offer? ✔️ Animation Supervisor at Warner Brothers Animation / formerly ILM (17+ years) ✔️ Teacher at Animation Mentor/Academy of Art University/my workshops (15 years) ► IMDB: https://www.imdb.com/name/nm1940902/
Need tips and help with your animation at an affordable price? ► Sign up for my Spungella Animation Workshop! $499! No minimum level requirements! From beginner animation up to advanced acting pieces!
You get unlimited planning discussions and 16 video reviews, which can be weekly or every other week or whenever you want/can submit, they never expire! Example reviews are available here on my channel.
All right, let's play the whole thing here. There's no sound, but you got a bar-bar-bar,
we got a guitar, and yeah, it's very cool. I think this is a great solution. It looks cool,
you definitely understand this, and then we got the end. I think what I would do,
there's something, not that we're, you know, everything is clear. To me, everything works,
and it's clear. I think the major mechanics, they work pretty well. I'm just looking at the root,
I remember the root having some issues. Just be careful, you have a pretty fast move through here
with that push-off, and then on top of that, we have one through with this leg, but then the
spacing gets suddenly a lot slower right through there, where I feel like it would still have that
momentum, and I would just probably just go backwards and then have her more, if you want to
fix that, go backwards from that and imagine that if she would have wider spacing and go a bit further
by going backwards with it, she would land maybe through here, just globally bring everything back
so that she would probably start, you know, here-ish instead of here. There's just a little
it's not huge. I think it works. It would be like a slight polish, I think, to try out how it feels,
but at the same time, there's also the feeling of, you know, there's weight, so it accelerates a bit,
and then here it's a bit more controlled. It's just, to me, it's very subtle. It has a slight
hint of, but then not really. Like, she goes down to really push off, and just visually,
it's there with that straight line, but then feeling-wise, it's just a bit of a,
that's the only thing there. That's a technical term for, she doesn't go as high and far
through that, but I don't see any major hiccups, anything crazy, even through there. She's done with
this. You might argue that on a turn like this, turning here and a slide through there, she
wouldn't have that much power to push herself up like that, so there could be a frame or two added
where she stabilizes that leg a bit more, and then shoots up. It's all pretty fast, so it's
not crazy. This is, to me, something that I would tweak and polish, and kind of do an A-B test to
see how it feels, and then the only thing out of everything I said that I would still tweak,
so out of everything, this is the note that would actually address. The rest is really just
optional, is that if you look at her route, I'm going to go through, sorry, that doesn't quite
look very appropriate what I'm doing here. I'm tracking like that, but I'm in a bit too high,
but anyway, let's put this on both of them. There you go, so you can see how she shoots up,
and then it's flat, so that I would still tweak to have more of an arc into this. It feels like
and because of this, because you're suddenly flattening, the couple things that play here,
you have all that momentum, but then this kind of just floats and feels light,
while those massive legs are shooting up, and then that's it. They also just suddenly stop.
Spacing-wise, you know, you have this, and then it just kind of stays there instead of
overshooting a bit, and then coming back. Not that it has to be like a, but still a bit looser. I
where you have this, and the next frame is pretty much the same in terms of height.
You have a bit of a sticky frame in the head. You can see how that head spacing goes to the left,
and then we suddenly stick into the space. So to me, having that up and down versus this is going
to help the head spacing. I would kind of loosen up and stiffen that up a bit more, as in loosening
up where you would have this, and maybe the leg would be a bit lower, the thigh. Then on this,
it would be here, and then one more a bit higher, and then you can come back into the stiffness,
because at the very end, there's a slight feel of this, and this, and the thigh. It's not a
huge difference, but the lower part, the shin area, just moves a lot more. Compared to this,
this feels a bit more with more weight, because you got all of this moving, even though the leg,
upper leg stops at this point, the rest continues, and because of that, it still pulls the upper leg,
the thigh area, just a bit higher, just a bit more. And then careful, this to me, even though
there's a good drag and slight rotation still happening, it just starts to have a slight feel
of a 2D card, those kind of drops. So to me, it would be something where we do this with a slight
overshoot, just a bit, and then through that drop, either you start doing a slight... I don't know if
there's enough time, I would again experiment with bringing that leg down a little bit, and then maybe
up again, just giving some life to it, so it doesn't feel like a cutout. It just feels suddenly
very light and 2D cardboard for that moment. This might just be me, but you got an impact,
you got a compression through there, that's all cool. Now, if this is where she hits and then
compresses, I would have that already go down. The momentum of the legs will continue on that
frame. This is a weird compression in here, but this doesn't follow through with the downwards
motion and momentum on that one frame, you're one frame late. And then after that, I think it's okay,
it's a bit, again, we're very twins. Hits at a different time, which is good, but then it goes
down at the same time. I would again, in terms of polish, really experiment with what if I really
offset those legs, and maybe have, you know, maybe push that ending a bit more, or maybe one leg,
only one leg goes down, and she really tries to be all cool, and she tries to keep one leg, just kind
of pushing that style just a bit more. Because this is cool, love all this, and then suddenly
it gets a bit simple through there, and then, and then it's a bit, then it's almost a bit too simple.
Legs up and down, and that's it, versus this is her character, right? Oh yeah, I'm all cool,
look at the guitar. Can you put this personality in here with that ending? Not saying that this shot
dies at the end completely, you gotta throw it away. I'm just throwing it out there,
is there something fun you can do, since this is so cool, that would make it into this ending where,
not that she brings up the guitar again, but she could do something to her arms,
or she keeps her, again, one leg up, you know, one leg only, I don't know, something to do,
to think about there. And I think that's kind of that, because you have all the
extra life in this prop, let's see, boing, yeah, that's all cool, it's mainly that.
So to me, it's kind of the polishy things to kind of watch out for, the main thing I would do is
the arc on the root, and then kind of switching up something in those legs there, and then you
could technically keep it, even if you want to do like a cliche at the very end, the last button is
her arm, and she gives a thumbs up, or the middle finger, whatever you want to do, that could be a
personality thing, but yeah, food for thought, and I'll leave it at that. All right, thanks.