What is the best Insulation? (Part 1)

Aarow Building
57 followers
10 Video Views·Dec 7, 2022
I'm Jake Bruton with Arrow Building in Columbia, Missouri, and today we're at our Spring Valley
project, and we're going to be having a conversation that I have all the time with clients,
and that conversation is, what is the best insulation? And I think after you watch this
video, you'll understand that that's not an easy answer, or that's not an easy question to answer,
but today we're going to talk to Steve Reamer of G5 Enterprises,
and let's get our conversation started. This is going to be interesting.
Good morning. Hey, good morning, Jake. Okay, so you're with G5 Enterprises. Yes, sir. And G5,
for us here in Columbia, is represented by baller insulation. Correct. In other parts of the state,
it's other things like InsulUSA, is that correct? Correct. Okay. Basically, we've got 13
branches. Most of them are based in Missouri, but we expand into Kansas, Oklahoma,
down into Arkansas. We've got Arkansas insulation that is in Springdale, Rogers,
another one in Harrison, and we've got locations all over Missouri, Joplin, Kansas City, and Nixa,
where our corporate is. So you guys cover a large market, and you're a fairly decent-sized company.
Oh, yes. And you've been in the insulation business for how long? I installed my first
VAT in 1977, so a while. So Steve's been around insulation for a while, and that's actually where
we'll start in just a second, is with VATs, too, because it's funny that you said it like that.
We wanted to talk just real quick. The idea behind this is, what is the best insulation
is not an easily answered question. The answer to that is, it depends. It depends on what you
have to accomplish, absolutely, and your budget. Yep. And so we'll talk about both from a budget
standpoint and from a utility for, like, this project, because we're here on the Spring Valley
project. Let's just start with Stiebrick and Building Science Corporation's rule for a net
zero house, or for the point of, sorry, how am I trying to say this, the point where things become
less a return on investment. Certainly. You know, the point where you should stop putting more
insulation in and focus on other things. Right. And that rule is 10, 20, 40, 60, and 5. And that's 10
underneath your slab, which is what we have here, 20 on any foundation walls, 40 on any walls above
grade, 60 in the attic, and then windows or doors that are at least an R5. And so here we're 10
under our feet. We don't have any below grade walls. We have a combination of things that we'll discuss
in a minute about what's happening in our wall. And this is roughly an R42. We went to an R70 in
the attic, and we'll talk about why we went above that 60 point. And then we're at R9 or R7 to R9
glass, depending on function of the unit. So we're really adhering to that paper from Steve Brick
and that idea that Building Science Corporation puts forward. And that's also a product of
Steve Basic, our architect, used to work for Building Science Corporation and now adheres to
some of those same philosophies because those philosophies we think are true. Okay. So the
conversation about insulation, after we know what our proportions might be for something like this,
yes, we can talk about code, which in our market, Climate Zone 4 is an R19
for walls, and I believe an R40? No, it's R38. No, you may be 40 here. And so there's different
ways to get to there. The code doesn't read, put this kind of insulation in. The code reads,
put this much R value in. And so the conversation should start with R value once we have that
beginning out of the way. So talk to us a little bit about what R value means and how that applies
to the things that we're going to talk about. Well, basically, R value is the effective way
that insulation stops heat flow through it. It's a resistance factor is how they name it. So
basically, it's set up in a plexiglass box with a light bulb underneath it,
and they transfer heat through it. And that's how you tell what the R factor is of a product.
There are people that are trying to work on a different factor
to come up with something that's more real world, you might say, because just the fact that it
stops heat moving through it in a encased box isn't real world. We've all got air movement outside,
you know, air movement inside a wall cavity, so that will reduce the R factor. We may have
soffit eaves that are letting things rush in through our assembly. Exactly. And inside a
wall, you've got, you know, air that's cold, that's dropping, and then it's rising on the
inside where you're closer to the drywall. So when it starts looping like that, it will reduce the R
factor in products that are fibrous that you can move air through. But they're all
good products. It just depends on what you have backing them up and the whole system that they're
built into. But that's basically what an R factor is, is the effective way that it can resist heat
transfer. And that's literally what the R in R value stands for. It's just its ability to resist
the movement of heat through it. So we have laid out in front of us here, and we'll just go through
them like one by one. We're not promoting one thing over the other. We'll talk a little pro
and con about each one. We may talk about environmental impact on some of this stuff.
But we're just going to pick and choose, and we'll just start with the one thing that you mentioned
already. And that would be bat insulation. You said 1978? Is that what you said? 76? 77. Okay.
So this product is a fiberglass bat. A lot of it is pink. A lot of it is yellow. Those colors don't
mean anything other than marking, right? It's the manufacturer. That's their mark. And so I grew up
with the Pink Panther and with Owens Corning Pink. And so it's one of those things that when I think
fiberglass, I think pink. I don't think of anything else. You can get this faced with a
vapor retarder on it. And you can get it unfaced. You can get fiberglass in anything from a 2x4
cavity to your attic space. And you can get it from R13 all the way to 38. Have you ever seen
higher than 38? We have installed some R49 bats. Okay. So you see there's a wide versatility with
this product. Talk to me about grading of insulation, Steve. The install. The install? Yeah.
Okay. Typically, HRS radars in a lot of locations, they are required to inspect housing after
the insulation is done. Grade one basically is no compressions, no gaps. All your cuts have to
be perfect around all of the outlets. It's difficult to do with a fiberglass bat, but it's possible.
It takes a lot of additional labor to make sure that you have good cuts, that you separate,
either separate the bat and tuck it behind your wiring or make a cut across it and try and get
that back together. It just, that's one of the products that it's difficult to get a grade one
without spending a lot of labor time, which, yeah, insulation is one of those budget items
that people have to build around. And so if we spend a lot of labor time making it perfect,
it begins to push it into another layer of insulation that we can do that is easier to do
than make all the cuts in the fiberglass. We might be able to spend more money on a different product
and get the same quality of insulation by spending less on labor. Correct. And so the system for
fiberglass is grade one, grade two, grade three. Grade one is a perfect install. Like you were
saying, everything's cut around, cut and fit tightly. It's, the bat is allowed to decompress
and expand because the R value rating that you're getting is not an R value when it's mashed down.
It's at the full depth of the cavity or the full depth of the intended depth of the product.
Basically what's doing the insulating is the amount of air that this bat can hold. The void.
Right. The void that doesn't seem like it's there. So if it's compressed, there's not much air at my
fingers. Yeah. When it's like that, it can hold a lot of air and that's what does the insulation.
You know, when, when a guy installs a bat in a wall and he pushes it down the sides
and compresses those edges, that's what they're talking about on compression,
that they don't want to see that. So, you know, all the bats have to be completely
out. A lot of times they face staple that product in. So the tabs are outside so that it can have
its full compression or its full expansion. So I was talking to one of the R&D guys that owns
Corning a few years ago at a conference. And one of the things that he said to me was, you know,
if you, if you think about where you cut around every single box, you know, there's 30 outlets
in that wall and there's 15 switches. And if any of them, if I can put my thumb in
without touching fiberglass, I've compromised 12 inches, a radius around my thumb of 12 inches.
So that, that to me says, while we talk about ease of installation, it comes in a bat,
you can fluff it and stick it in the wall and it's done. It also means that it's a complicated
product to get right. Correct. Or, or more complicated than some probably to get right.
Certainly more labor intensive. Okay. And so this is, this is like our first step. This is the first
installation that I installed as well. If we go from there, the next step up, let's go to bat.
So even though there's a couple other products here, let's talk about another version of bat.
And this happens to be what? This is a rock wool or a thermal fiber bat that is basically where
your fiberglass bat is sand or melted, you know, melted sand, melted glass that's spun out. This
is just made out of slag rock, a little heavier duty rock. It has a higher melting temperature.
So they use this product a lot more so in fire safing than they do, you know, just from a thermal
standpoint. Because it's made of rocks, we don't have to worry about it catching fire. Correct.
Correct. Well, you don't have to worry about fiberglass catching fire either. It will melt
sooner than this will, but this is a, this is a heavy bat. I mean, you can tell the difference
just in the weight of this, you know, little over square foot section that we've got here.
And so when we're still talking about bats, I raised this one up because I wanted to have the
moisture conversation and the fire conversation too. Okay. That when we're talking about moisture
in the wall, we're not talking about bulk water. Nothing we're going to talk about here is going
to perform greatly if you have water running down the inside of your wall. Right. We're talking
about incidental moisture that is small amounts carried by air or occasional seasonal wetting,
you know, due to condensation. So when we're talking about that and we're talking to bats
first, this guy is not going to be bothered by water or fire because it's made of rocks, right?
This guy is going to be pretty darn resistant to water, but it's not designed to be underwater.
Like we just said, it's not bulk water. Right. After we talk about bats, we go to a blown in
product and let's, let's note those. And then we'll talk about their ability to control moisture.
Okay. So first, first we have fiberglass. So this is, this is the same product as that,
is that correct? This is a, yeah, this is a InsulSafe. It's basically, this is what they
call a virgin wool. It doesn't have any binder in it, which the binder is what makes this bat
stay together. So you can take this and rub it on your face, rub it on your hands. It's not going
to itch like your standard fiberglass does. This is specifically made for blown in insulation.
You can tell the difference in the fibers of it that it doesn't have any, it doesn't have any
binder. It almost breaks apart on purpose. Right, right, right. So it, it doesn't have
the binder that this product is, so it's easily blown. And so this comes in a bag,
they dump it in the, in our market. Right. Bolivar dumps it into a hopper in a truck
and then they run pipe into the house like an enormous garden hose. Right. And somebody sprays
this either in a netted wall, a netted ceiling or in the attic. Correct. Okay. And so its ability
to deal with moisture is exactly the same basically as fiberglass. Right, right. It can be
blown in the walls and in, you know, ceilings, netted ceilings, tighter than this to where it
will have a greater density than this, so it will. So that thumb around the outlet problem
is not going to exist with the blown in product. Right, right, because it can just be blown tighter
up against all of the outlets. It, you know, it is, you're using more product, so you're,
you know, naturally you're spending more money on that, but it is a good product like that.
It's still a fibrous product. The air infiltration rate would be less on that
than what the fiberglass would, so you're beginning to get to a point where you're stopping
more air through it. Okay. You know, than what you can with a fiberglass bag. And air can move
pretty freely through this. Absolutely. It's surprisingly the amount, you know, we've done
a demo where there's dirt on the inside of the vat where there's been a, you know, a split in the
vat and air is just traveling through. Correct. And carrying all kinds of stuff. Yeah, if you do many
demos, you look around the perimeter of those vats and they're dirty. They're just brown. Yeah. And
that's from the dirt that's coming in around it. So it's a great filter, but it is a filter. But I,
like I said, in its correct condition, it works. It does prevent, you know, does prevent heat flow.
Yeah. Don't take any of the negativity that we might add or attach to any of these to be not
a recommendation. They all have their place. So next, you can even see the dust come off of that
one. This is a product called Cellulose. And it looks to me like that's newspaper. Is that correct?
Yes, it is. Okay. And so in our market, Cellulose and blown fiberglass are probably interchangeable.
We're going to use them in all the same spots, right? They are. You know, you can use Cellulose
to dense pack a wall just the same way that you would with this fiberglass. Loose fill,
blow it in an attic. There is little difference in R factor between them and, you know, in those
attic situations. You do have to blow more inches of fiberglass than you do of Cellulose to get up
your R38 or R40. But in an attic, you've got, you know, limited inches. I mean, unlimited inches.
Yeah. So you're not constrained by the space of the wall cavity, say, in an attic. So you can just
dump as much in as you want. Correct. Correct. When you start dense packing both of these materials,
you end up with an R factor that's within two or three of each other.
Okay. So they're pretty comparable across the board. This product being, they call it Cellulose,
if you remember from like high school science class, the trees are made of cell, plants are
made of Cellulose. And so this in the past has been made from sawdust. It's been made from all
sorts of things that were always started as a plant. They always have been organic. They've
always started as a plant. So my question is, this is recycled content, but if this is just
recycled newspaper and we use it in our wall and we have a little bit of incidental moisture like
we're just talking about, why doesn't this just turn to mold? Why doesn't it just rot?
It has chemical in it, so it won't. Okay. But it also, once it gets wet and the air holding
capacity changes, I don't want to say paper mache. I did say paper mache. You kind of end up with
that. Yeah. You know, it fills in those air holes when you take wet newspaper and compress it.
It doesn't have as much capacity to hold air anymore and do the insulating that you need it
to do. Okay. So while it's recycled content, they're also stuffing it full of chemicals and
borate specifically, right? To keep it from molding or mildewing, which it's a nerve once
it's in the wall and you're not touching it and you're not consuming it, it's not going to bother
you at all. Right. You know, most of these have some downside for the stuff that they have.
We all want to believe that our walls are going to be dry and that we have little moisture that
goes through them. It's not cellulose's fault that we get moisture inside the wall. It's what
we've done to control the moisture to it. But if that happens, then it becomes a material that's
really difficult to deal with. They have to get that out. And they can blow that wet and they can
blow that dry. What's the benefit of blowing it wet? The benefit of blowing it wet is you don't
have to put up a net. Okay. So I can come in today. You can come in straight in place right
there. You know, so it will stick in place until you hang your drywall. One key factor that you
need to pay close attention to is that you make sure that that material dries down to
a certain percentage before you start covering it up. Okay. So we're monitoring it. Yeah. You
know, to make sure that you're, that the moisture content is low enough to cover it up and,
and lock it in the wall. So then from a production builder standpoint, maybe the thing to do is net
and blow it dry. That way you can have crackers the next day, hanging things. Right. And that's
one of those, I'm always thinking about what is the production schedule look like? So after we
talk about bats and we talk about blown in, Oh, by the way, you can also get a mineral roll or
rock wool in a blown form. We just don't have anybody or yeah, a blown in place. Right. It's
a little more difficult on the machines. It wears and tears and on the person that's blowing it.
But again, you get the benefits of those two blown in place products in mixed with it's rocks. It's
not going to catch on fire. No moisture is going to bother. It's a little harder to come by. So
we don't have any of it here. So after we talk about bats and blown in, we start talking about
sheet goods. And there are multiple different kinds. I would say that also there is a mineral
wool product that comes in large sheets that you see a lot for exterior application that we don't
have here as well. And again, it's rocks. So it's not going to be bothered for being outside. So
we have three different kinds of board insulation here. We have poly ISO, XPS and EPS. Run me
through a little bit of what the difference in these products is. Basically, it's the chemical
makeup of them. Poly ISO would have the highest R factor of these. It needs to have this product
in place on it, the sheathing on each side of the skin on it. Yep. So it doesn't start to,
you know, decompose. But this is a, you know, it's a great product. Typically used above grade.
You can't get moisture inside that.
It starts to lose R value and integrity when you get it below grade and when you get it wet. So
now, I mean, there are people that are using this product below grade inside homes, you know,
on the inside of the elevation walls. And it's a good product for that, but it does have a good
high R factor. And this is like a R six and a half per inch. Correct. So this is like an R 13
and two inches here. Right. And then the XPS. XPS is just extruded polystyrene. These two are
closer in families together. This has an R five per inch used. Typically, it has a lot more
compressive strength than what this product does. So from a, you know, putting it on the exterior
of a foundation and then backfilling against it, it will withstand that where the product
wouldn't do that. This is approved for below grade. Correct. Okay. Correct. Basically, your
expanded is basically what you consider for your coolers. Yeah. I mean,
call it bead board. Yeah. It's just, you know, it's a lot of little beads of expanded
polystyrene there. Less R factor, not as not as conducive to, you know, compressive strength
on it. It will, you know, it will dent. So it's not like this product, but it's a, you know,
as far as exterior use below grade I don't see many guys use it on exteriors. They put it under
slabs like that. And so when you talk about all three of these products, these are all petroleum
based. They're all in that family. And it's my understanding that the poly ISO is probably
considered the most eco-friendly from a blowing agent standpoint. So in their manufacturing
process, they aerate the product, they shove air into it, just like we were talking about with the
other things. But they do that by introducing a blowing agent in the manufacturing process.
And while these two are on their way to being way more eco-friendly in the United States,
they're not yet. And the poly ISO is probably the best from an environmental impacts.
We've used the EPS and the EPS is an interesting conversation because you say it dimples,
but at the same time we can order different kinds of EPS that have different compaction
densities. Yeah. So this is actually a type nine. It's a 20 PSI, which, you know,
if you extrapolate that out, that's more weight than any house is going to have on it
per square foot. The interesting thing about this, the type nine specifically, it's what they put
under heated runways. And if you've ever seen them building up on ramps to build a ramp across
the highway, that's what they use as backfill because they can get a lot of space with high
compression quickly, cover it with dirt. They know this isn't going to biodegrade being underground.
And they're able to really use this in a lot of interesting ways that when I cut it and it
comes apart like a broken up coffee cup that I used to play with at the baseball field or the
softball field when my sister played softball. It's weird to think that that move has gone that far.
So these sheet goods, mostly in our market, you're going to see them inside. There is some
ability to do exterior foam. And we'll talk about exterior at the very end. We'll talk
here about what we have here. And so after we talk about these, we're on to spray foams.
And so again, there's an environmental conversation that everything on this half of the table is
probably not as good for the environment just from a manufacturing standpoint. There's an
argument to be made one way or the other in the long term of, well, if this house uses a lot less
energy, maybe that's better for the environment. So we could go back and forth on that. But
when we're talking about spray foam, the interesting thing that I think is really
interesting about spray foam, this is a product that's manufactured here. Not here in the state
of Missouri. I mean here. Manufactured on site. It's manufactured on site. The rest of these are
all taken care of and shipped to us and all we have to do is install them properly. These come
in chemical form and we have to mix it and put it on the wall. Now the gun sprays it out, right?
Do you want to talk to us about the process for spray foam? Sure. I'm going to cut in right here
and say that the conversation with our insulator was so good and the content was so great. This
video is actually only about halfway over. So what we're going to do is we're actually going to just
pick a point and splice here and next week will be part two. So thanks for watching. Stay tuned
for next week for part two.
