Was He Louis XVII ? - Karl Wilhelm Naundorff, date of birth unknown, date of death on August 10, 1845 in Delft, The Netherlands, was a Prussian Clockmaker who became famous for pretending to be the former Dauphin Louis Charles, also known as Louis XVII.
From 1810 to 1845, Naundorff tried in vain to be recognized by the French royals as the son of Louis XVI and Marie-Antoinette. He formed a court, appointed aides-de-camp, orderly officers, a ministry, etc.
Banished from France by Louis-Philippe I, Naundorff first found refuge in England, then in Holland, where he developed the “Bourbon bomb” and became director of the pyrotechnics workshops in Delft.
DNA Evidence in recent years has conclusively shown that Naundorff was not related to either Louis XVI or Marie Antoinette.
Music from https://musopen.org/: G.F. Handel - Concerto Grosso in b minor op 6_12 This work has been identified as being free of known restrictions under copyright law, including all related and neighboring rights.
Karl Wilhelm Naumdorf, whose date of birth is unknown, was a Prussian clockmaker who became
famous for pretending to be the Dauphin Louis Charles, also known as Louis XVII.
Naumdorf, who was known in France as Charles-Guillaume Naumdorf, appeared in Berlin at
the end of 1810, where he lived a quiet life, working as a clockmaker to earn a living.
For an unknown reason he was summoned to the police headquarters to be interrogated.
During interrogations Naumdorf stated that he was born in Weimar and that he was 43 years old,
but Naumdorf only had the appearance of a young man about 25 years old.
He was questioned further by suspicious police officers and at this point Naumdorf declared for
the first time that he was Louis XVII, the son of Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette.
Naumdorf claimed to have escaped from the Tour du Temple in 1795 and that he was now
seeking protection from the Napoleonic troops. After the French troops retreated, Naumdorf wrote
to the king of Prussia and the emperors of Austria and Russia to lay down his claim to the crown of
France, but he was never answered. So Naumdorf sent a letter to Marie-Thérèse of France,
the only surviving child of Louis XVI, but once again Naumdorf did not receive an answer.
After a while Naumdorf again wrote to Madame Royale and to Charles Ferdinand d'Artois,
Duke of Berry, his so-called cousin and son of Charles X, and stated in his letter that he did
not want to lay any claims to the throne, but simply wanted his name and his title to be
returned to him. On November 19, 1818, Naumdorf married Johanna Frederike Einert, also known in
France as Jeanne Frédérique Einert. The couple lived in Spandau until 1822, where Naumdorf lost
all of his possessions during a fire. The authorities accused him of having started the fire
himself. Furthermore, he was accused of taking part in counterfeit activities, for which he was
sentenced to a prison sentence of three years. Naumdorf was released from prison in 1828 and
moved to Krossen, a small town on the border with Cilicia, where he managed to convince more people
that he was Louis XVII. The king of Prussia, who was not at all convinced by Naumdorf's claims,
decided to have him arrested. Naumdorf was tipped off about the upcoming arrest and fled,
abandoning his wife and children. Via Switzerland, he arrived in Paris on May 26, 1833. He soon
obtained a group of supporters, who formed the semblance of a court around him. A meeting was
arranged with Madame Agathe de Rambeau, the official nurse of the children of Louis XVI
and Marie-Antoinette. De Rambeau was convinced Naumdorf was indeed Louis XVII.
Other previous courtiers also claimed to recognize Louis XVII in Naumdorf, in particular
the husband of Madame de Rambeau, the marquise de Brolio-Solari, Etienne de Jolie, and the
former secretary of Louis XVI, Monsieur Bremeau. In his book about Madame Vigée-Lebrun, the author
mentions that Naumdorf may have been a servant to Madame Vigée-Lebrun.
From Elisabeth Vigée-Lebrun, having been the painter from Marie-Antoinette until 1789,
Naumdorf could have learned a great deal about the royal family. On June 12, 1836,
Naumdorf launched summons claiming his part of the inheritance to Charles X and the Duchess of
Angoulême. Although Naumdorf had been tolerated in Paris until then, the prospect of a lawsuit
against the deposed King Charles X and the daughter of Louis XVI caused a huge scandal.
The French government decided that they had had enough and Naumdorf was arrested.
On June 15, 1836, Naumdorf was thrown into prison and the police confiscated 202 documents
in the possession of Naumdorf that so-called proved he was Louis XVII.
After 26 days in prison, Naumdorf was deported to England. After his deportation,
Naumdorf tried to earn a living as a preacher and as an explosives researcher. In London,
his activities became increasingly eccentric, with one of his ventures aimed at founding a
movement based on his mystical experiences. Naumdorf pretended to be a messiah.
Later, he tried to design a perfect detonation mechanism called the Bourbon Bomb. His discovery
failed and his house burned down, with Naumdorf suffering severe burns. Because of all these
failures, he ran out of money and in 1843 he was put in prison by his creditors.
The Dutch Ministry of War showed interest in the Bourbon Bomb and bought it from Naumdorf.
He was also invited to continue his research in the Netherlands.
After serving his prison sentence, Naumdorf left for the Netherlands in January 1845,
where he was appointed director of the pyrotechnic atelier in Delft by Wilhelm II.
However, Naumdorf died in August of that year. He was buried in the General Cemetery
Calverbos in Delft. His grave is not marked with his name Karel Wilhelm Naumdorf,
but has a marking in French. Here rests Charles-Louis de Bourbon, Duke of Normandy,
Louis XVII. Naumdorf's grave can still be visited. Naumdorf's claims have been the subject of much
historical and scientific controversy. The descendants of Naumdorf still have a number
of supporters, nicknamed Naumdorfists, and bear the surname de Bourbon, the use of which was granted
to them by the Netherlands. In 1943, a sample of Naumdorf's hair was compared to a lock of the
Dauphin's hair. At the time, it was concluded that the two samples have the same peculiar
medullary canal, an argument which prompted many of the Naumdorf supporters to feel strengthened
in their belief that Naumdorf was indeed Louis XVII. However, a second test in 1951 made
scientists reconsider their first results, and their conclusions were revised. The peculiarity
on the hair affected one in three persons, and the similarity was therefore considered to be
a coincidence. In 1998, DNA analysis was carried out. After a study of Naumdorf's mitochondrial DNA
and his right humerus taken from his grave in 1950, and a comparison to the mitochondrial DNA
from the hair of descendants in the maternal line of Maria Theresia of Austria, the conclusion was
drawn that Naumdorf was not Louis XVII. In 1999, the heart which was taken in 1795 by Pelletin
after the autopsy of Louis XVII, and which is preserved in the crypt of the Basilica de Saint-Denis
in Paris, was subjected to DNA analysis by the same scientific team. On April 19, 2000, during a
press conference, the science team declared that the comparison of the DNA shows beyond a reasonable
doubt that the heart kept in the crypt came from a child who was connected in the maternal line
to the house of Habsburg. For more information about Louis XVII or Pelletin who removed the
boy's heart, please click on the link you see in your upper right corner. The DNA analysis of the
heart of the child who died at the Tour du Temple is disputed by Naumdorfists, as they claim that it
could have belonged to the older brother of Louis XVII, Louis-Joseph I of Fins, who died of illness
at the age of eight in 1789. However, the heart of Louis-Joseph was embalmed according to royal
tradition, while that of Louis XVII was preserved in alcohol, which immediately makes any mix-up
impossible. Furthermore, the heart of Louis-Joseph was lost after the revolution and thus it is very
unlikely that the heart preserved in the royal crypt of the Basilica of Saint-Denis is the heart
of Marie Antoinette's eldest son. In 2004, a contradictory analysis was commissioned by the
descendants of Carl Wilhelm Naumdorf. Naumdorf was exhumed again and analysis was performed directly
on Naumdorf's skeleton. However, the Bourbon-Naumdorf family never published the results of these tests.
This concludes today's video about Carl Wilhelm Naumdorf.
I hope to see you next week for a new video. Thanks for watching!