2022 Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro vs Nissan Frontier PRO-4X vs Rocks, Water & Mud - Which Truck is Best?

Family Auto
135 followers
42 Video Views·Dec 4, 2022
Hey folks, welcome to the Truck King YouTube channel and rematch day. Once again, we have
the Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro facing off against the Nissan Frontier Pro 4X and we're going off-road.
In this video, we're at a brand new off-road park, so we have a whole bunch of new obstacles
to explore. Make sure you stay tuned. This is a rematch of a video we made last year. We took
a Tacoma TRD Pro and a Frontier Pro 4X to our Ironwood test facility and we had them battle
it out. Now, spoiler alert, I'll just let you know, the Tacoma did come out on top. So why are
we redoing this? Well, a couple of reasons. The biggest one is because the trucks aren't the same.
Now it's 2022 and we have the Nissan Frontier Pro 4X King Cab, that is a Canada-only model,
and over there, the TRD Pro, it has new tires, it has updated suspension, and it has a higher
price tag now for 2022. So on my right, the Toyota Tacoma, it uses a three and a half liter
naturally aspirated V6. This engine is making 278 horsepower, 265 pound-feet of torque, and it is
sent through a six-speed automatic. On the flip side, we have the Frontier, very similar strategy,
also a naturally aspirated V6, but that's a 3.8 liter and it's making 310 horsepower,
281 pound-feet of torque, and that is sent through a nine-speed automatic. And yes,
the Frontier does make the most power in the midsize segment, plus it's sent through more
gears. So we will let you know the differences in the powertrains once we get out there.
Now let's talk about the off-road packages before we get out there. And if you go for Pro 4X or TRD
Pro, well, they're pretty similar upgrades. You're getting all-terrain tires, you're getting a rear
locking differential, you're getting a unique set of shocks, Fox shocks on the Toyota,
Bilstein shocks on the Frontier, and then you're also getting skid plates underneath.
And now we can take a look underneath the trucks, thanks to our truck ramp. So first of all,
here on the Tacoma, I want to show you these exposed tow hooks right here. They're a little
bit low underneath the bumper, but it is nice that there are some decent tow hooks. There's
also one on this side kind of tucked up under the skid plate. Now, yeah, that's a nice beefy steel
skid plate, and it's big. It really extends well beyond that front differential. Now up here,
of course, you have your unique suspension setup. That's a beefy control arm right there and those
Fox shocks. Now, as we move back, I'm actually a little surprised by the lack of protection here
in the middle of the truck. The transfer case is tucked up nicely up there, but this piece of
exhaust right here is quite exposed. Actually, it hangs lower than this steel frame rail,
so this might end up getting beat on a little bit. In fact, it looks like it already might
have taken a hit or two. Now, as we roll to the back, you do get a plastic skid plate there on
your fuel tank, and you'll also notice your other Fox shocks. Those are Fox shocks with remote
reservoirs at the rear end. They look nice and big. Oh yeah, and of course, you can't forget
to mention with the Tacoma, those are rear drum brakes. This truck still has rear drums in the
back, unlike the Frontier over there, which has discs. Now we'll put the Nissan up and we'll see
what it looks like underneath, and now it is Frontier time. So looking here in the front end,
you also do get some nice big exposed tow hooks. I think they're actually a little easier to get
to here on the Frontier than they are in the Tacoma. Now, first up, you do get a nice skid
plate. Immediately behind that, another steel skid plate, and that continues back until this
area, but then here in the midsection, also another nice steel skid plate there on your transfer case,
and guys, here's a big deal. That is a steel skid plate for the gas tank. Even on the F-150
Tremor and the Raptor, this is a plastic skid plate, so it's nice that Nissan actually takes
their armoring seriously, and you get a steel plate for your fuel tank. Now when it comes to
suspension, you can see the set of Bilstein shock absorbers right back there, and besides that,
this is pretty much standard Nissan Frontier under here. You can also see the Bilsteins up front here.
So yeah, I think the Tacoma obviously has more done to the suspension, but when it comes to
overall armoring underneath, I want to give this one to the Frontier. I also have to quickly nitpick
something else on the Nissan. The amount of rust on a lot of these components, and keep in mind,
this is a brand new truck, and yeah, there's already quite a bit of rust underneath of it.
Now, we do see rust on just about every truck we put up here, but this one stands out to me as being
a little bit more than normal. The other thing that really jumps out when you look at the spec
sheet here, these trucks are very similar when it comes to sizing. The wheelbase is within an inch,
overall length is within two inches of each other, so they really are just about the same. Now when
it comes to off-roading, ground clearance is listed at 9.4 inches for both trucks, so that's the same,
but the Tacoma gets better angles, and that has actually been improved for 2022. So approach
angle over there on the Tacoma, 36.4 degrees versus just 32 degrees on the Frontier. Breakover
on Tacoma, 26.6 versus 19.6 on the Frontier, and then departure on the Tacoma, 24.7 versus just
23.3 on the Nissan. So on paper, Tacoma has an edge, but there's a penalty for that, and that
is the price. It's even more expensive for 2022. That truck as it sits is $61,000 here in Canada.
On the flip side, if you go for the King Cab model of the Pro 4X, well you're going to save money.
That thing starts at just about $47,000 here in Canada. So we're going into this knowing that
you're paying over 10 grand more for the Toyota. So now the question is, sure maybe it's a bit
better, but is it really worth the price difference? Well that's what we're going to look to solve
right now. And here we are folks. Welcome to the Minden Off-Road Park. Now of course we still have
all our trails on Ironwood, but we like to switch it up too and try something new. So this is local
to us. It was about a 40 minute drive, and we want to give something different a shot. And see like
these are just these big massive exposed rocks in the center of the trail. And dad's in the Nissan
behind me. And there goes Steve climbing a stump. Well that was cute. Okay well that's rugged man,
rugged. Okay so great trails. The only complaint I have so far is that the guy left all the stumps
behind. So and then as the dirt washes away, and as vehicles crawl around, and they continually
seem to get taller. So anyway it's a little bit of fun here trying to get around some of this crap.
So plus we've had two days of rain, so there's a bit of slop here. Oh man here go the hills. Here
comes the hills. A little wicked S-turn up the hill here. Okay friggin trees. So at the moment
we're just running four high. I haven't used the locker yet. I like to save that for when I'm
in trouble. So we'll see how this goes. I've been clearing all the rocks so far. You've kissed any
skid plates or good clearance? Oh you've been running over sections. Yeah I don't know what
you're talking about. The Tacoma is eating the stumps for breakfast. No you left the stump behind,
but like we're going to call you stump jumper. That's a tricky one. You don't want to slide down
that hill into the tree. Yeah talk about harsh angle. Wow. And I hate to tell you, but this
frontier does not corner as well as that Tacoma. Yeah I can see it coming through there. Actually
you just sort of slid your front end over on the mud and it helped you rotate around the corner.
Yeah no doubt the frontier does not have the maneuverability and these are tight trails out
here so you notice it. You're doing three point turns where I don't have to. Get in here I'll give
you that. Yeah it's beautiful scenery and I love these big exposed rocks. This is one of the cool
things we have in Ontario right? All these exposed rocks out in the middle of the bush.
It feels like you're in Moab when you're still surrounded by bush and bugs. Well and for those
who don't know what we're talking about is this is what's called the Canadian Shield
and it's all exposed rock due to all the glacial ice ages that basically scoured all the dirt off
of the top of these rocks. So we're looking at what was here at the beginning of time.
All right that's a problem rock right there let's see what the Tacoma does.
Oh he just cleared it nice. Now another thing that Tacoma has I'll get a shot of it here
these front facing cameras so when you hit your view button down on the side beside the wheel
you actually get this front view as well which honestly I have used a few times because you can
see the rocks there on the trail so you can get a sense for where your wheels are going to be
next to the rocks and then I can also hit it again and get the side view where I'm looking
right down at my wheels. I think that's a really valuable view especially on trails like this
and it should be noted still in just four high but when you go into four low
these views on the the dash show up automatically. Okay so we're actually right at the end now of
this first trail and we're just going to drop back onto the main trail but the actual drop
onto the main trail is quite severe so I got dad to spot me on this one
because honestly I don't want it to drop off right onto a rock although it still might I
don't know if the clearance is going to be enough but at least I got some eyeballs outside of the
truck. There was the big step still good on the clearance I think we're gonna be okay nicely done
Tacoma. Okay now I'm here in the Frontier and I'm gonna make this exact same maneuver here at the
end of the trail off of this rock face. So we've already said it immediately I notice Frontier
does not turn as well as the Tacoma does on these tight trails although with that TRD Pro
there's also that big hood scoop on the front end and the hood on the Toyota sits a pinch higher
so I actually like the visibility out of the Nissan a little bit more and now I'm about to
step off this rock face and it cleared. Whoa I did not expect that to clear I was nervous about that
one guys. Well not bad the other thing I have to comment on are the brakes in the Tacoma they don't
feel that strong I don't know if that's because it's the drums in the rear but comparing the two
the Nissan seems to have grabbier brakes and I like that for coming down hills like that.
Okay folks we're just coming off this same trail for the second time
and we switched trucks so I've now done it in the Frontier and the Tacoma same as Dad.
So there are some differences we're going to keep hammering this drum Tacoma handles a lot
better than the Frontier. Tacoma suspension takes care of you a little better than the Frontier but
on the positive side Dad the powertrain here in the Frontier it's just better it's easier to
modulate it's smoother it's not as jumpy the Tacoma always feels like it wants to jump on you
and when you're doing this crawling that's not what you want so I'll take the powertrain out
of the Frontier all day long over the Taco but then clearance wise the Tacoma was a little bit
better uh tires wise I think it was a little bit better so yeah I think the powertrain from the
Frontier but everything else from the Tacoma. Certainly powertrain I give you that and brakes
and brakes are better. They are they grab a lot tighter and when you're coming down these hills
we're not using downhill descent control we're just using right foot and yeah the Frontier feels
a lot better. And sight lines we mentioned this that big bulging hood in the in the Tacoma you
don't have that here this hood really falls off in front of you so I feel like I can see better
out of this truck. It is somewhat better. So those trails were not bad at all it was fun to do
something new but uh there wasn't quite enough deep mud Dad so what do you say we maybe go back
to Ironwood and uh give a little Hydroline action. We got a good rainstorm last night so it should be
awful wet back there. All right let's do it. Let's go. And here we are folks back on the Hydroline
now another huge shout out to the Minden Off-Road Park if you guys are in Ontario go check that
place out the truth of the matter is that we ran basically everything we could the majority of the
obstacles in that place are meant for vehicles with lifts and at least 35 inch tires not stock
trucks even these ones so uh yeah we wanted to though get a little bit more mud and water going
which is why we're here on the Hydroline which is so swampy right now it is absolutely soaking wet
there is more water here than there even was a weekend or two ago wow this is deep so far she's
chugging through as i sit here and wait for dad to wade his way up to the next camera point he's
got his big boots on today because there's so much water i have to complain about something
here in the Tacoma and that is the fact that the multi-terrain select crawl control and the rear
locking differential none of them work in four high you have to be in four low to access any of
those off-road systems and i just don't agree with that i would like to be in mud and ruts mode that
would change up my throttle mapping and my traction control in four high i don't want to
have to go into four low and Toyota is the only brand that makes you go to four low for all of
that stuff Nissan you do have to be in four low to lock the rear end even that i don't get sometimes
i like to lock up when i'm in four high whereas these trucks tell you you have to be in four low
so i just don't necessarily agree with needing to be in four low to access the best off-road stuff
on a pickup truck okay and now we're coming into the deep trench and so far so good on the mud
really the thing out here today is how deep this water is so let's hope everything's sealed up
oh my gosh it's deep okay baby let's go we're in it now we're in it now still in four high
oh and she's chugging oh it's deep
it's got to be above the doors man okay i'm getting to the end there's my big rock on the
passenger side not bad tires right over here comes the hill climb oh there's a skid there's a
skid oh then just the one skid plate okay not bad at all so i'm going to use crawl control
there is five different speed settings i am on the low setting and for whatever blessed reason
toyota still uses the abs system and you know what crawl control i believe was the first off-road
cruise control systems and when it came out it was really impressive we thought it was such
cool technology and now after using systems from every other brand this is not good guys this abs
sounds like the truck is kind of exploding itself uh and then second of all look forward
brake forward brake forward brake this is not smooth even a little bit uh yeah you know what
crawl control let's see if i turn up the speed a bit it's still man just shouldn't sound like that
especially when every other brand has figured it out to not have it sound like that now i am going
to crank up the speed now i'm in position four let's go right up to high now i'm full speed
crawl control going back into the water my foot is off the brake off the gas this is all toyota
and full speed and crawl control is still really slow like i'm three kilometers an hour two
kilometers an hour so again where some of these other brands have decided to give you these systems
at higher speeds toyota keeps it extremely slow and then crawl control right now it's also like
throttle throttle throttle throttle it's not that smooth either with the throttle input
so as much as i think crawl control is smart why is it smart well they can do things i can't
it can break one individual wheel at a time stuff like that but besides that i gotta tell you guys
i'm not loving crawl control today it's just so jerky and kind of unsettling and unnerving
um yeah kudos to toyota for being the first one to kind of go there but in the meantime i would
say just about every other brand has surpassed them with just how smooth and seamless their
off-road cruise control systems really are well uh that's it for the tacoma she did a nice job
let's go see what the frontier does on the hydro line all right ladies and gentlemen and here we go
into the deep water and it is deep oof there's a rock that i did not find in the tacoma
as i dropped in and then i gotta get my momentum up a little bit here we go
frontier nice smooth power delivery man this water is deep there's the rock on the passenger
side and now we come up the hill what happens here oh skid plate skid plate and skid plate
yeah clearance the clearance even though they're both listed at identical ground clearance
uh the frontier is definitely kissing a little bit more however the frontier is also better
armored so at least i feel better knowing that what's going on underneath the truck
is pretty solid now the frontier made it through though this little nissan is doing everything the
toyota is doing we'll have to see what it's like going back down the hill and through okay so
exactly like in the toyota i'm actually going to switch it over to four low now and there is no
off-road cruise control here in the nissan that is not a system that nissan bothered to introduce
all nissan has is hill descent control so we turn on hill descent control and now what's kind of cool
here in the nissan is it's automatic so it should just sense this hill and start to grab me which it
is my foot is off the brake off the gas and this is way smoother than what was going on over there
in the toyota now the toyota will also drive you on flat ground the nissan won't do that it's only
going to do this once you're on a hill uh but yeah it's it's oh yeah more rockets here in the
nissan man that hurt a little bit but uh oh dragging that belly dragging that belly thank
you skid plates that was the hitch to departure angle dang a couple degrees are making a big
difference that rock is massive right there here we go now what i noticed on that rock i don't know
if this is a trait of the tires but where the tacoma has been climbing up and over things like
the stump you saw earlier the the frontier keeps hitting big rocks and then glancing off to the
side so i don't again i don't know if it's a function of grip or clearance but where the
tacoma seems to climb things the frontier seems to hit them and bounce right off that's what
happened to me with that rock out there in the middle and kind of threw my head into the glass
wow uh so frontier is through it's out it is definitely worse for wear underneath but again
you got to keep pointing out it is doing everything the tacoma is doing well we're
off the hydro line now and once again dad's out of the bugs he was getting eaten out there i'm sure
um so this is a bit of a tricky one we wanted to do this rematch to bring these trucks back
together because they're a bit different now especially the tacoma and you know what dad the
differences show uh the tacoma has more approach more departure more break over and it was just
hitting less rocks than the nissan was plus i think the tire upgrade on the tacoma really helps
it quite a bit too now on the flip side i kept mentioning the king cab here there's no actual
real difference between this truck and the crew cab off-road they have the same wheelbase it's
just that you're getting the tiny back seat uh what's exciting about this truck though of course
it's canada only and that's always fun so after this day of off-roading here's where i'm kind of
at dad straight up off-road prowess if you're comparing these two you take the tacoma it's
it's just got the clearance it's got that suspension it's just a hair better out here
on the trails but then you look at the whole package and you remember that the tacoma is over
ten thousand dollars more and the frontier went everywhere it went today so uh how are you feeling
i agree with what you said as far as if uh booting around in the woods is all you ever do
which of course is not whatever anybody ever always does yeah um then yeah the toyota is your
truck however uh ten thousand bucks and i think steve and i both agreed that this powertrain
is superior to what's in the tacoma right now so i'll keep my ten grand and go frontier okay
fair enough well uh now we'll do the full wrap-up and i'll let you know what i think
and now the after action report first of all the nissan here has more salad than the toyota does
and the salad's a lot higher up on the truck it was just down deeper in that stuff second of all
you might have already noticed that skid plate we put a nice dent into it and you know what this is
actually aluminum i remember being on the launch event they announced an aluminum front skid plate
i said why aluminum it's gonna bend it might even puncture and look this is our first time out with
the truck it's already bent that big steel trd pro skid plate it took some hits but it still
looks good so yeah that was a bit of a weird decision on nissan's part and just know that
if you beat on it you're gonna bend it well folks we have arrived at the end of this one so what is
the verdict well at the end of this day this frontier kind of feels like the all-around truck
it's pretty dang good off-road it's nice on-road and it's gonna work
fairly hard for you but this video was really about off-roading and i know it's a lot more
expensive i just find myself being drawn to this toyota tacoma trd pro the suspension is so good
especially at high speeds and then the clearance makes a big difference so it felt considerably
better out there if i had to lay down my money i think i would pony up and go for the toyota
now of course though i want to hear from you so go in the comments let me know what you think of
both of these trucks and this comparison as always while you're down there don't forget to hit like
hit subscribe hit join to become a member and then come right back here to truck king
to see what we are testing next see ya
