Botticelli, Birth of Venus

Renaissance & Reformation in Europe
170 followers
10 Video Views·Dec 2, 2022
We're in the Uffizi, and we're looking at
The Birth of Venus by Botticelli.
This is, of course, one of the most iconic images
in the history of Western art.
Venus is fabulously beautiful.
How could it be otherwise?
So she stands radically naked in a Renaissance painting,
not in a Christian context here.
Until, really, this point in the Renaissance,
the only time you would see a nude was Eve.
But here, Botticelli's portrait.
The ancient goddess of love, Venus.
And he's portrayed her, actually based her,
on an ancient Roman sculpture of Venus.
Which was actually a copy of an even earlier
ancient Greek sculpture, which is known sometimes
as the Modest Venus, and which was actually
in the collection of the Medici.
We think that this painting might have actually
been for one of the Medici court,
perhaps even for a cousin of Lorenzo de' Medici.
So Venus stands in the middle.
She's born of the sea, and seems to be
being pushed in by the winds, the zephyrs
that are personified on the left.
She stands on a seashell, or almost stands on a seashell.
There's so much impossibility in this painting.
And when she gets to the shore,
she'll be received by an attendant
that's ready to wrap her nude body.
But we're, I think, delighted that she hasn't
gotten there yet, because the body is just so beautiful.
It's so sensuous, and it's an impossible kind of pose.
It's not really contrapposto.
There's this extraordinary curve to the body
that I think suggests that she's got a very flexible
kind of skeletal structure.
And even the zephyrs, who are those winds
that blow her to shore, are intertwined in impossible ways.
And every figure here floats.
When we look at Renaissance paintings,
we generally expect to see real naturalism.
We expect to see figures that have weight,
with bodies that make sense,
existing in a realistic space.
That's what we think of when we think about the Renaissance.
But that's not what Botticelli gives us.
Some art historians have suggested
that Botticelli is looking back to ancient Greek painting.
And the only painting, really,
that Botticelli would have had available to him
from the classical Greek tradition
would have been Wey's painting,
where figures are often isolated against a ground.
This is really a frieze.
All the figures, and this is very much
a Botticelli characteristic, are pushed forward.
And they-
Kind of occupying a single plane.
That's right.
And they're sort of isolated, these three groupings.
And you can almost imagine them as line painting on a vase.
In fact, this painting is really linear.
And because of the patterning,
because of the quality of the linear,
it sort of defies space.
I mean, yes, we can look into the deep space,
but this is not a Masaccio.
The attempt here is to really de-emphasize deep space
and to instead create a sense of pattern,
create a sense of beauty.
This is a painting, presumably,
and we're just guessing, we don't know,
that is really about beauty,
perhaps in a Neoplatonic sense,
both beauty as physical, as sensual, as erotic,
that leads one to a notion of divine beauty.
Right, that there are two kinds of beauty
and that through a contemplation of physical beauty,
we can arrive at divine beauty.
Botticelli is creating a kind of beauty
that is a result of, of course, the narrative.
It's a result of the elegance of the figure herself,
but also through the use of pattern,
through a kind of purely decorative quality.
We can see that especially in the traces of gold
that he's placed in her hair, in the trees to the right.
There's a kind of sensuality here
that's irresistible, right?
Pink flowers fluttering between Venus and the Zephyr,
the beautiful lines that create the waves,
the lines from her hair, the fluttering drapery.
It's a beautiful world that we want to enter.
