California Insider show is sponsored by Birch Gold Group. Protect your IRA or 401(k) with precious metals today: birchgold.com/california - "We need to have control, but we need to have consensus on that control from all parties involved. And plus meeting the needs of the public and what's best for the public."
Siyamak sits down with Kevin Olson, retired staff chief with CalFire.
Is California’s approach to wildfires our best option? Are we spending more money to control wildfires rather than prevent them?
A deadly wildfire continues to rage out of control.
The ecosystem in California is fire.
It's not if it's going to burn, it's when it's going to burn.
An explosive wildfire bringing devastation to northern California.
All the work that we're doing to reduce emissions
went away for the last 18 years because of these fires.
We've spent years of allowing the forest just to grow and grow and grow
and suppressing all the fires.
So our fuel loading is tremendously higher than it was in the past.
John Muir wrote when he was going to California, he says
he loved the California forest because you could ride a horse through that.
They were clear. There wasn't much debris.
We can do that by logging.
We can do that by grazing.
We can do that by prescribed burning.
And it has to be a combination of all those to protect our forest.
My guest today is Kevin Olson, retired staff chief with Cal Fire.
All the species of plants and animals all depend on fire for survival.
And so it's meant to burn.
And that's how our ecosystems evolved is burning.
Is California's approach to wildfires our best option?
Are we spending more money and effort in controlling wildfires
versus preventing them?
Stay tuned for an insider's perspective.
Before we get into today's interview, we want to ask you to sign up
to our California Insider email list.
You will receive exclusive updates on our upcoming documentary
and get the latest inside stories on everything that's happening in California.
Go to InsiderCA.com and sign up.
Now, let's get into today's interview.
Well, thank you for inviting me here today.
We want to talk to you about fires in California.
The fires are getting bigger and bigger.
The fire season in certain areas of California inside of California is all year now.
In 2020, we had the largest amount of fires.
Actually, all the work that we're doing to reduce emissions
went away for the last 18 years because of this, these fires.
Can you tell us more about why we are having these fires?
The bottom line reasons is part of the environment.
The ecosystem in California is fire.
Fire has to be part of the environment in California
for the redwood trees to regrow and for
all the species of plants and animals all depend on fire for survival.
And part of the issue why we're having bigger ones.
Yes, it's where we're in a warming time with the climate.
We went through about 100 years of where we suppressed everything.
So the fuel loading, the tons per acre is much greater now in many areas
than it would have been in the past.
In a study done out of the University of Reno and their fire ecology lab,
they estimated that every acre in California
before we started suppressing fires burned about once every 20 years.
So that meant, you know, some places would burn every five years.
Other places burn every 40 years.
But California would burn.
So it's meant to burn.
And that's how our ecosystems evolved is burning.
And now that we've been suppressing
with the warm weather and the winds, it's time to burn.
We always had a saying.
It's not if it's going to burn, it's when it's going to burn.
And since we can do a great job of suppressing such smaller fires,
when does it burn?
It's when we have the severe conditions, when we have the Santa Ana winds
blowing or the north winds blowing and combine that with a lightning storm
or a man caused fire.
We we have a lot of issues.
So it's natural for us to have this fire.
Absolutely.
What are the impacts of this?
Does it supposed to is it supposed to burn like all the way?
How does it work?
Well, back in the day before we suppress fires,
you know, I go back to what John Muir wrote when he was going to California.
He says he loved the California forest because you could ride a horse
through them and which meant that they were clear.
There wasn't much debris.
So if you had a fire that was a low intensity of fire,
like we try to do with prescribed burning right now,
and it goes through and burns up all the litter and the ground litter
and maybe a few places here and there where it'll get up in the trees
and burn the trees.
But that was good for the forest and it kept it clear.
But we've spent years of allowing the forest just to grow and grow and grow
and suppressing all the fire.
So our fuel loading is
tremendously higher than it was in the past.
And that just leads to when it does burn, because when you when the fuels
are, there are the bushes or the brush,
a certain percentage of it becomes dead fuel.
You know, you look at your plants around your house
as your rose bushes grow up, parts die and stuff.
Well, if that dead stuff is left hanging on the tree or the bush,
then that's just like kindling for the fire to take it really quick.
And that's what aids or adds to how fast it'll burn.
And you put a little wind behind that and it goes.
Where if it burns more often,
you won't have that as much of that dead fuel inside the live fuel.
So the fires we had in the past, based on what you're saying,
is actually wouldn't really kill the trees.
Not as much as they are right now.
But you figure before we started suppressing fires between two
to three million acres burned every year in California.
And how much is it burning now?
Well, we're back up to about two million a year, one to two million a year now.
But in the 70s, 80s and 90s,
you know, a large fire was a 10,000 acre fire.
And some of those years we burned 115,000, 200,000, 300,000.
A big year was 500,000 acres.
So we've really kind of just pushed back
when it's going to burn.
And when it was burning, it looked like
it would be a different kind of fire, right?
Right. And take the trees with them.
It would be much more lower intensity fire, and I'm sure there were fires.
And you can read some of the old literature and folklore
about fires that would burn all summer long.
But, you know, and we see that in the backcountry nowadays
with the federal government and their let burn in some of the backcountry
that once the intense fire behavior or the winds die down,
they just get a slow, creeping, moving fire, cleans up the forest really nice
and is quite good for the environment.
Now, our approach to these fires and actually
preventing these, have we done much to prevent them or anything about it?
Oh, yes. You know, we we're looking at, you know, how to prevent fires.
You know, we we want to protect all our infrastructure.
We want to protect all the buildings
because that's the main thing that we need to really look at right now,
because the forest, it's good for the forest to burn.
Yes, it's bad when we have an intense fire and it burns everything.
Even the big trees, you think it's good?
Not all of them at one time, but it it does get rid
of a lot of the diseased trees and the dead trees.
And, you know, we don't want manmade or man caused fires going.
We we want, you know, we have ignition devices
that, you know, we we've seen cars.
We've trained, changed a lot of the regulations on where cars
and going in the grass, no smoking in the forest.
You know, we we've done a lot through prevention to reduce the amount of starts.
So we have done that part of it where we are we are not.
We're careful about people making a fire somewhere.
Right. But what about the process?
And there's a lot of complaint about that.
We have a lot of fuel, as you mentioned.
Is there anything we could do differently that we have?
I think we really need to look at using prescribed burn more
and prescribed burn around some of our critical infrastructures,
some of our watershed, because Cal Fire, then back in the beginning as CDF,
they were created through legislation to protect the watershed of California.
So we need to really protect our watershed
so we can do that by logging.
We can do that by grazing.
We can do that by prescribed burning.
And it has to be a combination of all those to protect our forest logging.
We've proved with the Cal Fire demonstration state forest
that you can have what they call sustainable yield logging,
which is you don't go in there and clear cut and take every tree,
but you select trees.
So the total sum of trees that you take,
that never changes the amount of board feed available.
You know, it always stays the same because you only take the newer growth
or the older growth and you measure it out and you only take certain trees
and that getting in there and disturbing the ground
causes seedlings to grow.
You move all the brush into a pile and either you get rid of it
or you burn it later when it's, you know, in the wintertime
when there's three feet of snow on the ground, you can burn the pile.
You know, that doesn't help much with the carbon sequestration
and try and reduce the carbon output.
But it's, you know, we can do a little bit of carbon
in the wintertime during prescribed burning, or we can do it all at once,
you know, on a big fire, a major fire in the summertime.
Now, is the logging, there's a lot of complaints
that we're not doing that logging anymore.
And it seems like the roads, because the loggers would maintain the roads
or the forest department would maintain the roads.
And and those roads are not maintained well anymore.
Yeah, there's always logging roads.
And, you know, that that would be for our foresters and the logging companies
and and to address environmental concerns, because we don't want roads
everywhere into the forest, because then that leads to overuse.
And, you know, we want we want to definitely control
the use of our forests and our lands.
The largest landowner in California is Sierra Pacific,
and they own a lot of forest up there.
But, you know, their logging presence in California is greatly reduced
because of the restrictions that's been placed on logging in California.
Do you think these kind of restrictions, sometimes they hurt us?
Because we have heard that to do controlled burns and to do logging
a lot of the environmental groups, they don't like that.
Right. Come after it.
Yeah. And that's where we need to come to an educated consensus
with everybody. What what is it we need to do?
Because we need to log.
I mean, you can after a fire burns through a forest,
you can cut and salvage the dead trees.
But you have like two years to do that before the rod of the wood.
But when you're talking, you know, one hundred thousand acres to try
and even get the permits to get in there and do that can take more than two years.
And they've tried.
So why does it take two years?
Environmental reviews.
You know, anytime you have to push so much dirt to make a new road in the forest,
you have to get special permits for that.
So it's it's very regulatory intensive.
And I'm all for controlled.
And I don't want anybody running wild in the forest, cutting every willy nilly.
But but we need to come up with a formula that that meets the needs of everybody,
because, you know, that's a huge industry for California was logging at one time.
So do you think these laws have gone beyond
being reasonable to a point where they might be hurting us in the long run?
Or I think so.
You know, I think there is a lot of overregulation in California.
But I'm not saying, you know, we need to have control,
but we need to have consensus on that control from all parties involved.
And plus meeting the needs of the public and and what's best for the public,
you know, because because we these big fires,
we have to do everything we can to protect ourselves and our towns.
And because that's that's the biggest waste on all the fires is the destruction
of our towns, our people and our watershed, because once the trees are gone,
then it washes away the topsoil and we have to get regrowth.
But, you know, but we don't want overgrowth either,
because a mature or a pine tree uses about 150 gallons
or about 10 gallons a day per inch in diameter.
So some of the bigger trees are using 150 to 200 gallons a day,
where that's sucking the water out of the ground.
When you go from 60 trees per acre to maybe 200 trees per acre,
you're looking at thousands of gallons more that the trees are pulling out
of the ground instead of having a store there.
So that's you know, that adds to our drought and our water shortages
is because our forests are overgrown.
So if we have a more dense forest, it takes a lot more water
and pulls the water out of the ground and doesn't hold as much
for when we need it in the summertime.
Interesting.
Now, we have been told that we are spending a lot of efforts
on the firefighting part, but we are spending a lot of funds on that.
Yes, but we're not doing the control burns and we're not doing the logging.
And that's kind of it's kind of the way
we allocate our funds are more when the disaster happens
and we don't prevent much. Right.
They are just now and they have been for the last several years
really looking at the prevention part, more funding for prescribed burn,
more funding for other methods to clear and protect the forest.
But that is definitely takes a backseat to the fire control
that we're doing right now, because we we want to prevent people's houses
or businesses from burning down.
And and that's kind of taken the lion's share.
And they've done an excellent job in really
increasing the funding available for Cal Fire and for the local governments
in California and the federal governments to prevent or to suppress fires
because they are proportionally need more because of the size of the fires issue.
But yes, we need more, more
direction on what we can do to stop that prescribed burns, fuels treatment,
you know, cutting fire breaks.
It it's it's growing, but probably not at a fast enough rate
compared to the dangers of the fires out there.
We've also been told that it's not very visible
when you do those kind of prevention work.
Well, yeah, and you don't get a lot of press for it.
Yeah. And it's hard to sell that.
Yeah, it's and that's true with anything.
If your prevention is not glamorous,
the heroes stopping the fire is glamorous going out there
and cutting a fuel break is very labor intensive and not very glamorous at all.
But, you know, and it's hard to say, OK, why was this town saved as well?
Because we built a massive fuel break around it.
We were able to stop the fire or treat the the surrounding
to keep the fire from coming to the town and push it down
another gully or another direction.
Now, what do those towns can do?
If you're living in a town that is like in the rural rural area,
you're close to the to the forestry and what can you do?
They they have the resources available through CAL FIRE to
to build fire plans, fire, prescribed fire plans
to actually go out there and see what needs to be done,
where the risk areas are at in the town or the area,
what they can do to to probably pretreat the area, which,
you know, remove fuel or cut a fire break or tell people to move.
You know, it's just
you there can be effective, you know, this kind of anecdotal.
But on the large fires that were burned through Napa several years ago,
I have a brother and sister in law that have a house up there
and they bought it and they said, Hey, Kevin, can you come and tell us
what we need to do to our house?
Because we're worried about fires up here.
And I went there and I went through with the groundskeeper
and I go, you need to do this, you need to do this.
We clear this back to the property.
And they only lost one of their buildings
when the fire burned right through their property.
It's with 70 mile an hour winds.
And I mostly it was caused or benefited
because of the pretreatment that was done on the vegetation around their house.
The type of vegetation that I told them they need to get rid of
or that they were they can keep near the house.
And the person that originally built the house used great materials
and construction that was fairly fire hardened on that area,
on the main house and several of the other houses.
So there are things you can do.
Oh, absolutely.
You know what?
Probably the biggest
thing that you can do is when you're building in the wildland areas,
actually look where you're building.
You know, don't build in a canyon, don't build
in a gully.
Don't build mid slope if you can help it,
because those are all very, very hard to protect
when the fire is racing up towards you down below or racing towards you.
Is there any recommendations for the prescribed burning?
How would how would you do that?
Prescribed burning needs to be in areas that actually eliminate a threat.
You know, we need to look at the infrastructure or the resources
we want to protect and then how a prescribed burn in that area
would protect them.
Because we don't want to burn and put carbon in the air just to burn
and put carbon in the air.
We want to have a goal in mind to reduce the fuel load.
So it would eliminate or really reduce the threat of a fire
going through that area and threatening town or city
or some type of infrastructure that we have there that we want to protect.
So is that possible?
Because because. Oh, absolutely.
But do you think people so is the fire department
actively looking at areas and saying, OK, these are the areas that are risky?
We should clean. Yes.
Yes, they are looking at that because we have a great fire history
since about 1900, and it's all available online.
And you can actually lay the layers of fires over from the past over areas
and see where the fires are going to burn.
And it was kind of fascinating sitting with some of the people
really knowledgeable in this, say, OK, a fire burned here in 1940.
And there was another one in 1980.
What was the difference?
And it might be a 30,000 acre fire.
And there may be four thousand four thousand acres difference in the size
because it's going to burn very similar in all those areas.
And you can use that to predict where you need to do your prescribed
burning to reduce that.
How difficult is it to get the permits and do these prescribed burns?
It's not difficult in the sense that
the regulations are really that hard.
It's just writing the prescription.
Where are you going to burn?
How much you're going to burn?
What if it goes beyond this and make sure it's protection
and what the weather is going to be like getting permission from all the landowners?
See where if it's if it's a prescribed burn on federal land,
that's much easier because you have one one group of ownership
and it's the federal government and they work under stewardship
and they need to protect that land.
But if it's a Cal fire burn and you might have five or six different landowners,
then you have to get cost sharing between those landowners
because if if it's a cattle rancher and they're benefiting from the burn,
we're burning up all the big brush and that will allow grasslands to come in
and protect and and help benefit them.
And there's got to be a cost share with that.
It's usually not much and it's not usually a showstopper.
But and just getting the permission, if you have a small bunch of acreage
in the middle and somebody goes, well, I don't want my property burned,
then that really requires some negotiation to get that in there.
And that does hold up a lot of burns.
So this is this seems like there might be some gridlock in this process.
Yes, there is.
Yeah, it's never just we're going to do this and go out there next week and do it.
Some some of the bigger control burns have taken years in planning to do.
Do you think we have to change that or do you think it's necessary
to do that much planning?
Oh, it's definitely necessary to do that much planning,
but it shouldn't take so long and we need to.
If more people understood the benefit and what we're trying to do in the long run,
I think it would go.
So it's it's part of an education.
It's part of understanding, you know, the end goal.
It's there.
You know, I haven't worked on that side of it in a long, long time,
so I don't really know what all the regulations are right now.
But it is it is time consuming.
In terms of education, you mean people need to understand
that fires are not bad for the nature, especially the ones you mentioned
that they are not burning the big trees?
Yeah. You know, when I hear on the news, you know, the fire went through
and destroyed all this.
You know, I can look.
But what did it clean up?
What is the benefit of the fire going to the area?
You know, we're going to look at all the new growth
because you go back several years to when they had all those massive fires
in Yellowstone and I think it was the early 80s, late 70s.
And they said, oh, it's going to destroy Yellowstone.
But what they found out is fires burned in a mosaic pattern.
There was no pattern to how, you know, it burned up this bunch of trees over here,
but it didn't burn over here.
And all the new growth and wildlife and all the plants that came back
because it burned, it started a lot of people thinking,
well, maybe fire isn't that bad.
Maybe, you know, because it is part of the natural ecosystem out there.
And we need it.
So we should trust the nature more.
Yes. We need to work in tune with the nature.
You know, the native Californians, the Native Americans that were here,
they used fires for centuries to clear fields and make room
for what they needed to do before we even started thinking about it.
So when people look at these fires, we're kind of people.
It's devastating.
It's big fire. Yes.
And people are always look at a lot of people are saying
this is because of climate change
and we can't do anything about it.
Is that true?
I do not believe that's true.
I do believe that the climate is changing, that we are having warmer.
I mean, it's you look at the records we are.
Have we been there before with the warm and dry in our history?
I'm sure we have, because we've only been keeping records for about 200 years
out of, you know, millions of years that California has been here.
But what we need to do is we just need to adapt our suppression methods,
our protection methods, our pre
our fire prevention methods to match
what's going on in the fire environment right now.
So maybe we need to look at creating greater clearances around our our structures.
You know, maybe we need to put more power lines underground.
We need to look at more water storage.
There's many things we can do.
So it's not hopeless because we're very and we have a lot of ingenuity as people.
And I think we can overcome this.
It's just we need to get down and really not blame it on one thing or one another.
Just what do we need to do to protect ourselves and our people?
Do you think we have become like that based on what you're seeing
in the way we treat these fires and other other issues?
Do you think we have become more like we hear an excuse?
We have an excuse and we don't take action anymore.
As much as we used to do 20, 30 years ago.
We might might have been more action oriented.
Yeah, I think we are more action oriented because we're, you know, we're such a
society right now where people are afraid to make a decision at times.
Well, I can't do that because I haven't been told to do that
or I can't do that because I need to get all the clearances and stuff.
But, you know, we need to ask more questions.
And and, you know, one of my favorite things is why not?
OK, can we we need clear here?
Well, we can't do that. Well, why not?
You know, we need we need to find out what we can do and pursue that.
And not everybody's going to agree with everything.
But we all agree that we must look at this
and tackle this problem together.
And do you think the politicians in Sacramento, do you think they have a good
handle of what's going on with these fires?
Or do they have a good line of communication to people that are on the ground?
You know, I think that's more individual because some of the politicians
that I worked with when I was working out of Sacramento were great, very supportive.
You know, I think that the turnover in the legislature
has kind of hurt some of the standard programs, because
when you get a new legislative session in, you know, we started
where we had to reeducate or educate all the newcomers in there,
what the mission is, what we're doing, how we're going.
But it was while I was in Sacramento, I did see the budget
grow from about a billion dollars a year.
Now it's up over two billion a year, which needed to happen.
You know, certain programs are more expensive.
The the amount of inmates that are available to to fill our camps
and run our crews is much less than it was 15 to 20 years ago
because of the early paroles and the changing and sentencing.
So that's necessitated where we have what we call free crews
or firefighter one hand crews and that we've put together for fighting fires.
And that seems to be working quite well.
You know, we've looked at other avenues like the California Conservation Corps.
We now have a lot more three C's crews out there as fire crews and helping.
And and, you know, one of the adages we came up with the camp program,
there's no such thing as a bad crew, just a bad leader.
So now in terms of the budget, the two billion you mentioned,
how much of it is going to prevention?
How much of it is going to suppression?
Is this all for suppression?
No, it's it's the total Cal Fire budget.
And I haven't really looked at those numbers in the last couple of years,
but it's probably closer to 70 to 80 percent is going to suppression.
What about the firefighters?
What's the attitude when there is a big fire somewhere?
Oh, everybody wants to go there or southern.
How does everybody wants to go?
You know, I don't know of any firefighter that goes, oh, there's a big fire there.
I don't want to go there.
You know, it's we we want to go out there
and make a difference and put out the fire if we can.
So the mindset is like you just got to get to the yeah, to the fire and make it.
Yeah. You know, it doesn't matter if it's your your city or your camp.
No, we'll we'll go anywhere and put out the fire,
which is, you know, when we're told to.
And that's the hardest part, because you hear a big fire.
You know, you're in central California.
You hear something big going down south.
It's like, hey, when are we going to go?
When are we going to go?
Who's who's up to go out of county from this unit?
You know, which engines are next in line to go?
Everybody wants to know that.
Now, for young people, if young people want to get into this profession,
would you encourage them to get it?
Oh, absolutely. And why?
Because it's exciting.
You know, you know, you take good care of your family.
You have camaraderie with the people you work with.
Some of my best friends in the world are still people I worked with over the years.
And I talk to some of them almost daily, even though I'm retired.
If you're interested in becoming a firefighter,
seek out the community colleges.
They have most every community or many of the community
colleges have great firefighter programs.
Look at go to the
California Professional Firefighters website and find out organizations
around there that will let you do ride alongs that will.
You know, there's Explorer Post programs.
There's mentor programs available through the fire agency.
And it's just not a man's world.
It's a woman's world.
I started in the firefighting business in 1980
was my first season as a seasonal firefighter.
And there has been women in the fire station since the very first day I started.
And we would be missing something if we didn't have a big, diverse program.
It's, you know, everybody brings something to the table.
It's it's great.
And it's a lot of a lot of fun, a lot of work.
You got it. You're going to sweat.
You're going to get tired.
You might go days without showers and you can see some horrific things
and you have to be strong.
But that's where your friends and everything come in.
Do you have any other thoughts for our audience?
The fires are going to happen.
Be prepared.
You know, seek help.
Seek out the professionals to come out and look at your property.
Do property surveys.
See what you can do to prevent, you know, protect yourself from fires.
Have a strategy or plan if you do start to get overran.
Because chance always favors those who are prepared.
Kevin Olson, retired staff chief at Cal Fire.
It was great to have you on California Insider.
Well, thank you very much.
Thank you for watching.
Please click the icon on the left to subscribe to our channel.
We bring you the most pressing issues California is facing
with straightforward and in-depth interviews.
See you in the next video.