Featuring Reps. Drew Stokesbary, Drew MacEwen, Dan Griffey, Chris Corry, Jacquelin Maycumber, Gina Mosbrucker, and Kelly Chambers.
Senate Bill 5693 would:
- Make 2021-23 fiscal biennium supplemental operating appropriations. - Increase spending to $65 billion in 2021-23, a $6.2 billion increase to current spending levels. - Provide no meaningful tax relief, despite our state's $15 billion budget surplus.
House Republicans introduced 26 amendments to the budget bill, including an amendment to provide a sales tax cut and another to fund the police. With a $15 billion budget surplus, we believe it is time for the Legislature to provide meaningful tax relief for Washingtonians. We also believe it is critical to put more police officers on the streets, protect and create jobs, make wise transportation investments, and bolster our state's rainy-day fund.
Unfortunately, there is one flaw in this budget that will, if this amendment is not adopted,
will preclude me from being able to support the budget. This amendment, I hope though,
is adopted so that I can support the budget. This amendment would reduce some of the funding
proposed in the budget so that we can provide the citizens of Washington with a one-half of a
percent sales tax cut. Madam Speaker, the last two years, it's been no secret, have been incredibly
tumultuous. When we adjourned almost exactly two years ago, COVID-19 was just hitting Washington
State for the first time. We were one of the first states in the country to be affected.
Schools were just temporarily closed. And as the effects of that became obvious,
among the many other impacts to our lives, state revenues collapsed. Well, remarkably, in the time
since then, state revenues have not only recovered, but have gone far beyond where we ever would have
expected them to be at, even before the pandemic hit us. Entering this session, after you account
for the revenue forecast changes and the caseload and maintenance level changes, we're looking at
a budget surplus over the next four years of something like $13 to $15 billion. Never in our
state's history have we had so much money with which to spend in the budget. So all session long,
myself and my colleagues in my caucus have been arguing for a tax cut to be put forward on the
floor of this body. But unfortunately, the budget before us provides no meaningful tax relief, no
permanent tax relief, no meaningful tax relief. This amendment would fix that by creating the
budget capacity to fund the 1.5% sales tax cut. I went back today and looked at the supplemental
budgets for the last 20 years, which I guess, since they're every other year, would only be the
last 10 supplemental budgets. The highest one spent $1.7 billion over four years. The budget
before us would spend $12.8 billion over four years. This budget is almost 10 times as expensive
as the next biggest supplemental budget this body has ever passed.
Yet no part of that is providing meaningful tax relief to the people before us, the people we
represent. This amendment before us would fix that. Our revenues have increased so dramatically
that I am confident that we have the ability to both fund all of our needs that we need to fund
this year and provide meaningful tax relief to the people of Washington. I think we owe it to
the people of Washington to share in the economic largesse of the state. Many of our constituents
are struggling, but the state isn't. Yes, we have needs to address. Even with this amendment,
it would still be the biggest policy spending increase that this body has ever passed.
But we could also do it in a way that provides tax relief to the people we represent.
I strongly urge a yes vote on this amendment, Madam Speaker.
We have mass inflation going on right now. 7% is a conservative estimate, I think.
And what more can we do to help the people of this state than to say,
here's a tax cut on one of the most regressive taxes in this state. And I'd also like to remind
this body, this isn't our money. This is the taxpayers' money. The Speaker's about to open
the roll call machine. The Speaker has opened the roll call machine. Has every member voted
who wishes to vote? Would any member like to change their vote? The Speaker's about to lock
the roll call machine. The Speaker has locked the roll call machine. Clerk will announce the total.
Madam Speaker, there are 39 yeas, 49 nays, 4 excused. The amendment is not adopted.
This does a number of things for law enforcement. And why is that important?
Well, we've got safety issues. The number of commissioned officers we have in this state
has dropped. Wait times have increased at the Law Enforcement Academy. And so what this does
is address those issues. $5,000 signing retention bonuses for officers. Grants to
local law enforcement for body cams. Funds 10 additional basic law enforcement classes.
And provides other studies and recommendations on how we can fight this crime. And if you look
at WASPIC's latest crime report, Madam Speaker, it's quite disturbing. This is why we really need
this amendment. Murders are up 47 percent. Manslaughter 100 percent. Fraud 131 percent.
We are ranked dead last in the union when it comes to the number of law enforcement officers
we have per capita. That's a problem. And those statistics show it. This amendment goes towards
addressing those issues. We have an inherent responsibility in this body for the public
safety of this state. And it's time that we back our law enforcement officers with the very tasks
that we give them. And give them the necessary funding to protect the citizens of this state.
I strongly urge this body's adoption. Thank you. These crimes are rampant. Sleepy Little,
Allen Washington, 1,200 people. We cannot muster enough support resources. Madam Speaker,
this is important. We need to do this now. We need to vote now on this so we can bolster our
law enforcement. So we can make this crime go away. Madam Speaker, let's adopt this amendment.
There are over $995 million in unspent federal stimulus funds right now that could go to fix
this. That's another reason to vote yes. There's other great things in this bill. We talk about
accountability. There are grants in here to help local law enforcement agencies with body camera
costs. That's a great way to encourage local communities to adopt body cameras for their
law enforcement officers. Additionally, the comment that we see about performance metrics,
since when is measuring something bad? I think the best businesses are constantly refining what
they do and looking back on what they've done. Frankly, Madam Speaker, we don't put enough of
this in the work we do here. I think this is a good amendment that makes good use of federal
stimulus money and actually works to help heal our communities and support our law enforcement
officers. It would be great to keep the people who want to serve and protect their communities
who have it in their heart to do the right thing in the positions that they're in. That would be
great. Right now, the legislature has made it difficult to stay in that profession. Unfortunately,
it's one of the biggest issues right now in the public. You hear it all the time.
Law enforcement officers are leaving at a higher rate. They're in danger. First responders are in
danger due to recent legislation. When you do have one-time money, you invest it in those people
who are investing in you. Those people are investing in us tonight, Madam Speaker. We need
to keep the ones that are there. We need to invest in the next generation. We've never seen it where
this many officers have left law enforcement. We've seen them retire early. We've seen them
not decide to be an officer. We've seen those who are an officer looking for other jobs.
Madam Speaker, one of the best officers in Placotet County, a very good friend of mine,
was undercover. He did every job that you could do in the county sheriff's office.
He came to me and he said, because of what happened last year and because of the bills
that came out, and he fought with me. He was testifying. You've probably seen him testify
numerous times on numerous bills under use of force. He said, I can't do my job.
I can't keep the community safe. He said, that's why he became a law enforcement officer.
He said, you took that away and he quit. You can Google on any site right now across the
state of Washington and you can see people just throwing their hands up. I know none of us in
this body tonight or in the state of Washington want lawlessness. I want citizens, just like you
and I, to be law enforcement officers, to correct the law. So please vote yes on this amendment.
The speaker is about to open the roll call machine. The speaker has opened the roll call
machine. Would any member like to change their vote? The speaker is about to lock the roll call
machine. The speaker has locked the roll call machine. Clerk will announce the record.
Madam Speaker, there are 43 yeas, 50 nays, 5 excused. The amendment is not adopted.
We know what's going on in Eastern Europe right now. It's going to have a dramatic impact on
energy prices. We've also got inflation here at the home front, in addition to globally, seven
percent. What is the relevance to the budget with that? Well, it greatly impacts the spending power
of our citizens. We rely tremendously on sales tax revenue. The Federal Reserve next month will
more than likely increase interest rates. That'll have an impact on consumer spending. We will see
a slowdown in spending, most likely over the coming 12 to 18 months. And so as we head into
this conference with the other body and come with the final budget that we'll vote on yet again,
I urge everyone involved to look at that ending fund balance and let's increase it. We had an
unexpected surplus of 14 billion dollars. When I got elected in 2012, our biennium budget was
around 32 billion. We have 14 billion surplus? Holy cow. We've got to increase our ending fund
balance to make this work. We do not know and we cannot control what's going to happen in the
coming year. And I'm very concerned for the welfare of our citizens that if we're not able
to adapt and pivot and respond to changes in the economy that are beyond our control, that we're
going to put them in a dire situation and make draconian cuts that are the worst time to make
when you're in a recession. I hope we don't go into recession, but we are certainly looking at
some serious dark clouds on the horizon right now. Let's put the state in a better position
so that when that if those storms do come to fruition, we are in a position to be able to
handle it. What we're saying tonight isn't that there is going to be something bad, but we believe
there could be something bad on the horizon. And when we have a budget that is set up to have such
a low ending fund balance and security for the future, I'm worried that the smart choices that
we're not, you know, that we're not making now are going to lead to drastic choices in the future
for us as a state. Madam Speaker, I don't want to have to come back here next year and cut
programs. I don't want to have to come back here next year and say no. Unfortunately, we are setting
ourselves up for that. We're not providing any real tax relief for Washington. We're not putting
any meaningful money back away where it belongs, where the people of the state expect us to have
our savings in order, like we expect them to have their savings in order when troubled times come.
There is a lot of good stuff in this bill, a lot of stuff that we have broad support for,
that we agree on, and we've heard that tonight. Unfortunately, there's a lot of stuff in here
that gives us serious concern. And Madam Speaker, when we do things in a manner that doesn't come
together as one Washington, we often pay for the price for that. It may not be today, it may not
even be tomorrow. If the good member will not impugn members but speak to the policy, please
proceed. Thank you, Madam Speaker. As I said before, our best policy for the state, this
policy that comes out of here, works together in unison and in broad agreement. Unfortunately,
this budget is not that, and I'm urging a no. There are a number of concerns with this budget,
and they've been mentioned before, but I will reiterate, there is not meaningful tax relief
in this budget. And at the end of the day, the money really belongs to the people.
And at a time with just raging inflation, much of which most members of this body have not seen in
their entire working career, unless you've been working more than 40 years, you probably haven't
seen inflation like this. And I think at a time of that type of uncertainty, the best thing that
we can do for the people of Washington is let them keep more of their hard-earned money,
so that they can put gas in their tank and continue to go to work, so that they can buy
groceries to feed their family. And while, you know, you can't fund every tax relief proposal
all at the same time, reducing the sales tax rate and property tax relief, add all those
things together, but you can pick and choose and do those things, and I wish we would have
implemented some of that stuff in this budget today, Madam Speaker. So for those reasons,
I'm going to be a no and urging a no vote on this.
When I first got elected, Madam Speaker, which doesn't seem that long ago, despite the gray hair
you might notice on your screen, our enacted state budget spent $33.7 billion out of the
new general fund. The document before us today would spend $65 billion. In my less than four
terms in this body, our state budget has doubled. I don't know of many of my constituents who have
seen their income double, and yet we're telling them that despite us as a state having the
resources to double our spending, we're unwilling to return any of the money to them more than a
three-day one-time sales tax holiday. I don't think that's the right thing to do, Madam Speaker,
and despite all of the other wonderful things in the budget.
Please do not impugn members. Please proceed on the policy.
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I do not think the policy of increasing spending by $12.8 billion
and not providing any meaningful permanent tax relief to the people who supplied those $12.8
billion in tax revenue in the first place, I do not think that's wise policy. I think it would
be much better policy to our constituents to provide them with meaningful tax relief rather
than a three-day one-time sales tax holiday. So despite there being many other good things in the
budget, I cannot support a document that fails to recognize the difficulties that our constituents
have faced and provide them with the tax relief that they deserve. Please vote no, Madam Speaker.