Bronzino and the Mannerist Portrait

Renaissance & Reformation in Europe
170 followers
6 Video Views·Nov 22, 2022
So let's talk about the Mannerist style and how it appears in portrait painting.
Okay.
So this is by Bronzino?
This is a painting by Bronzino.
This is called A Portrait of a Young Man from around 1540.
We don't know exactly who it is, and therefore it has that title.
And it's located in New York City at the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
So we can all go see it?
We can all go see it if we're in New York, yes, absolutely.
You know, it looks so elegant, and so immediately I think of Mannerism.
Yeah, absolutely.
The elegance of the image, both in terms of the way that it's painted and in terms of
how this young man presents himself are two of the things that really stand out.
So actually, maybe we should start by saying in general what some trademarks of Mannerism
are and how this relates to it.
So that elegance?
Okay, elegance is definitely one thing.
A kind of hyper-sophisticated elegance.
Other things that are typical of Mannerism include a very enigmatic quality, a puzzling
quality.
Right, things that don't make sense.
The harder a Mannerist image is to understand, the better it was to a certain extent.
And they seem to almost make things confusing on purpose, right?
Absolutely.
And then also another important characteristic of Mannerism, and we could say this about
sculpture as well, is that the artistic virtuosity becomes an integral part of the work of art's
meaning.
Some people call Mannerism the stylish style, not only because of the subject matter and
how it's presented, but also because of the creation of the work of art and its technical
difficulty, the kind of fireworks display of technical skill is also an important aspect.
And sometimes I think that it almost seems like if they did things wrong, they were kind
of showing off a kind of sophistication in an odd way.
Absolutely, or at least making you wonder if they did it wrong is part of what a Mannerist
artist might do.
I thought I remembered one artist writing to another one, next time you do a painting
of the figure, put the right hand on the left arm.
That wouldn't surprise me.
To do it wrong, in a way doing it wrong proved that you knew how to do it right so easily
that it was a kind of showing off to do it wrong.
Sure, sure.
And also we should say these characteristics, the reason why they emerged, there's lots
of different theories people have, in part perhaps because a new generation of artists,
starting with Pontormo, but then also Parmigianino and Bronzino, they needed to do something
different.
They felt like all the possibilities had been exhausted in the high Renaissance, the works
of Leonardo and Michelangelo and Raphael and Titian.
Well, it does kind of seem after the School of Athens that the height of naturalism of
what the Renaissance wanted to do had been reached, and what was there for new artists
to do?
And so a new generation of artists turned away from the priorities of naturalism and
classicism and overriding logic that we saw in the earlier 1500s.
Also, Mannerism can be tied to the Medici, both in terms of the election of a Medici
Pope, Leo X in 1513, but also the return of the Medici to Florence in the teens and especially
in the 20s and 30s.
So, what was it about the Medici?
Well, when they become Popes and when they return as Dukes of Florence, ultimately, they
cultivate a very, very sophisticated court because they want to prove that they are peers
of the great court rulers of Europe.
And so the Mannerist style develops, in a way, in partnership with these efforts of
their leadership to create a, as I said before, a hyper-sophisticated, elegant setting for
their court.
So the Medici are no longer pretending to be allies of the Republic, and they're really,
in a way, embracing a kind of aristocratic lifestyle.
Yes, certainly by the middle of the 1500s, definitely.
So, let's talk about how this image reflects these kinds of ideas and themes.
First of all, obviously, the way the young man is dressed, the way that he's standing,
the expression on his face, all seem to exude this very cool sophistication, a great detachment,
and a hyper-articulated elegance.
All of these things are, in a way, characteristic of both Mannerist life as it was lived and
Mannerist art.
We can also talk about the way that it's painted.
Bronzino is one of the masters of the oil painting technique of the 16th century, and
when you're standing in front of this painting and looking at it, it's hard to see how it
was actually painted.
You can barely see any kind of brush stroke or any kind of surface texture.
So polished.
Exactly.
It's as if he's transcended the medium itself in its creation, which was also definitely
a goal of a Mannerist artist.
What else could we say about it in terms of Mannerism?
He looks very distant, very detached, but also, in a way, very posed to me.
This is not a position that one would catch one in naturally.
He hasn't been caught off guard.
No.
He looks very much like a model sort of taking a pose.
That's true, and that's an important part both of Mannerist culture as it was actually
lived and Mannerist portraiture.
The idea of the pose, the conspicuous nature of posing, was actually something that people
looked upon favorably.
It's so weird because we kind of look down at it.
We think people are insincere.
We have a different take on it, certainly.
But at the time, especially in the Medici circles of this period, obvious artificiality
was a goal of proper social behavior in elite circles.
Your identity was something that was to be performed.
You presented yourself to be seen in a certain way, and it was understood to be a performance,
something artificial.
It was supposed to seem effortless, but it was supposed to be clear that the real you,
whoever you were, was not something on display.
That would be gauche.
Instead, a very polished, artificial, superficial kind of performance is how you presented yourself
in these court circles and, as we can see, actually in this painting as well.
So a kind of mask.
Absolutely.
And that kind of fits in here.
Mannerists were obsessed with masks because of this idea that it presented something to
be seen and was obviously hiding something underneath.
This painting addresses those kinds of themes in several ways.
First of all, because of his conspicuous pose as we see it.
Usually a portrait is to present someone's physical appearance and identity, but the
way he's looking at us, it's almost as if he's saying, I dare you to understand who
I am.
Who I am.
Right.
Which is very, very typically Mannerist.
He also seems to be condescending to us in a way.
Perfectly.
Absolutely.
So there's all of that.
Just in the way that he presents himself, it's typically Mannerist.
But to return to the idea of the mask, there are several masks or references to masks in
the painting.
Some people say that his hard, kind of porcelain-like skin makes his face look like a mask, especially
because his eyes don't look in the same direction.
And also the way that the light sort of falls on his face.
It is very, very mask-like.
But then we can also look at the face that's like a mask at the edge of the table, facing
out towards the viewer.
And there's another one on the arm of the chair in the lower right.
And then if you look very carefully at the very bottom of the painting, the folds in
the fabric of his pants leg form two eyes and a nose, and another mask, therefore, in
the painting.
And this idea of things being hidden, and you have to search for the meaning, and suddenly
discover things that you hadn't...
And things not making sense.
All of these are important characteristics of Mannerism.
And we could talk about the book in that case, right?
Because normally, what would be in a portrait would help to tell us something about the
sitter.
Right.
And in this case, we kind of don't have anything except those masks.
Here we see a book, but it's closed.
It's not open for us to read and understand.
Just like how we are presented with a man, but he too, because of the way he looks at
us and is painted, is closed off to us.
And remains an enigma.
Like the window or door in the back that's also hidden from view, in a way, like the
book is closed.
Let's look at our other image as well.
Okay.
This is Bronzino's portrait of Ludovico Caponi, approximately the same date, and also here
in New York City.
This is at the Frick Collection.
His fingers, those elongated, boneless fingers, are also very typical of Mannerism.
It's very similar to the last painting we looked at, and to Mannerism in general, with
its refined elegance and the rather elongated forms, the face, the cool polish, and the
sort of firm skin that we expect to see.
Here he's not quite as aloof-looking as the last image, but still there's that sense that
he's posing for us.
He's presenting himself to be seen in a particular way, and we're never going to know who the
real person underneath is.
And so again, a kind of virtuistic painting, but also a very good demonstration of how
you were supposed to behave in upper-class society.
Just like in the last painting, we had a book that was closed, so we were presented with
something that we expect to understand, but are prevented from seeing into it.
Here too we have the same thing.
In his right hand, on the left, he's holding a cameo.
And usually when a man is painted in a portrait with a cameo, we see who it is because it's
his lover or some family member.
And here he holds it, we expect to see it and understand it, but he also covers her
face with his finger.
It's so fascinating how Mannerism evolves this style.
It's so different from the goals, the naturalistic goals of the Renaissance.
Yeah, and when you think about Mannerist portraits like these, in your head you can compare it
to something like the Mona Lisa, where she's not obviously posing.
And Leonardo's effort in a painting like that is seemingly more honest and open, and she's
engaging with you in a kind of expressive way.
Whereas in these Mannerist portraits, these two as well as many others, you are presented
with someone, but at the very same time you're precluded from understanding who they are.
Do you think that this has anything to do with the Reformation that's beginning to happen
or not yet?
Or more with court life?
I would say it's too early for that.
I think it has to do more with court life, especially because these are such secular
images.
That's true.
