Wild Camping Winter Comfort _ Sleeping Pads and Mats _ R Value

Outdoors Inspiration
15 followers
2 Video Views·Nov 15, 2022
Oh that's nice. Hello folks, I'm Seamus from Outdoors Inspiration. This is my
German shepherd, Petra. She always joins me. Today
I'm going to have a chat about the R number.
So just to make sure I've brushed up, I watched Prime Minister's questions today
in Parliament. Come on in Petra. Petra come here. Hello Seamus.
Not the R number. What are we on about R value?
Ah okay, sleeping mats. All right, okay. Yeah sorry, I thought
we're going to get all political for a second then.
Well that's a relief. Okay thanks, cheerio, bye-bye.
Ah right, okay, a communications error there. It's not actually the R number
we're going to talk about, but the R value. That's thermal resistance of your
sleeping pads and mats. That sounds a lot better to me.
And to be more precise, I don't just want to talk about the R value. In fact I'm
going to say very little about the R value.
But what we can look at are the type and range of sleeping pads and mats that I
like to use. I'm no expert in this stuff. If you want
to know the science behind how the R value works, and I'll talk about it in
brief, then I'm sure that there are channels
out there and I would recommend looking at the Thermarest site for a start
who go into that in some detail and can explain it far better than I can.
And as per usual, I'm not really going to do reviews on these. I'll tell you what
my views and opinions on my use of these particular pads and
mats are, but you may have different views and different feelings.
So let's start with closed cell foam mats.
I stopped using closed cell foam mats a long time ago.
Now I used them for many many years and they do have their value and I know that
there will be people out there watching this who will say, well there's nothing
wrong with them Seamus. There isn't anything wrong with them, I
don't use them.
There is a difference. But they have a limited
R value, that is to say they have limited thermal
resistance and limited comfort for me, and they take up more space than some of
the other mats that I use. So they're more bulky, don't have the
same thermal insulating properties as the mats that I use, but
they are or can be lighter. Typically with a closed cell foam mat,
a good one, you may end up with a thermal insulation R value
of about two, which is for summer use. Now I know that there will be people out
there that use closed cell foam mattresses
all year round and they'll swear by them in the snow etc etc.
Good on you!
But they're not for me. Now somewhere where we did use closed cell foam mats
quite a lot was in the Antarctic. Not in isolation and not on their own.
So what we used them for was an insulating layer between the floor,
the glacier, and our lilo. And I mean a lilo.
So the way that our sleep system worked back then
was that we would have a CCF mat on the floor
and that would insulate a thick rubberized lilo. And we're talking about
the type of thing, the blue thing with the
blue on one side red on the other with big bungs in it. So the idea of the CCF
mat there was to try and insulate the air in the lilo from the floor.
And on top of that we would then lay a full length sheepskin
and on top of that we would then have an expedition bag.
And those bags were extremely heavyweight down bags. No zips or
anything like that on them because that just leaves somebody an opportunity to
leave themselves unzipped. And we would have a thick pile liner and
I mean like buffalo style liner to go inside that bag.
And an outer bag that covered the whole lot
to ensure that your sleeping bag was protected from cooking and eating and
daily chores. So bearing in mind that some of the
field parties may be out for you know a month or longer,
six weeks, and even winter trips were sort of 10 days,
you needed to have a reasonably comfortable
night's sleep. So why is the R value of importance to us?
Well it's key really to having a warm night's sleep.
We can lose a lot of our heat through the ground and the R value tells us how
insulating effectively our sleep system is
against the ground. Since 2020 the R value has been consistently measured
against the standard, the ASTM standard, and that's measuring against a
controlled set of parameters. In a controlled
temperature environment a mat is placed on top of a sensor.
It has heat radiated through it and the amount of radiated heat that can be felt
on the sensor underneath is an indication of how much it's
allowing your body temperature to go through that mat.
If a product doesn't have an R number, ask the manufacturer,
ask the retailer. So an R number of less than two
is usually an indication that a mat is suitable for summer use.
Somewhere over two into three and possibly into the low four
we're looking at autumn and spring use and
five we're looking at four season use and six
is for extremely cold weather. Those are what those indications and
values mean. Now there will be variants in those
bands that's why i'm being very vague about it
and it's going to depend on you how you like to sleep whether you're a hot
sleeper, warm sleeper, cold sleeper and the other components of your sleep
system as well. So both of these mats are made by
Therm-a-Rest. They are self-inflating mats but I tend
to help them up with a bit of breath. Now people always used to say
don't blow them up because it affects them etc etc it's just got to be the
natural air pressure that inflates
them. I've never managed to get them to inflate by natural air pressure
and if you look on the Therm-a-Rest website they say that no harm can be
done by inflating any of their mats. So i'm
going to go with Therm-a-Rest they make the thing.
So I always top them up with a little bit of air. The shorter of the two mats
is a Pro-Lite 3 Shorty so that's about three quarters length
and the longer of the two is a Pro-Lite 4
full length. Now the difference in this is that one is thicker than the other
and one is longer than the other and I've got to be honest for
Dartmoor winter and even in the Lake District I've got away on a number of
trips we're just taking the Pro-Lite 3 Shorty down to about
minus three. It's probably not what it's rated for
however I always used to supplement it with some radiator backing.
Radiator backing is polystyrene lined with foil it's very thin about two or
three mil and I just roll up a few feet of it
around my tent poles and I'd supplement it underneath this
and it would help keep my body heat in for the night.
And you might well ask well what about the other end chambers what you're going
to lie your feet on and your legs they're going to get cold
well that's what I do with my rucksack. So the main part of me that I want to
keep warm the torso is covered by the mat
supplemented with some radiator foil backing for winter underneath
and my legs would lie on top of the rucksack. It actually is surprisingly
comfortable and I've had some really good night sleeps like that
but then as you get a little bit older you think well I can't be doing with
that kind of fuss so you move into a a full length mat. These Pro-Lites by the
way are now the Pro-Lite and the Pro-Lite Plus
not the three and the four. These are quite old
as am I. Now there are many manufacturers of self-inflating mats
there's loads out there to choose from OEX will make them you can get them in
Go Outdoors you get them from Mountain Equipment
lots and lots of people. The main drawback with some of them will be the
bulk and the weight but if you're happy to carry it that's absolutely fine isn't
it. At the end of the day it's a personal
choice and it's a personal choice as to how comfortable you want to be
or what you can get away with sleeping on isn't it. One really useful piece of
information is the fact that the R value of your pads is cumulative
so by placing one on top of the other let's say for example
that this is an R value of two and this is an R value of three
we now have an R value of five. Well that's great because we can have
one pad for summer one for winter and both for extremely
cold temperatures. Then about 10 or 11 years ago I
discovered the luxury of the Exped down mat. Down mats are a
great innovation because as part of their thermal insulating
properties instead of having all that foam
inside they're actually filled with down so when they
are inflated the down creates additional thermal insulation between you and the
ground. This is an old model and it's the down
mat 7 pump and one of the drawbacks is that
this weighs about 900 grams so it's not far off is it a kilogram.
The other drawback was that the pump system in this
which is underneath here consists of pumping your hands up and down over
these chambers whilst sealing off this valve simultaneously.
Although I've managed to make that work I've never found it particularly
effective. Consequently I've always just blown air into these because I've been
too lazy to get a pump sack for one. Now that can have a
detrimental effect on the down inside the mat because the
moisture in your breath can affect the insulating
properties of the down by sticking together
the fibers of the feathers. But it got to that point one day when I
just thought I've got to get this mat up and
I need it inflated so I blew into it and I've done it ever since.
I've had two in 10 or 11 years and one did blow a chamber
so the weld went and then this whole thing starts prolapsing and
bubbling up but although I've seen online people reporting that that's
happened I've got to be honest and say that this
mat has lasted very very well and it has been extremely robust,
very comfortable and very very warm. So there I was on holiday camping in
the Black Mountains with my son and I was using a down mat he was using
a down mat and mine prolapsed so the weld went so I had to get
something new to sleep on and it was summertime so I got my first
Therm-a-Rest NeoAir and this is probably the cheapest of the models
it's the NeoAir Venture and I've got to be honest and say I slept the rest of
that holiday on this and it was really comfy. One issue with it is that it
sounds like a bit of a crisp packet as you move in the
night but actually it's quite comfortable. I don't think
it's got a particularly high R value in terms of thermal insulation
but there we go it was summertime I think it's probably about 2.4
but couple this with another mat say a closed cell foam mat
a good quality one then we're going to get some really good winter performance
out of that so if you've got one that's 2.4 and
another one that's 2.4 well you're nearly at five there aren't you
and that's a really good high value so it's not all about spending money on
the on the most expensive mat sometimes you can
couple bits of kit together to make a really good sleep system.
Now I mentioned pump sacks which are devices for pumping up
some of these mats they're fairly simple devices they're like stuff sacks with a
valve on the end and that valve clips onto your sleeping mat
you then seal the end of the bag while it's full of air and you squeeze it down
and it'll fill your bag up however being lazy again thermarest
do this great little device called the neo air
micro pump very very simple I've been using one on the same battery for
for ages now there's an inflation side and a deflation side
obviously one for blowing the mat up and one for sucking air out of the mat
I've never had to use the deflation because this is intended to oops
this is intended to work only with the wing lock
valve system which is a modern system on thermarest mats this won't work on any
other mat there are other pumps available for
other mats not this one however when you unlock the wing lock
system air just gushes out of the mat when you
want to let it down it's absolutely beautiful
so I've never felt the necessity to deflate with a pump now I've mentioned
the wing lock system and the modern thermarest mats so let's
have a look at a couple of them so these are thermarest neo air
extherm mats they're wonderfully comfortable to sleep on
and have an r value of 6.9 now that doesn't mean to say they're
going to radiate heat I've heard people say oh they're too warm for me
well I don't feel too warm in my bed at night I want as much
thermal insulation between me and the ground as possible and this does that
for me now these both are slightly different this is the
extherm the standard extherm and as you can see it has rounded corners on it
top and bottom and that's cut down on weight I'm being perfectly honest
this is more than enough for me it's beautiful to sleep on
however for a bit of extra luxury I've got a wide
extherm max so the max means that it has square edges on it
it's not rounded like the standard mat this particular one is wide as well by
an extra couple of inches so the one on the right here is
absolute luxury to sleep on but it does take up a bit more space and it does
weigh a little bit more in terms of weight I can't remember the
exact weights I think this one is about the 500 and this one is about 600 grams
something like that but they pack down very very very small
now these two mats are so warm they've got an r value of 6.9 because
thermarest incorporate materials with a reflective value
within there to radiate your heat back up at you again
so they don't allow an awful lot of heat to escape
down through the floor but they are also supremely comfortable
and remember folks that this doesn't have to be expensive
some of those neo air exterms in fact the wide one is probably about 210
pounds the neo air venture I got for about 50
quid the pro lights I think I bought those
used second hand for about 30 40 quid so there's a whole range of
products available to suit a whole range of budgets and do remember that
the thermal insulation value of your pads is
cumulative so you could have something for summer
you could have something for those colder months and then you could combine
the two for the extremely cold months now I'm not going to stop and calculate
the cumulative value of all these pads together but what I do know
one thing for sure I'm going to have a very warm
and comfortable night's sleep so I hope this
little exploration of my sleeping pads and mats has been useful in some way to
somebody what we will do is talk about sleeping
bags to combine that with our sleep system on a later
thursday evening also on our outdoors inspiration outdoor
essentials sessions that I always record for a
thursday evening we're going to cover cooking we're going to cover water
filtration we're going to cover tents in a little bit more detail
there's lots of things we're gonna look at hard skills we look at navigation
as the nights draw in and start to get dark so stay tuned to the channel
look out for our regular wild camps so that generally happens about once a week
and then I have outdoors inspiration outdoor essentials on a thursday if you
like what we're doing with the channel please subscribe there's a button down
there somewhere it just tells me i'm going in the right direction
if you like the videos give us a thumbs up and a like don't hesitate to comment
because i'll always come back and respond to comment and additionally i'm
going to put a link in the description below for a
giveaway that we're running on this channel at the moment there's a very
short video on that link and it'll tell you how to enter a free draw
for a remote canister pre-heat tube stove
to set you up for this winter it's very simple but you've got to be in it to win
it we ready then Petra come on
onwards and upwards
