Why Doesn't the Earth Fall into the Sun - Monthly Mailbag

Science
125 followers
7 Video Views·Nov 15, 2022
Hello and welcome to Monthly Mailbag where we address your burning science questions.
We got a great question from a video where we talked about how the Earth doesn't fall
straight into the Sun. Kate said it was because the Earth has quite a lot of sideways momentum.
This is the same principle that keeps satellites, both natural like the Moon and artificial like
the International Space Station, from crashing down. But one viewer wanted to know where the
Earth got this sideways momentum. This leads to all sorts of other interesting questions like
why do the planets move in the same direction? And while we're thinking about the arrangement
of the solar system, why are all the planets in the same plane? And why are the big planets far
out? And what's the deal with the asteroid belt? To answer these questions we need to tell the
story of our solar system's origin. Space is a dynamic place with big clouds of gas and dust
swirling between galaxies, stars whizzing past, supernova exploding, and black holes collapsing.
In some regions of space you can find a lot of gas and dust nice and close together.
These are called molecular clouds. The movement of all the particles in the molecular cloud is
mostly random and there's a certain amount of pressure from when the particles bump into each
other. Competing with this outwards pressure is gravity, the fact that everything with mass
attracts everything else with mass. And if a molecular cloud has enough stuff in it, and if
it's closely packed enough and it isn't too hot, gravity will pull everything together, which makes
the gravitational attraction even stronger, which will pull everything closer together, which leads
to stronger gravity, eventually leading to total collapse. But if the initial conditions are even
slightly different, if the cloud is too large or too light, there won't be enough gravity to
overcome the pressure and you won't get collapse. And we really want collapse because that's when
all the interesting things start happening. The guy who figured out a formula for this critical
size and mass was a guy named James Jeans and he actually worked here. He lectured in this very
theater loads of times. He gave nine Friday evening discourses, he gave the Christmas lectures in 1933
on space and time, and he was actually the professor of astronomy at the Royal Institution
from 1935 to 1946, which is a position that no longer exists, but I kind of wish it did.
So once it starts to collapse, the angular momentum that the cloud had at a large scale is
conserved. And we'd expect the cloud to have some angular momentum because space is such a dynamic
place. All of the particles are whizzing about in random directions. It'd be very weird for all of
them to cancel out perfectly. Now, you might be thinking, surely if it's a random process, every
direction would be equally likely. So on average, they cancel out and you wouldn't have any overall
momentum. But there always is. Why? Think about flipping coins. If you flip two coins, what are
the chances of getting exactly one heads and exactly one tails? 50%. There's four possibilities.
You can get heads, heads, tails, tails, heads, tails, or tails, heads. And only two of those
cancel each other out exactly. If you increase the number of coins, you can ask that question
again. What are the chances if you flip 100 coins of getting 50 heads and 50 tails? Turns out that
there's an 8% chance. So 92% of the time, you're not canceling things out exactly. What about a
thousand coins? It's a 2.5% chance that you get 500 and 500. The more coins you add, the lower the
chance of everything exactly canceling each other out. But the universe is much more complicated
than just a pile of a thousand coins. There are trillions upon trillions of particles. Each one
can have any momentum in any direction. And so the chances that everything cancels out exactly
is very, very low, which is why molecular clouds always have some momentum. And that's why protostars
spin. So you have a giant collapsing cloud with a bit of spin. And as it gets smaller, because angular
momentum has to be conserved, it starts spinning quicker. The same way when a figure skater draws
their arms in, their rate of rotation goes up. And that increased spin is what flattens the cloud out.
Spheres will flatten when you spin them quickly, just like Blu-Tack on the end of a small motor.
So if you take a small sphere of something soft, like Blu-Tack, and you put it on the end of
something spinning, and then if you attach the rest of the power source and get it to spin,
and it'll flatten out. So what started off as a sphere just by spinning ends up as a plane,
which is exactly what happens when molecular clouds start to shrink, kind of when they
start collapsing in, they start spinning quicker, and they flatten out, which is why the whole solar
system is in the same plane and we don't have anything orbiting, kind of. So now we have a flat
spinning plane of material collapsing in on itself. And at a certain point, the center will
get dense and hot enough to start fusing hydrogen, and that's when a protostar becomes a star.
Meanwhile, in the rest of the disk, you've got a bunch of gas and dust whipping around,
knocking into itself. And denser materials like iron and silicates will sink closer to the star,
but are kept from falling in by the speed of the rotation and by the solar wind,
which is a fast stream of charged particles that comes from the star and pushes things out.
The bits of dense material keep knocking into each other and creating more and more material,
eventually becoming the terrestrial planets, Mercury, Venus, Earth, and Mars.
At about five astronomical units out, which is just shy of the orbit of Jupiter,
is the snow line, where it's cold enough for volatile materials like water, carbon dioxide,
ammonia, to become solid rather than gas, and so they can start smashing into each other
and accreting into cores that will later become the big planets like Jupiter and Saturn.
Jupiter and Saturn got really big relatively quickly, which is what allowed them to capture
hydrogen and helium before it all got blasted away by the solar wind. Uranus and Neptune are
actually thought to be failed versions of Jupiter and Saturn. They never quite got enough material
before the solar wind took over. So that completes the set of four terrestrial and four giant planets
around our sun. But what about the asteroid belt, that ring of material between the orbits of Mars
and Jupiter? Where did it come from? Because Jupiter and Saturn formed so quickly, every time
the bits in that space got even close to being planet-sized, what we would call planetesimals,
the big planets would essentially rip them apart, flinging bits into the outer solar system,
absorbing quite a bit of material, and sending some stuff inwards as well. And it's that inward
stuff that we care about because that's what enables life on Earth. In the early days of the
solar system, it was too hot for much water to exist at Earth's distance from the sun. You had
to get out to the asteroid belt before water could freeze and clump together. And then when those
clumps got started getting thrown around by Jupiter and Saturn, it's lucky that a lot of it landed
here on Earth because without that water I wouldn't be able to be sitting here in this
lecture theater. Life as we know it is impossible without water. So to summarize, where did the
Earth's angular momentum come from? It came from the angular momentum in the molecular cloud that
went on to form the sun and the solar system. But why did that molecular cloud even have any angular
momentum? Because of the statistical fact that it's very hard to flip lots of coins and have them
all cancel each other out exactly. And why do all the planets move in the same direction? Because
they were all formed from the same molecular cloud. And why are they all in the same plane?
Because when things spin, they flatten out. And finally, why are the big planets far out? Because
there's a lot more light stuff than heavy stuff in the solar system and light stuff only becomes
solid far away. Isn't the universe awesome? We tried something new with Monthly Mailbag this
time. We took an in-depth look at just one topic. So let us know what you think. As always, if you
have any questions, leave them in the comments below or reach out to us on Twitter or Facebook.
If you like the work that we do, make sure to subscribe for more videos. I also want to
particularly thank Merrick Kukula, the Public Astronomer at the Royal Observatory Greenwich,
and Martin Davis, the Public Program Manager here at the R.I.,
who helped me wrap my head around this nebulous topic. See you next time.
