You're watching a feedback session for the Spungella Animation Workshop. Topics that are covered: lipsync, body mechanics, acting, maya animation.
What experience do I offer? ✔️ Animation Director at Paramount/Nickelodeon, formerly Warner Brothers Animation and Industrial Light & Magic (18 years) ✔️ Teacher at Animation Mentor/Academy of Art University/my workshops (15 years) ► IMDB: https://www.imdb.com/name/nm1940902/
Need tips and help with your animation at an affordable price? ► Sign up for my Spungella Animation Workshop! $499! No minimum level requirements! From beginner animation up to advanced acting pieces!
You get unlimited planning discussions and 16 video reviews, which can be weekly or every other week or whenever you want/can submit, they never expire! Example reviews are available here on my channel.
All righty, what is it for their sound? I think Donkey Kong is the best game ever.
Donkey Kong sucks. You know something, you suck. Ladies and gentlemen, the volume inside of this
bus is astronomical. I think Donkey Kong is the best. All right, all right, so that is your
submission for two previous demo real animations. All right, the main impressions that I have,
I'm gonna bring down the sound a bit, is that once we start, there's immediate movement down here
and he moves from there over and it gets a bit tricky in terms of where to focus. Now, I think
he talks and that helps, but there's like if you want to make him fidgety, I think this could be
something where maybe you start the shot earlier to show him how he is, then this guy moves and
then you calm him down a little bit and then you have that moment of, you know, imagine this moves
first, kind of antsy, then this guy moves over, starts talking, he kind of stops, he's kind of listening,
then he has this bigger reaction, so we go back to this guy and then, careful, even though I'm now at
the kid's, you know, the focus there, I want to look at what the kid is doing, but then you got this
ginormous move on this guy, so I'm going back to this guy and watch out, they are a little bit tied
together in terms of their movements, in terms of what they're doing, so a little bit of a dance move there
like this sounds for this and I think his reaction is a bit too soon to sucks, I think you can have
four or five frames later, so you can finish this, so he hears it and then he reacts and after that
it's okay, because then he moves over, looks, gives us time to move over to the kid, he says his line
and then he has his reaction and then that's the end of that. Broadly speaking, I think in terms
of where we're going, where we're looking, that could be helped a bit. I'm not sure you need
this, this could be pushed over to the side, maybe some stairs here,
just because you got a lot of lines in there that kind of cut into the cleanness of the silhouettes
in terms of the shot that's needed. From a technical point of view,
there's a lot of stuff going on, where I see mostly a lot of IK arms
and there's just a lot of movement throughout, where it feels very busy. It gets a bit better
through there and definitely better through there. The beginning just feels very busy and
swimmy and spliney, where just things move like very separately, where there's an interesting
pivot almost in the middle of that wrist, breaking that wrist a little bit and then you have a lot
of straight lines in those arms. It's tricky, because I know you want to hold on to this and
keep that IK, but I see a lot of straight moves, sudden stop and it'll pivot point changes,
and even this here feels very straight as it goes and then stops. Then we kind of go back the same
way, then we go straight the other way and then watch out, there's some very separate moves in
terms of what the shoulders are doing, which are very strong. I know this is like a reaction,
but it gets a bit poppy in terms of what the elbow is doing, what those arms are doing.
And then this gets a bit strong and how quickly that chest comes to a rest, because it's not
extremely cartoony. So when you have those mechanics in there, it gives it a bit of a harsh feel.
But the main thing I'm seeing is that like here, is he still playing while he says this?
Is that the idea? Versus wait a minute and then maybe you can do this, where he might
watch out for the silhouette to it. It's a bit of a short arm where we could leave this,
and then that could hold on to the controller while his arm is out here on that, kind of
reinforcing that lean, like wait a minute, I'm going to stop playing to tell you that you're
the one that is not correct here, and so on and so on. That's the other thing, because I feel like
we're stuck in this constraint of holding that prop all the time, where I like that you have
some changes, so he's not always stuck in this, but it just feels like we could push
what he's doing with his arms and silhouette-wise and just body language-wise a bit more.
And I think this is a bit too relaxed, he gets very sleepy in his facial poses,
it gets a bit better through there, he gets more concentrated. And then for the kid,
getting broader notes, but there's something really wobbly in his thighs and even the pelvis,
where I feel like they're really, it's like he is holding himself up in the air,
so the butt is not touching the couch, and now he's just wobbling things around. That's mainly
what I'm seeing here in this area, and this feels getting very straight, very IK, which I know legs
are, but you know all that path, and you can see how this is moving and sliding over, while the
orientation of the foot is the same. It's very, the arcs need to be worked on a bit more, if you
want to do something fidgety. At the same time, it could just be simplified, where he just kind of
kicks his legs in and out, and maybe put that foot out this way, so we have a bit of a nicer silhouette
then, and the foot aligned with the shin there. Then as you go into this, careful when we have,
and a lot of rigs have that, where like the lids are aligned like this, just like the eyebrows,
where everything turns into this, and we can, hold on, let me just delete this here, and I think we can
counter those eyes a bit, so that the lids are a bit straighter, and you do the angriness just
through the brows. I think we are a bit high with the lower lids there, same thing here, see for me
the lids come out, come in this way, versus from there, so watch out, you might have to rotate those
eye sockets around. Speaking of IK, you got some intersections here, but this feels very IK, because
the path is very straight there, in terms of what the arms are doing, same thing here, it goes through
there, and it feels like, hey, the silhouette's a bit wonky with forearm, upper arm overlapped, the wrist kind
of broken for how much it's delayed through there, and especially here, broken, get a tangent through
there, you could have a cleaner, wider arc for a nicer silhouette, but this feels all kind of
broken through there, where I bring that elbow lower, and then it almost feels like his hand is
pushing his face around, through there, and then same thing with the other arm, as you go up,
it gets very straight pathwise, and straight pathwise up there, muddy silhouettes, because if you just hit
seven in your mind, without any background there, just be like, this kind of sticks out there,
versus, this gives us a better idea, this for sure, at the end of the day, broken, feel the wrist right
through there, just quick, and then you have very default looking fingers, in terms of the spacing,
it's not really an appealing hand pose, where they could be either more tight, or more relaxed,
depending on the motion there, it's okay here, I don't mind that gripping, the other thing that
happens is that, when he is like, yeah, you know what, don't get all sucks, he could turn around,
and be more like, I'm gonna talk to you, and then that way, we have a change in posture,
it gets more of the c-curve, and reverse, we can just be more aware of that line of action,
and everything play to camera, this guy is a bit three-quarter, that helps, it just, the silhouette
gets a bit wonky, in the shapes, and in that way, it goes, you know what, he could turn,
right, he could still have his legs, but he could at least turn a little bit, and then, whoa, and then
he could really have, you know, his legs over, and be like, oh, like, and hold on to this, like,
don't, don't yell at me, type of thing, because if you look at what the legs are doing to that,
there's just basically stuck in that forward pose, and I think we can then also play up,
how he's bigger, heavier, staying where he is, but he still plays with invading the other person's
space, versus this kid can, you know, if you make him fidgety, it could be fidgety, in terms of how
he kind of moves around, and sits differently, and stuff like that, versus just going, I kill legs
with this, but that's my main thing, I feel like there's a lot of, just IK problems, and just
general posing that I would revise, in terms of how to approach the contrast between an adult,
and a kid, and, and how to sit, and move, this gets into my, my usual pet peeve of, I wouldn't put a
in front of a photo, just because it's such a, such a style clash of what's going on here,
in terms of what he's doing, let's go back here, put some volume back, let's see here, so here,
hold on, where's the sound, my sound is gone, I know what I just did,
that's strange, that's okay, we can watch it without the sound, oh, because I accidentally hit
the speed change, ladies and gentlemen, there's some moves where, ladies and gentlemen,
like this really pops down, it gets a bit fast, and how the arm moves, and how it comes to a sudden
stop, gentlemen, inside of this butt, okay, just wanted to double check, in terms of if any, I can
look at it, in terms of animation, now, even like that flip up, feels a bit fast, and then, watch
out, gets a bit, gets a bit, oh, the upper body and head, I know she has an extra rotation there,
but there's something where everything kind of moves as one there, and this feels really broken,
how that hand holds the mic, this would be rotated in, to hold the mic, I would love to see any kind
of reference you have for this, how you got to that pose, so watch out for stuff like that,
sometimes she feels almost off model, in terms of how you push the shapes,
but the main thing to me is just the fast movements, that feels like timing breaks,
and then we kind of pop into a moment, it's kind of an odd moving hold,
and then, yeah, it's almost like a pop, and I don't know if that's an IK arm again there,
where it kind of holds too much, so that's kind of forearm overlapping with the upper arm, so I
would either bring this, you know, you want to break the arm, either down or below, to see the
structure of the arm, that gets a bit better, there's a timing, but then it gets a bit wavy,
in terms of what this arm is doing, especially with that turn there, and then this gets to me
a bit fast, it's almost a bit pose to pose, where just everything moves over,
I know there's a slight delay on that arm, but as you play this in real time,
and this gets a bit too, I know she wants to go out and broad, it's gonna be awesome,
this gets a bit twins, but I think what you could do, is put in geometry for this pole,
maybe for some of the chairs, and maybe there's another pole here, something,
then you can maybe play a bit more with the set, where she could hold on to something,
she can lean on something, I think what's happening now, is she is just constantly moving,
that's my main thing, I know there's some moments, where it feels like she's stopping,
but like right off the bat, the shot starts, and it's hard to focus on what's going on in her face,
because immediately stuff is moving, and all of that is moving until here, so okay,
a little bit of a pause, but then I feel like that's a bit of a harsh clunky stop to the
mechanics, but then back into bigger move, and I'm distracted by this wavy move here,
and then we're following this arm, and then it's another big move, and then it's another big move,
and then that, and that, and with a really big eye dart at the end, switching, which
he much looks at me, and I think there's just, besides that hole there, it's just constantly,
constantly moving, where, hold on, let me set timeline limits here, where I feel like we want
to work a little bit more on specific focus moments, where she can talk, hold, and maybe
play up a bit more with her face, and then go back into some broader acting, where you have
maybe one or two gestures total, and not something here, something down here, then down here,
then upper gesture up there, down again, and then a broad gesture, and then another kind of
sub gesture, the same of the sub pose there, there's just constantly, she feels like she's
constantly, there's no like build up, she's always there, right off the bat, we're going into
that kind of level, and I feel like we could have a bit more contrast in terms of
what she's doing, where the accents are, and again, maybe play up where she is, and use the set,
you just can again replicate that with some simple shapes, or you know, or you put her in a
different environment, but visually, I would not have her over a photo, and I know you say bus,
I was gonna say maybe she could be somewhere else, but she does say bus,
because the other thing that you could do, I know this is more work, but imagine you could stage it,
where it's a bit flatter, maybe, but again, you put this as a CG model, and then you have people here,
and you don't have to really animate them, but I think it could be really fun to like, they're
trying not to look at her, like someone's really loud in this, and maybe she could have, you know,
something with some speakers in here, it's like, you know, push this in terms of, I love performing
in a bus, I got my speakers around me, I love to sing, maybe she has a backpack with speakers,
kind of really, you know, stylize this, and all of these are kind of, maybe there's on the phone,
or just kind of looking down, like I don't want to talk to this person, that's weird,
and then you can have something where if person's here, she would lean over to talk into that
character's face, and then turn around, and you know, there's another character, and then she
could lean in there, so you have a broader movement of what the body is doing, some fun
interactions with them, and again, they're just kind of, they're just kind of there looking down,
that way you don't have to do too much animation, and then at the end, you bring one broad thing of,
oh, astronomical, and you know, she has her big singing moments type of thing, in terms of the
posing, and I would kind of play with that, since you're saying these were demo real animations,
like this feels a bit simple of character-centered over photo, and that's it, where I feel like,
okay, well, we place them in a bus, what else is in a bus? Well, you got the driver,
driver could complain and look back, you got passengers, what could we do with them?
What happens if you put, you know, this is the personality of this character,
then you got the situation of where that character is in a bus, potentially with other people,
so then what is the result of a big, boisterous, but happy and like excited person, maybe in the
middle of a bus with lots of people who are just, who don't want that attention, then what happens?
And then you can see a kind of interaction between all these characters, that could be more interesting,
that's what I will push, in terms of it being a demo piece. But that's just me, this was a lot
more work, so I'm just going to leave it at that, you tell me what you want to do with this,
how far you want to push this, and that's it, right? Thanks. All right, there's an email, you can sign up,
you can start whenever you want, you can submit whatever you want, you get 16 submissions,
either way, a like and subscribe would be awesome, all right? Thank you.