Fiscal Year 2023 Budget Request of the Department of Interior's Office of Insular Affairs

House Committee on Natural Resources GOP
41 followers
4 Video Views·May 18, 2022
Well, the economic assistance provisions under those agreements expire at the end of 2023.
So the goal is to get something to the Congress for its consideration before then.
But I would say that Ambassador Yoon, the President's Special Presidential Envoy for
the Compact Negotiations, has given a spark to the process and that we're well engaged
with all three of the freely associated states now and have plans to meet and to move things
forward.
I think everybody is looking to come to agreement in a timely manner and in a way that's mutually
beneficial in our nation-to-nation relationships.
Thank you.
I'll add my voice to the other voices that you've heard today in opining the importance
of getting those agreements renewed, not just for the benefit of those countries, but also
for the benefit of our own national security.
Talking about the OIA's budget request, the largest budget increase in the request was
for the renewable energy projects, and I know we've had a couple of questions about that
already.
My question is this.
This budget increase is specifically targeted at renewable energy, which I think many of
us on the committee support.
I'm a supporter of renewable energy, but also we recognize that renewable energy projects
come with their own set of problems and challenges, and in particular, in my own state of California,
you can see some of the problems that have been caused by a premature shift to renewable
energy at the expense of other forms of energy generation, because it comes at the cost of
grid reliability.
So when we're talking about parts of the world where grid reliability is already a problem,
why focus on just these projects instead of some of the other things that have been brought
up?
For example, upgrading some of the existing power plants to use liquefied natural gas,
for example, which would be not only more cost effective, but also enhance grid reliability
more than the projects that you're focusing on.
I think the answer to that question is that we do focus on traditional generation.
The insular areas require fuel for their base load capacity, whether it be diesel.
I think the Virgin Islands are using the good propane now, but certainly that's not going
away any time soon, and so you do have to be thoughtful about how you apply renewables
into the grid.
That's where our relationships with the National Renewable Energy Lab and with EnergyWeek to
work as consultants alongside with the consultants that are already there with the utilities
to make sure things go smoothly.
And we have invested in things beyond solar panels.
We've invested in things that improve the efficiency of the generation and distribution
systems, whether it be automation and things like that, in addition to solar panels and
battery storage that provide a level of resilience to a facility like a hospital in case of a
disruption, power outage, and that type of thing.
So we try to be thoughtful in how we apply the funds from the energizing and insular
community programs, but it's not fully limited just to solar panels.
Sure.
Well, I didn't imply that it was.
I'm just concerned because we want to get the territories up to a level of maximum grid
reliability as soon as we possibly can, and I want to make sure we're exploring all the
avenues to do that.
So as a follow-on question, let me ask you this.
We talk a lot in this committee about territorial self-determination.
Why not just take this money, give it to the territories for the purpose of improving grid
reliability and let them decide what the best use for those funding would be?
Most of the budget from the Office of Insular Affairs, we have a close relationship with
the territories and their leadership.
Certainly this is an application-based program, and the governors have a chance to chop off
on the applications from their territories and have a chance to say what their priorities
are, and we certainly take recommendations from members of this committee, too, for certain
projects, and we give them extra weight.
So certainly we do not make investments on our own.
These are grants that we award to these territories.
They apply for them and we award them.
It should represent their requirements and their needs.
Okay.
Well, I'm glad to hear that.
I'm going to join the chorus of voices in saying that I think what the territories want
the most is cost-effective, reliable energy generation.
And I think renewables have a place in that, but so do transition fuels like liquefied
natural gas, and I hope that the administration keeps that in mind.
Absolutely.
Thank you.
Great.
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
I yield back.
Thank you.
Ms. Porter, Ms. Keeley, you are next.
You have five minutes.
Thank you very much, sir.
I want to start by just associating myself with Ms. Radwagon's questions, and I am really
consistently encouraged by this committee's bipartisan approach to the U.S. nuclear legacy
and want to thank Ms. Radwagon for her leadership in particular on this.
As we all know here, but as I keep reminding the American people, from 1946 to 1958, the
U.S. conducted 67 nuclear tests in the Marshall Islands, and radioactive waste from these
tests is stored at Runit Dome, which is a leaking concrete containment structure.
Mr. Dunn, your office funds the Department of Energy to do environmental analysis of
the groundwater at Runit Dome, and they have been required by law to give Congress a report
every four years starting in 2012.
This is the year 2022.
Have they finished the initial report to Congress?
Not that I'm aware of, no.
No.
The answer is no.
Yeah.
Have they, and by they here we mean the Department of Energy.
Right.
Has the Department of Energy given you a cost estimate for what environmental monitoring
will take because you have to fund it?
To date we've provided them with $2.1 million, and there's $1.2 million remaining in that.
Great.
So I'm going to go there next.
So I know that you've given them money and that you have money remaining, but have they
given you, we're here to try to figure out what you need.
Have they told you, has Department of Energy told you what money they need to do the required
environmental monitoring to clean up our nuclear mess?
I haven't engaged personally with them on how much it would cost, and I would like,
it would probably need to be updated from whatever they had requested previously.
And certainly we would look at their request and provide any funding as appropriate as
required by law.
Will you ask the Department of Energy to tell you what they need to do the job that Congress
has mandated them to do?
Yes, we will.
We'll ask.
And if they don't respond, let me know because I want to be helpful.
You mentioned that you've given DOE $2.1 million and that there's about $1.2 million remaining.
When I held a hearing in the Oversight Subcommittee of this committee, Department of Energy told
us that, quote, this is one of their, quote, highest priorities because we have people
working on this all the time.
When was the last time these people working on it all the time at DOE gave you an update
on Runit Dome?
I haven't received an update from them.
I don't know that they would, but I'm not sure what they're doing right now.
I would say that travel restrictions for groundwater monitoring would be very difficult simply
because of the COVID travel restrictions.
Yes, there are definitely travel restrictions in place.
So let me ask you this, because those travel restrictions are a challenge.
Has DOE asked you for your help?
Has DOE asked, has Energy asked Interior for its help in getting an exception to the travel
ban so they can get out there and do this groundwater monitoring?
Not that I'm aware of.
Will you commit to this committee to working, to pushing, if necessary, the Department of
Energy and working with the Marshallese people to make that happen?
Certainly we would work with the committee and the Department of Energy and any other
interagency parties we need to be able to fulfill the law.
Your office is the source of funds for this program, so it is incumbent on your office,
the Office of Insular Affairs, to conduct oversight of how money is being spent, but
also whether money is being spent for the purpose it was intended.
So while DOE is the party here that is not doing the work, your office is the entity
responsible for making sure that work is getting done.
I want to turn with my remaining time to the Supplemental Education Grant Program.
It's called SEG.
And your office administers that program with funding from the Department of Education.
When was the last time the Supplemental Education Grant Program, when was the last time it was
fully funded?
It hasn't been fully funded to the level that authorized.
So the last time it was fully funded, according to my research, is 2010, 12 years ago.
They are supposed to be getting $6.1 million in 2004 dollars adjusted for inflation.
And full funding is going to happen this year and be around $8.1 million.
What are those grants used for?
Those grants underwrite early education programs in the Marshall Islands and the Federated
States of Micronesia, including some nutritional assistance.
Okay, so we're not fully funding a program that children depend on for food.
It's really hard to overstate the importance of that funding in a country like the Marshall
Islands where one third of children have stunted growth from malnutrition.
We just finished talking about the nuclear legacy, the U.S. nuclear legacy in the Marshall
Islands and how the United States isn't owning up to its promises on that issue.
I would like to enter into the record this story from last November about the potential
for China to take advantage of the United States' failings here.
I am really heartened that Ambassador Joseph Yun has been appointed as the special presidential
envoy for compact negotiations, and I think that is a positive step.
But ultimately, we have to keep our commitments with things like school lunches, with help
with climate change, with addressing that U.S. nuclear legacy.
Those things, our commitment to keeping our promises, are going to make the difference
between whether China or the United States has influence in the U.S. solar areas.
Thank you very much.
I yield back.
Thank you, Ms. Porter.
Thank you very much.
I'm a supporter of the Republic of the Marshall Islands, a really great advocate.
Now I recognize Mr. Moore.
Mr. Moore.
Thank you, Chair.
You have five minutes.
Thank you, Chair.
Mr. Sobolik, you noted that the GAO argued in 2002 that Micronesia and the Marshall Islands
served in a, quote, no role in U.S. strategy in the Asia-Pacific region.
Today, we know this is far from accurate, given the presence of crucial DOD equities
in these locations.
We can almost look back 20 years and say maybe that's why so much, maybe we're playing so
much catch-up now and why there is real struggles of, you know, in the South China Sea and areas
like that.
So I think you correctly stated that, and calling that out is nice.
As we look forward to future threats, what current assessments do you think we need to
carefully reconsider so we don't get caught flat-footed or, I would argue, more flat-footed
than we already are?
Congressman, I think that is the right question to be asking, and I think we need to jettison
the posture and the assumption that we are uncontested in our relationships with U.S.
territories and with freely associated states, and more broadly, that our presence in the
Pacific Ocean is guaranteed, because it's not.
It's absolutely not.
And you're right to link this to what's happening in the South China Sea, because ultimately
from a strategic and a military planning perspective, these Pacific island nations matter for the
national interest of the United States and for the American people because they are what
allow the U.S. Navy, the Air Force, the Army, and the Marines to forward deploy with relative
ease and keep logistics lines running from the west coast of the United States all the
way to Japan, to the Philippines, to Guam, Hawaii, and elsewhere.
These relationships with the freely associated states in particular are crucial.
They not only help us forward deploy, they also deny China's military free and open and
unmitigated access to the region.
But for all the reasons you mentioned just now, sir, I think we're realizing that we
have been assuming that this is a guarantee for us, and I think the discussion that we've
had with other members with the Marshall Islands and nuclear waste and others with how we're
falling down on our own obligations and with the Solomons recently in the South Pacific,
we have been caught in flat footed.
I think we need to jettison all those assumptions that we are guaranteed in our presence.
Let's continue on with that.
I appreciate you highlighting the freely associated states.
I agree, and I serve on Armed Services Committee, and members of that committee and I share
the concern and your concern of China expansionist behavior.
We can look at that across the globe, but in particular, if we keep it in that region.
You're advising the Biden administration.
What are some of the key things that you suggest and you would advise the Biden administration
to do to further expedite the renewal of the compacts of free association?
Yes, the main sticking point with the marshals in particular, which Representative Porter
was just talking about, is the issue of nuclear waste.
And the big hang up there until recently has been the Biden administration believing that
all claims in the situation were settled in the 80s under the Reagan administration.
I think it's important for the Biden administration to actually review the terms of the agreement
that we negotiated with them.
Even though the claims are settled specifically under titles 10 and 12 under that agreement,
title 13 opens the door to continued cooperation on both sides on continuing matters.
And you don't reopen the legal claims at all by doing so.
So we are not endangering our own position in the relationship at all by helping them.
And I think we have a moral obligation as well for all the reasons we've discussed previously.
This is the reality, I think, when it comes to our foreign policy with China.
A lot of these important issues that we could get hung up on have nothing really to do with
foreign policy.
This is nuclear waste.
This has to do with something that happened way back in the 40s and the 50s.
But it's a referendum on our trustworthiness as a partner.
And in that case, it is absolutely related.
So I think that issue is going to be a bellwether for how this stuff goes.
Thank you very much.
Chair, I yield back.
Thank you, Mr. Moore.
Did I miss anybody?
I think we've got everyone covered, if I got it correctly, if I got it correctly, okay.
So, again, I want to thank the witnesses for their valuable testimony and of course the
members, my colleagues, for their questions.
The members of the committee may have some additional questions for the witnesses and
we will ask you to respond to this in writing.
Under Committee Rule 3.0, members of the committee must submit witness questions within three
business days following the hearing and the hearing record will be held open for 10 business
days for these responses.
If there being no further question without objection, the committee now stands adjourned.
Thank you.
