What are the biggest problems within the cocoa and chocolate industry today? Are there any initiatives to challenge the status quo? We spoke with Charles Snoeck from IDH, a sustainable trade initiative. As Beyond Chocolate Program Manager, Charles is working together with different actors in the cocoa and chocolate industry to bring about systematic change within the chocolate trade.
Reconnect to the origins and future of your food. FoodUnfolded is powered by EIT Food, an extended body of the EU. This project is co-funded by the European Union.
You're listening to Food for Thought, a food-enfolded podcast.
Maybe we can just start with a little bit about who you are,
Charles, and explain your background for our audience.
Sure, thanks a lot for the invitation to speak about this topic I'm very passionate about.
My name is Charles, I work for IDH, the Sustainable Trade Initiative,
that is an organization based in the Netherlands that is,
such as the name says, focusing on sustainable trade.
And I work more specifically as Program Manager for Beyond Chocolate.
And so that is the Belgian Sustainable Chocolate Initiative
that brings together all stakeholders in the industry to
really move towards ambitious targets in terms of sustainability.
My background was not in cocoa and chocolate for the whole of my career.
So I worked for a couple of years in Belgium for WWF,
working specifically on the topic of imported deforestation.
Then I moved to Fair Trade in Belgium, where they pushed me into cocoa and chocolate,
which honestly was probably the best move in my career until now.
And that gave me the opportunity after a couple of years to move
as Program Manager for Beyond Chocolate.
So yeah, today what we're really going to discuss, Charles,
is the problems with the cocoa industry today and what is being done about it.
Especially given your introduction and the project that you're working on,
I thought that it would be really good to have this discussion with you.
So just diving straight into it,
I wanted to briefly talk about the history of cocoa.
How did we get here?
What are some of the biggest problems that are happening within the cocoa industry
or the chocolate industry for consumers that maybe aren't so familiar with cocoa?
I think it's a very vast question and there's a lot of different elements
that we could bring here.
First of all, let me start by being clear, I'm not a historian,
but I'm passionate about the topic of cocoa
and the work that needs to be done on supply chains, to be clear.
And I think that is very well known.
There is definitely an urgency for the sector to really move towards better trade
and trade that benefits the people and the planet.
That's what we are talking about today.
But now, how did we get there?
I think maybe the easy answer to this would be our addiction to chocolate.
And that started a long time ago.
Actually, cocoa and chocolate appeared on the European continents already in the 1600s.
So we're talking about a couple of centuries ago.
And so it came to Belgium that was under Spanish occupation
and it came from Latin America.
And so that's when we discovered cocoa and hot chocolate.
And there a whole culture of chocolate actually started developing.
And so I'm sure you know, and most of the audience will know,
that Belgium likes to define itself as a chocolate country.
You know, we have the biggest chocolate factory.
I think I can claim that Belgium invented the pralines also in early of last century,
right in Brussels.
If you walk around in Brussels, you'll see that one out of two shops almost,
figure of speak, of course, that is selling chocolate.
Well, I think it's not so much a figure of speech.
I've seen it.
Around the Grand Place, it's almost all chocolate.
And so we're very passionate about that.
And I think that also through the years,
there's a real craftsmanship that was developed.
And so there's really this culture of chocolate.
And I was also educated in a family where,
you know, we give chocolate to each other on special occasions.
Okay, you've got flowers, but the next one is flowers and chocolate, right?
We do agree on that.
And so I think there's a big fascination for the product and thus also a big demand.
Now, what we haven't seen enough in the last years and probably generations
is having that same love and respect in our culture of chocolate
translated through the whole supply chain.
And so that results today in indeed a couple of important challenges in the sector.
And here, I must say also, I prefer to use the word challenges and not problems,
because to me, chocolate is not a problem.
Actually, it's probably part of the solution.
And I think that if we can really transform our supply chains,
and again, share the benefits of this product that everyone is so fascinated about,
I think we can really have a powerful tool for the good.
But then we need to make sure that indeed we create and support this transition.
So then what are some of the biggest challenges within the cocoa industry today?
Definitely, and that's also the essence of the Beyond Chocolate partnership,
is that we have an agreement on the big challenges or the big topics
that we want to address together as stakeholders in this sector.
And there's actually, I'll try to keep it simple,
because of course, there's many things to talk about.
But I would raise four challenges and probably in order of importance.
The first one is the challenge of poverty or even extreme poverty.
And so here with Beyond Chocolate, the outspoken ambition is to ensure
that producers on the long term can earn a living income.
Living income is one that is sufficient to cover all your basic needs,
food, education, transport, health, etc.
Today, that gap between the actual level of income
and what would be a living income in the two biggest cocoa producing countries,
Côte d'Ivoire and Ghana, is huge.
Today, according to several studies,
producers earn less than one euro a day or even less than 70 cents a day.
Of course, life is cheaper in Côte d'Ivoire.
But let's be honest, also with 70 cents a day, there's not much room for investment.
So that to me is really the biggest challenge that we face in this supply chain.
And actually, it's not much different from other commodities
that you might also cover in other stories.
But here again, I believe that with Chocolate,
we have a product that can help to make a real move forward.
So challenge one, definitely breaking this poverty trap,
because the poverty trap, to me,
is at the root of all the other challenges that we have in cocoa.
The two next ones would be deforestation and child labor.
Deforestation, if you look at the numbers,
and I don't want to become the statistician here,
but if you look at, just Google a couple of satellite maps,
and there's been great work done by a couple of NGOs
to see the impact on forests of our consumption patterns.
And there in, again, these two countries, Cote d'Ivoire and Ghana,
they lost a huge part of their forest coverage.
And when I say huge, I talk about more than 80 or 90% since their independence.
So it is important, it is that important that today
we actually need to start talking about reforestation.
And so I'm not saying it's all cocoa,
but for those two countries,
cocoa definitely has been a driver of deforestation.
Child labor is another issue
that is widely spread across agricultural commodities,
but that is also relevant in the cocoa sector.
But here, I'd like to give you a quote
that was given to me by a cocoa producer
in one of my first encounters with a cocoa producer.
And he said in French,
Estomac affamé n'a pas d'oreilles.
And so in English, it means
that a hungry stomach doesn't have any ears.
And that is exactly what I mean,
with poverty is at our root
and we need to be able to solve that
if we want to really propose solutions
that work on the other challenges.
Because the reality for a cocoa household today
is that it's a daily struggle to put food on the table
and to put all your kids at school.
And as long as that is a struggle,
there's little room for other actions
and specifically actions
that are linked to sustainability targets.
So we need to address that.
The fourth and last one would be transparency in the sector,
but that is also a more general.
Yeah.
I mean, I think it was interesting,
your point about, well,
the fact that if you have a hungry stomach,
it's very, there's very little room for anything else.
And it was interesting
because with Food Unfolded last week,
we had covered a fair trade campaign
that I'm sure you're aware of, Charles.
And we had some of our community,
they had asked us,
oh, well, is fair trade more sustainable for the environment?
Like, should I even buy this
if it's shipped all the way from another continent?
Because this has been on the forefront
of many people's minds
in terms of environmental sustainability.
But it's a difficult conversation.
I remember engaging with some of our followers
and saying that,
but ultimately it's your decision,
but it's not one or the other necessarily.
And sometimes you have to bear in mind
that in order to achieve environmental sustainability
in the long-term,
you also need to provide a financial sustainability.
But of course you also have,
well, you can't necessarily have financial sustainability
if you don't have environmental sustainability.
But I think that's a very important point
that maybe a lot of conscious consumers,
we tend to forget about.
No, and I do agree and I understand the tension.
And I think that it's great
that this conversation is taking place.
And just like you say,
everyone should make his own choices,
especially if you're,
I think it's already great to be conscious about it
and to think about it.
And indeed, you might decide that for you,
one of the options of,
because here we're talking about
reducing your environmental footprint.
One of the options might be to focus strictly
on local ingredients.
It's probably a huge challenge,
but it might be the best solution for some amongst us.
And I think we need to respect that.
On the other hand,
and that's a bit of the point that I was making earlier,
trade is really a powerful tool for development
or a catalyst.
And I'm sure that we've all had these history lessons
when we were kids,
where we talked about the golden era of this or that city.
And I remember very vividly the golden era
of the Belgian city of Bruges.
And that golden era actually is associated
with really good trade at that point.
And so there you see that trade is really,
through the history of mankind,
has been a tool for development.
Now, the thing is,
we need to look at the quality of that development.
Is it the development that we want or not?
But my point here would be,
don't blame the tool,
but look at the results.
I guess maybe diving in more to,
because these are kind of the misconceptions,
I think that was actually in my next question,
which was what are some misconceptions
people might have about the cocoa industry
and its challenges?
It's, to me, probably your most difficult question
because I'm in it.
And I know that I tend to, again,
to talk about this with a lot of my friends
and family members.
So I think that the misconceptions,
I've probably tried to manage them in my close circle.
But if I can pick one that comes back sometimes
is that nothing is being done
or that nothing has been done in the past.
I think if you look at the cocoa industry,
definitely in recent years,
it has been one of the most proactive sectors.
I'm not speaking about impact and results.
I'm really talking about,
you know, unlocking investments,
developing programs,
trying new things,
investing in research to better understand
what can be done
and what results can be achieved,
what cannot be done and what is needed.
And so here I think the good thing with cocoa
is that there is a lot of movement.
I think that the less good side of this
is that sometimes there might be a lack of direction
because the challenges are so huge.
There is no simple solution to a complex problem.
And so there's still a lot to be discovered,
uncovered and a lot to be done
before we can really speak of a situation
that is acceptable or ideal.
But there is already a lot of dynamism,
a lot of movement,
a lot of investments also.
And so I think that this is really,
again, at the essence of Beyond Chocolate,
what we aim to do is really in Belgium
with this program,
bring all stakeholders together
to put all the pieces of the puzzle on the table
so that we can get a good look at it,
identify gaps, see what works, what doesn't work,
what are the conditions
to make some strategies work or fail.
There's a lot that we need to learn.
And here what is important with Beyond Chocolate
is that we try to do this in an inclusive way.
That was actually my next question.
Yeah, well, it is important
because I think, and these are two,
you know, two sentences that come back often
if you read about cocoa
or if you're interested in the sector,
you will see that no actor alone
can make the difference.
That's one.
And the second one,
that there is no silver bullet.
There is no simple solution
and there is no one size fits all.
And so taking these two points in consideration,
what we wanted to do with Beyond Chocolate
is really start working as a convener
and bringing all these expertise
and all these views and all these points together.
And so today in Beyond Chocolate,
you have actually coalitions
that are starting to be created
that regroup the traders with the retail,
with civil society organizations
that decide to work directly together
with one or more cooperatives
to try to level up our strategies,
our impact models with the ambition to deliver results.
Again, we're a proud Belgium chocolate country, right?
And here I like to just grab a quote from Spider-Man,
that with great chocolate comes great responsibility.
And I think that this is really
what the sector in Belgium wants to do.
We really want to associate the quality
and reputation of Belgian chocolate with sustainability.
And so we have high ambitions for that,
but are also realistic.
The challenges are rough.
And so there's a lot to be done.
But at the same time,
doesn't Belgium also source most of its chocolate
from, for example, Latin America,
where you have more niche kind of cocoa producers
that kind of focuses more on like
the quality of the way that it's grown.
There seems to be a difference in cocoa production
and where it's sourced from.
Exactly.
And that's also something
that is probably not known too much.
But so the origins of cocoa
are definitely in Latin America.
And when you look at the market today,
actually there's two countries
that produce two third of the cocoa
in terms of global volume.
And that's called D'Ivoire and Ghana.
So not so close to Latin America.
If you zoom out a little bit,
you'll see that three quarter of the cocoa
that is produced globally
comes from Western Africa in general.
So you add Nigeria and Liberia and Cameroon there,
and there you have the big cocoa producers on this planet.
Latin America still is an important supplier of cocoa,
but indeed you can see big differences
both in the production as in the product,
the end product.
And indeed what you've experienced
is like you say is more niche
and where actually you are in a market segment
where the tasting of cocoa and chocolate
is much more close to winery.
So indeed you can start associating different tastes
and that has to do of course on one hand
with the bean and the genetics of your cocoa plant
and of course the craftsmanship.
On the other side of the cocoa belt,
you've got West Africa.
And there what you'll see is actually
it's another market segment.
What you have in West Africa is the big volumes,
as I've said.
And so that's a totally different market segment
as actually they respond to different needs.
When I look around and I invite everyone to do the same,
just go through your supermarket
and start listing all products
where you can find a little bit of cocoa or chocolate.
You'll see a gigantic variety of products
where there might be one or two percentages
of cocoa or chocolate in it.
But so there's also a big demand on the market today
for cocoa that is not specifically investing
in a specific quality or type of taste.
But that's a segment.
And again, it's our addiction to cocoa.
It's a segment where you want to have big,
stable volumes that can guarantee
that everyone has his doses of chocolate
from time to time.
And there what is important is again,
stability of volume and stability of taste.
Not so much the quality part.
So you'll see big differences in the production.
In West Africa, you'll have one or two varieties of cocoa.
When you go to Latin America,
I know of cooperatives
where they are actually investing in seed banks
to try to work on the conservation of cocoa genetics
to be able to respond to the need of these niche markets.
But that's also, it comes back to the,
there's no one size fits all solution
because there is no one cocoa market.
When we talk about chocolate,
we think about the chocolate tablets
and maybe the pralines and this craftsmanship.
The reality is that there's cocoa
in a lot of products around us
and that maybe that's something
that we need to be more conscious about.
I think we don't even realize how much chocolate
we have in our kitchens and supermarkets,
but it's everywhere.
And again,
Protein bars or something.
It's not just chocolate bars.
Yeah.
And it's not necessarily bad.
Again, it can be a powerful tool for development.
And if we manage to develop that aspect,
I think we can really create a strong movement
on that market segment as well.
I think maybe I'd like to elaborate a bit
on the point there
that it could potentially be this tool
to kind of raise people out of poverty
because I know we also had this conversation before,
but there's been a lot of investment made
over the last few decades.
And has there really been much of a change
for the people that are actually living in Ghana or Cotiba?
Has it really done anything
or are we kind of just dabbling around
and it just hasn't really helped at all?
No, it's important to bring nuance
in the response to this question
because there's indeed a lot that has been done.
And the reality is that some strategies
or some projects might have better results than others.
Now, also, it is important to be very clear
when we look at the top line indicators,
let's come back to the challenges
and let's look at income,
deforestation and rates of child labor.
These indicators cannot be turned to green right now.
I think we need to be very clear about that.
The evolution over the last decades
has probably been negative.
If you look at these indicators,
deforestation has not stopped,
child labor and specifically also
with such a crisis as today,
we know that there's issues on that challenge as well.
And so if you look at the top line indicators,
we're not where we would like to be, of course,
as a society, I mean, as a whole.
It's true for cocoa, but it's true for many other things.
Now, what I also want to say,
this doesn't mean that we need to throw everything away,
everything that has been done.
And so that's why I really believe
in this constructivism or constructive approach.
Let's bring everything together
and have this discussion together
because we know that different actors
have different parts of the response
that need to be given.
And here, I want to also include the governments.
Here, we're lucky in Belgium to have an investment
from the Belgian government in such an initiative
that is also triggering companies to take action.
But we need to also develop ways
to support local governments,
to also invest in sustainable development
of their cocoa sectors.
Let's be clear about this.
Cocoa is an important economic facet
of Côte d'Ivoire and Ghana.
It is a particularly important commodity
to generate their incomes
and the incomes that this sector can generate
for these two countries
can then be reinvested in its people.
That's, of course, the ideal situation.
But that is the reason why I believe
that we need to be able to put everyone at the table
so that we can empower every actor in his own function
to take this extra action
because we need extra action, that is clear.
Yeah, I do see your point there.
And I do know that,
I think it was a few months ago,
or at least I've seen an article about Côte d'Ivoire,
the government had made a minimum premium
that needs to be paid on top of all of the cocoa
that's purchased from its producers.
And I think that's a great initiative.
And it's like,
this is exactly the kinds of initiatives
that we need from government.
But at the same time,
if that's not followed through by companies,
big companies that are purchasing this cocoa
from these regions,
you see, for example, with Fairtrade,
I know that they had increased their minimum price
by a little bit.
The farmers had felt,
look, this isn't enough for us.
We really need a higher minimum price.
And they had an 11% drop in volume sales.
And I think, of course, it's complicated,
especially with trade and product and profit
and profit margins.
And it's difficult.
But at the same time,
this is maybe more of a personal opinion than anything,
that I do think that certain actors
also do need to step up and really commit,
especially,
and I think this is actually adding to your point,
if anything,
because if the government does this,
but then the companies don't follow through
with supporting that,
then in the end,
it doesn't actually help raise up everybody
and all the actors involved in that cocoa supply chain.
But it's just, there's this sense,
and I think many consumers also perhaps feel it
because many of our followers have also mentioned,
well, is it not just greenwashing?
Are these companies really concerned about child exploitation?
Are they really concerned about deforestation?
Or is it just kind of something nice,
a little label that they put on their packaging?
Or are they actually trying to do anything and change things?
Because the general sense is that
when you see an 11% drop in sales
because the minimum price has increased,
it feels as if,
well, then these companies aren't really committing,
and that it feels as if the profit is taking precedence
over more, I guess...
No, I understand.
Ethical commitments, yeah.
Definitely, I understand your point and this discussion,
and there's a lot of elements in there that are true.
And here again,
I think that's why we want to bring everyone at the table,
and not only companies and governments,
I think, for example,
civil society actors have an important role to play in there.
I would like also to bring in producers and producer organizations
because producers are entrepreneurs.
They're not so much different from entrepreneurs
in other countries in the world.
They have a business,
and they want their business to succeed,
to be able to invest in their kids.
Very logical.
There's nothing much different about that
between a cocoa producer and me, for example,
except that probably the cocoa producer
will be more creative in reshaping its business model
to make sure that he gets the best out of it,
even if the best is far from sufficient today.
So we need to bring everyone into this story.
But here also, I think it's also today very easy to become cynical.
I need to admit also, I have my cynical moments,
and it helps to identify critical points also,
but it doesn't help to move forward.
Cynicism doesn't do that.
It has great value, and I love it,
but it doesn't help to move forward.
And so here I'd like to challenge the idea a bit
that the companies are stepping back
because of a small increase in price.
That is the case, but maybe as consumers,
we have a role in there to play as well.
Maybe they are stepping back
because consumers are not willing to
or because companies believe consumers
are not willing to move together with them.
It's just more complicated than that.
Cocoa in particular is a very, very competitive market.
And so here also, the reality is that
taking a huge step in terms of sustainability
generally comes with a cost, right?
The thing is that as a company,
if you want to survive in the economic models
that we have today,
you need to be able to have an economic model that is viable.
And here in a highly competitive market,
it's very difficult to take a giant leap forward
if you don't have the confidence
that your competitors will not take a step back.
Because if they do,
you are actually pricing yourself out of the market.
And so here again, this is to me
a very valid reason to try to create
that famous level playing field.
That is a buzzword now.
But that level playing field actually,
to say it in a very simplistic way,
should allow to, at the same time,
raise the floor and raise the ceiling.
You know, creating a zone where actually
the champions that want to take steps forward
are enabled to do so.
Also because they have the assurance
that their competitors cannot lower the bar on the other hand.
And so there you can try to create this positive movement
that step-by-step moves toward our ambition.
But to do that, we need to be in this together.
Do you feel for everybody
that you've kind of been in contact with, Charles,
that there has been an overall sense
that we really do want to actually change things?
Because I think that you see something
that perhaps a lot of consumers don't normally see.
You interact with stakeholders
that are within the cocoa industry.
And I don't know.
I think because there's this disconnect
for consumers also to this chain,
I think that it would be interesting
to hear your perspective on,
as somebody who has interacted with all these stakeholders,
whether you really feel that there's this sense
that there is change coming,
like people are really trying to work together
to find solutions.
I think so.
Today, I'm blessed with Beyond Chocolate
to have this partnership where stakeholders are active.
They are participating in meetings,
sharing experiences,
developing new projects and new approaches,
testing new approaches
to see if they can innovate also to trigger more results.
So indeed, I'm blessed with an active group of stakeholders.
And actually, that already triggers dynamism on the market
with new products appearing on the shelves in Belgium
that indeed raise the bar
and aim at delivering much more impact
for cocoa producers and for environment.
So definitely, there is movement.
And we need to be able to support that.
So it's important to see that as well.
Now, I understand that this might not be visible yet.
Also, this new dynamism on the Belgian market
is relatively young, but it is strong.
So I am confident that we are moving in any sense.
Now, I'd like also to maybe turn the thing around,
turn your question around.
And I'm pretty sure that you'll find very little people
that are ready to commit to sell or buy a product
that is actually supporting child labor or deforestation.
I have never met someone that is actually openly supportive
of having a product that actually is an infraction
to human rights or environmental rights.
So that is also true.
And what I see in a wide variety of stakeholders around me
is that there's indeed an acceptance of the urgency,
an acceptance of the need to implement new strategies
and to be bold.
Also, I think there's acceptance
that we don't know enough right now.
And definitely that we need smart mixes of interventions.
Just intervening on one or another aspect
will never be sufficient.
And so this discussion is going much more into detail
in the last years.
And I think that's a very good sign.
So my hope is that with the work that can be done on COCO
and on this lovely product that chocolate is,
is that we can hopefully start sharing learnings also
with other sectors and other commodities
because the challenges are, of course, not limited to COCO.
Definitely.
And actually, I just wanted to go back to your point
about COCO really being this commodity
that could help not be the solution to issues,
but be part of the change
to bring and uplift these people out of poverty.
Because when I do remember a comment,
I'm just bringing this up because it's so fresh
from our fair trade Instagram campaign last week.
But one of our followers had also mentioned,
well, the problem is that a lot of these farmers
don't know the true value
of what it is that they're producing.
And do you think that that's actually the case?
Because I think that perhaps,
again, we sometimes kind of picture these producers
and farmers as maybe like,
oh, well, they actually don't know
how much their COCO is really worth
because maybe they've never even tasted chocolate.
They don't see how much the world loves chocolate
or like in the West or something like that.
But I think that, I don't know, from the sounds of it,
that might actually be maybe more ignorant
to believe that because it sounds like
these producers actually know much more
than what we think that they actually know.
If that makes sense.
I'm happy you say that.
No, I'm happy you say that
because I think we need to also look at ourselves,
indeed, in all sectors,
not only in commercial sectors,
but also in the nonprofit where I've worked
for the whole of my life now, right?
But indeed, that might be a good misconception
to list as well.
I would here try to make the point
that we should avoid the infantilization of producers.
You know, most of the time,
again, they are entrepreneurs.
They know what they do.
They generally know why they invest
or why they do not invest.
And so I try to always remain humble
in that in relations
with many different types of stakeholders
and try to, you know, take a positioning
of willingness to learn from the other ones
and from the reality of their context and their needs.
And so what you see there is indeed,
Cocoa produces,
it is true that often chocolate doesn't manage to come back
under that form to Cocoa producers.
But I would not say that they do not know
the value of chocolate.
I would not say that they do not know
that this is an important sector.
When you speak about about,
I think it's about 6 million people in Cote d'Ivoire
that are working in that sector.
You know, it would be really weird
that they don't know that it's an important sector
for the global market.
You know, 6 million people working in it.
Again, that's really a lot.
And also, you'd be surprised also
by the level of creativity,
but also of efficiency of the investments
and the directions that they want to take
as entrepreneurs again.
And solutions that might come up from producers
might not always appear to make sense to us.
But this is where I think we need to learn to be humble.
And stop the infantilization of producers.
I would love to see the situation evolve
where producers indeed,
through better income,
are empowered to make choices.
Today, and I'll come back to the estomac family,
the hungry stomach.
Today, the reality is that
there's little choice available for producers.
Cocoa is called a cash crop.
Today, it is the crop that makes most sense to cultivate
because it is the one that brings cash.
Even though it is not sufficient cash,
even though there's huge challenges,
but we need to look at the bigger picture.
And so probably the choice of cocoa
is the best choice today in that given context.
And I'm not placed to say
what a producer should invest or not invest in.
I think we need to try to evolve towards a situation
where they are empowered to make choices.
And here I have a firm belief also
that people and myself coming from a family
with a lot of farms and agriculture,
I firmly believe that farmers want to take care
of the ground that gives them work
and that allows to cultivate products.
The reality again is that
a hungry stomach doesn't have any ears.
And so you cannot force sustainability to be a priority
as long as the context is not favorable for that.
If you ask a cocoa producer today,
what can we do to help you move towards
this situation of a living income?
The honest response will be buy my cocoa
and buy my cocoa at a good price
so that I can start investing in sustainability,
in sustainable cocoa
or in other income generating projects.
And so, yes, I think we should...
There's no simple response to that.
And yes, definitely, there's different programs
that are looking into that
and looking how we can create a supportive context
for diversification of income because they're also...
I think it's one element of the response
that we definitely need to look at,
but also that will not be sufficient on its own.
And then in terms of, I guess,
other initiatives that Beyond Chocolate is part of,
could you maybe share some
that have been maybe successful?
And I put successful in quotes
because I think success is kind of difficult
to, I guess, qualify
because it depends how you look at it.
I would say successful in the sense
that the impact models that are implemented
are an upgrade of what has been done before.
So I think with Beyond Chocolate,
indeed, we are lucky to have a lot of active stakeholders.
And so they bring a lot of expertise
and strategies on the table
that we can then discuss and evaluate
and see how they can build on each other.
And with this program also,
the Belgian government has created a fund
to co-finance projects
that aim at realizing the ambition
of Beyond Chocolate faster
and aims at developing business models
that we can upscale.
And so today there's nine projects
that are co-financed.
And these are really projects
that are focusing on the cocoa value chain
and indeed on raising the income,
ending deforestation and ending child labor,
but also taking into account that this is a process
and that we need to be able to evolve step-by-step
with a coalition of partners that makes sense.
And so definitely,
there's a couple of interesting projects.
I would label them as successful
in the sense that they are truly innovating
and that definitely some of these commercial partners
have decided to step up their game
and to develop expertise
and at some point also take risks
because for a company,
innovating and innovating in sustainability
is also a risk.
And so we have now nine pilot projects
with companies that are willing to take risks
to actually, you know,
support this transition of the sector
that we are aiming for.
So we have champions.
All right.
Is there anything remaining
that you would like to share, Charles?
Maybe for, yeah, our audience.
Yeah, eat chocolate.
I think it's a good way to end this conversation.
To me, you know, I've been lucky enough
to be able to have some good discussions
and even develop friendships
with a couple of cocoa producers.
And this helps me a lot today in my job.
And here again, I'd like to stress
if you'd like to make a difference
in the life of cocoa producers as a consumer,
this is a great excuse
to just put your mouth full of chocolate.
But then also as a consumer,
be conscious of your role and dig deeper.
I think there are products now on the shelves
in almost every supermarket
that are, you know,
that are going a step further,
that really already speak of living incomes
and of raising the bar
and of going one step ahead.
And these products actually
are a great tool for development.
And as a consumer, if you buy these products,
you're actually also supporting
the initiative of the company
that is showing their willingness to move forward.
And so here really,
I think it's time to, you know,
to make our concept of development and aid evolve.
And that we need to empower and not aid.
And this you can do by having great trade relations.
And yeah, basically that's it.
And that works for cocoa producers,
but it also works for the bakery next door
or the farmer that is farming
a few kilometers away from here.
If you want to, as a consumer,
to make a difference, get informed,
ask questions, ask tricky questions,
allow yourself to fail sometimes, it's okay.
You know, there's nothing in this world is perfect.
And I think that's okay too.
But what we want to do is have movement and dynamism.
And that's the only thing
that would be unacceptable to me is a status quo.
And so as long as there's movement,
there's something that we can work with to move forward.
So eat chocolate, be part of that movement.
Huh, maybe I should go buy some today.
I have my secret stash, such as most people.