California's War on Law Enforcement Explained

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
Sign up our newsletter 👉 https://ept.ms/CAInewsletter
My guest today is Vern Pierson, District Attorney for El Dorado County.
Is California experiencing a cultural war on our law enforcement? Are police officers being overly scrutinized for every action or inaction?
#california #education #publicschool
-
🔴 Enjoy Up To 50%👉https://ept.ms/3UO46vT
🔵 Stay up-to-date with exclusive newsletter: https://ept.ms/EpochTVNewsletterYT
💛Support us to fight for the truth👉https://donorbox.org/epochtv
We're talking about corruption amongst law enforcement here, and I'll say right up front,
I was a deputy attorney general. I have personally prosecuted members of law enforcement for
misconduct on the job. So there are some bad police officers. In every profession, no matter
how good the training, no matter how good the screening, you are going to have a few, to use
the expression, bad apples. Let's say doctors. We don't talk about it, but one of the most common
causes of death in America is a doctor making a mistake. We all accept that doctors occasionally
make mistakes. They should be held accountable. But we don't exaggerate and have news stories
night after night after night of doctors making mistakes and the media and politicians pretending
that this entire profession is full of people that are criminals and want to kill people,
because it's not true. And it's not true as it relates to law enforcement.
My guest today is Vern Pearson, district attorney of El Dorado County.
It's so rare that an officer is actually committing some type of
shakedown or misuse of their office or police brutality, things like that. It's not to say
they don't occur because they do, but it's very rare. Is California experiencing a cultural war
on our law enforcement? Are police officers being overly scrutinized for every action
or inaction? Keep watching for an insider's perspective on how law enforcement is handling
crime under the microscope. I'm Siamak Khorrami. Welcome to California Insider.
Well, thank you for having me.
We want to talk to you about the police. Some of our guests and our audience have been wondering
why the police is not responding like they used to do to 911 calls, to certain theft and robberies.
Can you tell us what's going on with the police?
Well, there's a number of things that are going on, but there's really been a shift
in the last several years. What I would characterize as a cultural war on police
that has essentially gone on where we have politicians and the media largely that are
misrepresenting and exaggerating misconduct on the part of the officers. That's certainly
a contributing factor within that. Additionally, you have staffing. As a result of that war on
police, it's very difficult to recruit law enforcement. What we've seen is that there's
been a significant decline in applicants. At the same time, there's a smaller and smaller number
of people who are actually working as police officers. Things are changing. We're seeing
people working more over time and being able to do less. But there's more than that.
Let me give you, for instance, in San Francisco over the last year, there's been a lot of media
attention on a cannabis shop that was burglarized a couple times. A number of stories about these
burglaries taking place culminating with the owner of the cannabis store, marijuana store,
putting a bunch of video cameras around the building and an alarm. The alarm goes off
middle of the night and two San Francisco police officers in vehicles pull up down the street
and they sit there for a short period of time. The burglars leave and they don't apprehend them.
The scrutiny from the media has been, why didn't those officers immediately rush into
that burglary in progress and detain the people? Let's stop and think about that for a moment.
I suspect what they were doing was waiting for a supervisor because of the world we live in.
You have to look a short distance to my county. Two and a half years ago, we had deputies responding
to theft of marijuana. One of the deputies was shot and killed during a similar type of incident.
It's very easy to sit back from members of the media and the public and say,
why aren't the officers immediately rushing into that situation? It's like, well, number one,
there was a danger involved in it. Number two, if they go in and there's a good probability that
the people that are there doing that type of crime are armed so they get into a gunfight,
then the question is, well, why didn't you wait and have appropriate resources?
What's the old expression? Catch 22. The law enforcement is increasingly
in a catch 22 situation where either way they handle the situation, they're criticized for
either doing too much or not doing enough. You mentioned a culture of war on police.
Can you explain this? What I mean by that is the members of the
misconduct, the occasional and very rare misconduct that does in fact take place
and made it portrayed as though law enforcement is routinely doing illegal stops, routinely shooting
African-American men, for instance, and they're doing it over and over and over again,
and they're playing it and portraying it that way. At the core of it,
back in 2014, we had an incident where an individual named Michael Brown,
and the facts are not disputed at this point. They were independently investigated by multiple
agencies, including Eric Holder's Justice Department. Michael Brown did what's called
a strong-arm robbery at a local liquor store. An officer who was in the area
made contact with him, and Michael Brown assaulted him and attempted to take the officer's weapon.
Eventually, there was a gunshot. The first gunshot that took place took place inside of the officer's
patrol car with Michael Brown fighting with the officer trying to take his weapon from him.
That's when the first round was fired. Ultimately, Michael Brown was shot and killed.
I'm describing an actual series of events that are very well documented
with forensic evidence and independent investigations, yet most of the people
watching this have no idea what I'm talking about because they've heard the story that
Michael Brown was killed by a police officer while he was trying to surrender with his hands
up saying, hands up, don't shoot. They've heard it over and over again. It was portrayed over
and over again. When the actual facts came out, a significant percentage of Americans
never really heard what truly happened. They believe that this was a murder. We have
very high-ranking members of the political class, the current Vice President of the United States,
tweeting things suggesting that he was murdered when they know full well that that's not what
happened. So you go from there, about eight years ago, and there's been a series of events
where the media has either misrepresented or exaggerated misconduct on the part of a
handful of officers. And we really need to put it in some type of context. And I'll say right up
front, I was a Deputy Attorney General. I have personally prosecuted members of law enforcement
for misconduct on the job. I put people in prison, law enforcement officers. So there are
some bad police officers. There are, in every profession, no matter how good the training,
no matter how good the screening, you are going to have a few, to use the expression, bad apples.
There's no question. And there's no question they need to be held accountable for their actions.
And as I said, I've personally been involved in doing that. Not a pleasant thing to do,
but it is something that has to happen. And it's our responsibility as DAs or prosecutors or
Deputy Attorney General at the time to do that. But that's a very, very small number. And when I
say that, there's data out there, 60 million on average contacts between law enforcement
and members of the public in the United States every single year. That's a lot of contacts.
Let's just focus on California and talk about specifically in California. In California,
you have on average about 1.2 million arrests taking place in the state of California.
1.2 million every year on average. So people that are being taken into custody for whatever
the reasons. Of those incidents, 1.2 million, you have about 2,000 on average, maybe
between 2 and 2,500 on average incidents that result in what people would characterize as a
use of force or some type of force. So it's not what people would call as a routine arrest.
So you go from 1.2 million arrests down to certainly less than 3,000 uses of force.
And then a number significantly smaller of that where a firearm is discharged and someone
is killed. And in the overwhelming majority of those cases, 80 plus percent, about 86 percent
of those where a police officer uses a firearm, the person that they are firing on is shooting
at them. And the person is armed and or trying them. And so then you get to a very, very small
number out of 1.2 million arrests where the officer has either done something wrong or has
committed some type of misconduct. But again, that is a very, very small number of cases.
In any profession, let's say doctors. We don't talk about it, but one of the most common
causes of death in America is a doctor making a mistake. We all accept that doctors occasionally
make mistakes. They should be held accountable. But we don't exaggerate and have news stories
night after night after night of doctors making mistakes and the media and politicians pretending
that this entire profession is full of people that are criminals and want to kill people
because it's not true. And it's not true as it relates to law enforcement. But for most people
who watch the news, it is portrayed in such a way and has been portrayed that the law enforcement
is the problem and that the criminals are really just victims of law enforcement. I mean, I know
that sounds like an exaggeration, but if you stop to think about it, that's really the way they're
being portrayed. So why do you think this is happening? I think it's more political expediency
than anything else. I think you go back to the expression from, I think it was Hearst that said,
if it bleeds, it leads. It's more exciting or emotional. It's exciting, yeah. To report on that,
whether reporting on the big picture of the statistics, like that there's this many contacts
and there's this many people working this police force and maybe there's a small percentage
are not the right people for this job. I think there's a certain amount of human nature within
that. The expression, the one that occurs to me is, I think it was a newspaper person that said,
if a man bites, if a dog bites a man, that's not news. But if a man bites a dog, that's news.
It's so unusual that a police officer commits a misconduct that it's news. It's the classic
man biting the dog, yet it gets portrayed that it happens all the time. And, you know,
30 years in the business, I've known an awful lot of detectives, an awful lot of police officers,
highway patrol officers. Most of them, the overwhelming number of them are people that
are very conscientious, smart, capable, and people who want to serve their community.
And so they get into this profession thinking that they can protect the public and be part of
the public. And that is, and then you take a tiny percentage. And as I said, you know,
I've done everything from prosecuting someone from shaking down Mexican nationals that were
working as migrant farm workers for money. That does happen. It is a practical reality
that, as I said, in every profession, you have a few people that shouldn't have been hired,
go astray, whatever it might be. They absolutely need to be held accountable. But it is a lie to
pretend that that is a large percentage or even more than just a very tiny percentage of people
in law enforcement. Some people are also concerned that there might be gangs within the police
departments. What are your thoughts on that? You know, I've heard about that. And I think
there's some evidence on isolated cases that there's been that type of misconduct. And again,
as I said before, a police officer belonging to a gang of any kind needs to be dealt with
administratively or criminally, depending on the circumstances. You should not be in a gang if
you're a member of law enforcement. But I think you hear about media attention on it. And it's
like so many other things, it's exaggerated. If you have thousands of officers, let's say in LA,
I mean, tens of thousands, actually, in LA County, and you have four or five that are in some,
I don't know, idiotic gang, let's call it that, that doesn't somehow tarnish the other thousands
that would never think of doing that. Yet it gets portrayed that way that it's common,
even though it's really not common. And that's kind of more newsworthy when you have those four
or five bad ones versus you have like the 9,995 that they're doing. And compared to other countries,
having lived, I've lived in Mexico and other countries and the police force there, you can't
trust half of the police force. Right. It's so ironic that you stop to think about, that's the
point, that we're talking about corruption amongst law enforcement here. And I've been
in this business for a long time. I've investigated quite a few officers for different things over the
years. It's so rare that an officer is actually committing some type of shakedown or misuse of
their office or their police brutality, things like that. It's not to say they don't occur
because they do, but it's very rare. And then you stop and look, it's like a country like Mexico
where 40% of law enforcement are on the take, 30 to 40%. I don't know what the exact number is. I
mean, you lived there. I was lost in Mexico City actually, and I was afraid of asking the police
because I had an accent in Spanish. I didn't want to ask the police for direction because I was like,
okay, I'm going to be in trouble. I don't know if I can trust these guys. I'd rather ask anybody else
on the corner of the street. Yeah. And yet you watch the media, media outside of the United
States, and they're like trying to gauge what is actually occurring here because of the way,
unfortunately, this sensationalism that has taken place here to portray a very tiny number of bad
actors as being the norm. Is there a correlation between the fact that there's this cultural war
on the police and the response time that we're getting with our 911 calls in LA
and the police reacting to theft and things like that? Yeah, there's a number of different theories
in terms of what's actually at work and causing some of those. Certainly staffing levels are part
of it. In other words, the staffing levels are down across America, particularly in major cities.
So that contributes to it. Lower staff, slower response times. But coming out, who was talking
about the killing of Michael Brown, there's some that theorized, and they call it the Ferguson
effect. The Ferguson effect was that Darren Wilson, the officer there, was completely in the right,
doing his job, engaging with a subject that had just committed a strong arm robbery. And then he
was villainized by the media over and over again over a period of time to where he left law
enforcement as doing some other job in hiding because he was so hated for something that he
was portrayed as doing that he didn't actually do. Some have theorized that because of that,
officers are less likely to make contact with criminals and that they will hold back more and
wait for more resources or wait for other people to be there. I don't know if that's the direct
cause of what people are saying. I certainly think it's a reasonable reaction for an officer that's
by themselves who makes contact with someone or sees someone to wait for another officer before
making contact in that. And not just because of cases like that in the media scrutiny, but because
of some of the policies. Policies that have been adopted here in California and other states that
require officers to have a plan going in, have a plan going out, and it causes them to delay because
it's like, well, I need to make sure that I'm doing things appropriately consistent with the
law now. So I think all of those things play a factor on it. I do think though that statistically
the most basic causes of crime going up start with the number of officers and what those officers
are doing. As the officers numbers go up, crime goes down. As the number of officers go down, crime
goes up. And then you add in all sorts of different factors like George Gascogne's
directive saying no firearm use enhancements and suddenly we have more people carrying guns in LA.
That is a direct cause of his poorly thought out policy. Some people wonder when these shootings
happen when the police is involved. Sometimes they fire a lot of shots. Some people are like,
why don't they hit them in the legs or somewhere? And what are your thoughts on that?
Well, there's a couple of different things. It's a very interesting question because
they'll look at it and say, well, why do they have to fire so many times? And it's like, well,
in the way law enforcement is trained and we're always in need of revisiting training and saying,
well, we could get better about this. We can do that. And I think that is happening. There's some
training changes. But from the military, when I was in the military to law enforcement training,
over the last 100 years, they've all followed this basic same pattern that you line up officers,
they stand on a line, they're firing at targets. They're told to, they're put in a situation where
it's a silhouette that they're shooting at. And they say, gun, something like that. And then they
fire at the target and they're trained to fire until the target is no longer a threat. It's
considered a threat is what they're doing. But because of the way they're trained,
they fire multiple times. So if you have three or four officers there and one of them fires,
there's this thing called sympathetic firing to where you hear somebody else, then you assume
there's a threat that you need to fire as well. And it's a subconscious approach to it. And then
multiple rounds are fired. But it happens very fast. I challenge people who are interested in
this. I've challenged you and I can help set it up if you're interested. Go through a simulator.
Have you ever been in a simulator? Go through a use of four simulators. I've been involved in
training detectives and prosecutors on how to investigate use of force incidents for many years.
What I always say to them is you're not qualified to do this work, to investigate these cases.
If you're not willing to put yourself in that situation to either do a use of force where
you're in a scenario and it's all around you and you're watching a video, you have a firearm,
you need to react to what's happening. So it's like a few seconds to decide. A few seconds to
decide. And what you realize is that the way your brain reacts to it is different in a traumatic
situation like that. And it's things that we see. I mean, just think about driving down the street.
Driving down the street, you see a car that slows or stops. There's a brief period of time that it
takes your brain to say, okay, the car, there's red lights in front of me. I need to react to this
somehow. My decision is going to be to put my foot on the brake and slow down. The same type
of thing happens with a police officer when they're confronting a situation on the street.
And remember, we call them to all sorts of situations. Police officers are called to
everything from a, I saw someone recently, a police officer delivered a baby. And those happen.
They get called to that. They get called to a fire. They get called to a domestic violence. They get
a typical day, depending on the city and the jurisdictions, all sorts of different things.
They have to be prepared for things that it's frankly impossible to be prepared for. And the
expectation is. So they have to go into that and then they react to those situations. And you try
to train them the best that you can. And you use force simulators. You use things called simunitions
where you actually feel, you know, it's like a paintball type thing is fired at you. And I think
anybody who's interested in this, you should experience it and see for yourself that it's
not the same as what, you know, it's not like a video game. It's a little bit different than that.
Is it hard for them when they're in that moment to aim for somebody's feet? Or I've heard this
from a lot of different people that why don't they shoot them in the feet or somewhere that
is not fatal? What are, is it very difficult to do? Is it hard to do the shooting or is it?
Well, so yes, this common thing of shoot for the, why didn't they shoot for the leg? And it's like,
it's almost to the point of laughable to anybody who is familiar with firearms.
Well, number one is if you shoot somebody in the leg or the upper torso, you have the possibility
of bleeding out very quickly. So it's not exactly that much safer to do that. But in what we see,
and we've seen this for many years, is that people in a traumatic event, like a shootout,
remember oftentimes someone is shooting, you know, this is like a two-way range. Someone is
shooting at the officer, the officer shooting back at that person. And in that type of excitement,
the people who, you know, train officers have made the judgment a long time ago
that it's far better to focus on the center mass of the target in order that they're not
shooting all over the place. And trying to shoot somebody in the leg or arm, things like that,
is more likely to one, either result in you missing them and not disabling or stopping the threat.
Because remember officers really should, and again, as I said before, there have been officers
who have murdered people on the job. There have been officers who have committed all sorts of
different types of misconduct. It's rare, but it does happen. But most of the time,
they are in a life or death situation when they discharge their firearm. And I think the judgment
is that it's far better to teach them to shoot directly at the center mass of the target,
or the threat, I should say, in that incident. And now this must be a very difficult job. It
seems like we can't recruit enough because of this cultural war. So these people are looked
down upon now because of the media, right? And it's a very difficult job. It looks like
you have to go from one call to another one and who knows what you're going to get yourself into.
It's a very difficult job, both physically, emotionally, it's hard on your family,
the types of things that officers, firefighters as well, that they respond to what they see,
the most long-term emotional toll that it is on them. And then to be portrayed as being villains
just makes it that much worse. I think if you talk to most officers today, and people have been
around for 20 years or so, and you say, if your son or daughter was interested in law enforcement,
would you recommend them pursue a career in law enforcement? Most would tell you they would
encourage them not to go into law enforcement, do something different because of that. That has
really hurt recruiting. And throughout the United States, really, this whole cultural war on the
has resulted in us having fewer and fewer officers on the street. And statistically, we know
the most effective deterrent to crime, the thing that causes crime to go down, or the reverse of
it causes crime to go up, is the number of officers that you have on the street. There's
been numerous studies that have looked at, over the last 20 or 30 years, that 10% more officers
in a given agency results in a crime reduction of between 3% and 7% reduction in overall crime.
So by having more officers, you have less crime. What we're seeing in America right now is we have
fewer and fewer officers, particularly in larger agencies, fewer and fewer officers that are
actually... So like in Los Angeles and San Francisco, we are short of officers, right? Yeah, we're having mass
numbers of retirements. And academy classes, LA County, or actually LAPD, because of COVID and
other reasons, recruiting, they should be running multiple classes at any given time. And they're
far behind on that because they can't get enough qualified people to come through the pipeline to
become a police officer. Now, what's the solution to this? Is there a way for this to turn back
around? Or is crime going to go up? Where are we right now? And what is the solution?
You know, for me, sitting on the outside, in some sense, I live in a county that has very low crime.
We're between, you know, Eldorado County, Placer County, a few other counties, we have the lowest
crime per capita. We have very good law enforcement. We have very good community engagement.
We have officers that, laterals, where they come from one agency up to Eldorado County.
And they say, you know, I talk to them and say, hey, why'd you move here? And they're like,
I can sum it up this way. They have community appreciation days for law enforcement because
people appreciate law enforcement. We have to change that. We have to change it in cities
like Sacramento, Los Angeles, San Francisco, to where the public does not see law enforcement as
the enemy. Instead, they need to see law enforcement as part of the community. I mean,
I read the LA Times and the coverage of it. And you would think that LAPD is a all-white,
very aggressive law enforcement agency. And nothing can be further from the truth. It is a
very integrated, a lot of women, a lot of people of very different ethnic backgrounds within LAPD.
And yet, you don't see that represented by the media. And it's shameful. We need to change that.
We need to change the way the media covers and portrays law enforcement here in California.
Do you think things will change anytime soon? Or do you think there will be
more of these people quitting the police force? Well, I certainly hope that we change. I think
the way we see crime going up, I mean, we're at a point now where LAPD is reporting that they've
had a 24% increase in homicides over the last two years, year to date between 2020, year to date to
2022. 24% increase in homicides. Overall homicides in the state of California are up dramatically.
No, they're not as high as they were in 1992, which was the record going back 30 years.
But we're on track within a year or two to get back up to those numbers. And it's devastating,
devastating number of homicides. And I hear, I see stories in the media where they say,
well, they're not as bad as it was in 1992. It's like, yeah, but they're higher than they've been
in the last 15 years. And they're dramatically higher over the last two or three years. And if
that trend continues, we will be right back to- And most of the residents are very concerned
in LA and even other cities that we have talked to on the show, but the media hasn't really
acknowledged it. Yeah, the media has been very slow to acknowledge it. And the way I would say
is that I have a conversation with a reporter out of LA and I casually said, you're basically saying
don't believe your lying eyes, to use that expression. People are seeing the crime,
they're feeling the crime. If you go to San Francisco, let me give you a good example on it.
People are saying, well, the property crime data shows that it's increased, but it hasn't increased
that much. Anybody that goes to San Francisco right now, if you're from out of the area,
if you talk to a local, they will tell you, leave your windows down on your car
because if you don't, it's going to be burglarized by the time you get back. But if you leave it down,
they'll look around in your car and see that you haven't left anything valuable
and then they won't take anything. That means crime is up. Crime is up dramatically.
The reporting is lagged because people think there's no sense in reporting some of the crimes
that's occurring. For property crimes, we're maybe reporting one in three that are actually
occurring, so the data doesn't necessarily reflect it. But you can't hide homicides and
shootings. Those things are more accurately reporting and they're up dramatically.
So Vern, what you're saying is that we have a lot of police officers and these officers
have a lot of interactions with the public, but there's only a few that become really big
stories. But when they happen, they're so traumatic, somebody dies, and then the public
just remembers that. Is that what you're saying? I think that's exactly right. I think it's exactly
right that it's a rarity. Let's put it this way. The media stopped covering car accidents
a long time ago. Why? Because they happen frequently, unfortunately, and tragically,
sometimes people are killed in car accidents. But they're so common that they're not covered
anymore. Just like that, law enforcement officers who commit misconduct, it's so infrequent,
it's so rare, that it's a big deal. And so it gets far more coverage and it makes it seem as
though it's a common occurrence when it really isn't. And when they do a good job, they don't
get any coverage, right? No, they don't get coverage. Or they get less. They do a good job
by, whatever it might be, solving a big crime, there'll be a little bit of attention. Generally,
the officers, the friend that works for LAPD for robbery homicide, and he's solved a number of
really significant, difficult cases, that if you heard about it because it was a significant case,
you might hear about it, but you certainly don't hear that the detective that did extraordinary
work on the case to solve a difficult case, you don't really ever hear that side of it.
Do you have any other thoughts for our audience?
No, I hope it changes. I think your question about how do we change this,
the practical reality is we need more police officers. We need good police officers. And by
villainizing law enforcement, we're causing more harm than good. And we need to change that trend.
Vern Pearson, District Attorney of El Dorado County, it was great to have you on California
Insider. Thank you. Thank you for watching. Please click the icon on the left to subscribe
to our channel. We bring you the most pressing issues California is facing
with straightforward and in-depth interviews. See you in the next video.
