Why was this recipe SECRET for 60 years

Cooking Company
48 followers
1 Video View·Nov 8, 2022
So today we're doing a cocktail that's so secret,
its recipe had been buried for nearly 60 years.
Today we're doing the Missionary's Downfall.
Today's cocktail is going to be blended.
And so I want to use this Nutribullet
because you can use a Vitamix or like a more powerful blender,
but I think this actually does a better job.
I think it's cheaper.
And it's just so much easier to put it all in here
than just, you know, blend it.
So we're going to take half a cup of mint leaves
and the recipe said half a cup of mint leaves packed.
So I kind of packed them in there a little bit.
I think it's a little bit over half a cup.
I think it'll be fine.
And then we're going to do three quarters of an ounce of honey syrup.
So originally Don the Beachcomber did a honey mix for this cocktail,
which is a one-to-one water honey ratio,
but to me that's just too thin
and you're not going to feel the honey in it at all.
So I'm doing a three-to-one,
like this is my normal three-to-one ratio.
Three quarters of an ounce of lime juice.
One ounce pineapple juice.
Half an ounce of creme de peche,
peach liqueur.
An ounce and a half of Cuban or Cuban-style light rum.
So by Cuban-style we would mean like Bacardi,
which used to be Cuban but is now Puerto Rican,
but it's still kind of in that same vein.
And then one cup of pebble or crushed ice.
Add it to our thing.
Blend it all up.
It has this nice smoothie consistency.
Now, normally this would go into a snifter,
but I decided I'm going to put it into a poco grande glass.
And then we're just going to fill it up like so.
And then, last but not least,
we're going to take some big bushy mint sprig here.
And if you wanted to, you could do a little pineapple wedge,
although I'm not going to do that today.
We'll get a little slappy poo in the crushy pants.
Stick it in there.
Voila!
There you have the missionaries downfall.
Oh my god, that's heaven.
It's heaven!
You know, here's the thing.
This is the very first time that I ever made this drink.
And I will say that I had my doubts
because you would think that when you shred up the mint that way,
that you'll get all the chlorophyll from the leaves, right?
And it would be very, you know, minty but vegetable-y.
And that is not the case.
This is actually really fantastic.
It's got a nice juxtaposition
between the honey syrup, creme de peche, and the pineapple.
But what's nice is that the mint is really prevalent,
but it hits you later.
So it's not like super minty up front.
It's really tropical-y up front.
And then you have this nice, like, kind of back mint.
If that makes sense.
Does that make sense?
Back mint.
Mmm.
That is fantastically good.
This is gonna be hard not to finish that before we do the thumbnail.
It's very, very good.
The story of this cocktail goes that it was created by Don the Beachcomber.
It was very popular in the 1940s,
but it could have been created as early as 1937.
And it was a closely guarded secret for 60 years.
Nobody knew the recipe.
And then, an enterprising bartender named...
I said enterprising bartender a lot today.
Anyway, a very...
But he is enterprising.
So an enterprising bartender named Jeff Beachbunberry
decided that he was gonna find out what the recipe for this drink was.
At some point, he found an ex-employee of Don the Beachcomber's
that worked there for 40 years
and convinced him to give up the goods on this cocktail.
And so he got the original recipe.
Or the original recipe as we know it.
The only recipe we're gonna have for it anyway.
It is a fantastic drink.
It is so nicely balanced, this drink.
It is fantastic.
So, do yourself a favor and make yourself a Missionary's Downfall.
Wah!
Ooh, that's... that's full.
Is this like a mint smoothie?
Yeah, kind of.
Yeah, it did.
You know, this is really annoying.
The only drawback to this thing is that the little ring,
the seal ring, comes out of this every now and again
if you don't screw it in.
Get in there, you ******.
Get in there.
Ah! So annoying!
That's not a stupid design.
So today, we're doing a cocktail...
So today, we're doing a cocktail that is so secret,
the recipe has...
So today, we're doing a cocktail that's recipe...
So today, we're doing a cocktail that's so secret,
the recipe is...
...to use this vitamin...
It's not a Vitamix.
No, it is a NutriBall.
Yeah.
I was like,
did I put that to the three-quarter mark?
No.
But they do.
They do, yeah.
No, I was...
Well, now I don't know.
Well, because it's funny because this is called
A Missionary's Downfall.
Right.
But then you were like,
did you see Murder...
The Murder of Mor...
What was it called?
Murder Among Mormons.
Murder Among Mormons,
which is literally A Missionary's Downfall.
No, well, now it's like,
how much should I spoil from the thing?
But it made me think...
Just say Spoiler Alert.
Spoiler Alert.
If you guys are watching Murder Among Mormons,
definitely tune out now.
Okay.
Now, spoil it.
I don't really care.
So the guy that it's about,
what's this like rare books thing?
He found all kinds of old manuscripts.
Oh, yes.
And he was forging.
And he's forging everything.
He was forging like plates from like the original
Mormon guy.
What's his name?
John Smith or whatever.
The original Mormon and like...
He was like,
and he got a little too greedy.
And when he started finding all the stuff that people
were asking for,
he was like,
oh, can you find this thing?
And like,
yeah, probably.
And that's how he got caught.
He also like,
he also almost sold to the Congress,
the Library of Congress,
the first printed,
the first oath of a free man,
which was the first printed American anything.
Right.
And they almost bought it.
And then because of the Mormon thinking,
they got blown up and didn't actually sell it.
But what if a G.F. Beach-Bomberi didn't actually discover
anything?
He just like,
G.F.?
G.F., yeah.
Did you say G.F.?
No, G.F. Beach-Bomberi.
What if he just forged all of it?
He just made up all these recipes,
and he just pretended like he found it.
It would be a scandal in the tropical drinks community
if that happened.
I don't think that he did that,
though.
Nobody thought the Mormon.
There are too many people involved,
though,
because he's like,
I went to this particular person and calls them out
by name.
I went to this particular person to ask their family
or to ask them to look in the,
you know,
so like,
he found like,
he went to the families of specific bartenders and found
their actual notebooks and stuff.
So he could be making that up,
but then don't you think the families of those people?
I mean,
unless they're all dead or something,
but like if they're alive,
then they would just call it out.
So it'd be like too easy to trace.
I don't know.
Maybe they're all in on it.
Maybe,
maybe,
maybe you think that he,
I mean,
he would have definitely,
I don't think he turned it into a lot of money like
the Murder Among Mormons guy,
though,
because I mean like,
how many books do you think he sells?
Like he probably,
you know,
he's made a very good reputation for himself.
He is,
yeah,
he probably goes like speaking and stuff and cocktail
programs or what not.
But I'm just wondering though,
I'm just wondering,
does Jeff Beach Bumberry watch this channel or have,
or are aware of us at all?
And if so,
is he going to see this and then take offense to your
positing the query that he might be forging tiki ingredients?
I mean,
only if he is,
right?
But I got to say,
if he's making up all of these recipes,
they're fantastic recipes.
So,
I mean,
that's,
yeah,
I'm in for it anyway,
you know.
So there it is.
