Should you save or invest when it comes to your financial goals? I have two different scenarios that you should consider so you can maximize saving for the short term and investing for the long term!
Disclosure: Links contain affiliates. When you buy through one of my links, I will receive a commission. This is at no cost to you and helps support my channel!
If you've ever been confused about whether you should save
or invest first, what does that process look like?
I'm here to tell you that there are actually
a couple different scenarios that you should consider
and I think you're going to fall into one of two camps.
We're gonna go over that in this video.
Before we get started, if you are interested
in getting your own personal finance questions answered
in a private setting, we can do so
through my budget coaching program, Budget Bootcamp,
which I will link in the description box below.
Let's go ahead and talk about should you save or invest?
Hey guys, it's Justine with Debt-Free Millennials,
the channel to help you crush your debt
and live payment-free.
So I actually got this question from Lanessa on Instagram
and this is what she had to say.
She said, I'm struggling with how to save smart.
How much should go in a 401k and Roth IRA
versus saving for a down payment
versus saving for a future wedding?
The wedding and house are still a long ways off
but figure I should start now while I'm debt-free.
Well, first of all, congrats on being debt-free.
That is amazing.
So now you have a bunch of choices and options
and that's what I love about when you get to this step
in your financial journey.
Once you become debt-free,
the choices of what you can do with your finances
are endless and regardless of where you're at,
if you're still paying off debt or you're debt-free,
when you take control of your finances,
you're basically just saying that I have options.
I have choices with my money when you're in control of it.
So let me talk about that first scenario
that I think might help you, Lanessa,
and help anybody else who's watching
who's in a similar predicament.
So scenario one, what I suggest that you start with
is to contribute to your employer's 401k
up to the match first.
So this is the easiest place to start investing
because if your employer offers a match,
then that's free money on the table.
So if you're going to contribute 5% of your paycheck,
your employer is also going to contribute
the equivalent of 5% of your paycheck
towards your retirement.
So you've literally just doubled your money
by contributing up to the match.
This is the easiest, most simplest way to start investing.
So check with your employer first
on whether or not they offer a match.
The second thing I wanna ask is what is the end date
for the down payment and the wedding?
When do you need those funds by?
Because weddings and down payments
typically have a shorter timeframe than your retirement.
So in this scenario, you would do your 401k match,
and then you're going to take a look at those end dates
because the wedding and a down payment or whatever,
maybe you're saving for a second car,
have shorter timeframes,
then you are going to figure out
what is the estimated cost for those particular goals
and then divide it out by the number of months left
until you need to hit that goal.
Now, when I was paying for my own wedding,
Kyle and I were really just cash flowing it in real time
as things popped up,
but we knew we wanted to spend less than $25,000
on our wedding.
And we ended up being under budget by,
I think it was $22,000 is what we spent in total.
But because I became debt-free in April of 2014,
and we got married in March of 2015,
we had a really short timeline.
And so a lot of my extra income and his extra income
went towards the wedding.
And retirement and investing
really was on the back burner for that year.
Because it was only a year and a short timeframe,
I don't feel like I missed out
because I was still contributing to my 401k at that time,
but I wasn't doing any other outside investing.
After that, so your step one, 401k,
step two, down payment, wedding,
whatever big savings goal you're going after,
you're contributing to the step.
The third step would be to contribute
whatever money is left over towards that Roth IRA.
So you're putting the Roth IRA second.
In this case,
because you're not getting an employer match
with a Roth IRA, typically in most cases.
And so that would be scenario number one.
Scenario number two would be just reversing the order
of when you're contributing to that Roth IRA.
So you're going to, again, start with the 401k,
get that employer match,
and then you're gonna dip into investing
into that Roth IRA.
So the biggest difference
between these two retirement accounts are how they're taxed.
So your 401k is going to use pre-tax contributions,
which means that you aren't getting taxed on that money
until you start withdrawing from the 401k,
ideally during retirement.
Now with a Roth IRA,
you are actually contributing with taxed dollars.
So you're already being taxed on the dollars
at the very beginning.
And then when you go to withdraw from the Roth IRA,
you are taking those withdrawals tax-free.
Now the benefits of a Roth IRA is that as we get older,
and let's face it, taxes just continue to go up over time,
that the money in a Roth IRA,
we're not going to be paying taxes on.
So you're literally paying today's tax rate
for future withdrawals and earnings tax-free.
And a 401k operates in just the opposite.
So you will be paying future tax rate
on that money that you withdraw from the 401k.
So right now in the year 2020,
the 401k max contribution limit is $19,500 for the year.
And that breaks down to $1,625 for the month.
So that's how much money in a month's paycheck
is what you would be contributing to completely max it out,
regardless of your employer match.
With a Roth IRA for 2020,
the max contribution limit is $6,000 or $500 per month.
So if you really wanted to max out both of these things
in scenario two,
then you would be putting more than $2,100 per month
towards these retirement accounts.
And then any money that is left over
can be used towards a down payment,
a wedding, or a second car fund,
whatever you're saving for.
So I think the biggest difference here
is if you are thinking of financial independence
and really building wealth rapidly
so that you can retire early,
scenario two is what I would go for.
Scenario one is really just a balance
of future and present needs.
So while you're saving, actively saving for your future,
you're also reserving money for the short-term goals.
Now I'll tell you what I personally do.
Kyle has a 401k through his employer
and his employer offers a 5% match.
So Kyle contributes up to the match
and then he did additional on top of it.
So I think he does about 15%.
I myself have a SEP IRA,
so that's a self-employed retirement plan,
and I self-manage that through Vanguard.
I contribute $1,000 per month towards that account.
So in addition to the SEP IRA,
I'm only contributing just $200 per month
towards my Roth IRA
because we prioritized Kyle's 401k
and then we're prioritizing saving for a down payment
and a second car.
So much like you, Linessa,
I have two different savings goals
that I'm really focused on,
and the down payment is taking a large chunk
of our discretionary income
because we know we want to purchase a house
within the short-term, like within a year or two.
And then also for our second car,
since we are having our first baby
and we're thinking about having a second car
would be a lot easier than being a one-car family,
which we're currently doing.
So we'd rather have the money saved up now
so that when that day comes,
we'll have the money ready to go.
Once those two goals are complete,
we're going to reprioritize
and make sure we're maxing out our Roth IRAs
that Kyle is contributing that 19,500
full max contribution limit towards the 401k
so that we can reprioritize investing.
I hope that helps you guys.
I'm curious to know in the comments,
how are you balancing investing and saving?
What's really taking priority?
Is it the 401k?
Is it the Roth?
Do you have short-term goals?
It's a lot to deal with.
Now, if you still have question marks in your head
about all of this,
don't forget that you can check out Budget Bootcamp.
It's that private one-on-one budget coaching session with me
where we can talk about your own personal financial situation
and get you back on board.
Thanks so much, guys.
If you liked this video,
make sure to give it a thumbs up
and I'll catch you in another video.