Cincinnati's Hidden Train Tunnels, Cincinnati, Ohio

Discover the world
57 followers
31 Video Views·Oct 31, 2022
Welcome back to another episode of History in Your Own Backyard. I'm your host, Susie Selig,
here today in Cincinnati, Ohio. We are at some abandoned train tunnels and, well,
there's some unfinished business we're going to talk about. And here to tell us about that
unfinished business is Jeffrey Jacoic. Thank you for being with us today. Thanks for having me.
So you actually, before we get into this, you've got a history, all of your own,
known in the tri-state as being a foremost expert in trains and inter-transit. So talk to me about
your history really fast. So real briefly, I came here to go to UC for architecture school back in
late 90s, early 2000s. Go Bearcats. Yes. And coming from Chicago, which is a very railroad and transit
focused city, I was kind of curious about what everything was around here. And I even did one
elective studio project relating to transit, streetcars, light rail, that sort of thing.
And just started researching everything and trying to figure out sort of what's around and how it
worked, what was the history. And as you go, you find various other mysteries and other undiscovered
things that just, you know, pique your interest and goes from there. So piquing my interest is
one of the first things we're going to talk about today, that we're at the Oak Street Tunnel, right?
Yes. But from the 1850s, so this goes back really far, but even before that, you were saying
something 30 years earlier was happening with that, with a different tunnel. Right. So this
tunnel was finished around 1881, 1882, but the history of the railroad and getting transportation
through Walnut Hills really goes back all the way to the 1850s when a predecessor company
called the Dayton and Cincinnati Shortline Railroad was proposing to build a mainline
route from downtown Cincinnati, essentially due north to Dayton, bypassing the longer
Mill Creek and Great Miami Valleys, basically to make a route to Dayton that was a good
seven miles shorter than competing railroads. And their plan was to collect a bunch of other
railroads that were being constructed at the time from Norwood and Sharonville and coming
from Lebanon and other places and funnel them all to downtown. But in order to do that, they needed
a big tunnel because we're here on Walnut Hills, which is at a much, much higher elevation than
downtown. And especially in the 1850s, climbing any particularly steep grade was next to impossible
for most railroads. So in order to get through this hill, they needed a long tunnel that was
going to be 10,000 feet long, basically stretching from where the casino is downtown now all the way
up to where I-71 and Blair Avenue crosses kind of near Xavier University. And starting in 1852,
they began digging. There was construction at the south portal, which is near
Reading Road and Elsinore and Eden Park Drive at the north portal by where I-71 is now.
And then there were also three shafts that they dug from various places in Walnut Hills.
One of them is just two blocks back this way. So they started digging from all five points.
By 1854, however, they had exhausted their money and only the shafts and the portals were dug a few
thousand feet, but then they were basically out of business. And that project sat essentially
mothballed until other railroads were like, okay, we can't wait for this anymore. We still need a
downtown. And this is the way we want to go. But that tunnel was just going to be too expensive
to complete. So they had to kind of go to a plan B. Jeffrey, how deep, how deep was that?
So we're 40, 50 feet below Walnut Hills here in this cut. But the Deer Creek Tunnel was roughly
another 200 feet further below us, which was what was necessary in order to have a reasonable grade
from one end to the other. Right. All right. We were talking earlier to you, sorry, about plan B.
What was that plan B? So plan B, unrelated to the original Dayton and Cincinnati short line,
one of the railroads that was planned to connect to that was the precursors to the Cincinnati,
Lebanon, and Northern. Lebanon is the county seat of Warren County, and they had been bypassed
by other railroads that had been built because they're on kind of a ridge between the two
valleys. But then they saw that their town started to stagnate as development and industry started to
collect around the railroad routes, and they were basically high and dry. So they had been
attempting to build a railroad to Cincinnati and or Dayton for a couple of decades. And then by the
1870s and early 1880s, they had finally gathered enough stock subscriptions and other support
to start construction. And by that time in the 1870s, there was something of a
fad of narrow gauge railroads. Okay. Rail gauge is nothing more than the distance between the tracks.
Thank you for explaining that, because I'm not the only one who didn't know that. Okay,
say that one more time. Rail gauge. So rail gauge is just the distance between the tracks
or the two rails. Okay. The Deer Creek Tunnel, they were planning for up to a wide gauge railroad,
which the distance between the rails was six feet. That was pretty big. Okay. Standard gauge
nowadays is four feet, eight and a half inches. Okay. In the 1850s and whatnot, they hadn't really
settled. Every company kind of did their own thing because they were either making their
locomotives and cars and stuff in house or through local suppliers. But that made it difficult to
interchange because if your track was different than another company, you couldn't run over it.
And in the 1870s, narrow gauge railroads became a thing. They're only three feet between the rails.
And the idea there was that they'd be less expensive to build, less expensive to operate,
because you didn't need as wide a right-of-way. The cars could be smaller.
But ultimately, narrow gauge railroads kind of fell out of favor by the 1880s and 1890s because
of the problems with interchange. Okay. And they weren't really all that much cheaper to build
when all was said and done. But that's what the Cincinnati-Lebanon and Northern was. Okay.
Running from Lebanon with connections to Dayton, down through here to Court Street.
They had opened from Avondale North in about 1880. And then their kind of last hurdle was
getting through Walnut Hills here. Jeffrey, this tunnel right here, tell us about it.
So the Oak Street Tunnel here, built again 1881 to 1882, was still necessary to try to bring the
grade down just enough so that they weren't having to crest the entire hill. Nevertheless,
it still ended up with a three and a half percent grade on the other side from starting at
McMillan Street and going down. And most railroads don't want anywhere more than like
one and a half percent. So that's really steep? It's very steep. Okay. So they would need to use
like helper engines to help get cars up the hill. They had problems with runaway trains,
basically crashing into the Court Street terminal area, especially in like wet or icy conditions.
And it was a major hindrance to freight operation. Because, you know, even with helper engines,
they might only be able to take a small handful of cars rather than a long train.
And so it really illustrates why the deeper level Deer Creek Tunnel was a much better plan.
But it was just so much more expensive to build that they didn't have the means. I mean,
like I said before, that was a 10,000 foot tunnel. This is only about 1,000 feet long.
Then there's a little gap and then underpass at McMillan Street. So we're at such a much higher
elevation that it really did constrain operations a lot. Can you talk about how the tunnels were
constructed? So they're fairly typical from construction wise for the time they're walled
with stone, arched with brick. Originally, they were arched with wood timbers that were eventually
replaced with brick. But because of the type of rock that we have up here near the top of the
hill, there's a lot of fairly hard limestone. And so they actually had to do a lot of blasting
in order to create these trenches. And in fact, this tunnel was actually cut in cover.
So it was an open trench just like we're in here. But then they built the tunnel
over and covered it back over. But during the summer of 1881, they were doing so much blasting
with like powder and dynamite. And they were in such a hurry to get the line finished that they
didn't even put like netting or any covers over their blast holes. So rocks would go flying all
over the neighborhood and even killed a couple of people in the neighborhood,
including one small boy even. So the city tried to kind of clamp down on some of that
activity. But there weren't even any laws at the time to prevent such a thing. So I think that
they did ultimately do some netting and other precautions. But yeah, so it was a pretty rough
and tumble kind of a situation. Construction back then is very different than it is today,
yes? Yes, I think so. And without the blasting powder and whatnot, it was basically just men
with pickaxes and shovels otherwise. Jeffrey, how did the use of the tunnels change when the
gauge just went to standard? So not a whole lot at first, actually. Like I said earlier, when
they found out that narrow gauge railroads were not all that they were supposed to be,
there was a major push to convert to standard gauge. Now that's obviously pretty difficult
because you have to really do it all at once and replace your equipment all at once in order for
it to work. So there's a lot of capital investment involved in that. But in the mid-1890s, the
Cincinnati, Lebanon, and Northern finally decided to standard gauge their whole route,
which also made it a much more attractive purchase for the Pennsylvania Railroad
that ultimately bought it a little later. But all they did was essentially
move one of the rails to the new spacing and everything seemed fine. However, in I think 1916,
two passenger trains were going through the tunnel in opposite directions,
which apparently had not happened much or at all beforehand, and the train sideswiped each other.
Nobody was killed, but it damaged a lot of the coaches. And so at that point,
they decided to remove the double track through the tunnels and install a gauntlet track,
which basically just means two tracks that kind of overlap and then come apart. They don't actually
really interconnect with each other. They're just sort of running over the same location.
So they had to install some signals and whatnot to prevent trains from going through at the same
time. But even fairly recently, the tunnels had been investigated for possible use for light rail
or other modern transit projects. And the narrow width has actually been kind of a problem because
it would be still the same pinch point now than it was at the time.
Jeffrey, why did the railroads close?
Well, obviously not all of them did. But in this case, after the Pennsylvania Railroad had
purchased the Cincinnati-Lebanon and Northern, it was kind of treated as sort of a branch line.
It wasn't like a high priority main line, partly because of the steep grades and some of the tight
turns and other things. But even in the 1920s, I think, a short five-mile stretch from downtown
through Norwood generated more rail freight than just about any other railroad in the entire system.
But as we get into the 50s, 60s, and 70s, a number of factors start coming into play.
One is just as industry moves either out to the suburbs or out of the country completely.
And also generally the increase in use of trucks instead of trains for flexibility and cost
purposes. So a number of customers started declining. But really the final nail in the
71, not just because it helped with trucking and whatnot, but it ended up wiping out a lot of the
businesses that the railroad served. There was actually a track past Court Street down
Eggleston Avenue, which was full of multi-story warehouses and other businesses. And coming up
the Deer Creek Valley between Redding Road and Gilbert Avenue had historically been
an area of heavy industry, steel mills and tanneries and whatnot. And a lot of these
businesses were just simply wiped away in order to simply just to build the highway.
To the point where by the time I-71 was finished and a couple of bridges had been built across it,
one up kind of near where the Deer Creek Tunnel was going to come out and also down near
Elsinore Avenue, basically the line was out of business. So they didn't even really get to use
those brand new bridges and rerouted track to stay away from the highway.
And also there wasn't any real push by Pennsylvania Railroad and later
Conrail to keep this operational because of the difficulties of climbing this hill.
Which is a good business decision if you think about it. Ultimately. Yeah. Now the railroad is
not completely gone. It still exists through Pleasant Ridge and Deer Park up to Blue Ash.
And then there's another disconnected section up near Lebanon,
but it's all been sold off to different companies.
Thank you for watching another episode of History in Your Own Backyard. I'm your host
Susie Selick here today in Cincinnati, Ohio. Jeffrey Jacoic, thank you so much for being
with us and sharing some of the mysteries of these tunnels. My pleasure. Yeah. And remember,
travel slowly and stop often. Bye for now.
