Survive The Jive The Golden One. Traditionalism Paganism Islam Evola Guenon The Cheddar Man

The Nutritional
35 followers
5 Video Views·Oct 30, 2022
STJ is a good m8, subscribe to his channel for +10 in Wisdom. Also check out his new documentary on India: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6WxtD...
☩ The Greatest Instagram: https://instagram.com/thegloriouslion
☩ Glorious Garments:
Now the question I want to ask
Who are you? I've actually heard of you. Many of my subscribers have heard of you.
You have the charisma of a Saxon chieftain and the appearance of a European gentleman.
That was my Nigel Farage, but in a good way, obviously.
Introducing my man, Survivor The Jive. So first and foremost,
before you watch this video, Tom has just gotten back from good old India and made a
very good documentary, which you can watch below. First link in the description, give him a subscription as well.
Anyway, I thought to have a little conversation with Tom regarding
some things which might be interesting for you all to
partake in.
So yeah, welcome.
Thank you, Marcus. Good to be on the channel.
Okay, so I've talked about this in a few videos, in a few podcasts,
but I haven't addressed it directly to the actual channel and my audience.
And that's obviously about traditionalism, because a lot of people misunderstand the
meaning of traditionalism with a big T, like Evola and Gunon, etc.
So do you have anything to add to that? I know that you've been talking a bit about that
earlier on as well, but to keep people up-to-date, do you have anything to add to my...
Yeah, so the word tradition obviously has a wide understood meaning,
or which can be literally any custom that is preserved between generations.
And traditionalism, then, people will assume is any
ideology that is in favor of the continuation of this tradition.
But there is another
meaning
to traditionalism with a capital T, as you say, which is associated with a specific school of thought,
sometimes called Sophia Pluralis, or the perennial philosophy.
And in that, there isn't really a major concern with the continuation of all,
or of any specific custom, of just random customs. Rather, there's an idea, it's about the idea that
well, it's synonymous with the word truth. Tradition in that context means truth.
And it's basically centered around the idea that different traditions, and in that is specifically referring to religious traditions,
each of them are centered around the same truth, and therefore all legitimate.
But that they each
reflect different peoples, and different perspectives on the world, and being in the world, and therefore are proper and distinct to different peoples.
But that they are all legitimate
for their own
parts of the world, and for their own types of people.
And that tradition is basically the preservation of your people's
tradition, which is its own,
is the correct way for your people to engage with that one truth.
Yeah, and a note here, you probably all heard me say this Jonathan Bowden quote, and it's like,
yeah, you've heard me saying like a thousand times. I always greet him with it, so,
and it's like,
and this I'm quoting now, and this is true for quite a lot of rightist and perennial minded people.
I'm not philosophically perennial, but many right-wing people are, actually admire elements of Islam,
for their strength, for their belief, for their ferocity, for their knowledge of who they are, end quote.
And that he says,
philosophically perennial, and that is what Tom is talking about now, in the perennial truth. So a truth that is, yeah,
yeah, goes for most cultures. So Bowden, like, he read some perennial
philosophers, like Julius Evola, but he wasn't necessarily
perennial. He wasn't perennial in mind, as he says to himself. Many people nowadays often are interested in
the right in general, that we're also reading Julius Evola, but they're not so much interested in Sophia Perennis.
There are many, like, authors within that school,
none of them are associated particularly with right-wing politics, except one, Julius Evola. The rest weren't really in any way associated with politics.
There are some, even today, who are
quite well known, and Professor Nasser is in Canada. He's an Iranian who lives in Canada.
He teaches Islamic studies at a university there. He's quite a famous
perennial philosopher.
The main names in the school are René Guénon from France,
Frithof Schoen, who's a German, and
Julius Evola, of course.
Martin Lings is a more recent one. I think he only died quite recently.
He was in contact with
the Prince of Wales,
who is, in fact, the patron of a perennial philosophy school in the United Kingdom
called
the Telemus Academy.
Telemus Academy, sorry, and
that
has various speakers on different traditions and religions and
tries to bring people into that philosophical worldview, which Prince Charles is
sympathetic to.
René Guénon, obviously, he admired elements of Islam, if I understood things correctly.
Yeah, he did. When he wrote the first book, it was about Hinduism, and I made a video on that book.
But he was, at the time, a Catholic. He was raised in France as a Catholic. Later, he decided that the
traditional virtues in Catholicism had been compromised, and
therefore he decided it was better to look for a more well-preserved tradition, and he became a Sufi. It's a form of Islam
practiced in the easternmost regions of Europe.
It's a mystical type of Islam, which is less
concerned with the letter of the law of the Qur'an,
and has some more
nuanced conceptions of divinity, and also is, within Sufism, there is the potential for
appreciation of other traditions, whereas
Islam, more broadly, as a religion, has no appreciation, especially for
the pre-Abrahamic traditions. Yeah, and also when René Guénon
admired elements of Islam, this was obviously before this whole
invasion of Europe, so it's not that he
he cocked to Islam or anything. It was just a scholar on the search for truth, and that was beforehand, so...
Well, he did become a Muslim, and he did move to Egypt and leave Europe.
Yeah, I mean, a bit cockish, but it's still not... And married an Egyptian, and yeah...
Okay, I'm a bit of a heretic, to be honest, but...
I mean, it's not my place. I'm not going to say what's right and what's wrong,
but he tries to do that, and I think Schoen, as well, became a Muslim. Many of the original
traditionalists became Muslims, but not all. There was also a whole collection of European
traditionalists in Thailand for a while, who became Buddhists, and
there are also... I mean,
Evola was...
Originally, he called himself a Catholic pagan, but he moved away from paganism a bit, but he was never a Christian.
But in regards to Gunon, I'd say it would have been worse if he did it today, because now we're like the West and Islamists
today in a bit more of a
metaphysical boxing match than, say, 50 years ago.
So, I mean, I'm just pointing out that I'm not condoning of his behaviors, but
well, actually, in a way, I am, because he was obviously on the quest for enlightenment, and
it took him there, and he shared his wisdom and his teachings with us, so we have that.
He was
correctly
recognizing a
problem in the West, which was growing and had been growing for a long time, and
his ultimate
diagnosis was that it was not likely to be solved. He predicted two likely outcomes for the West.
One,
or two, one, the more preferable one, would be that the West would be
spiritually renewed
by
an understanding of spiritual tradition, which it
learned from other cultures it came into contact with.
It doesn't necessarily mean they have to become Hindus or Muslims, but that they would learn from the need for the tradition.
Alternatively, if that never was achieved, he predicted that it would be that the West would be
absorbed by the neighboring
civilizations which had traditions, most likely Islamic civilization, because that was the closest one.
And if that was written in the 20s or something, I'd say about 90 years later, close to 100 years later,
it seems that he was on to something there.
Yeah, and also, I don't know if I've ever said this in a video.
I know I've said it in in a speech, at least. I might have said it in in a podcast.
I don't know if I've said it in an English podcast, but just to clarify,
I have expressed admiration for Islam for the same reason Baudan said something.
For their knowledge of who they are.
Exactly, and he has a point.
But what I mean, then, is not that I want white Sharia, and that I want us to become Muslim.
I want to see what makes them strong, okay?
Because they are very passionate about what they're doing. And like you said, in the first alternative, that we learn from other cultures,
see how strongly passionate they are. They have a fire within them. I want the same thing, but perhaps in, for us, a pagan
version. So that is why I, if I say I admire elements of Islam,
it's not that I want Northern European women to have like burqas or anything, because that's not our way.
But I want to see, it's almost like if you have a guy with a magic sword on flame,
and then I was like, okay, I want the same sort of sword.
I can't have that sword, because it's suited to his hand and everything, but I want to know the ingredients.
What kind of metal, what kind of magic does he use?
So I think it's, and this is also, we're talking about these counter-Jihadist individuals who are just finding faults with Islam all the time.
They're criticizing Islam from the wrong perspective.
It's like, oh, Islam is too traditional. And it's like, there are good things with Islam, then there are bad things with Islam.
Yeah, as I was saying, what I want to see is that, okay, they have something.
I want to know what it is, and I want to utilize it to revive our own spirituality, our own culture.
And this is also something Jonathan Bowden said, I know, and that's Europe will completely disappear unless we revive, basically.
I don't know which speech it was, but it was really good, and I totally agree. We need to revive.
And this sort of counter-Jihadist mindset that, oh, everything Islam does is wrong, and we have to do the opposite,
it's really, it's not particularly glorious, in my humble view, at least.
But it overlooks some of the problems, and it's kind of indicative of a tendency to look at the symptoms rather than the causes of problems that we have as Westerners.
Things were on their way to the current conditions before they reached the state that they're currently in, and that's what needs to be addressed.
And that's one of the problems with the more broadly understood meaning of tradition, and conservatism.
It's a reflexive desire to preserve something just because it's familiar, which isn't good at all.
And that is not what I mean when I talk about tradition and preserving tradition.
If a beautiful house is destroyed, and then an ugly one is built in its place, and then people, at first they hate that ugly building, but over time they've come to find it familiar.
Then if someone says, I wish to rebuild a beautiful building where this ugly one currently stands, there will be those who, having grown so attached to this familiar ugly building, will say, no, let us preserve this ugly building.
They are not traditionalists, they're just reflexive conservatives, and I have nothing to do with that ideology, I have no interest in that kind of perspective, resisting change because it's unfamiliar.
Yeah, it sort of reminds me about the sort of capitalist American conservatives who view America in the 50s as the epitome of, and they don't understand that capitalism, communism, it's...
and then you have traditionalism on top, because traditionalism is more concerned with higher values, metaphysical qualities, whereas socialism is here to the left, capitalism is here, it's still based upon money.
Yeah, yeah.
Yeah, and I'm the same. But I also feel that it is not desirable for people to adopt the traditions of other peoples. And this is something that the Dalai Lama has said recently.
You live as part of other people. You're not an atomized, single, complete unit. Man has never existed in that way. It's a fiction.
There you have it, liberals.
And the Dalai Lama said that this means that when a Westerner converts to Buddhism, what happens to their Christian family? When a Buddhist converts to Christianity or whatever, the same problems happen.
Even if there's nothing wrong with that tradition in itself, it can create these problems. Now, there are instances where perhaps it has to happen. There's no other option.
Because he thought that the next closest thing was the Arab tradition, and that among the Arab tradition, the Sufi one was the nearest to Europe.
I personally believe that we know enough about Indo-European traditions in general, and specifically ones local to us, like the Nordic-Germanic tradition, that we can properly practice a sincere and complete Indo-European tradition today.
And much of the infrastructure and the power hierarchies in the Catholic Church are completely compromised and anti-traditional. So you're fighting an uphill struggle, whether you choose to be a pagan or a Christian at this stage.
Middle Ages.
Yeah, exactly. I mean, you said this before in a private conversation, that it permeated the entire society.
Yeah, everything was built on it. But the hierarchy of medieval Europe was entirely built around God. The legitimacy of the king, the nobles, everything was believed in a notion of Christian morality.
Because in Christianity, it's almost like you're always guilty. There are no good Catholics because they have inherited a sin.
Because Catholicness is about Catholic.
Exactly. Whereas for us, as pagans, we have shame as a barrier towards the inherent behavior. So, we're not guilty until we are guilty, and we have shame as a sort of regulatory thing there.
And then also something, I think, Stephen McNallen wrote in his book Asatru. It was like, a key difference is how you view life. Christians view it as, you get your reward if you're a good boy. You get it in the next life.
Yeah. I think the pagan perspective also recognizes reward in a more immediate sense. So, in paganism, you can pray for things in this life. So, you don't just pray for salvation. In fact, you don't pray for salvation, really.
Yeah. On a semi-related topic, and I think since I have you on the channel, you might want to utilize this opportunity to dispel some blasphemies that has with the cheddar man.
Cheddar man?
So I saw an article the other day saying that it was, they were wrong or something. Have you any insights into?
And whether you take a sample of one of these from Spain or Britain or anywhere else in Western Europe, it's pretty much the same. There's not a great deal of genetic drift. There's some, but they all form one genetic cluster.
He was not a sub-Saharan African and no one has ever argued that he is. So what they've done there is extremely misleading and unscientific and dishonest.
And I mean, fake news. They've used up all of their credibility by now. So, yeah. All right, cool.
And that's a form of psychological terrorism that should not be forgiven by anyone.
So instead, look at all your population genetics directly from the sources or at least from Survive the Jive.
Cheers for having me on.
First.
I get like three comments saying that every time.
