Analyzing The Painted Veil by W. Somerset Maugham - Love, Death, and Christian Parallels

Marian H
3 followers
1 Video View·Oct 29, 2022
Hi everyone, I hope you're doing well today. It's a Thursday night, but I just had to film
this because I just read the most amazing novel called The Painted Veil by William Somerset
Mawum. And yes, that's how you say his name. So this is going to be a bit of a different video,
but I wanted to just go over it in some great detail actually. And I'm going to start with
what the book's about, talk about the characters and the themes,
and a few of the major plot points. But I'm going to pause the video a little ways in and
let you turn it off if you do not want to know the ending, because I decided that
I needed to talk about the whole book, including the ending. It's just that amazing. It is one of
the very best novels I've ever read, honestly. Yeah, I don't want to hype it up too much, but
I just was deeply impressed with The Painted Veil. I do want to get the elephant out of the
room before I start and say that this is a very dated novel. It's from the 1920s, I believe,
and so you'll find a lot of racial slurs and derogatory language regarding the people of
China where this book takes place. So bear that in mind. Very typical of a book from that era,
and indeed pretty offensive. Just wanted to let you know before you go into it. So
where to start? So early on in the book, I just had this thought, and I'll just read it.
Humans want to be flattered. Our pride appeased because it gives us a sense of power. Also,
mutual flattery. But when you love someone, you don't flatter them. You, in fact, hold them to
a higher standard and help them be become accountable to more than their mere pride.
I mentioned this novel was written in the 1920s. It reminded me of a couple other books
from around the same era, and those two novels are The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald
and The House of Mirth by Edith Wharton. The Painted Veil, just to keep us focused here,
The Painted Veil reminded me a lot of both of those books, but it is very different. I would
say it is the antithesis to The Great Gatsby, and its main character of Kitty Fane is the antithesis
to Lily Bart from The House of Mirth. Just to kind of put it in context, how this novel affected me
and how very impressed I was with it. So I mentioned that it takes place in China. More
specifically, it starts out with this young lady, Kitty, and she marries this young man named
Walter Fane, who is a bacteriologist in China. So first they go to Hong Kong to live,
and it talks about life in Hong Kong. And if you've watched the movie The Empire of the Sun,
you kind of get an idea of what that was like. Very similar, you had this,
the colonials living in their own area, and then everybody else was, you know,
the general populace was outside the walls of that colonial district, so to speak. Anyway,
the problem is that this lady, Kitty Fane, does not love her husband Walter.
And why does she not love him? So the thing that's really important about the story,
and what you have to keep in mind, is Kitty's background. She comes from a family where
the father is not particularly successful. He never brings in as much money as his wife wishes
him to. His wife being Kitty's mother, of course. And Kitty's mother is very demanding of the
father, and she's really just interested in her family. Sorry, this seems to be out of focus.
She's really just interested in her family making a name for themselves in the world. So
since her husband has not, she's counting on the fact that Kitty will marry well.
Kitty and her sister. So this reminded me very much, like I said, of the House of Mirth,
and especially that dynamic of the overbearing mother and the, I guess you could say the weak
father. Kitty ends up marrying this young man Walter, whom she doesn't really love,
but she's kind of running out of time. At least in those days, it was considered to be running
out of time, as you reached your mid-20s and were not married. He, on the other hand, is very much
in love with her, and so it pains him a lot, as you can imagine, that she doesn't return his feelings.
So yeah, they go to Hong Kong. This is where things start to go really wrong.
Although you could say they were probably doomed from the start, seeing as how Kitty doesn't love
Walter. But in Hong Kong, she meets Charlie Townsend, and Charlie is a middle-aged guy
who is very charismatic. He is already married, but he and Kitty start in an altruist relationship,
and eventually Walter finds out. So when he finds out, Kitty wants to get a divorce,
but Charlie will not marry her for obvious reasons. He doesn't want to divorce his wife.
He basically just uses his wife, and he has children as well, so he has no interest in
getting embroiled in scandals, public scandals. And he sends her away so she doesn't get a
divorce. In fact, she and Walter are embarking on a journey to go to this town, and I'm trying
to remember the name of the town. I can't think of it off the top of my head. But they go to this
town, and the town is stricken with cholera. Walter is pretty much the only medical man
in the vicinity, at least that's my understanding. So he goes there to try to help them, and he
insists that Kitty comes with him, and she doesn't really have anywhere else to go at this point. She
does not want to go back to her mother because her mother just doesn't want her around.
And she feels a bit angry, a little bit ashamed, mostly angry with Charlie because she expected
him to forsake all and pursue her completely, but that is not the case. So it's with these very
mixed and bitter feelings that she follows Walter to this town where there's cholera.
And as you can imagine, it's pretty scary for her as well. So that's kind of how the book starts
out. I feel like I'm starting to ramble a little bit. But a lot of drama, a lot of heartbreak,
especially for Walter. Walter is a very decent young man, and that is something that
comes, I think, as a bit of a surprise to Kitty. She kind of resents it because he is so decent and
she is, you know, cheating on him a little shamelessly. So it is very awkward and painful
when they get to this village. And for the most part, she really doesn't see him all that much
because he's busy working and she doesn't really have anything to do here until she meets the
nuns. So there is a convent here and there are a few sisters who are trying to keep things together
at this convent. And it's basically an orphanage as well. They have many, many children there,
especially abandoned daughters whom their families did not want. And they're also trying to
take care of those who have this terrible disease, because we're talking about an epidemic.
And not only are the children dying, but the nuns are dying as well. So it's quite a very
tragic situation. When Kitty finally goes to visit the convent, she is completely taken
aback by the poverty that these nuns are living in. And not just that, but the
peace that they seem to have within them, in spite of the suffering, in spite of the hard work,
and all of the children that are clamoring around them. These nuns are nevertheless
at peace and she senses that they have this thing that she does not have. So there's Sister
St. Joseph and then there's the Mother Superior. I don't remember what her name was. I'm not even
sure it's mentioned. I tried to find it just now and couldn't find it. But anyway, something that
that kind of brings up too is there's a lot of contrast in this book between families. And
in the Mother Superior, Kitty finds a very strong woman. She's very principled. And
it's completely different than her own biological mother back in England.
And it makes Kitty feel inspired, a little ashamed, and just awed, frankly. She's always
awed by the Mother Superior. And then she becomes friends with Sister St. Joseph as well.
Another person they meet here is an officer. Was he an officer?
Waddington. We'll just call him Waddington. He's a character. He's a Britisher who's
really one of the few other Europeans in this town. And he becomes a friend of Kitty.
He's kind of a comical character. He's a bit cynical. So there's kind of a bit of comic relief
there. But actually, he's a pretty serious character in his own way. He's not very friendly
to Catholicism, but he does respect, I think, the nuns and helps them out when they need help.
So there's an interesting dynamic there that I think is pretty realistic.
Okay, so that's the basic setup of the plot. I want to dig a little deeper into the relationship
between Kitty and Walter. Why does she dislike him so much? And why did he marry her to begin with?
Walter is a very bookish young man and completely opposite of Charlie Townsend.
Charlie is old. He's a womanizer. He is athletic and just a general popular guy.
Walter is unpopular, very nerdy, nervous, I would say, introverted, and not confident in
social settings. So when he meets Kitty, I mean, she's a very beautiful young lady,
and he also believes he can't really do any better than her. And he really loves her for
kind of mysterious reasons. And Kitty doesn't find him charismatic or attractive at all. It
was just a marriage of convenience from her perspective. But the thing about it is when they
get to this town with the cholera, she starts to hear things about him from other people. So Mr.
Waddington tells her what a jerk Charlie is and what a decent person Walter is, even though Mr.
Waddington, again, doesn't really like anybody. But he realizes that Walter is a person of character
and decency and has really done all he can to help these sick Chinese citizens. And
the nuns love Walter as well, because he shows true care and concern for their orphans and,
again, for the general people who are suffering in such a hideous way. And that's another thing
that's kind of interesting about how this is written is everything is told very much from
Kitty's perspective. So in order to meet these other characters, it really is presented in this
organic way where she's talking to Charlie directly, and then she goes and talks to Mr.
Waddington a great deal, who sheds light on the other characters, which she has to,
at first reluctantly, but eventually she comes to understand what he's talking about. And she
realizes she's been used by Charlie and that Walter has always loved her from a place of respect.
And, well, until the affair was found out. And the same goes for the sisters. So,
again, everything's from her perspective, which makes it a little heavy at times.
But you feel like you're very much enveloped in the story. And another thing I really loved
about this book is it's written a lot like The Sight of Paradise by F. Scott Fitzgerald.
He uses very short chapters. There's actually 80 chapters, but they're very, very short. Some of
them are a page or less than a page. And so it's told in a series of vignettes, which I really
enjoyed. And it gives you kind of a, I mean, I was thinking about this from a writing perspective,
and I feel like the short chapters really are very reflective of real life. When you go about
your life, you're not writing a book continuously, at least, I mean, hopefully not. You know,
when you're looking at it in your mind's eye, it's a series of vignettes. It's a series of scenes.
It's not a continuous narrative. There was one scene in particular that was so moving to me.
And it's when they're at dinner and in their bungalow, which used to be a missionary's until
the missionary died. And then they came in and ended up taking the bungalow to live in.
They're eating dinner and the Chinese cook brings in salad for them to eat. And Kitty just is eating
the salad. And she's very bitter at this point against Walter for bringing her here and bitter
at everything that's happened. And she's really missing Charlie. And, you know, he tells her,
you shouldn't be eating that salad because it's not safe. And she's just eating it in this
rebellious manner. Suicidally, you might say. But what's so interesting is Walter,
he eats the salad too. It's kind of a weird scene, but it really speaks to this gap between
that he's trying to always span and she's always holding back. Because she can never seem to get
out of these things that her mother and her background and just herself really have instilled
in her since youth. And so it's so hard for her to accept someone else's view and someone else
seeing her in a different light too. So things are pretty bad in this town, as I've already mentioned.
It even mentions here that people were dying at the rate of a hundred a day. And again, Walter's
there every day working tirelessly. And what really struck me was the fact that, you know,
he's terribly hurt by what Kitty did to him. And what he's done is he's transferred his love to
these people here. He no longer has any feelings for her. That's made pretty clear. So he has
poured himself into this mission of his and there's, you know, he still treats her with
respect and care, but there's just nothing left. And when she starts to see that,
when she starts to see his qualities and also starts to see that he doesn't love her anymore,
there's an immense depression that comes over her, as you can imagine.
A few other things that I just want to touch on before I kind of get towards
the end of the book and the bigger picture that I was taking from this story.
Let me see if I can find the right quotes here. There's this whole problem of
Kitty's adultery and just the way that she perceives what happened and how she's not
really taking responsibility for what she did. And this quote here really sums it up. She considers
it as regrettable and shocking even, but to be forgotten rather than to be repented of.
It was like making a blunder at a party. There was nothing to do about it. It was dreadfully
mortifying, but it showed a lack of sense to ascribe too much importance to it. And
this kind of comes back a few times, this idea that it's just another thing that happens in life
and something that she feels as she goes from place to place. I mean, she kind of holds on
to this idea, well, this happened at this place and it doesn't hardly seem real anymore,
and what does it really matter anyway, because people are dying of cholera.
So she really tries to downplay what she has done. And that in itself is preventing her from
finding this peace that she sees in the sisters. And this is further compounded by the fact that
she's quite sure the Mother Superior knows what she did, but still includes her. In fact,
at one point she becomes so frustrated with herself, Kitty does, she decides to come work
for the Mother Superior and tend to the orphans in the convent. And again, though, she still
cannot find, even in that kind of selfless work acts, if you will, acts of kindness,
she cannot find that peace and becomes even more disturbed, I would say, at what has happened.
And again, it ties back into this phrase, regrettable and shocking,
not something to be, quote, repented of. And without repentance, you cannot find salvation.
That's a theme of the Painted Veil, which is so painfully demonstrated in
What Happens to Kitty. So I'm going to have to go into spoiler territory now,
major spoilers, the whole ending of the book. So if you would like to stop the video here and go
read the book, it only took me like maybe three, four hours to read the book total.
I highly recommend it. And maybe you can come back and watch the rest of the video after you've read
it. But I'm going to keep going here. But spoiler alert, because I hate spoilers. I like to read
the whole book myself. But maybe you've already read the book, or maybe you don't
care so much about spoilers. But I'm going to let you have a chance to stop the video and
go read the book if you wish. All right, we are back with the Painted Veil,
spoiler territory. So throughout the book, I was really reading it as an allegory.
And at first I was thinking, that's just me. I am trying to read my own opinions into this,
etc. But there are so many things in the book that I feel really point to this idea of an
allegory. I just think that, well, I wanted to talk about that. And, you know, if you've read
the book, let me know your thoughts on that interpretation. There is this underlying theme
of Kitty needing redemption, but not just redemption, reconciliation, and reconciliation
with who. So let's go back to her family for a minute. So I mentioned in the last section,
she's got a domineering mother and a weak father. And the family, the mother, the two daughters,
view him as just a breadwinner. They don't try to develop a meaningful relationship with him.
And, you know, they just don't care about him at all. And it's this weak relationship Kitty has
with this weak father that sets her up for this incredibly negative relationship with
the charismatic man of Hong Kong, Charlie Townsend. And this lack of a dynamic here,
this broken relationship, becomes a really twisted relationship with Charlie. He becomes
a surrogate father of sorts. And, you know, she talks about this almost spiritual
relationship that she has with him. And whenever she's feeling lonely and empty,
she wants to be with this guy who clearly throughout the book is shown to be an abuser
and a womanizer and really could care less about her in the long run.
Contrasted with the younger man, Walter. And Walter is the one who loves Kitty
at first, certainly unconditionally. And I would say throughout the book unconditionally.
He doesn't abandon her. He doesn't, you know, he treats her as well as can be expected. And
there is one detail in the book that's really interesting. Again, we're in spoilers now.
But she asks him, you know, why did you bring me here to this town that's stricken with cholera
knowing I could die? And he said, yeah, I did that because I was so angry with you
that I thought you might die. And she's kind of been suspecting this all along. And then she's
it's a bit shocking to her, but not completely shocking. But that kind of explains to me the
scene where he's eating the salad, which we talked about earlier. You know, he does feel this very
real connection to Kitty. And in spite of the way she's abused his love and mistreated him in every
way, he feels this sense, this honor bound duty towards her and not just duty, but actual love.
So what happens? Well, I was actually kind of surprised. I thought Kitty was going to die,
but actually it's Walter who dies. And he's out helping people as he is doing every day.
And one day they come and get Kitty and tell her he's he's going. And she shows up there and he's
on his deathbed and just doesn't really even register that she's there. And
within a very short time, he's dead. So once again, Kitty is alone. And again, she's still
in Hong Kong, or I should say she's still in the town where there's cholera. Charlie and his wife
are still in Hong Kong and her mother is still back in England. You would think that by now,
having watched her husband die in a terrible way, that Kitty would have a change of heart, right?
That she would completely change her ways and everything. But this is where the novel is
absolutely brilliant. She doesn't change because she hasn't found the redemption or the
reconciliation. She hasn't repented and she hasn't been reconciled with the father, right? And just
the death of Walter is not sufficient because she hasn't gone through that personal process.
So what happens? She goes back to Hong Kong and she goes right back to this guy. This guy who
treats her like dirt. And she's distraught, right? But yeah, she goes back to the same guy.
And there's one more thing that I almost forgot to mention and which is actually pretty significant.
So I'm sorry for neglecting to mention it. But Kitty is pregnant. She has a child.
And Walter knew that, by the way. And she doesn't know whose child it is.
And when she told Walter that, he was extremely distraught, as you can imagine. She wanted to
lie to him and tell him it was his, but she really didn't know. So she just told him she didn't know.
And that was kind of the final nail in the coffin of their relationship, you might say,
as far as any chance of love and happiness. And then he didn't live to see the child born
and know whether, you know, there was any resemblance to one or the other.
Yeah, so she goes back to this jerk. You know, she knows that she's
prostituting herself, right? She knows that she's at the lowest of the low.
And he's also a bit of a predator. So it's not just, you know, it's not just her fault,
obviously. But it's just a terrible situation, this cycle of going back to this guy.
And this is where she does make a smart decision. She decides, you know, I can't
be in the same city as this guy, obviously. She's got to go back to England. And it's at the same
time, or during this voyage, she finds out her mother has died. But it is significant that she
makes this choice. This moment she decides to leave Hong Kong is the real turning point, the
beginning of the repentance, right? So she goes back to England, she finds out mother is also
dead. And there's this beautiful scene with her father, her real father, where Kitty sees what
has happened, what the kind of damage her mother had caused in the family. She sees that, you know,
again, he's a weak guy, but he's not a bad guy either. He stayed with the mother all this time,
even though nobody loved this father. Kind of a little bit like Walter, you might say.
You know, she realizes finally, getting away from him, getting away from the mother in that way,
she realizes this brokenness here. And that's when she decides she's got to turn around. And
there is a beautiful moment of reconciliation. It's kind of ironic because the father,
at this point, when the mother dies, he's just learned that he's got in a great position
in the Bahamas as some kind of official. I don't remember exactly what it was, but he's going to
be leaving England. And, you know, he says, you don't need to come with me. And he doesn't really
have any particular feelings for his children, as you can imagine. But she's like, no, we are
still family. Doris has married somebody else by this time, and she wants to mend the relationship
with her father. So she goes with him to the Bahamas with the child. You know, she has decided
to try to make a new life for herself and break free of this ugly cycle. And I will actually read
a couple of quotes from the book that kind of tie into this suggestion of a Christian allegory.
One of them is by the Mother Superior, which I kind of alluded to in the previous part.
And let me see what she says here. This is so good. She says, remember that it is nothing to
do your duty that is demanded of you and is no more meritorious than to wash your hands when
they're dirty. The only thing that counts is the love of duty. When love and duty are one, then
grace is in you and you will enjoy happiness, which passes all understanding. And it's so
interesting because that is exactly what Walter did, right? Now, he struggled a bit with the love
part, right? Because he'd been wronged so greatly. And, you know, there's only so much you can...
Like, he might have been able to forgive better if he had had more time, more time to himself,
perhaps, and if she had actually turned her behavior around earlier. But at least
he did his duty, right? And the Mother, you know, is the Mother Superior that is
is telling her you shouldn't feel good for just doing the bare minimum, which ironically she
wasn't even doing at the time. But that is something that we kind of forget, especially now.
We always seem to hear these messages that if you just do this, you know, this good deed, or if you
just do the things that should be just a given, that you're somehow moral and particularly
righteous. But that's not really the point of duty. The other thing I wanted to read was the
actually the very ending, if I may. I'm just going to read some excerpts from the ending,
and I'm not going to read everything, obviously. I just want to read a few of the quotes. She says,
Oh, Father, I've been through so much. I've been so unhappy. I'm not the kitty I was when I went
away. I'm terribly weak, but I don't think I'm the filthy cat I was then. Won't you give me a chance?
I have nobody but you in the world now. Won't you let me try to make you love me?
Oh, Father, I am so lonely and so miserable. I want your love so badly. I want a girl because I
want to bring her up so that she shan't make mistakes I made. When I look back upon the girl
I was, I hate myself, but I never had a chance. I'm going to bring up my daughter so that she's
free and can stand on her own feet. I want her to be a person independent of others because she is
possessed of herself, and I want her to take life like a free man and make a better job of it than
I have. So there's this part in the first part of the book that I forgot to allude to, and she's
talking to Mr. Waddington about the Tao, and he's trying to describe it to her, and the way he
describes it is kind of ambiguous, right? There is this ambiguous element to it that can't be quite
pinpointed, and so that's very much contrasted throughout the book with the confidence of the
Catholic nuns, and so the very ending of the book goes like this.
The sun rose dispelling the mist, and she saw winding onwards as far as the eye could reach,
among the rice fields, across a little river, and through undulating country the path
they were to follow. Perhaps her faults and follies, the unhappiness she had suffered,
were not entirely vain if she could follow the path that now she dimly discerned before her,
not the path that kind funny old Waddington had spoken of that led no whither, but the path those
dear nuns of the convent followed so humbly, the path that led to peace. So I think that this reading
of it, though it may seem a bit, um, it may seem like adding another layer of interpretation, I think there
is something to that, that he was trying to get at here, and while Walter is not by any means
the perfect type, if you will, of Jesus, and while the Father is by no means a type of God the Father,
still this kind of, uh, this pattern that you see is really a pretty strong allegory, and Kitty,
of course, falling so low and suffering so much before that turning point is also,
I think, a very good allegory. So anyway, um, I really loved this book. I think it makes a wonderful
companion to books like This Side of Paradise, The Great Gatsby, and The House of Mirth, except
I feel like this novel puts everything into a really beautiful perspective, and I still appreciate
those other novels as well. It's just that this one, again, it just puts certain elements into
what I feel like are a more proper setting. So thank you so much for watching, and I hope to
see you in my next video. Let me know if you have any thoughts on this novel, any suggestions for
future videos. Please like the video if you enjoyed it, and I'll see you next time.
