Monica Seles #1 Ranking Scandal

TennisTalk
5 followers
9 Video Views·Oct 29, 2022
On April 30, 1993, Monica Celes was leading Magdalena Mileva 6-4-4-3 in a quarterfinal
match at the Citizen Cup in Hamburg, Germany, when she was stabbed in the back by a German
factory worker. Unable to finish the match or the tournament, WTA officials decided to award
Celes her ranking average for that event, 332.2133 points, rather than the points she would have
received by retiring in the quarterfinals. Two weeks later, the Women's Tennis Association said
We felt then, as we do now, that awarding Monica her average in Hamburg was the appropriate
decision to make under the circumstances, Gerard Smith, chief executive officer of the WTA,
said. The WTA wanted to provide Monica with some ranking protection immediately after the
devastating attack. Also, we felt it would offer her some additional comfort during her recovery.
The players and the WTA board of directors determined that no further adjustments should
be made for the tournament Celes will miss until she is able to play again.
A vote was held at a tennis tournament in Rome in 1993, and 16 of the 17 top players who voted
rejected the proposal to keep Monica at her number one ranking. Steffi Graf did not participate in
the tournament and was thus absent from voting. Celes was disturbed that the Women's Tennis
Association left it up to the players to vote on whether to leave her ranking unprotected after
the Hamburg event. The outcome was that Celes's ranking was not protected. Gabriela Sabatini did
not participate in the voting but players who did vote to strip Monica of the her number one
ranking included Arantxa Sanchez Vicario, Martina Navratilova, Mary Jo Fernandez,
Jennifer Capriati, Lori McNeil, Zena Garrison-Jackson and Natasha Svareva.
Martina maintained at the time that the Celes attack was an isolated incident.
The problem the then president of the WTA said, was how Celes would be ranked after the first
six events. The only fair way for her to come back is number one because that's how she left,
she said. There was no discussion about that. The discussion was about how long she would keep it.
You can't just keep somebody number one forever, Martina said. Hopefully, it is only going to
happen once, and she will have ample time to get her ranking back if she backs it up.
Steffi Graf who did think it would give an unfair advantage to Celes.
Graf herself has said she does not want or need the ranking at this stage of her career.
But, all of us, we have to play all year long, Graf said. I mean we all have to struggle through
injuries, through our problems, through tough matches. You know, it has been a very sad
incident and is tough for everybody. But I think it is difficult for us as players to choose what
to do. It is difficult to say if it is the right thing or not. It's not fair that he should get
what he wants, said Celes, who lost her ranking, along with her French Open title, to Graf a month
after the stabbing. This guy planned to do this to me, and he had what it takes to do it.
