India's Economy: Economic Superpower?

Wealthy Bulls
66 followers
4 Video Views·Oct 27, 2022
This is India, tipped to be a future world superpower. The fifth largest economy in the
world is expected to be the third largest by 2030 according to the IMF. As the world's largest
democracy, India's future is bright, yet its economic story has had its fair share of challenges.
In 1980, its GDP per capita was higher than China's, but today China's is five times higher.
Likewise, neighbouring Bangladesh reportedly overtook India on a GDP per capita basis in 2020.
So, what has happened and how can India achieve economic success?
How India's history informs its economy today. To understand modern India,
we must first look to history and India has a very rich one, literally.
For over 700 years, the subcontinent was estimated to have been the wealthiest place on earth,
accounting for an estimated quarter of global trade up until the 18th century.
And then, as is often the case in history, a colonial empire turned up.
In India's case, this was the British Empire. Britain wasn't the first foreign power to hold
sway over the continent, but its economic impact was profound over nearly 200 years
of colonial rule. For starters, Britain's interests were principally economic.
It's estimated that in today's money, the British Empire extracted a whopping $45 trillion from
India. The infrastructure built and the institutional legacy were geared towards
the efficient extraction of one thing, India's incredibly vast resources, which undeniably
created structural problems, having a lasting impact until today. So, following independence
in 1947, India spent decades trying to survive with limited international trade, on the belief
that the size of its internal market and the idea that self-reliance would avoid the international
exploitation which can come with capitalism. As a result, India was transformed into a mainly
centrally planned economy, where the centralised institutions of British India were easily adapted
to this new command structure. Yet, as history has revealed time and time again, a top-down model
of state-controlled economic growth was unsustainable, especially for such a diverse
nation such as India. So, by the 1980s, the country started to really open up its businesses to drive
certain sectors. But, and there is a big but here, the state continued to manage capital flows,
including its exchange rate. You see, India had until that point always fixed its currency,
the rupee, to others, initially to the British Pound and then to a basket of currencies.
The problem was that by 1990, continual state intervention was bankrupting the country.
The final push came with the collapse of the Soviet Union, a main export market, alongside
increases in the price of oil during the First Gulf War, at which point India's pegged exchange
had exhausted the central bank's reserves to intervene in the currency markets. This forced
India to seek IMF assistance, and unsurprisingly, these bailouts came with conditions, of trade
liberalisation and free market reforms, with the currency becoming more free-floating,
but still subject to intervention by the Bank of India and restrictions. Importantly, it was these
liberal reforms which have led to the Indian economy we see today, a mixed economy of private
and public sectors, where certain sectors such as banking and power still largely operate under
government monopoly, which shouldn't come as too much of a surprise given the history of state
intervention, though the impact of opening up to trade shouldn't be understated.
Why India's exports have been a quiet success When most people think of India,
they don't consider the nation to be an exporting powerhouse, particularly when it
to manufacturing. India has struggled with protectionism, recording the highest tariffs
of any major economy, yet one phrase often quoted is that if China was the world's factory, India
was getting ready to be its back office, highlighting the nation's stellar service sector
exports, particularly in IT. But in reality, the nation's manufacturing sector has grown
on average by 12% per year between 1995 and 2018, giving it the third best performance in the world
after China and Vietnam, and nearly twice the world average. Now, despite India's lingering
protectionist policies, this could start to sound like India was following the same development
model as the tiger economies of East Asia, one based on manufacturing. But before we get ahead
ourselves, there is a fundamental difference. India's export growth has been overwhelmingly
skewed towards high-skilled manufacturing and services, as opposed to low-skilled exports in
things like textiles. And this really is astounding, as virtually all models of international trade and
growth would have predicted the opposite. You see, India has a very large low-skilled labour force,
so on the surface, its comparative advantage is in low-skilled exports.
This makes its high-skilled specialisation a bit, well, unique. One answer often floated for this
is India's large, English-speaking, educated population. But any explanation misses a
fundamental point, that by underserving low-skilled manufacturing, the nation is
estimated to be missing out on at least $140 billion of unskilled activity per year. And
remember, this is in a country where over 90% of the labour force operates in the informal sector,
so the stability, formal employment, security, and not to mention pensions,
which come with any increase in formalised manufacturing, is certainly required.
However, India's unbalanced export growth is more than just a missed opportunity,
it can present a real challenge to future growth. Why India's over-reliance on skilled exports
could lead to slower growth. Firstly, let's be clear here, India's excellent skilled service
sector is a good thing. It showcases the country's ability to compete in a highly productive and not
to mention lucrative space. But, the over-reliance on the sector is a huge risk, one which can be
summed up in economic terms by the Lewis curve. The Lewis curve highlights the process of
structural transformation in any economy, through the redeployment of resources, particularly people,
from low productivity to high productivity jobs. The classic example of this is actually China,
which experienced the transfer of labour en masse from low-productive low-wage agriculture,
to high-productive higher-paying manufacturing. In India's case, we need to look at two of its
curves, one for high-skilled tech and the other for low-skilled manufacturing. Over the last two
decades, it has rapidly climbed the high-skilled tech curve, to the point where skilled labour
is harder to come by, as reflected through reported difficulties in labour supply and
subsequently higher wages. On the other hand, India has barely climbed its lower-skilled
manufacturing curve, as demonstrated by India's exports, two-thirds of which is skilled-based,
and only increasing in size over the last 20 years. The problem here though, is that the
nation's engine for growth has been driven by high-skilled exports, which may be unsustainable
in the face of scarce skilled labour and higher wages. Critics have suggested that India's
inability to follow the likes of Vietnam or China in growing its low-skilled manufacturing base
is an issue, but at the same time offers an avenue for future growth. And this opportunity
shouldn't be overlooked, especially as China transitions away from the sector,
alongside a decline in its workforce by 30 million over the next decade.
Now, when discussing India, comparisons over whether it's going to follow China's growth
model are often made, but when China was at a similar stage of development as India is now,
it was growing much, much faster. So, why hasn't India grown as fast as China did?
Well, if we put aside the capitalising on its comparative advantage in low-skilled labour,
China has had a much higher rate of gross domestic investment, estimated to be about
70% more than India, alongside six times more patent applications filed by foreigners,
which is an excellent economic indicator of wider economic traits like innovation,
infrastructure and business climate. Not only has China's investment rate been higher,
but its difference in interest rates between borrowings and savings,
otherwise known as its spread, has been lower and this enables money to circulate more efficiently
in the system. This financial advantage goes beyond interest rate spreads though,
with Chinese banks having extended credit at two and a half times that in India.
Corporate tax rates are also lower in China, as well as how the government moves money around,
with China moving proportionally more tax revenues to underdeveloped regions.
To put this in context, China transfers over 50% of tax revenues, whilst India transfers
just over a third. Yet, things aren't all bad for India. One of India's greatest advantages
is its young population, which is already acting as a demographic dividend.
India will overtake China's population by 2027, and its population is set to continue to grow
over the next 30 years, whilst China's declines. This will provide a huge boost to domestic demand,
with an estimated 500 million people expected to enter the middle income class over the next
decade, which will provide India with the largest growth in its middle class anywhere in the world.
This isn't to mention that although China has been built on infrastructure,
investment and manufacturing, India is only just getting started on these three pivotal factors.
The population is still largely a rural one, with only a third of the country living in cities.
This is surprising, considering there are over 300 cities with more than a million people.
As any economist will tell you, cities tend to be more productive places than isolated,
poorly connected rural areas where opportunities are often limited, but just as startling is where
the growth of urban areas is coming from. Contrary to popular belief, most of it isn't
from farm to urban migration, but due to natural growth. This helps to explain India's persistently
large non-urban population, with a staggering 40% of its labour force still employed in agriculture.
As highlighted before in other countries, urban migration comes with a host of challenges,
like rampant poverty and inequality. The persistence of poor infrastructure and inadequate
housing is a real problem, which just goes to highlight how moving to an urban area
is not the perfect economic solution. Now, even before 2020, India's growth had shown
signs it was stumbling, which is not something you'd expect from a superpower on the rise.
So, what about India's slowing economy? This came as a bit of a shock to many commentators,
as India went from possessing the title of fastest growing major economy to reporting 5%
growth in 2019, its lowest in a decade. This is still an impressive number, but not if India
wants to hit its target of becoming a $5 trillion economy by 2025, which by the way, would require
an almost doubling of this growth rate. Now, there are just as many explanations
for why India's economy slowed as there are economic commentators, but a few have been
highlighted more than others. One is that there's been a more bleak global economic climate,
particularly in the light of rising protectionism. Another was a slowdown in consumer demand,
which is worth digging into a bit deeper. Slowing consumption in India was seen in part
through a decline in new bank lending. As banks faced rising non-performing loans,
investment fell as market confidence declined and the unemployment rate rose.
So, what has India been doing to propel its economy? To be fair to the government, it has
been trying to attract new manufacturing for years, launching its flagship Make in India campaign
back in 2014. Though, as alluded to earlier, over 90% of the country's workforce operates in the
informal sector, which is a huge problem when providing social security, collecting taxes,
and regulation, especially considering the tens of millions of day labourers who rely
on inconsistent wages. Their vulnerability became a real problem when the economy shut down in 2020
and is a core reason as to why India's economy was hit almost twice as hard as the world average.
This hasn't gone unnoticed by the Indian government. To help address this,
labour laws have been streamlined, replacing 44 labour codes with 4 laws in an attempt to reduce
red tape. As you can also imagine though, such a large informal sector doesn't make tax collection
an easy task. The best example of India trying to address its chronic tax evasion issues is the now
infamous demonetization of 2016, when an unbelievable 86% of the country's entire
physical cash base became illegal tender overnight, done in order to catch tax evaders
as they rushed to cash in their old notes. The short term shock of this was undeniable,
causing an economic slowdown. Yet, as mentioned earlier, government barriers, particularly when
it comes to trade, are still a fundamental issue. A recent example was India withdrawing from an
Asian based free trade agreement called the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership,
which covers over 2 billion people, in 14 Asian countries, who account for over 30% of global GDP.
The government had concerns over the lack of protection for manufacturing, and a large
absence in the free trade agreement of the service sector, which, as highlighted,
is India's key export strength. But, whether India can claim its place as an economic superpower
after becoming the most populous country on earth, will just like other countries,
depend on its ability to trade competitively, address its bureaucracy, and formalise its
largely informal economy. So overall, India's growing economy has had its fair share of
challenges. For decades a closed economy, the nation has seen rapid growth in its high skilled
exports, though the sustainability of this as a source of growth has come under question.
This has underpinned India's non-traditional development to date. Highlighting its
under-represented low skilled manufacturing base. And this is something which is likely to
become a growing opportunity as the world decouples from China's supply chain, and China
itself seeks to rebrand its economy towards services. Trade has been given as a key reason
for India's stellar growth over recent years. Yet, the country has the highest tariffs of any
major economy. Whilst comparisons of India to China are common, the countries are inherently
different. India is still predominantly a non-urban based society, yet to capitalise
on this potential. But, things are changing. Demographics are on its side, with a middle
class set to grow by over 500 million over the next decade, propelling its economy forward.
However, the nation's slowing growth, even before 2020, was a cause for concern. How
India manages its development over the next decade will be crucial to whether it achieves
economic superpower status sooner rather than later. So now it's over to you. Do you think
India will overcome its reliance on high skilled exports in the years to come? Or does it really
matter? Is India on track to become an economic superpower? Let us know in the comments below.
The Old Simplified team really enjoyed making this video, so if you think we've earned it,
leave us a like and consider subscribing. It really helps grow this channel. And as always,
see you in the next video.
